10 Iconic Movie Characters With INSANE Continuity

Good luck following these crazy timelines!

leatherface prequel
Lionsgate

Some franchises go to amazing lengths to ensure that their continuity is perfect, leading to amazing pay-offs for fans when details are brought back for twists and surprise endings. However, many are less fastidious, especially if sequels are written or produced by different people, or if films are rebooted to serve a new Director's 'vision' of the story.

Many of the films on this list have tried to go in a creative direction, then written themselves into a corner. So have either messed with the timeline in order to fix the problems, or given up entirely and rebooted the whole series, ignoring the previous continuity.

Television spin-offs are another factor that can create problems, as they are often designed to give a fresh perspective on a story, and usually involve a different production team and actors. They are also frequently set in the modern era, so narratives from the original films (or books in some cases) need to be updated to be accessible to a modern audience and include updates in technology.

Lets try and untangle the web of continuity timelines of some of the worst-offending movie characters...

10. Bumblebee

Bumblebee Review
Paramount

The original Transformers film showed Megatron crashed on Earth several thousand years ago and was discovered in the Arctic in 1897. Sam Witwicky goes on to meet Bumblebee in 2007 on his mission to find the AllSpark. The sequel, Revenge of the Fallen, revealed that the Transformers actually arrived on Earth in 17,000 B.C. and had been living in hiding since before human civilization.

Dark of the Moon told us that the moon landing in 1969 was to investigate a crashed Autobot spacecraft with technology the Decepticons tried to use to transport to Earth until Bumblebee destroys it. The Government in Bumblebee, however, appears to have no knowledge of this event.

In Age of Extinction, the Earth was formed around a Transformer called Unicron, which was the ancient enemy of the Transformers’ home planet Cybertron and led to the extinction of the dinosaurs.

The Last Knight reveals that Transformers were on Earth since the dawn of time, and in 484 A.D. they helped Merlin and King Arthur beat the Saxons. Bumblebee went on to battle alongside the allies in World War II, in a Nazi-fighting squadron.

The film Bumblebee retconned this to show Bumblebee sent to Earth in 1987 (as opposed to 2007 in the first film), with no mention of his time during the war or the moon landing. He is the first Autobot to arrive and is hunted by two Decepticons who are working with the government to catch him who claim they are the first contact with humans.

What?


9. The Xenomorphs

Alien Xenomorph
20th Century Fox

The Xenomorph aliens were first encountered in Alien when the Nostromo ship investigated a distress signal on a planetoid LV-426. Their investigations resulted in a face-hugger attacking Kane, then bursting out of his chest and going on the rampage, until being destroyed by Ripley.

Prometheus and Alien: Covenant gave us an origin story for the Aliens, when we found out that android David, who was created by the Weyland Corporation in 2030, was the original bio-engineer of the aliens. He arrived at an unknown but habitable planet on the Prometheus and managed to bring alien embryos aboard the Covenant by impersonating their android Walter.

Alien vs Predator proceeded to completely negate this origin story when it revealed that the Predators had been breeding Xenomorphs for hundreds of years on Earth in order for them to hunt them as a rite of passage for young adults. This not only questions their origin, but also how they had managed to escape the notice of humans after being on their planet for so many years!


8. Michael Myers

Halloween Michael Myers 2018
Universal Pictures

The first two Halloween films showed Michael Myers as a young boy who killed his sister, then escaped from a mental institution as an adult and went after teenager Laurie Strode. It was then revealed Laurie was Michael’s other sister and Michael ends up presumably dying in an explosion.

The fourth, fifth and sixth films changed direction, introducing his niece Jamie, and a storyline about a cult cursing him to kill his family and trying to clone him as Jaime’s baby.

The reboot in 1998 disregarded the cult storyline and revealed Laurie Strode had faked her death and been in hiding for 20 years with her son. The film ends with her chopping Michael’s head off with an axe. However, the twist in the next film shows Laurie had instead killed someone dressed as Michael and he finds her again and kills her.

Rob Zombie then remade the original, showing Michael growing up in the institution. It was implied he wanted to have a relationship with Laurie, kidnapping her and trying to show her that they were family. He also has visions of his mother and this continuity ended with him being killed and Laurie apparently taking on his personality.

In a further reboot in 2018, Michael escapes after being institutionalised for 40 years and tracks down Laurie, now an old woman with a daughter and granddaughter. The film ends with them leaving him burning in the basement, but it is implied he survives, as two more films are planned for this instalment.


7. Connor MacLeod

Highlander - Connor MacLeod
20th Century Fox

The original Highlander film, set in 1985, told the tale of Connor MacLeod, a Scottish immortal who died in battle in 1536, came back to life, and now lives in New York with his adopted daughter. The immortals battle until one remains, collecting the combined power of all the others, and the film ends with Connor triumphant after defeating the others.

Highlander II: The Quickening was set in 2024 and came up with a back story for the immortals, claiming they were aliens from the planet Zeist sent to Earth to destroy each other as punishment for their crimes. This contradicted the first film where Connor is shown growing up as a child in Scotland. A Director’s cut removed all mention of aliens, changing to an ancient society that sent immortals to the future as punishment instead.

The third film ignored the second showing Connor now living in Marrakesh with his adopted son. He is attacked by further immortals, negating the premise in the first film that he had defeated them all, but he proceeds to be victorious again.

Highlander: Endgame tried to bridge the films with the TV series, in which the prize was never won because there were still many immortals. Connor is revealed to be an ancestor of Duncan MacLeod, the protagonist from the series. After Connor’s daughter is killed, he tells Duncan to behead him so he can pass on his power to him.


6. Wolverine (X-Men Cinematic Universe)

Wolverine X-Men Hugh Jackman
20th Century Fox

Born in 1832 as James Howlett, Wolverine's bone claw mutation manifested after his father was killed by groundskeeper Thomas Logan. Wolverine killed Logan before learning that he was his real father. He left with his half-brother, Victor (Sabretooth), and they fought together in several wars, surviving a firing squad due to their mutant healing abilities. They were recruited into William Stryker's black ops military mutant unit Team X. Now calling himself Logan, he eventually left, working as a lumberjack in Canada, before being recruited as Mystique's bodyguard in 1973.

Wolverine's timeline splits into two paths, hinging on the pivotal event of Mystique's murder of Bolivar Trask. Richard Nixon's government captures Mystique and uses her mutant DNA to advance their sentinel programme. Sabretooth kills Logan's girlfriend, and he consents to Stryker bonding adamantium to his bones to help him fight Victor. After being shot with an adamantium bullet, he becomes an amnesiac cage fighter where he meets Rogue and is recruited into the X-Men.

He ends up having to kill Jean Grey and the sentinels become a horrific mutant torture programme. In 2023 Kitty Pride sends Logan's consciousness back to his younger self in 1973 where he stops Mystique from assassinating Trask and persuades Nixon to shut down the sentinel programme. He returns to the future and everyone is alive again, only to all die when Professor X has a seizure that kills all the X-Men apart from Logan. Sadly, he goes on to die from adamantium poisoning, but might still appear in the MCU. Congratulations if you kept up.


5. Norman Bates

Norma And Norman Bates Motel
A&E

The Psycho film sequels and television series veer away from Robert Bloch’s books quite considerably.

Psycho II shows Norman escaping from the psychiatric hospital and dying in the novel, whereas he is released in the film. The film also introduces Norma’s sister Emma, who claims to be Norman’s real mother. The third film reveals that Emma was actually Norman’s aunt and she killed his father as she was in love with him and he chose Norma, however, the fourth film states that Norman’s father was stung to death by bees. The television series shows Norman killing his father after witnessing him abuse his mother.

Norma and her lover Joe are killed by Norman in film using strychnine, whereas in the series he kills his mother with carbon monoxide poisoning in an attempt to kill himself with her. Norman has a twin brother Robert in the novels but a half-brother Dylan in the TV series (from a relationship between Norma and her brother). The series also shows Norman killing Marion Crane’s lover Sam in the shower instead of her.

Norman’s final fate is either dying in a car crash in the books, surviving and recovering in the films (with a baby on the way), shot by Dylan in the 2013 television series, or dying of old age in the mental institution in the original 1987 television series!


4. Hannibal Lecter

Hannibal Lecter Mads Mikkelsen
NBC

The TV series Hannibal changed several details and altered Lecter's timeline significantly from the books and films. In the novels, Lecter first meets Will Graham after Graham reaches out to him as the doctor who treated one of the victims he is investigating. This ends with Graham realising that Lecter is the ‘Chesapeake Ripper’ and Lecter is arrested after attacking Graham.

In the series, Lecter is introduced as a psychiatrist and consultant to the FBI, who becomes Graham’s therapist when he is traumatised after having to kill a suspect he was investigating. The two develop a close friendship, working on cases and having therapy sessions until Graham realises Lecter’s secret.

Problems obtaining the rights to The Silence of the Lambs, including Clarice Starling and Buffalo Bill, meant that Lecter’s storyline in the show had to be changed. Whereas the novel Hannibal ends with Starling and Lecter becoming lovers and running away together, this is changed to Lecter having a relationship with his psychiatrist Bedelia Du Maurier and a closer friendship with Will Graham. The film Hannibal also ends in a different way with Starling handcuffing herself to Lecter to catch him then him cutting off his hand to escape.

Season 3 ended with Graham and Lecter falling off a cliff, and series creator Bryan Fuller revealed that if Season 4 had happened, Lecter and Graham would have been on the run from the FBI, mirroring Lecter and Starling’s story in the novels.


3. Spock

Mr Spock Star Trek The Original Series
CBS

Spock's timeline in the original Star Trek stated he was born in 2230 to Vulcan ambassador father Sarek and human mother Amanda Grayson and was raised on Vulcan. In 2266 he joined the Starship Enterprise as First Officer under Captain James Kirk on its five-year mission. He goes on to die in the second film The Wrath of Khan before being resurrected in the third film The Search for Spock.

His continuity becomes slightly altered in the fifth film The Final Frontier when we discover he has a half-brother Sybok, and in the television series Discovery, when we find out he also had an adopted sister Michael Burnham. Despite being raised with them, Spock never mentions either of them during the original television series.

Spock's timeline completely changes in the J. J. Abrams reboot films where he joins Starfleet in 2255 and attains the role of Commander by 2258, meeting Kirk when he is his instructor. They answer a distress call from the planet Vulcan and find out it is under attack from a Romulan, Nero, who came back 129 years from the future followed by an elderly Spock to destroy Vulcan as Spock had failed to save Romulus in the future. This sets off an alternative continuity.

Spock and Kirk go on to encounter Khan in this reality, but manage to stop him without Spock dying, and they continue to start the five-year mission on the Enterprise six years early in 2260.


2. Sarah Connor

Terminator Dark Fate Sarah Connor
Paramount Pictures

Sarah Connor’s fight against Skynet and the Terminators is portrayed in six films, a television series, a trilogy of novels and a comic book crossover with Superman!

Sarah’s continuity following the first two films goes in several different directions. An alternate ending to T2 shows her alive 30 years later, as a grandmother, with John a Senator and no trace of Skynet. Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines, however, reports that she died of leukaemia in 1997.

Terminator: Genisys, acts as an alternate reality to the previous films, with Sarah’s parents killed by a T-1000 when she was nine. She is found, raised and trained by a reprogrammed T-800. When Kyle arrives 11 years later it emerges John has been turned into an evil cyborg in the future so they time travel 33 years ahead to defeat him.

Terminator: Dark Fate disregards all the films since T2, revealing John was killed in 1998 by a T-800, leaving a grieving, alcoholic Sarah to eventually go on to help train the new future leader of the resistance, Dani.

The Sarah Connor Chronicles TV series shows Sarah and John time travelling ahead of when she should have died from cancer, with the help of a female terminator. The T2 novels show Sarah and John living undercover in Paraguay with their Austrian neighbour Dieter, who is the model for the T-800. Working with the FBI brother of Miles Dyson, they stop Skynet and Sarah ends up marrying Dieter.


1. Leatherface

Leatherface: Texas Chainsaw 3
New Line Cinema

The Texas Chainsaw continuity appears to have five different timelines with all the sequels and reboots!

The first two films show Leatherface living with his brothers and Grandpa. He is called ‘Bubba’ and his family is the Sawyers. The sequel ends with him being killed with a chainsaw and then blown up by the uncle of the victims in the first film. The third film ignores the second and shows him living with different brothers, ‘Mama’ Anne Sawyer, and his daughter(!). He is referred to as ‘Junior’, and survives the events.

The third timeline changes the family name to ‘Slaughter’ and introduces yet more brothers, a sister-in-law and the return of Grandpa. Leatherface is called ‘Leather’ in this incarnation and survives.

A remake of the original and a prequel backstory followed. Born in a slaughterhouse, his mother died during childbirth. Deformed and thrown in a dumpster, he was found by Luda Mae Hewitt, who raised him as her son Thomas. Leatherface survives, but with one arm cut off with a chainsaw.

The latest series consisted of a sequel and prequel to the original film. Leatherface (Jedidiah Sawyer) is taken to a mental institution as a boy and his mother Verna helps him escape as a teenager. His handsome face is torn in half by a bullet so she sews him up and puts a mask on him. Verna marries a rich man and Leatherface goes to live in the basement of her mansion until she dies and his cousin Heather inherits it.


In this post: 
Leatherface
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Acclaimed horror novelist and screenwriter... just kidding, eats pizza and watches horror movies with her cat