10 Insufferable Rom-Com Leads That Don't Deserve Love
Just because they get the girl/guy doesn't mean they're not human trash.
There are so many romantic comedies out there, you guys. The best ones succeed because they have likeable leads with chemistry, and it's easy for us to imagine ourselves falling in love with them. It's wish fulfillment at its most basic level. But while few romantic comedies can hit those incredible highs, at the bare minimum, all of them depend on the very basic tenet that when we see their leads in action, we can on some level understand why another human would fall in love with them.
And it's truly shocking to see how many films fail in that regard. It shouldn't be difficult to come up with a generally non-offensive romantic lead that all viewers can sort of use as a cipher for all the attributes they're looking for, but for some reason, filmmakers insist on frequently putting monsters on our screens.
These are mean, manipulative, messed up characters that no person in their right mind would fall in love with, yet we're asked to watch time and time again as some poor misguided sap runs into their arms.
Why? How many writers have been in some seriously unhealthy relationships to consider this kind of stuff normal, and worse, romantic?
10. Preston Meyers - Can't Hardly Wait
Preston Meyers is the kind of character that you really just want to sit down and slap in the face. Dude, just because you and a girl both like the same flavor of Pop Tarts does not mean that you are soulmates and that you should spend your entire high school career creepily obsessing with her and then pouncing on her the second that she breaks up with her long term boyfriend and is probably in an emotionally vulnerable place.
She is 100% correct to yell at you and everyone else for trying to make a move on her when she's been single for less than a day. Also, you're going off to college. Now is not the time to confess your love to some girl that you honestly don't know that well. What do you expect to happen?
Even if she does like you, you're both leaving, and it's not like you've been together and are both dedicated to making a long distance relationship work. You're just emotionally manipulating her into feeling something for you because you're a "nice guy" when she should be able to go off to college, no strings attached, and actually learn to be by herself for once in her life. Bad form, Preston.
9. Mark - Love Actually
There are a lot of characters in Love Actually that are pretty terrible in their respective relationships, but Mark definitely claims the trophy of worst ever.
Crime #1: Ruins his best friend's wedding video by creepily focusing in on his new bride, constantly, with a plaintive longing that is inappropriate and just plain rude.
Crime #2: Rather than keeping his crush on his best friend's wife buried way down deep, he chooses to bring her into his drama, making things awkward forever.
What kind of monster behaves this way? Even if she likes you, SHE'S MARRIED TO YOUR BEST FRIEND. What do you expect to happen? How does this play out in your sociopathic mind? Because on Christmas, Mark shows up on her doorstep, demands that she lie to her husband, and proceeds to confess his undying love for her.
As though that's going to play out well. It's a selfish move, and the fact that the movie seems to want us to think that it's romantic is honestly pretty messed up.
8. Nick Marshall - What Women Want
This is probably one of the most offensive films of the 1990s, and it has next to no redeeming qualities.
It's just a pile of stereotypes and tired humor about how women are soooo complicated and difficult to understand, when in reality if men like Mel Gibson's character (who is, let's face it, pretty much just playing a toned down slightly less racist version of himself) would take a minute to actually listen and use their brain instead of bleating on about how they just don't understand what women want from them, things would all go a lot smoother.
Anyway, Mel Gibson plays a misogynist who is gifted with the ability to hear women's thoughts, which gives him all this new insight and plays out with the sort of comic misunderstandings one would expect from a movie swinging at this low level.
The fact that poor Helen Hunt gets roped into the proceedings and actually becomes this character's love interest is a tragedy. You deserve so much better, Helen. You really do.
7. Chris Brander - Just Friends
Chris Brander, despite being playing by one of the most charming and loveable men in the world (Ryan Reynolds, duh), is actually a pretty infuriating character. So he's a fat but kind high school student who has a major crush on his best friend Jamie. He finally gets the courage to write a note telling her how he feels about her, but she doesn't reciprocate his feelings. Bummer.
Fast forward to about ten years later, when he is a thin, handsome womanizer whose six pack abs can't disguise the massive chip on his shoulder. As soon as he gets the opportunity, he throws his handsomeness and success in Jamie's face, trying to make her feel so bad about what she let get away.
Furthermore, he perpetuates this notion of the Friend Zone, as though the only reason men should be friendly to women is so they'll sleep with them, and god forbid a woman not be attracted to one of her male friends, whose actions towards them seem to belie some sort of niceness for sex quid pro quo arrangement that women are always kept out of the loop on.
6. Alex - Heartbreaker
OK, on the surface, Alex is kind of a catch. He's a handsome Frenchman who, like Ryan Gosling, can reenact move-for-move certain key dance sequences from Dirty Dancing. But then you find out what his job is, and that quite frankly is a dealbreaker. Alex and his sister are hired by rich people to break up the relationships of their friends and family.
So say you're a wealthy father whose daughter is in danger of falling in love with an unsuitable match, you would hire Alex and he would swoop in with his bag of tricks to throw a wrench in the works.
On the whole, any man whose entire career is based around lies and manipulation is probably someone you should avoid in a romantic context (possible exception: handsome international spies, because they lie for Queen and country, and come on, we're only human).
Alex, however, is not a sexy international spy, just kind of a jerk who kills happiness for money and doesn't seem to feel bad about it at all, except for the one time where he happened to fall in love with his mark.
5. Joe Fox - You've Got Mail
On the surface, this character really should have been a slam dunk. First of all, Joe Fox is played by Tom Hanks, probably the most likeable Hollywood actor since James Stewart, who played the role in The Shop Around the Corner, which this film is based on.
So how is Joe Fox so indisputably terrible? Well, first of all, he's a mega book store owner who gets romantically involved with the poor little independent bookstore owner that he's actively trying to put out of business. It's gross, and he doesn't even seem to feel bad about it.
And the movie doesn't end with her getting to keep her shop, she just sort of realizes that his gluttonous megastore isn't so bad and excepts her livelihood's inevitable demise. Luckily, he'll get his own back in a few years when Amazon completely destroys his own business model and independent bookstores become the preferred outlet for shopping locally.
4. Harry - Something's Gotta Give
Harry is a geriatric who falls into that gross subgroup of older men who just can't bring themselves to grow up and date women their own age. (Meanwhile, older women are mocked and pitied for doing the same thing, because internalized misogyny.)
So he's dating the latest in a string of hot 20-somethings that are inexplicably going out with him, when the inevitable happens and he has a heart attack while in bed with her. Forced into bedrest, he has no choice but to briefly live with his paramour's mother (gamely played by Diane Keaton).
Like many of Jack Nicholson's roles, Harry manages to woo the female protagonist simply by being slightly less terrible than he was at the beginning of the film. It makes zero sense, and the women in his life should really have higher standards than this.
He's a condescending jerk for 80% of the film, then he says like one nice thing and Diane Keaton leaves Keanu Reeves, a kind, gentle doctor, for him. No, Diane. Go with Keanu. You won't regret it.
3. Paula - Failure to Launch
If this was a different kind of film, Paula would be its evil antagonist. She accepts money to pretend to date men just so that they will fall in love with her and decide to move out of their parent's home. Then once they've taken that massive step and are financially and emotionally vulnerable, she breaks up with them. Does she feel bad about this? Not really. Does she ever do anything to ameliorate the damage she constantly leaves in her wake? Nope.
It's only when she falls in love with her latest victim, played by Matthew McConaughey, that she shows any signs of remorse, and that's really only once she's backed into a corner and has no choice but to confess. And she's the hero of the film. Somehow, she's the one that we're supposed to root for.
It's an insult to women, that we could be expected to identify with this sociopathic monster, and it's an insult to everyone's intelligence that someone who looks like McConaughey would put up with such a deceptive, manipulative person after learning the truth about them.
2. Dean Proffitt - Overboard
Overboard is a fun, light-hearted film from the 1980s, but when you actually sit down and think about the plot, it's pretty crazy that this movie ever got made. The main character is a poor carpenter who gets thrown of a yacht by a bored, spoiled heiress after she isn't happy with his craftsmanship and he tries to physically intimidate her into accepting the work as completed. Which is, like, fair.
But when she later falls off the boat and gets amnesia, he comes up with a plan. Because the best way to fall in love and find a new mother for your children is to lure a woman with a brain injury into your home and con her into being your personal slave. That's right. He shows up at the hospital claiming to be her husband, brings her home, and forces her to take up her role as housewife and mother to his children.
Which is so beyond screwed up it's hard to even fathom, especially since it's played for laughs and heavily implied that she deserves this treatment. And what's worth, at the end of the day, he gets the girl. She forgives him for his lies and manipulation. Maybe her brain injury was more severe than we thought.
1. Benjamin Barry And Andie Anderson - How To Lose A Guy In 10 Days
In a way, these two actually are deserving of love, but only from one another, because they are both equally abhorrent piles of human trash. Unfortunately, it's unlikely that either of them are truly able to experience the emotion of love, because they're clearly sociopaths.
Their behavior in this film is shocking on two levels. First, that humans are actually capable of acting like this, and secondly, that any audience member could possibly find this romantic or charming.
Basically, these two are both engaged in bets that will require them to lie extensively to a person they're supposed to have feelings for. Andie is trying to show her ability to make a man break up with her in 10 days, and Ben is out to prove that he can make a woman fall in love with him in 10 days.
Why these are the types of things that normal, functioning adults concern themselves with remains a mystery. Their increasingly hateful, vindictive acts reach a fever pitch until they spontaneously confess their love for one another. Well, it's a good thing they'll have each other, because no one else probably would.