10 Insane Movie Plans That Completely Ignored Logic
10. Skynet's Plan To Kill John Connor - The Terminator
THE PLAN: With the war against the humans not going quite as they had planned, Skynet decide that rather than try and take out resistance leader John Connor using conventional means like tanks or bombs, they will send an unstoppable Terminator back through time and kill his mother, Sarah Connor, thus destroying their enemy before he had even been born and dealing the resistance a fatal blow. WHY IT'S STUPID: Except it wouldn't have dealt them a fatal blow at all. Yes, there might have been a slightly less charismatic and inspiring leader in charge of the resistance, but if John Connor was killed before he was born or even while he was an annoying teenager, then someone else would have ended up being in charge of the resistance. None of his fellow generals would have known who he was and therefore there would be no loss of morale or direction in their military campaign. Come to think of it, had the Terminator killed him how would Skynet even know that he existed and their mission was a success? My brain hurts.
9. Dennis Nedry's Plan To Smuggle Dinosaur Embryos - Jurassic Park
THE PLAN: Dennis Nedry is paid off by a rival company to steal the dinosaur embryos from Jurassic Park and then transport them back using his funky little shaving cream cold storage unit. Nedry plans on doing this by shutting down the park security systems using some complicated program he has set up and quietly popping into the lab before jumping on a boat and living a life of luxury permanently camped out in a KFC and buying new pairs of glasses. WHY IT'S STUPID: The very fact that he has to switch off the park fences in order to make his escape is utterly bonkers. While it's true that some IT guys exist in their own little worlds and are totally blind to the world around them, he surely new that there were frickin' dinosaurs wandering around the forests? Given basically everyone had left the island, why couldn't he just steal the things causally during the time before the boat returned and then smuggle himself off? Or seeing how he had some major financial backing, why couldn't it be arranged for some Costa Rican fisherman to pop over on his boat and quietly sail back to land? All of these would have been better than switching off the power to all of the electric fences and going for a stroll through a dinosaur infested island. This is doubly stupid when you consider Dennis Nedry almost definitely smelled of fried food.
8. Picard and Kirk's Plan To Stop Soran - Star Trek: Generations
THE PLAN: Having been sucked into the Nexus so Picard tracks down Kirk and after having a bit of a laugh cooking eggs and riding horses, they decide that they should probably go back and attempt to stop Soran from destroying the star and wiping out the solar system. Their plan is to leave the Nexus and arrive on Veridian III a full ten minutes before Soran launches his rocket, thus giving themselves loads of time to beat him up, stop the rocket from firing, leaving almost no risk of one of them dying on a rickety old bridge. WHY IT'S STUPID: While Picard is enjoying Christmas with his freaky looking children, Guinan explains that you can leave the Nexus and arrive at any point in history that you desire, so for Picard to decide on a plan of action that involves him and Kirk rocking up ten minutes before Soran fires off his rocket is probably about as dumb a plan as you could hope for. Why didn't he leave the Nexus and return to the Enterprise when he and Soran were having a nice chat in the bar? Picard could have had him arrested there and then and nobody would question it, Kirk would have been there to back up his story about the Nexus and then they could retire and open a bar called The Captain's Chair.
7. Eddie Kim's Plan To Kill A Witness With Snakes - Snakes On A Plane
THE PLAN: Gangster Eddie Kim beats the crap out of some dude in Hawaii and this brutal murder is witnessed by poor old Sean Jones. Kim decides to do what any self respecting gangster would and have the witness killed by smuggling a case full of venomous snakes onto the plane he is travelling on to Los Angeles, where the trial will take place. His goons give passengers leis which are covered in a snake-pissing-off pheromone so that they go crazy and wipe out everyone on the plane. WHY IT'S STUPID: While this made the efforts to kill Sean Jones much more hilarious, surely it would have been better to just smuggle a bomb onto the plane? Or get an assassin onto the plane who could just shoot/stab/poison him? All this messing about with snakes must have taken ages to organise and given that he had people on the inside (the security guards at the airport) he surely could have arranged for a bomb to be placed in the hold of the plane, wiping out his witness. Admittedly, this would have cut the run time of Snakes On A Plane down to around 15 minutes, but that's not necessarily a bad thing.
6. NASA's Plan To Stop A Massive Asteroid - Armageddon
THE PLAN: With a huge asteroid heading directly for Earth, humanity's only possible salvation comes from the plan to send astronauts to intercept the giant space rock, dig a big hole and burying then detonating a nuclear warhead. This obviously requires an enormous amount of calculations by NASA on what exact kind of detonation will divert the asteroid, plus they need to be able to actually land on the thing. They decide to entrust this mind mindbogglingly complex task to a bunch of miners. Obviously. WHY IT'S STUPID: Learning how to be an astronaut takes a couple of years usually and you have to be in absolutely peak physical condition in order to survive the rigors of space travel. So rather than getting some already trained astronauts and teaching them how to use a massive drill, they do the opposite and teach miners how to be astronauts. This is basically exactly the same as deciding to enter a horse into the Grand National and then insisting that the horse ride the jockey.
5. Samuel Ramos Plan To Kidnap His Own Daughter - Man On Fire
THE PLAN: In Man On Fire, businessman Samuel Ramos has some serious business debts from all of his important business things and so, in collusion with his attorney Jordan Kalfus, he arranges to have his own daughter kidnapped by some dodgy looking Mexicans. Once the supposed kidnappers demands have been met and the ransom paid, Pita (his daughter) would be returned unharmed and then using the insurance payout, Ramos could help to pay off some of the money he owes. WHY IT'S STUPID: Obviously this is a plan with a high level of risk attached, especially as Ramos has literally just hired Denzel Washington to shoot people in the face should they attempt the exact thing that he is planning, which seems like an awfully short sighted appointment. Even if his wife was adamant that they need someone to protect their daughter, surely he could have at least hired one of the kidnappers? The main question is though, why not just arrange to have himself kidnapped? This wouldn't even need to involve a shoot out in the street, he could just get a taxi to the kidnappers and play Call Of Duty for a week. His attorney could lean on his wife and advise her that paying the ransom is the best idea and then once he comes home they would get the insurance payout. But no, he messes it up and has to shoot himself because he is too stupid to be allowed to live.
4. The Rebels Plan To Deactivate The Death Stars Deflector Shield - Star Wars
THE PLAN: The Rebels are planning a pre-emptive strike on the supposedly not-combat ready Death Star, the only problem is that the space station is protected by a deflector shield which is being generated on the nearby moon of Endor. The fleet is in position and ready to attack and so it is down to Han, Chewie, Leia, Luke and a whole host of troops to land on the planet and deactivate the shield. The groups plan is to bypass the defence shield by using a stolen Imperial shuttle and a stolen code. WHY IT'S STUPID: The Imperials are a well oiled machine and I can only imagine that at some point, somebody would probably report that their shuttle was stolen. Given that these days we can track a stolen iPhone, I am pretty sure there would be some form of tracking device attached to their ships or at the very least the ships name and registration would probably be entered into some form Excel sheet so when the shuttle pops up on the Death Star's radar, the alarm would be raised. The Imperials next move would surely be to send some Tie Fighters to wipe out the stolen shuttle, thus ending any hope of the Rebellion successfully destroying the new Death Star and making the final battle in Return Of The Jedi are crap load more one-sided and depressing.
3. Daniel Hillard's Plan To See His Children - Mrs. Doubtfire
THE PLAN: After being sacked, kicked out of his home and asked by his wife for a divorce, Daniel Hillard's life is looking pretty crappy. In a totally not surprising turn of events, his wife is granted custody of their children and he is allowed to visit them once a week with the promise that should he actually get himself a place to live and a job then he can have more access. Rather than doing what the law has asked of him, Daniel decides it would be a much better idea to embark on some transvestism and pose as Scottish housekeeper, Mrs Doubtfire. This allows him unfettered access to his children and probably fulfils a life long desire to wear hosiery. WHY IT'S STUPID: Firstly, surely his wife would recognise that it was him, no matter how well done the make-up is? We can all tell it's Robin Williams and we are supposed to believe that his wife of many years doesn't find something odd about her new housekeeper? I can't see how a bit of make up and some fake boobs would totally throw her. There is also the fact that, it surely wouldn't have been that difficult for him to get a job and a house? Then he could have shown his kids and wife he is a mature man and she probably would have taken him back and he would not have got into further trouble with the law, which he so blatantly ignored. Get a job, get a flat and leave the dressing up to your private alone time.Finally, how much is this going to mess up his kids? If I found out my housekeeper was actually my dad in drag, not only would I be permanently embarrassed by him, it would turn that inappropriate teenage crush on an older woman into something seriously f****d up.
2. Raoul Silva's Plan To Kill M - Skyfall
THE PLAN: Having been sold out by M after hacking the Chinese on his lunch breaks, Raoul Silva spends years plotting his revenge on her. His plan sees him takeover an island, lure Bond to said island, get himself captured by MI6, have MI6 plant a virus into their computer system by accessing his laptop, escaping from his glass cage during the ensuing chaos and then finally to shooting M in a crowded courtroom. What could be simpler? WHY IT'S STUPID: Silva's motives are almost understandable, his desire for payback after M's betrayal is something a lot of crazed spies might want. The way he goes about it though is bizarre, why does he have an island? Why does he need to bomb MI6? Why does he need Bond at all? Given he ends up bursting into a courtroom and blindly firing in M's direction, you think he probably could have just skipped to that part. I know he wanted to her to see the bombing and then freak her out with some cryptic emails, but he could have sent her a PowerPoint presentation on why he hates her, then blow up her office. Would have saved himself so much time.
1. The Plan Kill The Alien - Alien
THE PLAN: After Kane pops an Alien out on the dinner table which then promptly runs off, the crew of the Nostromo realise that they have probably shouldn't ignore it like I ignore the mice in my flat and in fact must track it down and kill it. This doesn't work out too well for poor Brett who gets mauled by the newly massive beast and they can't just abandon ship as there are not enough places in the lifeboat for some hilarious reason, but let's not get into that now. So Dallas decides to jump into the air ducts with a flame thrower and try and drive the Alien toward the air lock where it will eventually be cornered, then they simply blow it out the 'eff out into space. WHY IT'S STUPID: Going one on one with an Alien is not exactly a great idea for a professionally trained marine, let alone someone who is essentially a miner, so the decision to do this in the environment that 100% favours the Alien is baffling. It's dark, Dallas has absolutely no room for manoeuvre and although he is covered from the rear by the closing of vents, he has no idea what is above or below him thanks to the crappy tracking devices that Ash hastily threw together. Given that they have control over the vents in the air ducts, why not just close them all off? There is a reasonable chance that you would trap it in there somewhere and then you can camp out in the lifeboat for a few days. There is only one entrance to defend so if the Alien makes it's way toward them they will be able to see it coming, not forgetting the tracking devices would give you plenty of warning. Much better than crawling around air shafts waiting to get eaten.
