10 Incredibly Talented Actors Who Will Never Win An Oscar

Some actors have all the talent and none of the luck.

When you watch the Oscars, they're really supposed to be all about talent. The actors who win get a tremendous amount of prestige, and for the rest of their careers they get to be referred as "Oscar-winning". It's easily the biggest achievement in the acting industry, and many people consider it to be a benchmark of success in their field. But what many tend to forget is that unfortunately, the Academy Awards are not exactly what you might call strictly merit-based. Sure, talent plays into it. But there are a number of other factors that determine who walks away with a statue. Politics, the type of film you act in, the very specific taste of the elite base of Academy voters, how you present yourself during the award season, how much money your studio has to campaign for your film, even the perception of "deserving" an award after a previous snub...all of these and more play a huge role in whether you win, or are just another nominee. So it's disappointing but not really surprising when you realize just how many actors out there are totally deserving of an Oscar, but will likely never receive one. Maybe a Lifetime Achievement Award, but everyone knows that's just the Academy apologizing for screwing up while an actor was actually making films and trying to make up for it after the fact.


10. Ewan McGregor

Exactly what was it that made people stop seeing Ewan McGregor as a serious actor? Was it his foray into the Star Wars universe, films that make every single actor involved seem like a wooden puppet? Or maybe his proclivity for getting his kit off in nearly every film that he did early on in his career? People focus on some of the sillier roles that he's done, and to be fair he hasn't always picked the best material. But it seems like a lot of other actors would be steeped in acclaim if they had half the body of work that McGregor has. His performance in Trainspotting may have been many years ago, but it's iconic. And more recently, he turned in a heart-wrenching performance in The Impossible, which could have wallowed in sentimentality but somehow managed to express real human emotion. Not every film he's done has been Oscar-worthy, but the fact that he's never even been nominated is honestly a bit shocking.

9. Johnny Depp

Hollywood is a tough town, and there's no way to sugar coat this: Johnny Depp has ruined his career. His insistence on constantly collaborating with Tim Burton to give the same old tired, eccentric performances in over half a dozen films in as many years has turned him into a joke. Which is a shame, because once upon a time he was one of the most acclaimed actors of his generation. If you go back and watch him in Ed Wood, he's such a bright, natural talent. And honestly, he probably should have won an award for that movie. But over the past decade and a half, he's consistently taken the same type of characters which allowed him to be lazy and collect a fat paycheck. And that choice to sacrifice his creative integrity, something that used to mean a lot to him, has cost him the one thing that matters most in the eyes of the people handing out the little gold statues: his legitimacy as an actor. Even if he does get his act together and start turning in great performances again, it's going to take a lot to repair his damaged reputation.

8. Liam Neeson

Listen, there's no judgment on Liam Neeson here. He found a way to rebrand himself as an action hero and continue to make a lot of money as he begins to head into his twilight years, and that's fine. His movies are fun and exciting, and his tough as nails persona is a perfect fit for the ex-boxer. But peel back Taken and A Walk Among the Tombstones and The Grey, and you'll find someone who used to be a really good actor. If you go and watch films like Kinsey and Schindler's List, it's hard not to feel like he's just on autopilot now. Can you really blame him, though? He played Oskar Schindler in Schindler's List, and he acted the hell out of that role. But he still didn't get the Academy Award. At that point, he was probably thinking that he was never going to be able to top that so why even bother trying? Still, credit where credit's due: he's got a thriving film career...just not the type that seems likely to be recognized by the Academy anytime soon.

7. Jamie Bell

Jamie Bell has been impressing audiences since he was a little kid and carried the surprise hit Billy Elliot, where he danced and acted his way into everyone's heart. He's one of the few child actors who has aged into an adult performer with grace, and has consistently chosen thoughtful and interesting roles. Which, sadly, is why he'll probably never end up being an Oscar-winner. He has a tendency to take on supporting roles, more comfortable as a sidekick rather than a leading man, and rarely takes on projects that are huge blockbusters. Bell also seems uneasy with the title of movie star, preferring to work on personally rewarding films rather than Oscar bait. Luckily for him, he seems perfectly fine with the idea of never taking home an Oscar, and seems to relish the life of a working actor much more than that of a celebrity.

6. Jake Gyllenhaal

It's sort of hard to pin down exactly why Jake Gyllenhaal is so underrated. Maybe because everyone made such a huge deal out of Donnie Darko, and now they're trying to temper their reactions for everything he's done since then? If your first major role ends up being such an iconic film, that becomes hard to top. And when a movie comes out and gets so much attention that it starts to be considered overrated, that label sticks with its star for much longer than it's applicable. Because Jake Gyllenhaal has been involved in a lot of really solid films since he started acting at the tender age of ten, but he doesn't get as much recognition as he probably should. In Brokeback Mountain, his performance was overshadowed by the stoic, nuanced turn of his onscreen lover played by the late Heath Ledger. Sure, he's had his share of missteps (looking at you, Bubble Boy and Prince of Persia), but for the most part, his work has been reliable and worthy of praise. Maybe things will change for him in the future, but right now it seems like he's doomed to never get the respect he deserves.

5. Robert Downey Jr

To be fair, this one could go either way. On the one hand, Hollywood loves a good redemption narrative, which Robert Downey Jr has in spades. To have been a young star with so much talent, then end up in jail on drug charges, and somehow manage to fight his way back to respectability as an actor...that's a truly remarkable story. But at the same time, it sort of feels like if they didn't throw awards at him when he was actively doing prestige films, like when he basically embodied the spirit of Charlie Chaplin back in the early 90s, it doesn't seem likely that they'll suddenly start handing them out while he's doing superhero movies and Sherlock Holmes. No disrespect to either of those franchises, but they're exactly the sort of films that the Academy frequently turns their noses up at. Frankly, it's astonishing that he was given a nomination for his work in Tropic Thunder. Maybe that's as far as the Academy's good will towards Mr Downey will extend, and he'll just have to be satisfied with a Lifetime Achievement Award twenty years or so down the line.

4. Edward Norton

One thing that the film industry does not forgive easily is an actor who makes waves. In the case of Edward Norton, it involves trying to exert more creative control over his films than the directors and producers are entirely comfortable with. Back when he made American History X, he turned in a breathtakingly vulnerable performance, but he also disagreed with the direction of the movie so much that he ended up working on the final cut with a different editor, and the original director Tony Kaye campaigned to get his name taken off the credits. More recently, he was cast as Hulk in The Incredible Hulk, and despite a respectable box office showing, the decision was made to hire Mark Ruffalo for the role when the time came to make The Avengers. While they've never come right out and given a reason for his dismissal, it's more than likely that there was some serious conflict between the opinionated actor and the Marvel producers. No matter how good of an actor he is, and no matter how much some people like to work with him, there's still that niggling reputation that he has as being "difficult" that will always hurt his chances of winning an Oscar.

3. Naomi Watts

Realistically, Naomi Watts has done just as many great films as other actors her age who have been rewarded at Oscar time. It highlights the arbitrariness of acting awards when you can point to an accomplished actress like Watts and wonder if she's any less deserving than, say, Nicole Kidman or Sandra Bullock. Have their careers really been any more rich and varied than hers to have merited the title of Oscar winning actress? She's been nominated twice over the years, for 21 Grams back in 2004 and for The Impossible two years ago, but each time she was beaten out. (Once by Charlize Theron and once by Jennifer Lawrence, which proves that there's nothing Hollywood loves more than beautiful actresses who make themselves ugly for a film and gorgeous young ingenues.) Time is not on Naomi Watts' side, either: history suggests that the Academy Awards are a young woman's game, and at 47 she is older than 63 out of 74 Best Actress winners. The Academy loves to reward their nubile 20-something actresses, and by this point everyone should be well aware that they aren't exactly stellar at writing good roles for older women.

2. Joaquin Phoenix

Look, there's no way around this. Hollywood may have many flaws, but they have a long memory. And the Powers That Be did not take kindly to that stunt that he pulled a few years back where he made a fool out of everyone (honestly, including himself) by pretending to have gone off the deep end pursuing a really terrible rap career, but actually was just making a really terrible faux documentary. Because art. After his ridiculously talented older brother River died tragically at a young age, they really wanted to embrace a narrative where his career was a feel-good story about natural talent and getting to honor his brother's legacy, but after a certain point the Hollywood elite seemed to decide that he was just too out there. Which is a shame, because he has turned in some really fantastic performances over the years and what, like it's uncommon to run across some eccentric actors willing to do weird stuff for their art?

1. John Hurt

If the Academy wasn't going to give John Hurt an Oscar for his work in The Elephant Man, one of the greatest film performances of all time, it's safe to say that they're probably just never going to give him one. Exactly what does the man have to do to get a little recognition? Since his career began in 1962, the English actor pulled off several top notch performances, but has always somehow fallen short of the big prize. When he was nominated in 1979 for his work in Midnight Express, he was passed over for Christopher Walken in The Deer Hunter, a film that preyed on lingering antipathy for the hugely unpopular Vietnam War to win over audiences. Two years later, he was nominated for The Elephant Man, and any other year he probably would have won...only in 1981 he was facing off Robert De Niro as Jake La Motta, a towering performance that is considered to this day one of the greatest ever. John Hurt was a victim of bad timing, that's all, but the sad truth is that at 75, he's not getting any younger, and his window for making another truly great film is getting narrower and narrower with every passing year.

Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.