10 Infamous Movie Plot Holes That Have Simple Explanations
Plot holes? Not really.
As much as online film discourse can be enriching and enhance the meaning of the movies we watch, it also becomes an arena for people to voice their discovery of supposed "plot holes" - whether reasonable or not.
By 2020, it feels like the term has lost all meaning, given how many believe a plot hole to be something which simply isn't explained to the audience, rather than an aspect of the story which actually breaks its internal logic.
These 10 movies, all classic works of cinema, have been raked over the coals by fans convinced they've found a narrative-derailing plot hole which makes it impossible to ever think about them the same way again.
But alas, this just isn't true at all, because these 10 apparent plot holes all have perfectly reasonable explanations, whether a result of basic deduction or the filmmakers themselves actually chiming in to clear things up.
Occam's razor states that the simplest solution to a problem is usually the right one, and that's absolutely the case with these 10 supposed lapses in story logic...
10. Why Does Buzz "Play Dead" Despite Not Believing He's A Toy? - Toy Story
The "Plot Hole"
If Buzz Lightyear (Tim Allen) doesn't believe that he's a toy, then why does he still play dead whenever humans enter the room? If he truly believes himself not to be a toy, wouldn't he quickly ruin the ruse for everyone and cause chaos?
The Explanation
It's been apocryphally suggested - albeit unproven - that an earlier draft of the movie's script saw Buzz playing dead in order to assimilate to the natural customs of the "planet" he landed on.
But a far more concrete answer was offered up by Lee Unkrich, who co-edited the first two Toy Story movies and directed the third.
According to Unkrich, Buzz's behaviour is governed by sheer involuntary instinct, a behaviour inherent in the creation of toys that's seemingly as natural as breathing is for humans:
9. How Did Bruce Get Back To Gotham? - The Dark Knight Rises
The "Plot Hole"
After Bruce Wayne (Christian Bale) finally manages to escape from Bane's (Tom Hardy) hellish, remote underground prison, how was he able to get back to Gotham City? And how did he do so without being detected by Bane, given that he had Gotham on full lockdown?
The Explanation
Beyond the obvious "He's Batman!" explanation - which really should've been sufficient - this is a symptom of the film's extreme time compression, as Bruce goes from trapped in Bane's prison to back in Gotham within just five minutes of screen time.
If you were paying attention to what Lucius Fox (Morgan Freeman) said just a few scenes before Bruce escaped, though, you'd know that there was a 23-day countdown until Bane's neutron bomb would decay enough to detonate.
As such, Bruce had more than three weeks to figure out his way home, which for a man of his skill-set isn't much of an ask.
Given that Batman Begins made it abundantly clear worldwide travel on minimal resources wasn't much of a stretch for him, as well as establishing that the Batcave is connected to the Underground Railroad through a series of tunnels, there was ample time and opportunity for Bruce to make it back into Gotham undetected.
8. How Can Kevin Order A Pizza If The Phone Lines Are Down? - Home Alone
The "Plot Hole"
If Kevin's (Macaulay Culkin) parents are unable to call him due to a tree falling on nearby phone lines during a storm, how is Kevin still able to call up Little Nero's for a pizza delivery later in the movie?
The Explanation
It's a fair enough question, albeit one answerable with some technical knowledge about how phone calls actually work. A Redditor with the necessary know-how suggested the accident only affected long-distance calls:
"I always assumed the tree actually severed the main trunk line to the whole town, but local calls within the same exchange still worked."
And if you didn't want to take a mere Reddit user's word for it, The Huffington Post reached out to AT&T Vice President-Federal Regulatory Hank Hultquist, who confirmed as much:
"Everything is changing now because all of this phone capability is moving into the cloud, but in 1990, that was absolutely a plausible scenario. When you’re trying to call from Paris, now you’re relying on a whole series of connections including undersea cables, any one of which could have a problem, which would prevent you from reaching some particular telephone number."
7. When Can You Actually Feed A Mogwai If It's Always "After Midnight?" - Gremlins
The "Plot Hole"
If you're not supposed to feed a Mogwai after midnight, when can you feed them again in the morning? What time qualifies as not "after midnight?"
The Explanation
Though there's never been a purely official explanation for this, employing some pretty basic common sense would allow most people to make a safe(ish) assessment.
Though the instructions are far from ideal, we can logically deduce that the rule is probably based on the Mogwai's own internal body clock, and so they will likely be safe to feed again at sunrise in the morning, ideally after they've been to sleep and woken up again.
As for the oft-cited issue of what would happen if you took a Mogwai on a plane across time zones?
It's probably best to give them a large meal a few hours before heading to the airport just as you would any other domestic pet, and not feed them again until the next sunrise in your new destination to ensure you compensate for any let jag.
6. How Did McClane Know "Bill Clay" Was Hans Gruber? - Die Hard
The "Plot Hole"
When Hans Gruber (Alan Rickman) affects an American accent and pretends to be a hostage by the name of Bill Clay, how did John McClane (Bruce Willis) know that he was actually a terrorist? Isn't that rather convenient deduction for a supposedly "regular" cop?
The Explanation
This apparent logical leap is caused by a small scene which was cut from the movie, in which Hans and his fellow terrorists synchronise their watches, revealing to the audience that the terrorists are all wearing the exact same timepiece.
And so, all is revealed to John when he offers a cigarette to "Bill," allowing John to see his wrist and notice that he's wearing the same time-piece as everyone else. In the words of co-writer Steven E. de Souza himself:
"When Bruce offers the cigarette to Alan Rickman, Bruce sees the watch. You see his eyes look at the watch. That's how he knows that he is one of the terrorists."
5. How Did Andy Re-Attach The Poster After Escaping? - The Shawshank Redemption
The "Plot Hole"
How was Andy Dufresne (Tim Robbins) able to re-attach the iconic Raquel Welch poster to cover the hole he escaped through? Doing so from inside the hole would be physically impossible.
The Explanation
This one's easily explained: he didn't. The poster is large enough to cover the entirety of the hole without blowing around in the draughty confines of a prison cell, and so Andy simply didn't bother securing the bottom corners to the prison wall.
It's even demonstrated earlier in the film when we see Andy digging the hole with his head under the poster, confirming that it was only attached at the top.
And so, when Andy made his escape, all he had to do was make sure the poster was sufficiently draped over the hole.
4. How Did Thanos Bring His Army To The Future? - Avengers: Endgame
The "Plot Hole"
How was 2014 Thanos (Josh Brolin) able to bring not only the Black Order but also his entire army to the present 2023 timeline with only a small number of Pym Particles?
The film explicitly states that a Pym Particle is required for every individual entity attempting to time travel, so how did Thanos create tens of thousands (if not more) for his army?
The Explanation
Co-director Joe Russo was unsurprisingly asked about this during the week of Endgame's release, and sensibly deferred to the simplest solution being the right one:
"There is a guy called Maw in [Thanos'] army, he was a great wizard. Thanos himself was a brilliant genius as well. Those two easily reverse engineered and mass produced Pym Particles."
Russo is of course referring to Black Order member Ebony Maw (Tom Vaughan-Lawlor) - aka Squidward - who was able to magick up as many Pym Particles as Thanos needed. Simples.
3. Why Don't Marty's Parents Recognise Him 30 Years Later? - Back To The Future
The "Plot Hole"
Given that Marty McFly (Michael J. Fox) was so pivotal in ensuring his parents George (Crispin Glover) and Lorraine (Lea Thompson) got together, why didn't they recognise him as their son 30 years later?
The Explanation
Given that Marty spends just around a week in 1955, it's completely believable that even Lorraine, upon whom Marty left a clear impression, would have only a faded memory of him some three decades later.
Memory is notoriously unreliable, and even if Lorraine and George saw a resemblance between their son and "Calvin Klein," there are literally hundreds of explanations a rational person would settle on before accepting the whole time travel premise.
In a recent interview, the film's co-writer Bob Gale confirmed as much:
"Bear in mind that George and Lorraine only knew Marty/Calvin for eight days when they were 17, and they did not even see him every one of those eight days. So, many years later, they still might remember that interesting kid who got them together on their first date.
But I would ask anyone to think back on their own high school days and ask themselves how well they remember a kid who might have been at their school for even a semester. Or someone you went out with just one time. If you had no photo reference, after 25 years, you'd probably have just a hazy recollection.
So Lorraine and George might think it funny that they once actually met someone named Calvin Klein, and even if they thought their son at age 16 or 17 had some resemblance to him, it wouldn't be a big deal. I'd bet most of us could look through our high school yearbooks and find photos of our teen-aged classmates that bear some resemblance to our children."
2. Why Didn't The Eagles Fly The Ring To Mordor? - The Lord Of The Rings
The "Plot Hole"
If the mission to destroy the One Ring was so perilous, why didn't Gandalf (Ian McKellen) just ask the Eagles to fly the Fellowship to Mount Doom so they could drop it in?
The Explanation
In J.R.R. Tolkien's novels, it's made abundantly clear that the Eagles aren't physically capable of carrying humans vast distances, to say nothing of the fact that the presence of the Eagles would've definitely alerted Sauron and had him circle the Nazgûl in retort.
Furthermore, it's important to remember that Hobbits have a particularly potent level of resistance to the Ring's corrupting influence, which absolutely cannot also be said for the Eagles.
It goes without saying that the main reason is that the story simply needs the Eagles not to fly the Ring to Mordor, but there are a number of plausible, in-built reasons for why they can't do it. Hardly a plot hole, then.
1. Why Wasn't A Time-Turner Used To Stop Voldemort? - Harry Potter
The "Plot Hole"
Why doesn't Harry (Daniel Radcliffe) just use a Time-Turner to go back and prevent Voldemort's (Ralph Fiennes) rise before he became a threat?
The Explanation
Though time travel is very much a device which is difficult to put back in the box once used, J.K. Rowling at least had the benefit of fantasy contrivance on her side.
Beyond both the books and the films making a pains to emphasise the dangers of using the Time-Turner, and Hogwarts' supply of Time-Turners being destroyed in The Order of the Phoenix, the Wizarding World is a deterministic universe, where the past is fixed and the Time-Turner can only be used to do things which were always going to happen anyway.
As such, attempting to use it to eliminate Voldemort would likely cause a nullifying paradox of some kind which stops it from happening.
The books further acknowledge that tampering with the laws of time can cause irreparable damage to the universe. According to Professor Croaker's law in The Cursed Child, "the furthest someone can go back in time without the possibility of serious harm to the traveller or time itself is five hours," even if the play does also admit the existence of illegal Time-Turners not bound by this restriction.
Basically, even stopping a being as destructive and powerful as Voldemort isn't worth potentially destroying the universe. In Rowling's own words:
"I solved the problem to my own satisfaction in stages. Firstly, I had Dumbledore and Hermione emphasise how dangerous it would be to be seen in the past, to remind the reader that there might be unforeseen and dangerous consequences as well as solutions in time travel. Secondly, I had Hermione give back the only Time-Turner ever to enter Hogwarts. Thirdly, I smashed all remaining Time-Turners during the battle in the Department of Mysteries, removing the possibility of reliving even short periods in the future."
Watch Next
Quiz: Can You Name The Aliens From TVs And Movies?