10 Huge Questions That Undermine Back To The Future

We love this film; it's a classic that's ignited so many imaginations with the possibilities of time travel. But it doesn't half ask a lot of questions.

Another New Year over and done, and we're still no closer to hoverboards. And there's a simple explanation for that; a longshot, but an explanation all the same. You see, Marty McFly changed a lot about 1955. And one thing he could have helped with, was popularising skateboarding, by stealing achild's soapbox scooter and snapping the wooden bit off the top. In a universe where this happened, Marty might have become a legend, and the history of skateboarding could have become radically different; and it could've become popular enough for technological advances such as the hoverboard. Not everything in Back to the Future has such a quirky explanation though. We love this film; it's a classic that's ignited so many imaginations with the possibilities of time travel. But it doesn't half ask a lot of questions. Here are ten of the biggest questions the first Back to the Future film poses, that actually undermine the film itself. Not that we don't adore and enjoy it, of course.

10. Why Do George And Lorraine Give Biff So Much Credit For Getting Them Together?

Back To The Future Punch Gif

So, towards the end of Back to the Future, we see the alternate 1985, changed by Marty McFly's actions in the past. And thanks to that punch, school bully Biff isn't George's boss anymore, he's practically his servant. Okay, let's take into account the moral message - if you stand up to the bullies, you'll be a roaring success - and skip over the question about whether you'd want someone who bullied you and your wife so close to your family. Instead, let's look at Lorraine's quote, "If it wasn't for Biff, we would've never fallen in love." Sorry, what? Have I missed something? Didn't Biff assault Lorraine in the parking lot? George may have totally forgotten that Marty helped him find the love of his life, but is really going to give Biff credit for just being there to punch? It was all George. He controlled his own density, as he would say. If I was Marty, I'd feel somewhat hard done by that I went to all that trouble to help my parents, and they thanked Biff over me. But George can't have changed that much if he doesn't realise that he shaped his own future.

9. Why Does Lorraine's Dad Question A Street Name?

Time travel fiction is good for those "I know something you don't" jokes. You know the type: person from our time goes back, mentions something from modern culture and confuses everyone. Back to the Future's full of these jokes, the best probably being Marty's rendition of 'Johnny B Goode' which only shocks his audience. Imagine if he'd have showed them dubstep. Another one of these jokes occurs while Marty's having a meal with his mother and his grandparents, as he mentions John F Kennedy Drive. "Who the hell is John F Kennedy?" his granddad retorts. The joke is that in 1955, no one knew who JFK was. Only this joke's not quite as good... Because since when has anyone ever questioned a street name? If I told you I lived down Gary Smith Street or Tim Henderson Road, would you ask who those people are? In fact, if this wasn't a time travel film, I doubt anyone would question anything peculiar that Marty says: they'd just smile and nod, or have in-depth and unknowingly insightful conversations. Which would make the film an awful lot shorter, and probably more boring, but definitely more realistic.

8. Why Isn't Alternate 1985 Hugely Different?

When Marty changes the future, back in 1955, he assumes that when he returns home to 1985, everything will be just how he left it. If time travel does exist, this is almost certainly not how it works. But that's another article for another day. Why though, in alternate 1985, do the McFlys live in the same house, if they're that much richer? If Dave works in an office, hasn't he moved out? If the Doc saw his time machine thirty years before he invented it, why isn't it that much more advanced in the alternate timeline? Despite all these niggles concerning the butterfly effect though, the biggest question usually posed by Marty's actions is whether he and the Doc would be friends, given he's got more of a father figure now. And whilst the Doc would've known to be friends with Marty, having met him in 1955, would they have followed exactly the same timeline to send Marty back into the past? Would sending him back create a paradox or a time loop? Now I'm just being pedantic, sorry.

7. Is The Film Unintentionally Racist?

What? Back to the Future? That classic, family-friendly, time-travel adventure with Michael J Fox? Look at Marty's first big mistake in 1955: he gives Goldie the idea of running for mayor. And later on, he gives Chuck Berry the idea for rock and roll. So two black characters in this film have had their big contributions to society suggested to them by a white man? Let's hope that was unintentional, at least. More to the point, why is Marvin Berry so keen on performing a second song with Marty, given how badly he messes up 'Earth Angel'? Chuck really was the one in the family with an ear for musical talent, wasn't he?

6. What Does Marty Mean, There's Not Enough Road?

It's one of the most famous lines in movie history: Marty claims there's not enough road to get the Delorean up to 88mph, and Doc Brown replies, "Roads? Where we're going... we don't need roads." But the line really should have been, "What are you on about Marty?" Because the night before, Doc Brown drives Marty home. He then departs for 2015, on that very stretch of road, and he does get up to 88 mph. Surely though, we can overlook that mistake for such a classic cinema moment...

5. Is There Any Need For The Second Film Whatsoever?

...Following on from that exciting cliffhanger of an ending though, why are Marty and Jennifer even going with the Doc to 2015 in the first place? The Doc returns back to 1985, and tells Marty that his kids are in trouble. But why would going to 2015 solve anything? Why couldn't he write a letter, like Marty did? That worked, to an extent. Why doesn't he just tell him what's wrong? It's surely easier for both Marty and Jennifer to plan out what they're going to do, rather than heading straight to the eye of the storm to sort things there? Doc should take a leaf out of Marty's book. One minute he's against finding out things from his future, the next he's telling Marty all about his. (Okay, not "minute", thirty years' thought probably could change your viewpoint.) And anyway, doesn't Marty - or Jennifer for that matter - have anything to say about the fact they're married with kids in the future? Isn't that all a bit too committal for a pair of teenagers? Seriously, sort out your problems today, and they won't be there tomorrow. That's the best message this film can give you.

4. How Did The Doc Survive That Lightning Bolt?

It's one of the tensest moments of the film. The Doc's scrambling to connect the cable that will conduct the electricity. It's stuck under a branch. Oh no, we're thinking. This is it. But then Doc Brown holds the cable in place. Exactly how strong is this man though? He's struck by lightning and on his feet only seconds afterwards. Is there no explanation as to why? The Doc made such a big deal about how they needed such a huge amount of electricity, and how you can only get such a huge amount of electricity from one source. And then he just lets that electricity pulse straight through him? Perhaps it's because it's some of the slowest lightning to ever hit Hill Valley. Seriously, watch it: it's an instance where light doesn't travel at the speed of light. It's a wonder Doc Brown didn't give up on the time travel and investigate that.

3. Why Doesn't Doc Brown Take Better Precautions To Avoid His Death?

I've briefly mentioned how Marty gave Doc Brown that envelope, telling him about how he was going to be shot in 1985. The Doc chose to take the precaution of wearing a bullet-proof vest, which saved his life. It's a touching moment in the film, that he silently admits that Marty was right by showing him the sellotaped letter from the past. But why doesn't Doc Brown take better precautions? Like, not stealing plutonium in the first place? He's had thirty years to think of this, and he's had thirty years' head-start to work out how to build a time machine: would he even run it on plutonium the second time around? The letter's a big vague about how he's going to die too: why doesn't Marty write in big capitals to avoid terrorists at all costs? Another big question though, is how the Libyans actually found him. How did they know he'd be at Twin Pine mall at 1:30 in the morning? Also...

2. Why Didn't Marty Give Himself More Than Ten Minutes To Save Doc Brown?

Marty's panicking that Doc Brown's ripped up those instructions to protect himself. Then comes the realisation, he's in a time machine. He can travel back to any time he wants! So why does he give himself ten minutes to save the Doc? What exactly was planning to do? If the Libyans found him in a random parking lot in the middle of the night, with no explanation of how, what exactly is the Doc going to do to save himself in ten minutes? Why couldn't Marty give himself a week, meet the Doc and hatch a plan with him? Or tell him to, you know, not steal plutonium from terrorists? Of course, the ten minutes he does give himself are then wasted, as the Delorean doesn't arrive at the shopping mall. But surely Marty should realise this too? He's seen it travel twice, and both times, it didn't end up somewhere different (although admittedly, the iciness on the car is inconsistent). Come on McFly, use your head.

1. Don't Marty's Parents Recognise Their Son At All?

There's a joke in a recent Family Guy episode about why George McFly never wonders if Marty is actually his son. After all, his wife fancies this guy called Marty, names her son after him, and then their son grows up to look like this very guy. And he never wondered? And they never wondered about those bizarre parting words about setting fire to the carpet? George and Lorraine might never mention their friend Calvin Klein ever again, but do they never look at their son and think, "Hey, you're really familiar." And if they really liked the name Marty that much, why did they name their eldest son Dave? Which questions do you have about Back to the Future though? Do you think I'm being too pedantic, and should just enjoy the film? Have you ever time travelled? Comment below!

Contributor
Contributor

Mark White hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.