10 Insane MCU Rumours Everyone Wanted To Be True
Tom Cruise playing a variant Tony Stark would've been incredible.
There's no entertainment property today, perhaps ever, that's sparked as much continued interest and excitement as the Marvel Cinematic Universe.
Even the superhero franchise's "lesser" installments get the rumour mill running overtime as fans speculate, obsess, and agonise over what might happen, often before shooting has even started.
It can be a ton of fun poring over all the ridiculous-yet-enticing rumours and fan theories posted online about upcoming MCU films, even if the scuttlebutt often turns out to be nothing more than creative, wishful thinking on the part of overzealous fans.
While many absurd rumours are simply that - silly what-ifs that Kevin Feige would never dare sign off on - others have been genuinely, compellingly off-the-wall enough that fans lamented when they didn't end up happening.
These 10 rumours, from mind-melting fan service to genuinely thoughtful and intriguing plot twists, would've certainly gotten everyone talking and, in at least one case, absolutely broken the Internet.
We'll never know for sure if these rumours would've actually turned out better than what we got, but the fact that they were never realised remains a sore sticking point for many...
10. Alexander Pierce Is Red Skull - Captain America: The Winter Soldier
The Rumour
Marvel fans - and simply fans of good acting - were thrilled when Robert Redford was cast as prominent S.H.I.E.L.D. official Alexander Pierce in the second Captain America movie.
It wasn't long before Redford accidentally spoiled the fact that he was playing a secret villain, which in conjunction with one of the movie's action figure lines reportedly featuring the villain Red Skull, prompted the rumour that Pierce was actually Red Skull in disguise.
This was further bolstered by an alleged soundtrack leak which contained a track with the rather on-the-nose title, "Alexander Pierce is the Red Skull."
What Actually Happened
As incredible as it would've been to see Redford shed his skin to reveal a red noggin underneath - especially given Red Skull's history of infiltration in the comics - this was sadly 100% bunkum.
Pierce is indeed the movie's ultimate villain, but he's a strictly flesh-and-blood human bureaucrat who has been secretly working as Hydra's leader within S.H.I.E.L.D.
Redford knocked it out of the park regardless, and in fairness it's tough to imagine the legendary actor, almost 80 years of age at the time, wanting to bother with the extensive facial prosthetics required to play Red Skull.
9. The Defenders Join The Avengers - Avengers: Infinity War
The Rumour
Starting in 2015, Netflix's various MCU series introduced new live-action iterations of Daredevil (Charlie Cox), Jessica Jones (Krysten Ritter), Luke Cage (Mike Colter), and Iron Fist (Finn Jones).
This culminated in the team-up series The Defenders being released in the summer of 2017, with many fans understandably going on to believe the persistent rumours that this was setting up an appearance from the group in Avengers: Infinity War.
Given that Infinity War was the first part of a mammoth superhero convergence event, why wouldn't they be in the mix?
What Actually Happened
Alas the Defenders didn't show up in Infinity War, and the only member of the quartet to appear in any MCU movie to date is Daredevil, who of course made a short-but-sweet cameo appearance near the start of Spider-Man: No Way Home.
However, Infinity War screenwriters Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely did confirm in interviews that they considered putting the Defenders in the movie, yet felt that given its already huge scope and large cast of characters, it would only be "a glorified cameo."
The Russo brothers later added that a big part of the problem was co-ordinating the story beats between the various Defenders shows with the MCU and ensuring that everything synced up perfectly.
8. Nathan Fillion Is Nova - Guardians Of The Galaxy
The Rumour
It wasn't long after Guardians of the Galaxy was first announced that fans began to speculate on whether or not the film would include Nova.
This only intensified when Gunn's good pal Nathan Fillion joined the cast, and the rumour mill worked overtime claiming that he would indeed play the cult fave superhero.
Gunn denying the rumour shortly before the film's release didn't help at all, only compounding fans' conviction that Nova would appear, most likely in a sequel-teasing credits scene.
What Actually Happened
Nova was sadly nowhere to be seen and Fillion's role ultimately amounted to a mere voice cameo, voicing a CGI alien inmate in the Nova Corps' prison The Kyln, who briefly crosses paths with Peter Quill (Chris Pratt).
On the plus side, this part is insignificant enough that it wouldn't prevent Fillion from playing Nova in the future, though one suspects that Marvel will be seeking a younger actor to lead their currently in-the-works Nova project.
7. Red Hulk Makes An Appearance - Captain America: Civil War
The Rumour
With Captain America: Civil War marking Thaddeus Ross' (William Hurt) first appearance in an MCU movie since 2008's Iron Man, word promptly did the rounds that he was coming back for a more substantial, action-orientated role.
More to the point, Ross would transform into his Red Hulk alter-ego from the comics, leading to a fight between him and the regular Hulk (Mark Ruffalo) which was said to rival the Hulkbuster battle from Age of Ultron.
Given that the entire problem of putting Hulk in a Civil War movie is the speed with which he'd resolve the conflict, pitting him against an equally powerful and smarter force actually seemed like a neat way to mitigate that.
What Actually Happened
Not only was Red Hulk nowhere to be seen and has never appeared in the MCU to date - and, with William Hurt's recent passing, probably never will - but his big green bro was also missing from the entire movie.
Red Hulk was actually considered for inclusion in the film, though was ultimately decided against due to the already-crowded canvas of storylines and characters.
Marvel was also committed to keeping Hulk's location a secret after he jetted off at the end of Age of Ultron, until he was of course revealed to have a major role in Thor: Ragnarok.
6. Heimdall IS The Soul Stone - Avengers: Infinity War
The Rumour
One of the MCU's most agonising mysteries to date was the source of the Soul Stone, as at the time of Avengers: Infinity War it remained the only Infinity Stone which hadn't yet been identified on-screen.
Some fans believed that it resided underneath the ground in Wakanda, while others were convinced by rumours that the Soul Stone was embodied by Thor's (Chris Hemsworth) Asgardian pal Heimdall (Idris Elba).
The primary "evidence" was that Heimdall's eyes glowed orange, and in Thor: The Dark World he memorably told Thor, "From here, I can see nine realms and ten trillion souls."
That... sure sounds like somebody who could be possessed by the Soul Stone, right?
What Actually Happened
As neat an idea as this was, basically every single rumour about the Soul Stone was wrong, as it ended up being held on the remote planet of Vormir, where it was guarded by Red Skull and could only be received by sacrificing the life of a loved one.
5. Hela Returns As Lady Death - Avengers: Infinity War & Endgame
The Rumour
Thor: Ragnarok introduced Thor's villainous half-sister Hela (Cate Blanchett), and though she seemingly died at film's end, that didn't stop the rampant rumour that she would be returning for both Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame.
This was in part spurred on by Mark Ruffalo seeming to suggest that Blanchett had worked with him on the two Avengers sequels, and also the theory that Hela would rematerialise as Lady Death, the literal personification of death.
In the comics, Thanos' (Josh Brolin) quest to annihilate half the universe was motivated by his love for Lady Death, and with Hela proclaiming herself "the Goddess of Death" in Thor: Ragnarok, who better would fit the bill?
What Actually Happened
Lady Death never appears in either movie, with Thanos' quest being entirely his own crusade to "correct" overpopulation and resource scarcity throughout the universe.
In an interview during Infinity War's press tour, the Russos confirmed that they didn't include Lady Death because they weren't interested in delivering a mere 1:1 adaptation of the comics.
4. Mephisto Is Behind Everything - WandaVision
The Rumour
Perhaps no single comic book entity has been more whispered about over the last year-or-so in MCU fandom than Mephisto, a frequent antagonist of both Spider-Man and Ghost Rider in the comics.
In WandaVision, many fans suspected that Mephisto would be revealed as Agatha Harkness' (Kathryn Hahn) shadowy, string-pulling husband.
And then once the first trailer for Spider-Man: No Way Home dropped, it was theorised that Mephisto was impersonating Doctor Strange (Benedict Cumberbatch), therefore explaining his stupidity in botching a spell for Peter Parker (Tom Holland).
What Actually Happened
Mephisto hasn't shown up anywhere yet - he wasn't Agatha's hubby, and Strange's slightly iffy behaviour in No Way Home was ultimately just some plot-motivated idiocy.
Many are still hoping that Mephisto might materialise in the upcoming WandaVision spin-off series Agatha: House of Harkness, but honestly, it's a total coin flip either way.
3. Agent Coulson Becomes Vision - Avengers: Age Of Ultron
The Rumour
Fans were devastated when fan favourite character Agent Coulson (Clark Gregg) met his demise courtesy of Loki (Tom Hiddleston) in The Avengers an entire decade ago.
And so, after the film's release a persistent rumour took hold in the MCU's fandom that Coulson would return as Vision in a future film, his consciousness somehow being transported into the comics' iconic android superhero.
It'd certainly have immediately endeared audiences to the character, that's for sure.
What Actually Happened
Coulson was ultimately resurrected on the TV show Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. through initially ambiguous means, and given the clear reluctance to have the series intersect overtly with the movies, Coulson's survival hasn't ever been directly mentioned in the mainline MCU.
Coulson's resurrection was confined to the TV realm, then, and Vision made his debut in Avengers: Age of Ultron as embodied by Tony Stark's (Robert Downey Jr.) AI J.A.R.V.I.S. (Paul Bettany).
While having Coulson become Vision would've been an interesting way to reintegrate him into the "proper" MCU without outright undoing his demise, it's hard to argue much with how things turned out given Bettany's brilliance in the role.
2. Tom Cruise Plays A Variant Of Tony Stark - Doctor Strange In The Multiverse Of Madness
The Rumour
The single most pervasive rumour doing the rounds ahead of Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness' release was that the film would feature a cameo from one of the biggest movie stars on the planet not yet involved with the MCU - Tom freakin' Cruise.
Word spread like wildfire online that the production had secured a small role for the Mission: Impossible mega-star as a variant of Tony Stark who would appear briefly during the film's chaotic journey through the multiverse.
Beyond the sheer entertainment potential of seeing Cruise playing around in the MCU sandbox, as alt-Iron Man no less, it would've served as a cute in-joke for hardcore MCU fans, given that Cruise had expressed interest in starring in a solo Iron Man film in the late 1990s.
If there's any movie that could've pulled it off, it was surely this one, especially with Cruise spending a lot of time in London last year shooting Mission: Impossible - Dead Reckoning Part One at the same time that the Doctor Strange sequel was in production.
What Really Happened
Cruise didn't turn up in Multiverse of Madness, though the film did at least deliver a bevy of crowd-pleasing - and then, totally horrifying - cameos in its already-iconic Illuminati sequence, namely Professor Xavier (Patrick Stewart) and Mister Fantastic (John Krasinski).
In a post-release interview, screenwriter Michael Waldron stated that he did float the idea of bringing Cruise in for a cameo after reading about the rumour online.
However, the actor was apparently on a tight schedule while shooting Mission: Impossible, no doubt further impacted by its numerous pandemic-related shutdowns.
1. Hulk Gets A Rematch With Thanos - Avengers: Endgame
The Rumour
After Thanos summarily kicked Hulk's ass at the start of Avengers: Infinity War, fans were eagerly anticipating a rematch between the two in Endgame.
Rumours soon enough circulated that we'd indeed get to see Hulk vs. Thanos #2, a sliver of information which was seemingly corroborated by merchandise leaks and didn't appear inherently ridiculous in of itself.
Yet what catapulted the rumour into the realm of absurdity was a "leaked" trailer description which claimed the movie would feature a sequence where Hulk trains to get into shape for round two, culminating in him saying to Captain America (Chris Evans), "My rematch is coming real soon, I can feel it!"
That ridiculous, iconic line became a meme long before Endgame was released, with fans divided on whether or not it could possibly be real.
What Actually Happened
Neither the line nor Hulk training to fight Thanos turned out to be true, but more surprisingly, Endgame came and went without the two goliaths actually having a rematch at all.
While Endgame certainly didn't leave fans wanting for action, it's a shame Hulk never got to give the Mad Titan a decisive beatdown.