10 Huge Casting Surprises Avengers: Doomsday Could Still Pull

Marvel must have something big up their sleeves for Avengers: Doomsday...

Avengers Doomsday Surprise Castings
Marvel Studios

For any other film franchise, announcing 27 names would surely leave absolutely no room for anyone else to join the party. However, this is the Marvel Cinematic Universe, this is an Avengers movie, and this is not the fans' first rodeo.

Simply put - is there anyone who truly believes that the full cast of Avengers: Doomsday has been announced?

There are a handful of names omitted from the backs of the chairs that are more than likely going to appear. No one is going to be too shocked when the Hulk, Captain Marvel, or Doctor Strange make their appearance. But there is still room for some genuine surprises.

There are certainly going to be some characters involved that Kevin Feige wants kept to shock the audience in their seats, and when you consider that the names he was happy to release beforehand include the likes of Ian McKellen as Magneto, Alan Cumming as Nightcrawler, and Channing Tatum's Gambit, chances are they are going to be big.

There's a stack of characters Marvel Studios could pull from Disney+, there are those that could return from the dead (if they were even dead in the first place), and a whole multiverse full of potential crossovers.

10. Jeffrey Wright As The Watcher

The Watcher What If
Marvel Studios

There has been relatively little multiverse in this Multiverse Saga so far, with only a handful of the 12 movies and 14 TV shows (and counting) addressing the possibilities of alternate realities. The likes of Spider-Man: No Way Home, Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, and Loki have toyed with the concept, but none more so than What If...?

The premise of the entire show was that The Watcher presented audiences with a different story from a different universe every episode, as he was sworn to observe only and to never interfere.

This rule was broken several times by Jeffrey Wright's Uatu over the show's three-season run, as he often went out of his way to avert multiversal threats and disasters, even forming the Guardians of the Multiverse to stop Ultron from taking over everything.

Knowing that a character like that exists in the MCU, and with such a talented actor in Jeffrey Wright right there, it would feel like one hell of a missed opportunity if Uatu didn't at the very least watch at some point throughout Doomsday. He wouldn't be the first Watcher to appear in an MCU film, but he would certainly be the most significant.


9. Elizabeth Olsen As Wanda Maximoff

Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness Wanda Maximoff
Marvel Studios

To say there are a few wild cards on the Avengers: Doomsday cast list would be an understatement. There are the likes of Loki, Namor, Magneto, and Mystique (Tom Hiddleston, Tenoch Huerta Mejía, Ian McKellen, and Rebecca Romijn) who could effortlessly play both sides of the hero/villain divide, and right there with them is Elizabeth Olsen's Wanda Maximoff.

The Scarlet Witch has grown through the traumatic life she has led into one of the most powerful beings in the world, she is one of the few who proved she could have easily handled Thanos (Josh Brolin) one on one, and had it not been for a slip of the tongue in the Multiverse of Madness, she could have had free reign across said multiverse.

However, after her villainous turn, she imploded a large mountain on top of herself, and hasn't been seen or heard from since. Olsen's name didn't show up in the Doomsday announcement, but that doesn't mean that she is gone.

There was a tiny red flash when Mount Wundagore fell, suggesting that she may have protected herself, ready and waiting for the right time to return. That could be Doomsday, and Wanda is a popular and powerful enough character that this would be a huge moment, but if she does come back, she doesn't have to come back alone.


8. Aaron Taylor-Johnson As Pietro Maximoff

Avengers Age Of Ultron Quicksilver
Marvel Studios

Remember the reaction to seeing Evan Peters' return in WandaVision, when the world thought that a reunion between Wanda and Pietro was on the cards? Everyone was giddy at the thought, but ultimately the actor's appearance was reduced to nothing more than a poor boner joke.

However, the ship hasn't quite sailed on Wanda seeing her brother again. There are some big names set to make their return to Marvel screens in the fifth Avengers movie, so would it be too much to ask for Aaron Taylor-Johnson to join them?

Taylor-Johnson's Quicksilver was an Avenger for a few minutes in Age of Ultron, before he sacrificed himself to save Clint Barton (Jeremy Renner). At the time, he was all that Wanda had, and it would be interesting not only to see him return for the sake of the character himself, but also for the dynamic with Wanda, what he would think about the things she has done, and how this would affect her.

Then there is the fact that having the Maximoff twins and Magneto appear in the same film feels like an opportunity that is just too good to miss.


7. Charlie Cox As Matt Murdock

Daredevil MCU
Disney+

Right now, it's strange to think back to just a few years ago when Matt Murdock was absolutely nowhere to be seen in the MCU. The rights for Marvel's Netflix characters were complicated, and after Daredevil was cancelled in 2018, it seemed as though the Man Without Fear simply didn't have a future in the franchise.

Now in 2025, the character is everywhere. Since 2021, Charlie Cox has made appearances as Daredevil in Spider-Man: No Way Home, She-Hulk, Echo, Your Friendly Neighbourhood Spider-Man, and of course, Daredevil: Born Again. He is arguably one of the hottest properties Marvel Studios currently has to boast.

While the biggest draws of No Way Home were obviously Andrew Garfield and Tobey Maguire, Charlie Cox's appearance was yet another 'oh my god' moment, as Matt Murdock finally hit the MCU big screen. 

Another showing in Doomsday would arguably garner an even bigger reaction from audiences, particularly if he came fully equipped as his vigilante alter-ego, and stepping in the ring with the Avengers. Daredevil is still up there with the biggest names in Marvel Comics, and it's time he joined them on the big screen.


6. Benedict Cumberbatch As Sheriff Strange

Doctor Strange And The Multiverse Of Madness Benedict Cumberbatch
Walt Disney Studios

As said toward the beginning of this article, it would be a huge surprise if Benedict Cumberbatch didn't appear as Doctor Strange in Avengers: Doomsday. The actor has said as much himself, however it may not be as straightforward as just Earth-616's Strange showing up.

Yes, this iteration of the Master of the Mystic Arts is likely to appear, but who says it will stop at just him? Cumberbatch has played no fewer than five versions of the character in the MCU so far, but how about a sixth?

Though the road to Doomsday has only just begun, there will still be at least one eye on Secret Wars coming 12 months later. Depending on how faithfully the film follows the comics, and assuming it will be based on the 2015 story rather than the original from 1984, Strange could stand with Robert Downey Jr.'s Doom as his right-hand man.

After Doom took control of the remnants of two worlds colliding, the version of the character known as Sheriff Strange saw a choice of either siding with the Latverian, or death. A broken world run by someone such as Doom was better than nothing, and what better use of a Variant could there be than this?


5. Charlize Theron As Clea

Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness Clea
Marvel Studios

Whether Sheriff Strange shows up in Avengers: Doomsday or not, you'd be a fool for betting against Earth-616's Doctor Strange showing his weird three-eyed face again. However, based on how things were going the last time he was seen on an MCU screen, he may not be coming alone.

In the first post-credit sting of the Multiverse of Madness, Strange was confronted by Clea, played by none other than Charlize Theron. Hers is a huge name to bring into the franchise, and surely it's only a matter of time before she returns, likely in a third Doctor Strange film.

But why wait that long? Even in a movie boasting 27 big names, Theron would be a huge addition, and it would make sense to see her with Strange. After all, she took the Master of the Mystic Arts into the Dark Dimension, and if he is going to return, there's no reason to think she won't be with him.

Even if her role was to be a small one in Doomsday, there to achieve nothing more than paying off the post-credit scene before a bigger chunk of screen time in a Doctor Strange threequel, Charlize Theron's Clea could make waves in the Avengers' fifth film.


4. Any Of The Eternals

Eternals Makkari Druig
Marvel Studios

There are certain characters that have appeared in the MCU and then disappeared without a trace, and with no real timescale or obvious return in place. Shang-Chi fell into this category until Simu Liu's name was announced as part of the Doomsday cast, and the Eternals fit the bill as well.

It's been four years since Sersi and co. graced the MCU, and only in Captain America: Brave New World has the movie been referenced elsewhere. Even in this, Tiamut the Celestial was a factor in the story, bringing adamantium to the party, whereas there wasn't any mention of the race of robot aliens themselves.

Of course, there may be a sequel on the way somewhere down the line, but at the moment Eternals feels like Phase Four's version of The Incredible Hulk. Very much the black sheep of the family, particularly as one of its big set-ups was for Mahershala Ali's Blade, which feels further away than ever right now.

All this to say that no one would expect the Eternals to make their return any time soon. Ajax, Gilgamesh, and Ikaris (Salma Hayek, Don Lee, and Richard Madden) are dead, Sersi, Phastos, and Kingo (Gemma Chan, Brian Tyree Henry, and Kumail Nanjiani) have been taken by the Celstial Arashem, while Lia McHugh's Sprite is living a relatively normal life on Earth, so they may be out of the running completely. But could there be room for a return for the likes of Thena, Druig, and Makkari (Angelina Jolie, Barry Keoghan, and Lauren Ridloff), who were last seen on board the Domo? Stranger things have happened.


3. Tom Cruise As Tony Stark

Iron Man Mark 7
Marvel Studios

There are certain rumours and fan casts that the internet often grabs hold of and that just never go away. Until they are realised, of course. One such instance was John Krasinski playing Reed Richards, which happened in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness.

The Doctor Strange sequel was also expected by many to feature Tom Cruise as a Variant of Tony Stark, with some believing to have seen him in the trailer, but nothing came of this. Cruise was reportedly Marvel's first choice for the role all those years ago, and even with other Variant opportunities in Deadpool and Wolverine, it still has not happened.

However, Avengers: Doomsday could be the difference. Robert Downey Jr. and Tony Stark are synonymous with each other, but with the Oscar winner now playing a different character in the MCU, could the reverse also be coming? Could another actor be set to play RDJ's old role?

In fairness, of all the entries on this list, this one feels like the most unlikely, but we are talking about surprises here, and it would arguably be one of the biggest jaw-droppers the Russo Brothers could offer.


2. Miles Teller As The Maker

Miles Teller Mr Fantastic Four
20th Century Fox

Doctor Strange isn't the only Marvel hero who could come face to face with an evil Variant of themselves, and again, this is one that could happen depending on how closely the comics are followed. 

With the incursion of two different worlds, in theory there are two different versions of everyone. In Reed Richards' case, there was Mr. Fantastic, and then there was The Maker, an iteration of Reed who had turned to a life of villainy after suffering multiple tragedies in his life. His origin is similar to that of Miles Teller's Reed in Fant4stic.

Yes, Josh Trank's movie was incredibly poorly received, but that doesn't mean that certain aspects weren't without their merit, and couldn't be brought back and redeemed to some degree. Miles Teller's Reed Richards has the potential not only to shock audiences, as no one is going to expect the Fantastic Four reboot to be revisited, but to bring something unique to the table as a secondary villain next to Doom.

Of course, for a Reed Richards Variant, it wouldn't necessarily have to be Teller, though his already-established backstory does work in his favour. Pedro Pascal could easily play a twisted version of the character, or why not bring back Ioan Gruffudd? 


1. Tobey Maguire & Andrew Garfield As Peter Parker 2 & 3

Spider Man No Way Home Tom Holland Andrew Garfield Tobey Maguire
Marvel Studios

The MCU has been in a funk since Avengers: Endgame, it simply can't be denied, but it hasn't been all bad by any stretch. Deadpool and Wolverine released to huge success both critically and commercially, Shang-Chi enjoyed arguably the best origin story in the franchise since Iron Man, and the Guardians of the Galaxy trilogy ended on a high.

One of the biggest moments of the Multiverse Saga so far, however, was the return of both Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield in Spider-Man: No Way Home. There wasn't a single person entering cinemas that didn't expect to see them rock up, but that didn't dampen the goosebumps.

A return in the fifth Avengers movie certainly wouldn't be as expected as before, but it would make a lot of sense. It's a multiversal scrap after all, and the good guys could use all the Spider-Men they can get their hands on.

The further away No Way Home gets, the less likely it seems that either Peter Parker 2 or 3 will return for either Spider-Man 4 or The Amazing Spider-Man 3 respectively, so get them back on screens in an Avengers movie. Neither of them had ever even heard of Earth's Mightiest Heroes before meeting Peter 1 (Tom Holland), but there'd be a spot open for them, without question.


Watch Next


Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.