10 Horror Remakes That Are Better Than The Original

HOW DARE YOU REMAKE THESE CLASSIC FILMS!?... Ah wait. These are actually awesome.

Fresh, original ideas in Hollywood have become as elusive as popular Adam Sandler films in recent years. Soulless cash-ins are far too prevalent in cinemas today, often revisiting stories that don't need to be expanded upon or even missing the point of the original film completely. Every week, it feels like movie fans hear the dreaded news that one of their favorite films is being remade. Cue the groaning. "How could they tamper with such a classic?", "It'll never be as good as the original.", "They'll never be as good as blah blah..." Admittedly, these reactions are entirely justified 99.9% of the time, but every now and again, a remake comes along that's not only good, but actually manages to somehow surpass the original. Classic horror films tend to be remade more than most, so fans of the genre have to wade through more garbage to find remakes worth watching, but they definitely do exist. Need some help? We thought you'd never ask. Join us this Halloween as we select 10 horror remakes which are actually better than the original. Whether these movies add something different to the story or simply execute the scares better, each is worth watching in their own right. Fanatics may wish to watch the remakes directly after the original movies to check if they agree with us, but for those of you who are too busy carving pumpkins and frantically searching for the scariest/sluttiest Halloween costume, you're better off just trusting us on this one.

10. Invasion Of The Body Snatchers (1978)

Based on Jack Finney's classic novel, the story of 'pod people' secretly replacing the population with emotionless alien copies is one of the most iconic science fiction stories of all time. Don Siegel's original version was released in 1956 and while critics largely ignored it at first, the film has since been heralded as a classic of the genre, so the pressure was on for Philip Kaufman when he remade the movie in 1978. Fortunately, terrific casting and a new take on the social commentary of the original made Kaufman's version a classic in its own right. While Siegel's film served as an allegory for the threat of Communism, Kaufman updated the subtext by taking aim at the narcissistic self-help movement of the 1970's, fueled by memorable supporting turns from Leonard Nimoy as a self-involved life coach and Jeff Goldblum as a struggling writer. The original Invasion of the Body Snatches remains an important benchmark for both science fiction and horror, but the 1978 update expands upon the original's themes in more detail, earning widespread acclaim from critics and audiences alike. Let's just not even talk about The Invasion, Oliver Hirschbiegel's ill-fated remake from 2007. Just thinking about it makes us long to be a 'pod person', so we don't have to remember the horror of watching it.

9. The Grudge (2004)

After the success of Hideo Nakata's Ringu and its inevitable US remake, J-horror became a worldwide phenomenon, one which film makers from both the East and West were quick to capitalize on. One of the more popular movies released as part of this new wave was Ju-on: The Grudge, which was already technically a remake of director Takashi Shimizu's direct-to-video Ju-on: The Curse. Sam Raimi's production company Ghosthouse Pictures jumped on board with a US remake, bizarrely asking Shimizu to return to the franchise yet again to helm an English language version, making this his third film based on the same story. Fortunately, Shimizu used a screenplay penned by a different writer called Stephen Susco, enabling him to approach the material in a fresh, new way. The Grudge's inclusion on this list may not be a popular choice for some, but this third version of the vengeful spirit's story retains the artistry of the original thanks to Shimizu's involvement, while tightening the focus of the interweaving, non-linear narratives into something more coherent. Of course, there are moments which feel too heavy-handed at times and the soundtrack is abused more than once in an attempt to derive some cheap scares, but this was also true of Ju-on: The Grudge on occasion. Neither film is exactly a modern classic i.e. they're both average at best, but if you're looking for a fun, easy-going horror movie, The Grudge just about overtakes the original in this case.

8. The Hills Have Eyes (2006)

Every now and again, a horror remake comes along based on a film that actually deserves to be remade. Wes Craven's original The Hills Have Eyes is undoubtedly a classic, but time had not been kind to the story of these vicious, mutated cannibals, so French film director Alexandre Aja took on the unenviable task of updating the movie. Modern remakes often tone down the brutality in order to appeal to a wider demographic, but fortunately, Aja understood the appeal of the original Hills Have Eyes and actually ramped up the gore with a number of brutal set-pieces that stay with you long after the credits have rolled. There's one sequence in particular, where the mutants invade the family's caravan, which is one of the most harrowing scenes ever included in a widely released Hollywood movie. Unfortunately, Aja was unable to recapture the quality of The Hills Have Eyes with his subsequent remakes, Mirrors and Piranha 3D, so fans should instead seek out his phenomenal French-language movie Switchblade Romance from back in 2003. Saying that though, Piranha 3D did star Christopher Lloyd and Kelly Brook, so who are we to judge, right?

7. Cape Fear (1991)

Both versions of Cape Fear follow a convicted rapist called Max Cady as he torments a family following the end of his incarceration in prison and both were critically acclaimed upon release. However, restrictions placed upon how dark the original movie could go back in 1962 were eased by the time Martin Scorcese took on the project in 1991, allowing for a more twisted take on the character of Cady. It's unusual for a director of Scorcese's caliber to tackle a high profile remake like Cape Fear, but the project was a resounding success, earning Academy Award and Golden Globe nominations for regular collaborator Robert De Niro and a young Juliette Lewis in a breakthrough performance. Morally disturbing scenes between De Niro and Lewis in particular freaked out audiences in a way that the original just couldn't explore due to the time frame in which it was made. Both versions of Cape Fear are certainly worth watching, but the remake's A-list talent and disturbing additions to the story make it ultimately superior to the original. Go watch it and enjoy... you sickos!

6. House Of Wax (1953)

Don't worry. This is not a celebration of the 2005 remake starring Paris Hilton. That deserves its own special place on a list we like to call "Horror Remakes That Suck Beyond All Imagining". Instead, we're celebrating the classic Vincent Price version from 1953, which was itself based on Mystery of the Wax Museum from twenty years earlier. Taking inspiration from a range of sources including Frankenstein and The Phantom of the Opera, Andre De Toth's remake has plenty of fun with Price's deranged sculptor who delights in creating waxwork models using the bodies of people he's murdered. Eschewing the humor of the original film from 1933, House of Wax is mostly silly throwaway fun, but the moment Price's disfigured face is revealed still looks great even now, especially when compared to the more recent remake which we wish to avoid mentioning again if at all possible... because it's a truly awful remake... so don't see it, unless you're planning to gouge your own eyes out moments before the film begins and... argh! We mentioned it again!!!

5. The Crazies (2010)

George A. Romero may be most famous for introducing the concept of zombies into pop culture with his classic horror Night of the Living Dead, but back in 1973, the director released The Crazies, a film about an infection that turns people insane. The concept of infected people running around attacking others at full speed pre-empted Danny Boyle's reinvention of the zombie genre in 28 Days Later by thirty years. Despite this, The Crazies failed at the box office upon its original release, although fortunately, Romero's horror has since become a cult classic, which was inevitably remade in 2010. While Romero remained on board as a producer, the new version of The Crazies took the potential of the exciting yet flawed original and tightened up the script, adding more tension and better effects to create a film that surpassed Romero's first effort. Credit must also be given to director Breck Eisner, who redeemed himself somewhat after helming the action-comedy Sahara, which was considered to be one of Hollywood's biggest financial failures of all time upon its release. Since then, Eisner has signed on to direct the sequel to the Karate Kid remake, because the world apparently needs yet more Jaden Smith flops in their lives. Cast the young star in a sequel to The Crazies remake where he suffers a horrendous death at the hands of the infected and now we're talking.

4. The Fly (1986)

Remember the version of The Fly that was released in 1958? Neither do we. It's not because Kurt Neumann's movie was bad by any means. In fact, the film holds up remarkably well even today as one of the best B-Movies of its generation. The problem is that thirty years later, David Cronenberg swooped along and remade the movie in his own unique, signature style, transforming the story into one of his key works. The plot remains essentially the same, following a mad scientist whose experiments on teleportation accidentally mutate him into a giant fly, but Cronenberg adds a tragic love story that appealed to the masses, while still including the gruesome moments of body horror that fans have come to expect from the director. Aided by disgustingly brilliant makeup and effects, the slow degeneration of Jeff Goldblum's physical appearance is truly horrifying to watch and the tension is heightened by the possibility that Geena Davis's character could be carrying his mutant offspring inside of her. With brilliant direction, stellar performances and an ending that is guaranteed to repulse and sadden audiences in equal measure, Cronenberg's remake is not just an improvement over the original, but stands tall as one of the greatest horror movies ever made. Just don't watch The Fly as a date movie. It could potentially put you off sex for life. That's what dreams of maggot babies will do to you!

3. The Ring (2002)

Hideo Nakata€™s original story of a reporter investigating the gruesome deaths that revolve around a strange video tape created waves across the entire horror industry, becoming one of the most successful Japanese films of all time. Inevitably, Hollywood jumped on board to produce a remake of The Ring as quickly as possible, prompting groans from fans of the original. With the help of novelist Koji Suzuki, who adapted his original story for both screenplays, American director Gore Verbinski achieved the impossible and created a US remake that not only received positive reviews, but actually sold more tickets in Japan than Nakata's original. Fans of the first Ring may resent the inclusion of the remake on this list, as Nakata's movie is clearly the more iconic and influential of the two. However, Verbinki's version is arguably better all round, with more atmospheric direction, an intelligent performance from Naomi Watts and a cassette sequence that's even more beautifully shot yet disturbing than the original. Unfortunately, the popularity of The Ring also kick-started a wave of inferior US remakes that plundered the Asian horror market, squeezing every last drop of originality from these horrors in a bid to make a few more dollars for the Hollywood machine. Damn you fat cats!

2. Evil Dead (2013)

The Evil Dead remake met more than its fair share of hostility prior to its release and rightly so. How could they even attempt this without Sam Raimi in the director's chair and Bruce Campbell chainsawing his way through demons as Ash? Original director Sam Raimi technically remade Evil Dead already in 1987 with Evil Dead II, a sequel which remixed elements of the first film with a new script, but Fede Alvarez was the brave man in charge of tackling an official remake. The Uruguayan filmmaker didn't hold back, surprising fans and critics alike by creating one of the most excessively gory and depraved horror films widely released in years. Nail guns, electric bread knives and of course chainsaws all make a violent appearance as new hero Mia Allen battles the demonic forces. Alvarez smartly chooses to reinvent the story with his own unique spin, rather than simply rehashing everything that has gone before. Sure, raping trees and dismembered limbs all make a reappearance, but Evil Dead still turned out to be one of the freshest horror films released in years, paying homage to the original while blazing new ground with a female protagonist and its own iconic moments. Two words. Snake tongue.

1. The Thing (1982)

Horror maestro John Carpenter always had a passion for Howard Hawks's sci-fi classic The Thing From Another World, even including shots of it on a television screen in his movie Halloween, so it came as no surprise when the director opted to helm a remake, simply titled The Thing. Expanding on the narrative of the original, Carpenter's The Thing follows a team of researchers at an Antarctic base who are under siege from an alien parasitic creature that assimilates and then impersonates other lifeforms. The nature of the alien creates unbearable paranoia among the scientists as they are slowly replaced and even Kurt Russell's central protagonist is under suspicion for the majority of the film. The Thing is a masterclass in tension thanks to Carpenter's precise direction and Rob Bottin's practical effects still set a high benchmark, even today. Despite flopping upon its initial release in cinemas, The Thing has steadily gained a cult following over the years and is now heralded as a classic among horror purists and academics alike. No matter how many times you've seen Carpenter's masterpiece, scenes featuring the severed spider head, the defibrillator and that blood test will always freak you out, even when you know what's coming. That's why The Thing stands head and shoulders above every other remake, taking its place as one of the seminal horror films of the past three decades. If anyone tells you otherwise, then they've probably been replaced by the alien creature, so you may want to a) ignore their review and b) run like hell. Are all of these horror remakes better than the originals? Can you think of any other additions to the list? And should horror movies even be remade in the first place? Remember to sound off in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

David is a primary school teacher who tries his best to turn every math lesson into a discussion on the latest Pixar film. Passions include superheroes, zombies and Studio Ghibli. In between going to the cinema, moving to South Korea and eating his body weight in KFC, David writes for a number of movie sites, http://becarefulyourhand.blogspot.co.uk/