10 Horror Movies Where Pranks Brutally Backfired
While most love a good joke, these films prove that some pranks are really no laughing matter...
The prank-gone-wrong is a staple of movies aimed at a certain demographic, generally teens and young adults. Pranks generally play a role in two sorts of movies. The first is raunchy comedies, where stuffy authority figures are taught a lesson in a sea of nudity, sex, and booze, leading to lots of laughs.
The second is not those things.
No, the second is the horror movie, and while the nudity and sex may still be there, the laughs aren't, and the pranks generally go very wrong, usually leading some poor innocent to humiliation, madness, disfigurement, death, or some combination of those unfortunate outcomes.
While the ideal is never to root for the killer, (although, let's face it, we love our Jasons, Michaels, Freddys, and Leatherfaces), some of these films make it very difficult not to take the side of the villain of these pieces, who, for the most part are simply going about their (usually depressing) lives when they are the butt of a life-changing prank.
In these movies, though, the joke is on those setting up the pranks, as even their best-laid plans go very wrong in these instances, leading to them getting their comeuppance in the worst way.
The victims in these movies aren't laughing so much now...
10. Friday The 13th Part 3 (1982)
Jason Voorhees, the antagonist of almost a dozen Friday the 13th films, is a cultural icon. Part of his appeal is a now legendary piece of his look, a white hockey mask with red triangles. Funny thing is, the mask was an accident born out of a cinematic shortcut.
Filming a movie is grueling at the best of times, and it can only be imagined movies with heavy makeup and gore effects are even worse. During lighting tests one night, it was decided to just plop a goalie mask on the actor playing Jason instead of doing his makeup. A few tweaks to the mask, and out of necessity was born a legend.
But how to work this great prop into the film? It was decided that character Shelly was to be a prankster, constantly annoying the other characters. At one point, he pops out of the water wearing the mask, scaring another character and ending up alone and sad. After Shelly makes a poorly timed trip to Jason's hiding spot, the hulking killer becomes the proud new owner of an iconic costume.
With this act of prankery, Shelly inadvertently added the final piece to one of cinema's most infamous killers. The mask made Jason an unreadable, emotionless monster, adding tremendously to his character and mystique and making him one of the most popular movie characters of the '80s.
9. Sorority Row (2009)
Sorority Row is a remake of 1982's House on Sorority Row, the common thread being mean sorority sisters whose prank gets out of hand. (Although many horror fans feel the original is a better film. Your mileage may vary.)
Sorority girl Megan's boyfriend Garrett cheats on her, incurring the wrath of the entire sisterhood. Angry, the girls come up with a plan for revenge. Through a convoluted series of events, Garrett ends up killing Megan in the midst of a prank that was only supposed to make him THINK he had killed her. Garrett and the other girls in on the prank dump Megan into a mineshaft and swear secrecy.
Eight months later, Megan's death comes back to haunt those involved, squaring them off with a mysterious killer, whom all evidence leads to be Megan, back from the dead.
In a twist on slasher formulas, the killer is NOT Megan, or even someone avenging her. No, our killer here is Andy, the boyfriend of Final Girl Cassidy. Andy's motivation is simple - he found out about Megan's death and, as a douchey control freak, knew that as long as there was a chance Cassidy could be connected to the prank, he could never have her all to himself.
So, instead of a completely rational and sane move like encouraging everyone to explain what happened, he killed every witness who could make the connection to Megan.
Pure slasher logic.
8. Urban Legend (1998)
1996's Scream led to a glut of slasher-lite, self-aware horror films. Urban Legend fits this mold to a tee.
Urban Legend's premise is that its young and attractive cast members are being killed off with, well, urban legends. A few characters are killed by a shadowy ax-wielding maniac. Another is killed with a riff on the Pop Rocks and Coke legend. Our Final Girl is close to having her kidney removed as in the 'organ removal and sale' legend.
An urban legend drives the whole movie, actually. We find out about halfway through that characters Michelle and Natalie, a few years before, played the "chase the first car that flashes you" game as they drove with their headlights out. Their actions panicked the other driver, who flipped his car and died, an act which will ultimately cause the death of over a dozen people.
See, the dead driver's fiancee, Brenda, decides that she will avenge his death through a complicated process of becoming friends with Michelle and Natalie and then killing everyone close to them via urban legend. What is never explained is how Brenda, played by roughly 120-pound Rebecca Gayheart, managed to overpower several men much larger than her and then drag their bodies across a college campus.
The film is also worth a peek for the who's who of young actors who would launch to stardom within a few years.
7. Slaughter High (1986)
Trying to describe the plot of Slaughter High is like trying to describe a fever dream - you can do it, but unless you experience it for yourself it doesn't really mean much. The movie tries to cash in on a few different genres from this time, namely slashers and teen comedies, and ends up in a mish-mash of tone and story.
The key points of the plot are as follows - Marty is a high school nerd, he gets bullied and humiliated by jocks, and ends up covered by acid from his own science experiment.
The '80s was a tough time for nerds.
Ten years later, the now-adult jocks all get reunion invites. They show up and find the school closed, only to say to hell with it, break in, and party anyways.
The jester-masked Marty, who was institutionalized and disfigured for a decade, has generously decided to be the welcoming committee. He lives out a decade of revenge fantasies and violently kills off those who tormented him, most of whom do enough dumb things like wandering off to take a bath, that it's hard to feel sorry for them.
Marty kills everyone, not even leaving a final girl, before a bizarre ending involving the ghosts of Marty's victims, waking up in a hospital, and ripping off his own re-grown face.
No happy ending for anyone here - just a bunch of dead jocks and a faceless Marty.
6. The Burning (1981)
Friday the 13th's dramatic success opened the door for legions of copycat films, all trying to cash in on that sweet, sweet gore-and-nudity market. Dozens of films attempted to replicate Friday's success, and it can very fairly be argued that The Burning is the best of the lot.
Taking place at Camp Blackfoot, which like all '80s slasher movie camps seems to be populated solely by sociopathic kids and staff, The Burning tells the story of caretaker Cropsy, a mean and cantankerous gent. Wanting to scare him, the campers set up a bug-filled, burning skull next to Cropsy's bed. He wakes up and is scared, surely; however he's a bit too scared and he knocks the skull over, starting a fire that leaves him disfigured.
After being released from the hospital five years later, he targets a new summer camp, Camp Stonewater, and begins to pick off the campers and counselors one by one, usually with a set of giant garden shears. Gory chaos ensues.
Cropsy, while mean, in no way deserved to be turned into a burnt, skin-grafted monster, so it is at least a bit understandable why he is so bent on revenge. Supported by gore effects done by legend Tom Savini, The Burning is one of the best summer-camp-gone-wrong films from this era.
The raft scene alone is worth the watch...
5. Terror Train (1980)
Another horror film made in the wake of Halloween's success, Terror Train is a slasher with a few twists.
The film starts at a frat party, where medical student bros lead quiet, reserved Kenny to believe he is going to score with Alana, a reluctant accomplice played by Jamie Lee Curtis. Instead, Kenny opens his eyes to find a corpse, taken from the med school, in bed with him. The ensuing and understandable trauma leads to him being institutionalised and vowing revenge.
Three years later, the same med-school friends take a New Year's Eve party trip on the titular train, which is surprisingly roomy, allowing for a lot of slashin'. Conveniently, it is a costume party, letting the inevitable killer easily move from disguise to disguise, taking new costumes as he kills their owner and adding a real element of "Who's the killer?" to the story.
By the end, only Alana, the conductor, and Kenny, our killer, are left. Kenny, who returned to avenge his humiliation and trauma, is very anti-climactically hit with a shovel before simply being thrown from the train.
In an unusual twist, it's revealed that Kenny spent much of the movie dressed as a female magician's assistant (did we mention the magician? It's David Copperfield, instantly dating this movie.) This fact isn't played for laughs or dwelt on; it's just laid out there that Kenny was comfortable in drag, just another example of the transvestite serial killer trope in horror movies.
4. Trick R' Treat (2007)
Trick r' Treat is a wonderful Halloween horror movie, featuring a series of interconnected vignettes all tied together by the adorable scarecrow-masked mascot Sam(hain.)
The 'Halloween School Bus Massacre' features a group of teens who play a trick on a quiet, Halloween-loving girl named Rhonda. Rhonda believes in Halloween tradition, including one that says as long as you have a lit jack-o-lantern, you're protected from the creatures of the night.
The prank involves taking Rhonda to a rock quarry full of water where legend says a busload of kids was driven to their death by parents who could no longer deal with them, aided by a complicit bus driver. Macy, the bad girl of the group, says they should leave 8 lit pumpkins in tribute.
Several of the group, meanwhile, dress as zombies, terrifying Rhonda and causing her to run back to the elevator. Macy, while cleaning up, scoffs at tradition and kicks a pumpkin into the water, a really bad idea which shows viewers what happens when you don't respect the rules of Halloween (a theme which runs through the movie.)
The undead kids ascend from the depths and tear into the group. Rhonda, who has locked herself and her still-lit pumpkin in the elevator, ignores the pleas of the group and leaves the pranksters to be killed by the zombified children.
Every rule has a reason...
(This description doesn't do the film justice - if you haven't seen it, do so!)
3. Don't Hang Up (2016)
Don't Hang Up is one of the first 'prank gone wrong' films to really allude to the potential of modern technology like viral videos, texting, and online research to pull pranks.
In Don't Hang Up, teens Brady, Sam, Jeff, and Roy convince a woman that not only has an intruder broken into her home, but that her daughter is in grave danger. They film the whole call, including the laugh-filled admission that it is only a prank, and go viral on Youtube.
A year later, Sam and Brady begin getting prank calls of their own, from a man named Mr Lee, who has apparently been watching them for some time. Eventually Brady's parents and his friends Jeff and Roy, as well as Sam's girlfriend Peyton, are pulled into the chaos, all winding up dead. Sam, however, in a fitting end, is framed for the murders, soon to be a celebrity for a very different reason.
Mr Lee turns out to be the husband of the woman from the initial call, who dropped the phone and didn't hear that it was only a prank. Thinking her daughter was the intruder, she shot her, then shot herself out of guilt. Mr Lee then makes it his mission to stop pranksters like Sam.
The film deftly deconstructs what fame means in the 21st century, and how easily people can and will ruin the lives or reputation of others for glory, often with irrevocable consequences.
2. Hatchet Series (2006 To 2017)
The Hatchet series is a throwback to gritty, early '80s VHS slashers, made by people who obviously grew up on that kind of horror film and wanted to pay homage to them thirty years later.
Victor Crowley, played by Kane Hodder, best known as Jason Voorhees in Friday the 13th 7 through 10, is a monstrous, undead creature who roams a swamp in Louisiana, killing anyone who crosses his path in some spectacularly gory ways.
Much like Jason, Victor is a victim of circumstance. He was born deformed and with a rare disease, (which we would find out in Hatchet 2 was the result of a voodoo curse), which caused him to be endlessly mocked by other kids.
One night, a group of said kids found Victor's house and threw several fireworks into it, starting a fire that trapped Victor. Victor's father Thomas, while attempting to get his son out of the burning house, accidentally hits Victor in the face with a hatchet, 'killing' him. Thomas eventually died from loneliness and the despair of having apparently killed his son, and Victor now takes revenge for both father and son on any unfortunate souls who wander into his swamp.
In a neat setup, Hatchets 1, 2, and 3 all run back to back, immediately picking up where the previous left off, and the series features a list of legendary '80s and '90s horror actors.
1. Carrie - 1976 (and 2013 Remake)
Carrie is one of the earliest adaptations of a Stephen King story, and some argue, the best, superbly telling of a sad, bullied loner who is finally pushed too far and takes her revenge.
There are actually two scenes in Carrie that could be considered pranks, both integral to the plot.
In the first, shortly after gym class, Carrie White has her first menstrual period. Not knowing what's happening, Carrie thinks she is bleeding to death and begs for help, only to be met with cries of 'Plug it up' and pelted with sanitary products by the other girls. This humiliation marks the moment Carrie's telekinetic powers are unlocked.
The second, and more spectacular, is at the senior prom. The power couple of the school rig the event, crowning Carrie as Prom Queen, only to douse her with pig's blood during her triumph. This is where Carrie finally snaps after years of bullying, kills most of the students and teachers via telekinesis, and lays waste to the town of Chamberlain, which is never the same after 'The Black Prom.'
At the end of the story, Carrie is fatally wounded by her religious fanatic mother, whom Carrie kills in return. There's no feel-good ending to this film and no winners.
(If you've never read the original Stephen King story, do so! He adds incredible details about Carrie's walk from the prom to her home that add immensely to the narrative.)