10 Iconic Comic Book Storylines That Are Currently Impossible

Outlandish arcs that couldn't yet be made in to movies.

Peter Parker Unmasked When it comes to making comic book movies, the various studios responsible for them have a near endless back catalogue of potential comic book story arcs to pluck their ideas from. We've already seen ideas like Extremis, Days of Future Past and various origin stories turned in to movies and next year's Age of Ultron is at least lending its name from a comic book arc. There is also clear evidence of an adaptation of the Infinity Gauntlet arc being adapted in to a movie, as Thanos attempts to gather the Infinity Stones in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. That said, there are also a number of great story arcs from throughout comic book history that simply can't be adapted on to the big screen for various - at least not for the time being anyway. Whether it's because the characters required haven't been introduced in movie universes yet, because certain required character rights are held in separate studios, because the concept simply wouldn't work in current movie universes or because of any other reason, some great stories simply wouldn't be possible in a movie right now - and that's what we're going to be looking at in this article. So, without further ado, here are ten iconic comic book storylines that are currently impossible and could not yet be turned in to a movie...

10. Secret Invasion (Marvel)

The 2008 Secret Invasion arc involved a subversive, long-term invasion of Earth by the alien race known as the Skrulls. Capable of shapeshifting, the Skrulls had secretly replaced many of Marvel's major superheroes with Skrull impostors over a long period of years, prior to the main invasion. It would be impossible to do in the current comic book movie climate, as the Skrulls aren't owned by Marvel Studios and their replacements in the Marvel Cinematic Universe - the Chitauri - have shown no signs of having any shapeshifting powers, so suddenly giving them to them would be silly. Plus, there has already been a massive infiltration storyline with HYDRA and S.H.I.E.L.D. so it would be far too repetitive. You might think it's possible in the Fox universe, but the whole alien thing wouldn't fit in the X-Men world and the Fantastic Four don't exist in that universe yet so, while it could be possible in the future, it certainly isn't at the moment.

9. One More Day (Marvel)

Spider-Man: One More Day was a 2007 arc in which, following the shooting of his Aunt May Parker, Spider-Man sought out help to save her life. He then encounters a woman who turns out to be the demon Mephisto in disguise. Mephisto says he can save Spider-Man's Aunt May in exchange for his marriage to Mary Jane Watson - if Aunt May is healed from her wounds, Spider-Man's relationship with Mary Jane would never have happened. After taking some time to think about it, the couple decide to go through with it on the basis that Spider-Man's identity becomes a secret again. Sure enough, Aunt May lived, nobody knew who Spider-Man really was and Mary Jane Watson and Spider-Man never became a couple. This arc could never happen in the current Amazing Spider-Man franchise as the supernatural concept of demons and reality altering magic just wouldn't work in what is a very science-based franchise. Simple as that.

8. Crisis On Infinite Earths (DC)

Crisis on Infinite Earths was a 1985 storyline that was one of the biggest events in DC history. It erased the DC Multiverse, rebooted many DC characters' origins and decreased the power levels of most of them (Superman, for example, dropped down the power scale massively after this arc). It also marked the end of the Silver and Bronze Ages of comic books. The story introduced readers to two near-omnipotent beings of opposing alignment - the good Monitor and the evil Anti-Monitor -who had been created as a result of the same experiment that created the Multiverse in the first place. The Monitor had been showing up in various DC comic book series for two years preceding the publication of the series and, at first, he appeared to be a new supervillain. However, as the Crisis event unfolded, he was revealed to be working on a desperate plan to save the entire Multiverse from destruction at the hands of the Anti-Monitor. It would be impossible to adapt in to a movie at the moment, as the concept of the DC Multiverse hasn't even been mentioned in the DC Cinematic Universe - and there simply aren't enough characters with origins and power levels to alter. As a result, the impact of what was a huge event in the comics would essentially be non-existent in a universe that is barely under way.

7. House Of M (Marvel)

House of M was a 2005 storyline that depicted a world in which mutants were the ruling majority and a group of super-heroes on Earth came together to decide what to do about the Scarlet Witch who had started to become increasingly mentally unstable. The X-Men were invited to Avengers Tower and a discussion took place that essentially saw the heroes deciding whether or not they should kill her, such was the threat she posed. However, Magneto - her father - was having none of that, took her away from the heroes and used her powers to create a new world. A conflict ensues in this new world - which has created more mutants and changed to roles of many heroes - but the heroes must band together to face Magneto and his forces. Scarlet Witch realises that Magneto actually cares more about mutant-kind in general than he does for her and, thanks to both that and her mental instability, says "no more mutants" and that's exactly what happens as a result. It wouldn't be possible in a movie at the moment for the simple reason that the Scarlet Witch doesn't exist in the X-Men movie universe. There are no mutants in the Marvel Cinematic Universe to get rid of - and there's nobody anywhere near powerful enough in the X-Men movie universe to take her place.

6. Batman: Year One (DC)

Batman: Year One was a 1987 arc which recounted both the beginning of Bruce Wayne's career as Batman and the beginning of Jim Gordon's career with the Gotham City Police Department. The story sees Bruce Wayne returning home to Gotham City, at the age of twenty-five, after training around the world in martial arts, man-hunting and science for the past twelve years, as well as depicting James Gordon moving to Gotham with his wife, Barbara, after a transfer from Chicago. Both men are very quickly introduced to the mass corruption and widespread violence of Gotham City and each set out to transform it in their own ways. In the current DC Cinematic Universe, it would be impossible to ever adapt this storyline, as the Batman we're going to be getting introduced to in the next film in 2016 is a seasoned veteran crime fighter. Ben Affleck - who is 42-years-old - will be portraying the Dark Knight, while no James Gordon has seemingly even been cast yet.

5. Blackest Night (DC)

Blackest Night was a 2009-2010 storyline, the premise of which is that, following a war between the willpower-fuelled Green Lanterns and the fear-fuelled Sinestro Corps, each team gets informed about a prophecy that states more corps will emerge and that they will all need to join forces in order to defeat the Black Lanterns €“ a corps of black ring-bearing heroes and villains who had died and been brought to life as undead monsters via the gift of the black ring. It saw returns for a huge number of dead heroes and villains and would make for a superb movie event that would combine the superhero genre with horror, as horrifying super-powered zombies attacked from every corner of the universe. It wouldn't currently work for a number of reasons - even disregarding the fact that Green Lantern doesn't yet exist in the DC Cinematic Universe. First, nowhere near enough heroes or villains have died to make a Black Lantern Corps interesting but, most importantly, the supernatural element wouldn't work. Granted, the franchise saw alien beings in its first movie but, with Batman being the next hero to appear, its still to grounded and science-based to accommodate an army of what are essentially ring-empowered zombies.

4. Avengers Vs X-Men (Marvel)

Avengers Vs X-Men was by no means great, but it was certainly a massive storyline when it was published in 2012. The story revolves around the coming to Earth of the Phoenix Force. It is deduced that it is coming for X-Men member Hope Summers and, when Captain America insists that the X-Men hand her over to the Avengers so they can place her in protective custody, Cyclops tells him that isn't going to happen, orders him to leave and a conflict breaks out, which eventually goes global. There is a very obvious reason why this can't currently happen - and that's because the Avengers and the X-Men belong to different movie studios and currently star in different franchises. Despite the fact that the comic book arc of this title wasn't received too well, there's no doubt that a movie would go down an absolute storm. Chris Evans' Captain America fighting Hugh Jackman's Wolverine, Chris Hemsworth's Thor against Michael Fassbender's Magneto and Scarlett Johansson's Black Widow duking it out with Jennifer Lawrence's Mystique, for example, would be awesome - and that make it a shame that it's not possible.

3. Civil War (Marvel)

Civil War was a spectacular 2006-2007 storyline which occurred following the implementation of the Superhuman Registration Act in the Marvel universe €“ the Superhuman Registration Act being a legislative bill which made superhumans register themselves as superheroes, but which saw a conflict occur between those behind the idea and those against it. It had the tagline €œWhose Side Are You On?€ While there's a possibility that something could be adapted on the big screen in future regarding this arc, there's absolutely no possibility of it being any time soon. For starters, there simply aren't even close to enough heroes in the Marvel Cinematic Universe to make it worthwhile, secondly there isn't a strong enough rivalry between different heroes to make it seem realistic (though there have been hints of a rift between Tony Stark and Steve Rogers) and, finally and most importantly, there's no sign of a Superhuman Registration Act (and no chance of it coming in to play any time soon, given that S.H.I.E.L.D. no longer exist in the Marvel Cinematic Universe and it is them who implement and enforce it).

2. Avengers/JLA (Marvel & DC)

Although we have our cinematic Avengers already and the cinematic Justice League are on their way, sadly - it goes without saying - there is absolutely no chance of teams squaring off like they did in this 2003-2004 crossover arc, which saw the two teams pitted against each other by Krona and the Grandmaster in a cosmic treasure hunt. Marvel Studios can't even use all of Marvel's own characters in the same movie universe - what with the characters currently being split between the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Sony's Amazing Spider-Man franchise and Fox's X-Men (and soon to be Fantastic Four) franchise - so the idea of being able to mix them up with characters from DC's Justice League is a million miles away from being possible. It would undoubtedly be very cool to see the likes of Chris Hemsworth's Thor duking it out with Henry Cavill's Superman or Jeremy Renner's Hawkeye taking on Ben Affleck's Batman, but it's absolutely nothing more than a dream at this stage (and whether or not anything like it will ever happen seems unlikely).

1. DC Vs Marvel (DC & Marvel)

In much the same way that JLA/Avengers is currently impossible for movie adaptation, DC Vs Marvel is as well - except this would be even more complex to do, even in the long-term. The story here was that two brothers who personified the DC and Marvel Universes became aware of the other's existence and challenged each other to a series of duels involving each universe's respective superheroes. The problem isn't only that a movie would require characters from both DC and Marvel - there's also the issue that it involved characters from all three of Marvel's different movie franchises. The likes of Thor and Captain America from the Marvel Cinematic Universe took on Captain Marvel and Batman respectively, Spider-Man from Sony's Amazing Spider-Man franchise took on Superboy, and Wolverine and Storm took on Lobo and Wonder Woman respectively (while characters like the Silver Surfer, who will be a part of the Fantastic Four reboot at some point, also had a battle with Green Lantern). The arc also allowed for viewer votes in the cases of some of the fights - and they could hardly do that with a movie! Essentially, a DC Vs Marvel movie will never happen - let alone now. So there you have it - ten iconic comic book storylines that are currently impossible and could not yet be turned in to a movie. Did you enjoy this article? Do you agree that these arcs currently couldn't be turned in to movies? Which other iconic arcs couldn't be given the Hollywood treatment yet? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section below. And please feel free to follow me on Twitter!

Contributor
Contributor

I'm a Tottenham Hotspur fan who loves comics and comic book movies.