10 Incredibly Talented Actors Who Will Never Win An Oscar
Some actors have all the talent and none of the luck.
When you watch the Oscars, they're really supposed to be all about talent. The actors who win get a tremendous amount of prestige, and for the rest of their careers they get to be referred as "Oscar-winning". It's easily the biggest achievement in the acting industry, and many people consider it to be a benchmark of success in their field. But what many tend to forget is that unfortunately, the Academy Awards are not exactly what you might call strictly merit-based. Sure, talent plays into it. But there are a number of other factors that determine who walks away with a statue. Politics, the type of film you act in, the very specific taste of the elite base of Academy voters, how you present yourself during the award season, how much money your studio has to campaign for your film, even the perception of "deserving" an award after a previous snub...all of these and more play a huge role in whether you win, or are just another nominee. So it's disappointing but not really surprising when you realize just how many actors out there are totally deserving of an Oscar, but will likely never receive one. Maybe a Lifetime Achievement Award, but everyone knows that's just the Academy apologizing for screwing up while an actor was actually making films and trying to make up for it after the fact.
10. Ewan McGregor

9. Johnny Depp

8. Liam Neeson

7. Jamie Bell

6. Jake Gyllenhaal

5. Robert Downey Jr

4. Edward Norton
One thing that the film industry does not forgive easily is an actor who makes waves. In the case of Edward Norton, it involves trying to exert more creative control over his films than the directors and producers are entirely comfortable with. Back when he made American History X, he turned in a breathtakingly vulnerable performance, but he also disagreed with the direction of the movie so much that he ended up working on the final cut with a different editor, and the original director Tony Kaye campaigned to get his name taken off the credits. More recently, he was cast as Hulk in The Incredible Hulk, and despite a respectable box office showing, the decision was made to hire Mark Ruffalo for the role when the time came to make The Avengers. While they've never come right out and given a reason for his dismissal, it's more than likely that there was some serious conflict between the opinionated actor and the Marvel producers. No matter how good of an actor he is, and no matter how much some people like to work with him, there's still that niggling reputation that he has as being "difficult" that will always hurt his chances of winning an Oscar.3. Naomi Watts

2. Joaquin Phoenix
Look, there's no way around this. Hollywood may have many flaws, but they have a long memory. And the Powers That Be did not take kindly to that stunt that he pulled a few years back where he made a fool out of everyone (honestly, including himself) by pretending to have gone off the deep end pursuing a really terrible rap career, but actually was just making a really terrible faux documentary. Because art. After his ridiculously talented older brother River died tragically at a young age, they really wanted to embrace a narrative where his career was a feel-good story about natural talent and getting to honor his brother's legacy, but after a certain point the Hollywood elite seemed to decide that he was just too out there. Which is a shame, because he has turned in some really fantastic performances over the years and what, like it's uncommon to run across some eccentric actors willing to do weird stuff for their art?1. John Hurt
