10 Most Inept Film Directors
Much fun is to be had with inept directors, whether is is wetting yourself laughing at their terrible films or putting out a petition for them to retire. What is amusing to note about inept directors is their profligacy and intestinal fortitude. The critics may hate them but they keep on beavering away adding new inept films to their repertoire whether people like it or not. Most of the directors in this list are cult directors. There may be terrible directors working in mainstream Hollywood. I don't know mainstream so I can't comment upon them, but I would be interested if you told me about them below. Feel free to add your very own inept director and enjoy the list!
10. Ulli Lommel
Given a break by Fassbinder as an actor, Lommel starred in many Fassbinder films which I quite enjoy, being a student of the German language. When Fassbinder died, left with no roles to fill, Lommel turned director and this is when it begins to get decidedly dodgy. His film, Die Zärtlichkeit der Wölfe was critically acclaimed and gathered a cult following. Lommel moved to America to see what he could do. He released a load of very mediocre films (apart from The Boogeyman which I will admit was a fun movie) right up into the 1990s and beyond - concentrating on horror. He is on his list primarily because of his dire direct to video Serial Killer films which are horribly directed, insipid and inept. Lommel gives serial killers a remarkably shallow treatment that reveals nothing about the subject and simultaneously bores the arse off the viewer. Utterly pointless as a director.
9. Ted V Mikels
Apartheid Slave Women's Justice. Now that is going to be a good film! Just one of Ted V Mikel's many colourful titles over the years. Few directors have thrown themselves into film making with such gusto and abandon as Mikels, creating his own personal visions rather than having to bow to Studio Diktat. Of course his films are all uniformly terrible to watch and ineptly constructed. They did the rounds of the drive ins and grindhouses where they gathered a cult following for their cheesy special effects and off the wall plots. The Corpse Grinders, Astro Zombies (which totally wasted the presence of the great Tura 'Faster Pussycat' Satana), 10 Violent Women, Blood Orgy of the She Devils - these films sound much better on paper than they are on the screen. Mikels was infamous for many years for living with his own personal 'Harem' of women in a castle. He has, since the mid 1990s, run his own production company - TVM Productions in Las Vegas. I hardly think he will be churning out Oscar nominated films, but Mikels has an enthusiasm in his films that makes them infectious to watch even though they are really, really bad.
8. Andy Milligan
An openly gay man who hated women, Milligan directed an abundance of ineptly made horror and exploitation films. He was apparently a very ill tempered and demanding director which is amusing because he couldn't direct for toffee. He picked fights with everyone, and as a tee totaller he was known to blow a gasket if anyone dared to smoke, drink alcohol or do drugs near him. Most of Milligan's work features horrible people sitting around bitching about each other and the world who eventually get their comeuppance in a display of didactic morality. To cover up his low budgets - frequently under $10,000 - he was famous for using the 'swirl' technique during violent scenes to distract the viewer from the shoddiness of the special effects. Cinematic atrocities perpetrated by Andy Milligan include The Ghastly Ones (which inexplicably ended up on the Video Nasties list), Fleshpot on 42nd Street and The Degenerates. He is widely considered to be the Worst Horror Movie Director Ever - he makes H G Lewis look like Luchino Visconti. I personally find his films intolerable to watch as they are so inept, not to mention the extremely crap acting and portrayal of so many unlikeable characters. Everyone is up to something and they kvetch away in an annoying manner for long periods of time without some action to mitigate their mean spiritedness. One thing is sure, if a cult around Milligan does appear, it will be full of morons.
7. Lucifer Valentine
On the list because he gave us Slaughtered Vomit Dolls, with which he tried single handedly to promote the subgenre of 'vomit gore'. Nobody joined in but Mr Valentine ploughed ahead with two sequels to Slaughtered Vomit Dolls - ReGOREgitated Sacrifice and Slow Torture Puke Chamber. It is not just the inclusion of vomit based capers that makes these films so inept, although the constant puking does not add to their appeal (except to emetophiles round the world). To construct a trilogy of films around vomiting is not big and it's not clever. But the films themselves are completely inept and bewildering. The plots of the films are negligible, the acting atrocious and the direction all over the place. In fact, the plots in the three movies fail to deliver any shocks or scares because they exist solely as a vehicle to showcase copious vomiting. Not as scary or disturbing as their reputation suggests, these films are just sick, sick and then sick again (literally!). Pathetic shock mongering.
6. Bruno Mattei
Referred to as 'The Ed Wood' of Italian cinema, Mattei was the ultimate Italian hack exploitation director in a sea that was full of them. Nobody I know in Italian cinema perpetrated filmic atrocities quite as bad as Mattei. I believe that an affectionate cult is growing around Mattei and his films. I will never be part of this. He is not inept enjoyable, he is inept bloody awful. Mattei directed a lot of Italian exploitation crap. His actors couldn't act, the dialogue was corny, the gore was lame, and Mattei stole footage and soundtracks from other films (most notably Goblin's soundtrack from Romero's Dawn of the Dead which popped up in the risible Zombie Creeping Flesh). Even Mattei himself said that his films were 'ugly' and he would have liked to reshoot them all. The only fun moment I ever had with a Mattei film was in Violence in a Women's Prison in which a bitch fight breaks out among a sea of human turds. And if that is the height of enjoyment you can get out of a director's oeuvre, his films must be pretty paltry stuff to watch.
5. Ed Wood Jnr

4. Doris Wishman
After being widowed at a young age, Doris Wishman got into the film industry and became a director of exploitation films. Her early career began with nudist films in the early 1960s. The most prominent of these was Nude on the Moon which featured a laughable storyline (a man inherits money and makes a rocket to go to the moon which is populated with telepathic women walking around with their breasts on show), poor dubbing of voices, lamentable acting and special effects that wouldn't hoodwink my dog. Wishman's films - whatever the subject and however poorly made, retain a charm built on goofy innocence. In two terrible, terrible movies, Wishman utilised the talents of 'Chesty Morgan' an average looking woman of Polish descent who couldn't act for toffee but possessed gigantic natural knockers - bigger than any actress in a Russ Meyer movie ever flaunted. The ensuing films - Deadly Weapons and Double Agent 73 were so jaw droppingly bad, they reached sublime heights of cinematic ineptitude. Miss Morgan's breasts are so vast, they inspire terror rather than arousal. Let Me Die a Woman in 1978, is Wishman's next notable exploitation feature which explored the world of sex changes in an oh so restrained manner. The concept of transexualism is handled so badly the film is stratospheric in its ineptitude - replete with graphic surgery of penis removal, interviews with trans-gendered people, a 'credible' doctor doing the narration (reminded me of Dr Francis B Gross in Faces of Death), and doctors probing a newly formed vagina. It was a tasteless affair and thus unintentionally hilarious - like so much of Wishman's work. It didn't surprise me to learn that Wishman had tried her hand at hard core porn film making. I have not seen her porn film efforts but I can't imagine they would be very erotic given Wishman's ineptitude. Nevertheless, she is a director who inspires affection amongst cult movie fiends because of her.naïve charm. Or maybe she was a cynical ham fisted cow. I will leave the verdict up to you.
3. Herschell Gordon Lewis
Herschell Gordon Lewis, known as the Godfather of Gore and probable instigator of the slasher movie, is an incredibly eloquent and avuncular man. Before he got into film making, he was a Professor of English, but he decided film making would be more lucrative. Lewis teamed up with notorious exploitation producer David Friedman and in 1963, they set about making the film Blood Feast. A wily man, Lewis hit upon the idea of gore and blood and guts to sell his movies. Audiences had not really experienced gory violence in American drive ins or movie theatres. Blood Feast was made on a minimal budget and it consisted of an Egyptian caterer called Fuad creating an altar to the Goddess Ishtar. He does this by mutilating women - taking a heart, a brain, a tongue, limbs etc. Eventually people twig on to his murderous shenanigans and that's the end of Fuad. Blood Feast was a massive success. It is such a gruesome film, 20 years after its inception, it was plonked on the Video Nasty list in Britain. However, Blood Feast is technically inept and really shows that Lewis had minimal training in how to make a film. This ineptitude plagued Lewis' films until he retired with the Gore Gore Girls in 1972. I actually think it is his ineptitude that endears Lewis to fans. But some may argue - who cares about technical stuff when Lewis was achieving his goal to gross out cinema audiences? Lewis' films, however, suffer from some very poor acting - dreadful acting and terrible dialogue - "Go fumigate yourself, craphead!" in She Devils On Wheels, is a typical Lewis line. While I think its hilarious, most cinema goers would have limited appreciation of Lewis' films - they are too 'bad'. The special effects are of the animal innard ilk, the gore and brutality in his films is extreme but it is clearly dummies who are copping spikes to the head, disembowelment, and getting their faces mashed in. Sometimes Lewis' films are so inept, they are downright bizarre. Check out The Gruesome Twosome in which 10 minutes or so of footage is taken up at the beginning of the movie with two styrofoam dummy heads with faces painted on them having a conversation! Lewis' artistic ineptitude has worked in his favour, with lovers of camp and bad movies revering him as a cult director. I think Lewis knew he was churning out garbage and I think he is amazed by the fans today who love his trash. As an HG Lewis mega fan, I find it hard to justify my love of his films. They are just so inept it is brilliant!
2. Jess Franco
Another contender for the title of 'The European Ed Wood', Jess Franco is a director who fiercely divides lovers of cult cinema - he is like Marmite - you either think his movies are total trash or overlooked exploitation gems. I stand somewhere between the two grounds. Franco produced a few gems, but 90% of his oeuvre was really crap. At his best, Franco directed mysterious, erotic and engaging pieces of cinema such as Female Vampire, Sadomania, Succubus and Count Dracula. At his worst he made confusing garbage with endless shots of women writhing naked in bed, zooming the camera on their pubic regions. Franco had some very good ideas and themes, and he was true to his own obsessions but he didn't half produce some rubbish - usually because he was a very prolific director who just wanted to get the film he was shooting over, so that he could start directing another slice of his fevered imagination. Poor budgets had a lot to do with it as well. I have watched a heck of a lot of Jess Franco movies, and I have about 10 of his films still in shrinkwrap. This sort of symbolises my attitude about him being like Marmite. I must say that any Franco film with Soledad Miranda or Lina Romay in it is worth watching for the sensuality of the two leading ladies. However, The vast bulk of Franco films are irredeemably badly made and thoroughly inept. I still love him though (I think...)
1. Uwe Boll
Described as the 'Ed Wood of the 21st Century', Uwe Boll has inspired flak and hatred for his inept approach to film making. Amazingly, the man has a doctorate in literature. His career would have been less ignominious if he spent it in academia. Boll is well known for a series of video games to movie interpretations that have all been pretty dire. His films are notorious for bombing at the box office in America. House of the Dead and Alone in the Dark are two films which are regularly excoriated to the high heavens by critics and are used as examples to showcase the ineptitude of Boll's film making. Critics called the two films so bad that other 'bad' directors could say "Well at least I didn't direct those films". His name now inspires terror in the video game world. Rumours are that he wanted to make an adaptation of Metal Gear Solid. When the creator of the MGS games was questioned about Boll's interest, he nearly had a heart attack. Boll wanted to make a World of Warcraft film and was told the movie rights would not be sold "especially to you". You know that you are hated whenever the Guardian newspaper holds a petition for you to retire and it gets 1,000,000 signatures. Boll is always game to stand up for himself in the face of almost overwhelming critical hostility. He has rather maturely called some of his critics "retards" and told some of them to "go f**k your mother". He challenged them all to a boxing match which is a bizarre way to try and prove your worth with the critics - maybe you should start making decent films instead. Nevertheless, the boxing matches went ahead and Boll beat up his critics. If he put the dedication he spends on rubbing critics up the wrong way into films, he could come up with something fairly good. But probably not.