10 Iconic Characters Movies Keep Screwing Up
So much potential...
On paper, adapting a famous character to the big screen should be the easiest way to make money. We know Sherlock Holmes, Captain Kirk, and Spider-Man are universally beloved, which is why Hollywood keeps pumping out adaptations of these iconic heroes.
Even if one of these films doesn't do well, it's not the end of the world. If the property gets stale, studios can put a different spin on it, like with the gritty reboot of James Bond. If an adaptation takes too many liberties with the source material, a studio can try again with a more faithful adaptation.
But there are some legendary characters who have rarely, if ever, been done right after they transition to film. Everyone loves the tales of Robin Hood, and yet, we struggle to think of the last adaptation we enjoyed. The Terminator has had so many mediocre sequels, it's easy to forget how influential and treasured the franchise once was. And there are some characters like the Fantastic Four who've NEVER been successfully adapted to cinema one single time.
Although these characters have so much potential, the movie world can't stop screwing them up.
10. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
In hindsight, it's a miracle the first live-action adaptation of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles turned out as well as it did. It was an independent film with a pitiful budget of $13.5 million, that had to bring our reptilian heroes to life without the aid of CGI. Just to make things more difficult, the filmmakers decided to amalgamate the dark tone of the comics with the wacky, comedic antics of the animated series.
Even though Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles should've been a dud, this adaption made nearly 20 times its money back, and is still regarded as the best adaption of the heroes in a half shell.
What makes this feat more impressive is how no studio or director has come close to replicating its success. The sequel didn't even make half as much. The third outing is best forgotten. TMNT was a step in the right direction, but failed to make a splash in the box-office, or in our memories.
The Michael Bay-produced reboot was meant to give us the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles movie we always wanted. Instead, it relied on fart gags, sex jokes, and enough product placement to put Mac and Me to shame. When the follow-up tanked, this incarnation of the ninja turtles was put to bed. With the recent adaptation, Rise of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles not fairing well on Netflix, it feels like the property is doomed to fail.
But there is hope. Because Seth Rogen's CGI adaption, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Mayhem, is set to be more in line with the source material and the original series, we might get our first good Ninja Turtles film in decades.
9. G.I. Joe
By the 1980s, the G.I. Joe toyline was as popular as He-Man or Transformers. It was so lucrative, Hasbro expanded the toys into a multimedia franchise. Before you knew it, G.I. Joe had his own comics, Saturday morning cartoon, and spin-offs. For many children, this action figure was the defining toy of the decade.
At least... in America. Although millions of kids were brought up with Duke, Roadblock, Heavy Duty, and Firefly, the rest of the world barely heard of them. Because the brand heavily focused on American soldiers, Joe never had much appeal outside the United States.
This posed a massive problem when Hollywood released the 2009 film adaptation, G.I. Joe: Rise of Cobra. Even though the film earned $150 million in the US, it made the exact same amount in every other country combined. The sequel, Retaliation, tried to salvage the potential money-maker by stuffing in more profitable actors like Dwayne Johnson and Bruce Willis. But due to poor box office returns and worse reviews, the film franchise seemed dead.
In 2021, Hollywood tried adapting G.I. Joe again, this time by telling an origin story of the series' most popular character, Snake Eyes. Unfortunately, this generic snoozefest bombed at the box office, earning a pitiful $40 million. At this moment, there's no discussion to release another instalment based on Hasbro's famous toy line. Based on how badly every film adaption has turned out, this should be a surprise to no one.
8. RoboCop
The 1980s had a hefty supply of fast-paced and intelligent action films, including Aliens, Predator, The Terminator, and Die Hard.
And who could forget about RoboCop? Even though the story of a dead cop turned into a cyborg sounds dumb, Paul Verhoeven turned this idea into a fast-paced, clever, thought-provoking satirical masterpiece.
RoboCop has become such a defining character in cinema, it's easy to forget that he has a grand total of ONE good movie. Not only did the sequels and reboot suck, the four TV series (yes, there have been that many) are borderline unwatchable.
Unlike other entries on this list, it's tricky to pinpoint why so many adaptations of RoboCop failed. The sequels and the remake weren't generic action flicks and maintained the satirical aspects of the original. And yet, they just didn't work.
Nevertheless, Hollywood is adapting the property once again. Director Abe Forsythe is pulling a Halloween by releasing a sequel called RoboCop Returns, which is a direct follow-up to the original, ignoring everything that came after.
Considering there are zero details about this project (including a release date), things aren't looking great for the future of RoboCop.
7. Universal Monsters
In the early 20th century, Universal's creature features ruled the theatres. They were so profitable, Frankenstein's Monster, Dracula, The Invisible Man, The Wolf Man, and The Mummy regularly crossed over with each other, conjuring the first cinematic universe into being.
Unfortunately, the Universal Monsters lost its appeal during the early 1960s, and has never recovered since. Over the last half a century, a decent adaptation of the studio's classic characters is released about once per decade.
But when the Marvel Cinematic Universe took off, Universal saw a golden opportunity. Since shared universes were all the rage, the studio believed it was the perfect time to forge a shared universe of their iconic monsters once again.
Sadly, this plan backfired immediately. The first instalment, Dracula Untold, was so forgettably generic, you probably forgot about it until now.
Instead of learning the error of their ways, the studio tried again, hoping their reboot of The Mummy would kick off their so-called Dark Universe. However, the film tried so hard to emulate Marvel's formula and humour, people who didn't even see the movie could smell the desperation from a mile away. Although a smorgasbord of follow-ups were planned, everything was scrapped when The Mummy was a dud.
But this former titan is not dead yet. After the Dark Universe dissolved, Universal took initiative and greenlit an Invisible Man adaptation that focused on telling a compelling story rather than setting up sequels and spin-offs. If the studio keeps looking at their properties like this, there is a chance the Universal Monsters films can recover.
6. Pinhead
The Hellraiser franchise declined so quickly, the biggest fans of Clive Barker's work may be oblivious to how many instalments there are. (They're ten, in case you were wondering.) Although the first two entries were well-received, every follow-up is god-awful. The last six sequels were so dreadful, they didn't warrant a theatrical release.
To understand why the series keeps failing, we need to look back at when it succeeded. The first Hellraiser blew viewers away with its cerebral gore, intelligent writing, expansive world-building, inventive monster designs, and genuine scares.
But what really put this movie on the map was Doug Bradley's towering performance as The Hell Priest, better-known by fans as Pinhead. This grid-faced demon is the film's defining character despite having ten minutes of screen-time.
And that's the key. The soul-tearing entity appeared just enough to showcase his power, but was never overused in the first instalment. Even though the character works best when used minimally, studios keep shoving him into every scene in the sequels, completely ruining what made the character stand out in the first place.
Hopefully, the reboot that's set for release this year will do right with the character for once.
5. Everyone In The Terminator
The Terminator launched James Cameron's career and turned Arnold Schwarzenegger into the biggest name in Hollywood almost overnight. Terminator 2: Judgment Day is regarded, not just as a perfect sequel, but among the greatest films ever made.
Then some studio tried to recapture that magic with Terminator 3. It didn't work. So, three different studios tried with three more sequels, each time receiving the same disappointing result.
But how can this keep happening? The actors and director of the original had almost no experience at the time, and yet, moulded a sci-fi masterpiece despite limited resources and money. How come there doesn't seem to be a single studio that can do it again?
Sadly, the Terminator has gone downhill for the same reason as most franchises - too much focus on money. Terminator 3's PG-rating was intended to maximise ticket sales but it diluted the threequel, turning it into a generic blockbuster. Salvation and Genisys focused more on creating a new trilogy rather than telling a singular story. Although Dark Fate was the best instalment in the series since Judgment Day, that just proves how much the bar has been lowered.
Because the franchise has been botched four times and Terminator 7 is officially cancelled (until the next inevitable reboot), it's clear the Terminator name will never be the same as it once was.
4. Robin Hood
No matter how popular a movie genre or franchise is, people can grow tired of it. Silent films, Flash Gordon, and Westerns dominated screens at one time, but now struggle to find an audience.
But one story that has endured longer than almost any other is Robin Hood. The British ballad is over 700 years old and yet, modern audiences are still fascinated by the heroic archer who robs from the rich and gives to the poor. Because his swashbuckling adventures feel timeless, you can understand why Robin Hood has been adapted to film and television dozens of times.
And yet, the bad adaptations far outweigh the good. In fact, it's difficult to think of the last Robin Hood film that was decent. The 2018 version was a travesty. Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves achieved the impossible by making the titular outlaw boring. Not even the great Ridley Scott could churn out a decent film about the legendary outlaw.
As depressing as it is to admit, the three best adaptations are The Adventures of Robin Hood (which is 84 years old), the Disney version, and the parody, Robin Hood: Men In Tights.
Although there's nothing stopping a studio from releasing a truly great retelling of Robin Hood, it hasn't happened in decades.
3. Fantastic Four
If you ask any group which is the best Fantastic Four film adaptation, there's always someone who will answer with, "The Incredibles". That may sounds like a joke but it's surprisingly accurate. Not only does Mr. Incredible and his family have the same powers as Marvel's First Family, Brad Bird's Pixar film captures the dynamic of the superhero quartet better than any Fantastic Four movie has.
The studio behind the 1994 Fantastic Four had so little faith in the project, they never released it, nor intended to. They only made a FF feature to keep the film rights for the property.
The 2015 version was a minimal effort, hampered by sloppy CGI, weak acting, and a bland script. The follow-up, Rise of the Silver Surfer, wasn't much better. Josh Trank's gritty reboot, Fant4stic, was so shoddy, it actually made viewers defend Batman & Robin.
Even though Marvel's first heroes have had a lot of bad luck, fans are still optimistic. Now that Marvel Studios have snagged the rights to adapt the property, the company can finally deliver a Fantastic Four film that's actually fantastic.
But we're not out of the woods yet. Until recently, the MCU seemed like a sure thing. But with interest and quality waning in the formerly untouchable franchise, we cannot guarantee the Fantastic Four reboot will be all that is promised. If the ball is dropped on the Fantastic Four for the fifth freakin' time, it's likely the property's reputation will be irredeemably tarnished.
2. Dark Phoenix
The Dark Phoenix plot in X-Men centres around founding member, Jean Grey, being corrupted by a cosmic entity called The Phoenix Force. After she becomes a galactic threat, the X-Men are forced to face her in battle, resulting in her death. The Dark Phoenix saga has been hailed as one of the most epic and emotional stories, not just in X-Men, but in all comics.
This tale is so monumental, it's no surprise it's been adapted to the big screen. But what is surprising is how filmmakers have totally screwed up this story. Twice.
X-Men 2 concluded with the Dark Phoenix plot being set up. But after director left the project, the script for the next instalment, X-Men: The Last Stand, was majorly revised, turning the most iconic X-Men story into a subplot.
So, when Jean Grey was reintroduced in the prequel, X-Men: Apocalypse, it looked like the franchise could redeem itself. Sadly, the follow-up, X-Men: Dark Phoenix, didn't work either. Because we barely had a chance to get to know this version of Jean, we didn't care what happened to her. Thanks to Jean's sporadic motivation and expository dialogue throughout the movie, the character and plot was wasted once again.
1. Everyone In Resident Evil
To the surprise of many, Paul W.S. Anderson's Resident Evil did better, critically and financially, than most video game adaptions. But after his series had five derivative sequels, fans were eager to see another filmmaker take a crack at adapting Capcom's legendary video game franchise.
Firstly, we got a slew of animated films, which centred on everyone's favourite curtain-haired hero, Leon Kennedy. But due to the forced dialogue and focus on action, we never cared about any of the characters. Unfortunately, the animated series, Resident Evil: Infinite Darkness, was more of the same.
Because the promos for Resident Evil: Welcome to Raccoon City highlight the survival horror aspect, it looked like we were finally getting the Resident Evil adaptation we deserved. But not only was Raccoon City another hackneyed mess, the characterisation was embarrassing. Leon Kennedy was turned into a cowardly wimp. Birkin was forgettable. Wesker was wasted.
Which brings us to the 2022 Netflix series, Resident Evil. Even though we were promised a scarefest from start to finish, we got a show filled with cringe-inducing dialogue and ridiculous dance numbers.
However, the biggest controversy that the series received was the portrayal of Albert Wesker, performed by Lance Reddick. Even though Reddick is a phenomenal actor, this incarnation of character is so far removed from the source material, you wonder why the filmmakers called him Wesker in the first place.
Years ago, Anderson was unanimously viewed as "the guy who destroyed Resident Evil". Upon reflection, his work is the closest any filmmaker or studio has gotten to getting the characters right or making the story remotely entertaining.