10 Infuriating Flaws That Ruin Otherwise Awesome Directors

Nolan's fight scenes can cure insomnia.

chris nolan the dark knight rises.jpg
Warner Bros.

We've all got our favourite filmmakers, but not even the likes of Hitchcock and Kubrick were perfect, and there's probably a quirk or signature trait that bugs you a little about even your most beloved director, right?

No matter how many Oscars you win or billions of dollars you make, it doesn't mean your filmmaking disciplines are always on-point, as evidenced by these hugely successful directors who nevertheless rub up a lot of people the wrong way for their behind-the-camera eccentricities.

We accept them in spite of their flaws because they do generally magnificent work, but we'd have even less to complain about if these 10 filmmakers reined in these peculiar, unnecessary and downright infuriating techniques. There's always room for improvement in the future, but their prior works are forever coloured by their misguided filmmaking tics.

Here are 10 infuriating flaws that ruin otherwise awesome directors...


10. Lens Flares Everywhere - J.J. Abrams

jj abrams lens flare.jpg
tumblr

Accomplishments: In addition to creating popular TV shows Felicity, Alias, Lost and Fringe, Abrams has directed a glut of successful movies, including Mission: Impossible III, two Star Trek movies, Super 8, and, of course, the third-highest grossing film in history, Star Wars: The Force Awakens.

The Flaw: Abrams has a much-mocked fetish for lens flare, to the point that on his Star Trek movies, he even shined powerful lights into the camera lens to enhance the effect. Super 8 also suffers with this, and the result is a distracting visual flourish that takes away from the rest of what's on-screen. Plus, once you see it, it's hard to un-see it.

Thankfully, Abrams' wife was the voice of reason and told J.J. to tone down the flares, and so The Force Awakens kept the effect pretty conspicuous. Now that Abrams is back to working on his own projects, though, will we see the flares make a return? Time will tell.


9. Self-Indulgence - Quentin Tarantino

quentin tarantino
Weinsteins

Accomplishments: Nominated for five Oscars and winner of two, his filmography needs no introduction, but as a writer and director, he's one of the most singular talents that the art form has ever seen. There are countless imitators, but only one Q.T.

The Flaw: Once upon a time, Tarantino's flowery, lengthy dialogues about restaurant tipping and tasty burgers were mind-meltingly unique and really quite brilliant. The problem is that as he has enjoyed more success, he's become more aware of what his fans want and leans into that to the point of absurd self-indulgence.

His cameos used to be fun, but then Django Unchained happened and it became far too smug and obnoxious (and his horrible Australian accent didn't help). The Hateful Eight, though an enjoyable film to a point, is in many ways the epitome of his self-regarding style: it is the height of his "they'll eat up every word I'm writing" powers.

He has crafted a three-hour-plus drama with an insistently slow pace, lumbering dialogue and not a single word or shot edited out for the sake of our sanity. Because how dare we miss out a word of Tarantino's dialogue, hand-delivered from the Gods themselves, right?


8. Quantity Over Quality - Woody Allen

Cafe Society Jesse Eisenberg Kristen Stewart Woody Allen
Lionsgate

Accomplishments: With over 20 Oscar nominations to his name and four wins (three for writing, one for directing), it goes without saying that Woody Allen is one of the most prolific and best-admired filmmakers working both today and over the last half-century. Who doesn't love Annie Hall and Manhattan?

The Flaw: On one hand, it's extremely impressive that an 80-year-old Allen is still able to make a new movie every year, having done so now for over 30 years. On the other, Allen just seems to enjoy churning out films regardless of whether he has anything interesting or new to contribute: lots of his recent films, such as To Rome with Love and Magic in the Moonlight, see the director treading water and pretty much just leaning back on the glory of his better movies.

Part of the problem is that Allen is so widely-respected by the acting community that even the most picky actors are desperate to work with him, and so will gladly sign on for even a mediocre Allen script, simply for the experience of being on his set. Hence why so many of his recent movies starring fantastic casts end up being thoroughly mediocre, even forgettable.

His best work still rises to the top, but it's amid a sea of missed opportunities and by-the-numbers middle-class drama.


7. Style Over Substance - Guillermo Del Toro

Ron Perlman Hellboy
Columbia Pictures

Accomplishments: Del Toro may have just one Oscar nomination (for writing Pan's Labyrinth), but he has a passionately devoted fanbase, for his earlier Mexican fare such as Cronos and The Devil's Backbone, his fanboy-friendly Hellboy movies, and of course the brilliant Pan's Labyrinth.

The Flaw: Del Toro is one of the most frustrating directors working today, because he's so talented and yet so often bogs himself down with generic or underwhelming scripts which don't do his strong style much service.

At the height of his powers, we get a Pan's Labyrinth, but lately he's been squandering his talents on the shallow Pacific Rim and disappointingly dull Crimson Peak. To his credit, both films look fantastic visually, and he directs them about as well as anyone could expect,

It's telling that Del Toro himself collaborated on both of these scripts, but it seems like more of his attention was devoted to the gorgeous production design rather than fashioning an interesting story and memorable characters.

When he finally settles on his next project, we'll be eagerly anticipating him (hopefully) breaking the cycle.


6. Excessive Sentimentality - Steven Spielberg

Director Steven Spielberg talks to the press during a photocall at the Lido in Venice to promote his new film Terminal during the 61st International Venice Film Festival.
Myung Jung Kim/PA Archive

Winner of three Oscars (including two for Best Director) and nominated for 16 awards in total, as well as having directed some of the most iconic movies ever made, including Jaws, E.T., Schindler's List, Saving Private Ryan and so on. In addition to being probably the world's most famous director, he's a mega-producer too.

The Flaw: Filmmaker Alex Cox (Repo Man, Sid and Nancy) once famously said of Spielberg, €œSpielberg isn€™t a filmmaker, he€™s a confectioner.€ Movie making is all about manipulation and eliciting a visceral, emotional response from the viewer, and though Spielberg has done this to terrific effect in the likes of E.T., Schindler's List and Saving Private Ryan in particular, his lesser effort are also often criticised for being overly manipulative and sentimental.

As an audience member, we don't want to be overly aware that we're being manipulated into an emotional reaction, but the likes of A.I. and War Horse held their heart on their sleeve, and the result was a mixed audience response. Even Spielberg's recent Best Picture nominee, Bridge of Spies, was lambasted for its overly persuasive musical score, and this really gets to the center of the problem: Spielberg loves overblown orchestral swells, which often ruin what should be more intimate emotional beats in his movies.

He's been doing this for decades, and though it sometimes does in fact work, it's highly unlikely he'll change his way this far into his career.


5. Writing Their Own Movies - The Wachowskis

wachowskis directors
wikipedia

Accomplishments: Lana and Lilly Wachowski are of course best known for creating The Matrix franchise, and though not exactly awards darlings, the siblings won themselves a legion of devoted fans with their ground-breaking sci-fi masterpiece, no matter how uneven the two sequels were.

The Flaw: Now, you have to give the pair some credit: they wrote Bound and The Matrix themselves, and both were highly acclaimed by audiences and critics alike.

Since then, however, every single film they've written has been extremely divisive with audiences: The Matrix Reloaded was deemed incoherent, The Matrix Revolutions anti-climactic, V For Vendetta messy (though they didn't direct it), Speed Racer style over substance, Cloud Atlas confusing and overblown, and Jupiter Ascending...well, you probably saw it, hoping for an original sci-fi vision, right?

Though the Wachowskis have likely worn out any good will they had with Warner Bros., they could really do with taking their cues from someone else for a while, because they clearly struck gold with The Matrix and haven't been able to deliver a movie since that most agree upon as being rock solid. It's a damn shame, because even Jupiter had its splendid moments: who didn't love the magnificently-directed Chicago chase sequence?


4. Obnoxiousness - Spike Lee

Filmmaker Spike Lee participates in AOL's BUILD Speaker Series to discuss his new film
Evan Agostini/AP

Accomplishments: Two Oscar nominations and an Honorary Oscar to his name, and Lee's most iconic works are unquestionably Do the Right Thing and Malcolm X.

The Flaw: For every jaw-dropping, politically-charged movie Lee has made, there's one that feels excessive or overblown, and ends up coming across more as obnoxious and irritating. For every righteous monologue in a Spike Lee movie, there's a film where Lee shoves politics into the scenario even when it doesn't really fit (Inside Man, anyone?), and for many viewers, it results more in an eye-roll or a prolonged groan rather than an appreciation for Lee's evident activism.

That's not to say that Lee should keep his mouth shut, but just think long and hard about the projects he picks up before forcing his own commentary into them.


3. A Fiery Temper - David O. Russell

I Heart Huckabees
Fox Searchlight

Accomplishments: Despite never winning, Russell has five Oscar nods for writing and directing, and has enjoyed a major career uptick since 2010, with massive acclaim being lavished on The Fighter, Silver Linings Playbook and American Hustle. Joy? Not so much.

The Flaw: Here's a flaw that isn't so much about Russell's films themselves but him as a person. Russell has a notoriously ferocious temper, such that George Clooney ended up grabbing him by the throat after he accosted crew members on Three Kings. There's also the infamous leaked video from the set of I Heart Huckabees, where Russell goes off on a shouting tirade at Lily Tomlin, calling her a "c***".

That's not all either: he also made Amy Adams cry on the set of American Hustle, and Christian Bale had to step in to tell Russell that he was being out of line. Though Russell still makes acclaimed movies, his reputation unfortunately precedes him and may explain why he's never actually won an Oscar. He is in effect his own worst enemy.


2. Bad Fight Choreography - Christopher Nolan

Dark Knight Rises Bane Batman
Warner Bros.

Accomplishments: Chris Nolan has three Oscar nods to date, and in addition to blowing away audiences with cerebral masterpieces such as Memento and Inception, has of course directed the ground-breaking Dark Knight trilogy, cementing him as one of Hollywood's most-acclaimed contemporary filmmakers.

The Flaw: For all of the superlative action in Nolan's movies, it's maddening that his close-quarters combat scenes always end up looking so damn clumsy.

Take Batman Begins, where the Bruce Wayne-Ducard ice fight was incoherently edited into oblivion to cover up for some fairly awkward fighting, while The Dark Knight Rises featured two Batman-Bane fights that just weren't very exciting or interesting to watch (though Batman's back getting broken was undeniably cool). Nolan puts so much effort into everything else, but it's the fight scenes that are directed and orchestrated without much care.

This became so much more apparent with the release of Batman v Superman, where Zack Snyder, for all his flaws, directed Batman's fist-fights with so much energy and visual flair. Nolan's look positively dull by comparison.

It's worth mentioning the incredible rotating hallway fight scene from Inception, but also worth remembering that the fight choreography itself was still totally by-the-numbers, and without the hallway gimmick, it's doubtful we'd still be talking about it six years later.


1. An Obsession With Digital Cinematography - Michael Mann

public enemies johnny depp.jpg
Warner Bros.

Accomplishments: Four Oscar nominations, for writing, directing and producing, best known for The Last of the Mohicans, Heat, The Insider, Ali and Collateral.

The Flaw: In recent years MichaelMann has shot his films almost exclusively on digital, and though this worked exceedingly well for the noir-ish Collateral, his successors, Miami Vice, Public Enemies and Blackhat, are all extremely ugly-looking movies.

Plenty of filmmakers do wonders with digital video, but Mann's decision to shoot his movies with a 360-degree shutter angle makes them look like a consumer home video rather than a big-budget production.

The frantic action in Vice and Enemies in particular looks like something an amateur director would make, with an overly smooth image that's unpalatable to audiences reared on more "filmic" cinema. This is of course compounded by the fact that none of these three movies were really much good, and so Mann is sorely in need of a comeback: perhaps a more cinematic approach might help interest audiences more in what he's doing?

Which annoying quirks and traits hinder your favourite filmmakers? Shout them out in the comments!


In this post: 
JJ Abrams
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.