10 Horror Movies With The Worst CGI
Bad CGI In Horror Movies That Turned Scares Into Laughs
Good horror is all about presentation.
Even the scariest screenplay will fall flat with audiences if it lacks in its execution, and for horror, that's all about looks.
Sure, there's more to be afraid of in what we aren't shown, but once we do finally catch a glimpse of whatever evil, supernatural or otherwise malevolent force has been sending shivers down our spine, it had better be damn believable.
Horror as a genre leans so heavily in forcing us to confront the things we can't explain, and in doing so, it sets itself a rather unique challenge: making the unbelievable believable.
When this is done right, it's terrifying. Through the use of good acting, practical effects and clever cinematography, we've seen so many ghosts, ghouls and splatterings of gore over the years that the horror audience has almost become immune to the gut-wrenching terror that these movies once inspired, but for every movie that pulls off those scares, there's another that simply doesn't.
The extensive use of CGI in horror movies is something that almost always dates the title tremendously, but the following entries go beyond that.
These are 10 times that horror movie CGI was the absolute worst.
10. Freddy Vs. Jason
While neither the Friday the 13th series or the Nightmare on Elm Street series have ever leaned too heavily on CGI - in fact, the latter is known for its extensive and impressive use of practical effects - there was one particular movie in which the visual effects used were notably bad.
In Freddy vs. Jason, a crossover title in which (you guessed it) Freddy Krueger and Jason Voorhees are pitted against one another, there is one scene in particular that boasts some truly laughable CGI.
When the standard slasher-movie stoner character Freeburg begins partaking in his favourite pastime, a giant CGI caterpillaresque creature appears complete with its own paraphernalia. It promptly blows smoke in Freeburg's face before luring him into a morgue and possessing him, revealing itself as none other than dreamworld murderer Freddy Krueger.
Not only is the lifting of an Alice in Wonderland character a bizarre concept for this slasher movie, but the CGI is utterly unconvincing, and the two come together in a perfect storm that makes this scene more likely to produce laughs than screams from its audience.
9. Deep Blue Sea
Deep Blue Sea isn't a title that's well regarded among fans of the horror genre.
In fact, it's not a movie that's ever commanded much respect from anyone, really - including star Samuel L. Jackson, whose issues with the movie's dialogue led to its most (or only, if we're honest) memorable scene.
Jackson's character, Russell Franklin, is a corporate executive sent to investigate a research facility filled with genetically engineered sharks, but after one of the sharks escapes and begins to kill, Russell and a team of researchers take refuge in a laboratory.
Devising a plan to escape the facility, Russell begins delivering a monologue about the importance of teamwork, standing beside a pool of water. Halfway through his rousing speech, a shark leaps up, bites him, and proceeds to drag his fresh corpse down into the murky depths.
The problem with the death is that the shark - which we thankfully only see for the briefest of seconds - is rendered in woefully cartoonish CGI, making the scene feel more like a weird outtake from Space Jam than a major plot point in a horror movie.
8. I Am Legend
I Am Legend tells the increasingly believable tale of a world ravaged by a virus, bringing about the apocalypse.
When a mutated form of the measles virus is used as a cure for cancer, things go predictably awry. 90% of mankind is killed outright, and most of the rest are turned into vampiric creatures known as 'Darkseekers'. That is, all but 0.2% of the human population, who appear to be immune entirely.
One such lucky guy is virologist Robert Neville (Will Smith), who lives in the abandoned ruins of Manhattan with his dog, desperately hoping to find other survivors. He also spends his spare time attempting to find a cure that will work on any survivors he might find.
While the ruins of Manhattan actually look pretty impressive, the movie's visuals fall short where it really counts: the Darkseekers.
Intended to lend a little urgency to Neville's struggle to survive, the Darkseekers ultimately fail to conjure any real emotion from I Am Legend's audience.
The reason? They all look like they've been ripped straight from a mid-'00s PlayStation cutscene. A few practical effects would have been enough to make them adequately menacing, but all we got instead was disappointment.
7. One Missed Call
One Missed Call was a 2008 remake of the 2003 movie of the same name.
It's not clear exactly what advancements had been made in those 5 years that warranted remaking the original Japanese horror movie, but it's pretty clear that it wasn't anything to do with CGI.
One Missed Call's premise borrows fairly heavily from The Ring, with victims receiving mysterious voicemails dated a few days in the future in which they die screaming into their phones.
It actually sounds like it could have once contained some promise, but One Missed Call really didn't pull the trigger on any of its more interesting points, particularly in the visual department.
There's plenty of bad CGI throughout, with characters hallucinating nightmarish features onto the faces of passers-by, but the worst - and funniest - moment comes late in the movie, when protagonist Beth is exploring an abandoned hospital.
In the hospital, she encounters a doll. But this isn't just any doll; it's infant-sized, covered in dirt and sitting upright, playing with a phone.
It's clearly meant to be a scary moment, but it's so surreal and poorly rendered that it's simply hilarious.
6. The Predator
It's easy to pick out horror movies from two decades ago and laugh at how the CGI looks when watched back today, but how about a movie that's barely a few years old?
Despite being the latest entry in one of the most recognisable franchises in cinema, 2018's The Predator features some truly terrible CGI.
For starters, there's the "Ultimate Predator" (yes, that's really the name they went with), super tall, and rendered in full CGI. Maybe in a movie outside of the Predator franchise, it wouldn't have seemed quite so offensive, but seeing the computer generated Ultimate Predator fighting a much more visually sound, practical effects based Predator "fugitive" only highlighted the poor design.
Then, there's the dogs. Predator Dogs, to be more precise - giant, alien beasts that appear to be half Predator and half canine.
The Dogs' design is conspicuously bad, even when judged against the shameless dreck that was this movie. A particular highlight is a scene in which the humans vanquish a Predator Dog, only to have it explode in luminous green goo all over the place.
5. Let The Right One In
Let The Right One In is a well regarded Swedish horror-romance, featuring bullied children, vampires and possessed cats. It received widespread critical acclaim, and (naturally) got an American remake in 2010.
It's a solid movie in near enough every aspect, although there is one moment in particular in which the creepy, unsettling atmosphere is offset by unintentional humour.
In vampire Eli's scramble to find blood, she attacks Virginia, who soon begins to feel unwell. She soon visits her cat-loving friend, only to be greeted by unnatural hostility from his usually friendly pets.
The problem? The cats are fully rendered in CGI, and they don't look overly convincing.
While Let The Right One In is able to carry a sense of unease and discomfort throughout, this particular scene's CGI is somewhat jarring, and it prompted laughs from much of its audience.
It's undoubtedly a shame, because Let The Right One In is such a great atmospheric horror movie, but ultimately, the nature of the felines' attack on Virginia and their overall presentation makes for a scene that's memorable in all the wrong ways.
4. Anaconda 3
The Anaconda series is widely known as one of - if not the - worst horror movie franchises of all time.
For some reason, in spite of its reputation, it can still pull in recognisable names.
Such was the case in 2008, when the series' third installment, Anaconda 3: Offspring, was released on Syfy, starring none other than David Hasselhoff.
A giant anaconda is taken from the Amazon River to a facility in Romania to be studied and experimented on, but when the creature escapes, it also sets free the queen anaconda, kills most of the research team, and disappears into the woods. A team of animal hunters are called in to capture the snakes, led by Stephen Hammett (Hasselhoff).
While it may be a TV movie, it's still part of a recognisable franchise, and the CGI is even worse than you might have imagined.
Despite the fact that they interact with real human beings, the anacondas look as though they were a borrowed asset from a late '90s video game, preventing this would-be horror movie from ever being remotely scary.
3. The Midnight Meat Train
The Midnight Meat Train is a 2008 horror movie starring familiar faces like Bradley Cooper, Leslie Bibb, Brooke Shields and Vinnie Jones. The fact that a movie with such recognisable actors is relatively unheard of should go someway towards describing its quality.
Based on Clive Barker's (yes, the same guy that wrote Hellraiser) short story of the same name, The Midnight Meat Train follows a photographer attempting to track down a serial killer known as "the Subway Butcher".
The problem with The Midnight Meat Train is, like the other entries on this list, its presentation. The concept is sound, and there's somethine genuinely terrifying about someone who exclusively kills while using public transport (which, let's face it, is scary enough anyway), but the excessive CGI gore used in TMMT is beyond awful.
A particular highlight is when Mahogany (Vinnie Jones) uses a hammer to smash Randall's (Ted Raimi) skull in, prompting a slo-mo shot of the man's CG eye to pop out of its socket before exploding and splattering his friends' faces with a ridiculous amount of gore.
It's utterly hideous, and not in the way it was intended to be.
2. The Thing (2011)
Despite 2011 movie The Thing's status as a prequel to the 1982 movie of exactly the same name, the former is lacking in its predecessor's quality.
The reason? Moving away from the original's groundbreaking and timeless practical effects and using liberal helpings of truly painful to watch CGI.
It's impossible to narrow this entry down to a single example, so let's just say that the entire movie is rife with CG "things", none of which look even remotely as good as those depicted in the original movie that came nearly three decades before.
The CGI used in 2011's The Thing is nothing short of a crime against cinema. Taking a story as beloved as John Carpenter's original and bastardizing it with such sub-par effects is enough to render any of the prequel's possible good points completely moot.
Interestingly, the team behind the movie had originally planned to use extensive practical effects, but the studio shot them down, instead ordering the CGI monstrosity we were eventually presented with, so let's not get angry with the wrong people, here.
Still, despite an impressive cast and a classic franchise, this 2011 prequel was entirely ruined by its awful, awful CGI.
1. Boogeyman
2005 horror movie Boogeyman isn't exactly a well-known classic, and for good reason. Critical panning saw the movie buried along with countless other bad horror movies in the genre's extensive back catalogue.
Doing its utmost to deliver a tense atmosphere and evoke the audience's fear of the unknown, Boogeyman tells the story of the titular monster, who apparently lives in every closet in the world. As a child, protagonist Tim Jensen saw his father taken by the creature, and has spent his life living without closets in order to protect himself from the creature.
Yes, that's the movie's actual plot.
Boogeyman's worst CGI moment comes during the movie's climax, where Tim inevitably faces the monster he's spent his life hiding from.
The reveal of the monster we've sunk over an hour of our lives to see is truly something to behold, and not even remotely in a good way.
Looking like something animated by a child during a school project, the creature appears from the closet, Tim hits him with a baseball bat, prompting the Boogeyman to explode into unconvincing CG bats, who disappear into equally bad CG lightning.
It's a bad movie, but the CGI on display is even worse than you'd expect.