10 Intense Movie Performances NO ONE Was Ready For
Were we ever going to be ready for an evil Patrick Stewart?
It's always fun to see an actor take on a a type of role they don't often get the chance to play. No matter how far into their career, any time a performer mixes things up, it's something exciting to watch.
Knowing an actor is about to play a character archetype we haven't seen them tackle in the past creates a slight swell of excitement. It's the thrill of our personal perceptions of a performer being turned on their head, as the actor embodies a serious, comedic or other-worldly roll we could never imagine them playing.
It's proof that an actor shouldn't be typecast for specific roles, and thankfully not every casting director has taken this rule to heart. Actors train for decades to master their craft, and rarely do we ever see their full potential.
Some of these unique performances might not win awards, or be ranked in their top 10 roles, but they're a monument to the lengths and depths and actor will go to for a role. They could be the defining roles and performances that change their entire career trajectory - opening up new opportunities for them to pursue in the future.
10. Jason Sudeikis - Colossal
When you look at Jason Sudeikis, you see a handsome, funny actor who's bounced from one comedy to the next. He's the charming one from those films you (probably) forgot you saw.
But given the chance to play a bad guy (a REALLY bad guy), and he's not so charming after all.
At the beginning of Colossal, the film makes us wonder if Jason Sudeikis' character Oscar is going to be something of a romantic interest for Anne Hathaway's Gloria. It certainly looks the case, but about a third of the way through the movie we get a very realistic portrayal of a real-world villain.
It's a welcome surprise when comedians play serious characters, so watching Oscar's turn into a nasty villain was certainly a twist. What's intense about his character, is that his behaviour is very familiar to a certain demographic of audience members.
The clever script, twinned with Sudeikis' charisma to play a gaslighting antagonist, generates a performance that feels all too real for people who've experienced adult bullying or specific levels of abuse.
It's hard to look at Jason Sudeikis the same way again after this film, especially since he's often playing such charming characters with his winning smile.
9. Natalie Portman - Vox Lux
What's amazing about Natalie Portman's performance in 2018's Vox Lux is that when she finally makes an appearance two-thirds into the movie, she makes an impact as if everything before that point didn't matter.
Portman is a tour de force in this movie, playing a famous pop star named Celeste. The charisma she brings is magnetic, and it's possible with Natalie Portman being a child-star who rose to fame, and maintained that status as an adult, she might have inserted her own experiences and thoughts into the portrayal of an unpredictable and hostile starlet?
As soon as Natalie Portman appears on screen, speaking in an aggressive New York accent, she's commanding the rooms and scenes she's in - and not just because she's the biggest name on screen. The character of Celeste is entitled and vindictive. Natalie Portman has played aggressive characters before, but she's never played someone as spiteful as Celeste, although some arguments could be made for Alice in Closer.
8. Olivia Wilde - A Vigilante
An argument could be made that a bulk of Olivia Wilde's career up until a couple of years ago was to play minor supporting roles in TV shows, or aimless love interests in B-List movies.
But when Wilde gets a chance to flaunt her acting chops properly, she goes all in (like in Drinking Buddies or Life Itself). Yet, it was still one hell of a surprise when she devastated audiences with her performance as Sadie in 2018's A Vigilante.
The portrayal of Sadie is a painfully tragic display of someone who is filled with so much anger and resentment for the world, but is equally terrified every time they're on screen. Olivia Wilde finds her own corner of presenting anti-heroes and occupies the entire space with a screaming, wide-eyed figure who is alluring at a distance, but will bite your hand off if you get close.
7. Patrick Stewart - Green Room
Over the course of his career, Sir Patrick Stewart has amassed a loyal and dedicated fanbase who have loved him for his time on Star Trek, the X-Men franchise or his work in theatre. It's very hard to picture him in any sinister way because a large number of his roles have been passive or heroic.
In Green Room, Patrick Stewart plays Darcy, the head of a small town Neo-Nazi outfit. Darcy is a character who commands a horde of idealistic, young skinheads who do his bidding at the snap of his fingers. From the moment he arrives on screen, there's a chill to the way his deep, almost harmonic baritone voice is flipped to be something we could associate with danger.
What makes this performance so jarring is more to do with the public persona of Sir Patrick Stewart.
Fans weren't ready for a role like this. His characters of Picard and Professor X were diplomatic, open-minded and empathetic characters, and while we know playing roles like these would be part of his job, it's still tense to see him play a character so casually evil.
6. Alessandro Nivolo - The Art Of Self Defense
A film about Jesse Eisenberg awkwardly learning karate should have been a quirky indie comedy. Instead, it's an uncomfortable representation of extremely toxic male standards, and it's thanks to one man.
Alessandro Nivola's role as "Sensei" isn't a screaming, jaw-clenching performance. But it is intense. The actor proves that you can be calm and quiet whilst still being the craziest character on screen.
A mixture of "wait, what was that?" dialogue, and outrageous physical acting present to audiences a man who doesn't exist, but is embodied everywhere in the real world. Nivola's delivery of his lines is of someone on the edge of either hugging, or hurting, the person he's in the room with.
"Sensei" is a man who revels in digging up insecurities and replacing them with manipulated weakness. Alessandro Nivola plays the character like a predator grooming his victims, and that's exactly what Sensei does.
Going into the film, you're expected to be drawn to Jesse Eisenberg's character, but he's one-note in comparison to Alessandro Nivola's performance as an unhinged cult leader.
Nivola has always been a minor actor, but hopefully with this performance he can finally graduate to a leading man status.
5. Tom Cruise - Tropic Thunder
Tropic Thunder is one of those comedies where every actor involved knew exactly what kind of film they were making. Of the five actors playing "actors playing soldiers", their performances on screen were the meta symbols Ben Stiller and Justin Theroux were angling for when the script was written.
And while Robert Downey Jr's controversial character might have distracted us initially, it's Tom Cruise as the vulgar Les Grossman that really catches us off guard.
Had Tom Cruise played someone like this before? What must the conversation that convinced Cruise to put on a bald cap have been like? Take away the knowledge that audiences had to double-check the awful studio head on screen WAS in fact Tom Cruise, it's still an in-your-face performance that really outshines the other cast.
This is smiling, running, stunt-performing Tom Cruise! He doesn't deliver hilarious f-bombs at every other sentence and steal the spotlight from the likes of Matthew McConaughey - but he does, and he did.
Maybe because we never expected Tom Cruise in this film, but his performance is the biggest take away from the movie.
4. John Travolta - The Fanatic
Here we go! A movie written and directed by Limp Bizkit's very own Fred Durst, starring John Travolta as an obsessive fan of a movie star. What could possibly go wrong - or right - with this movie?
John Travolta has had a few falls from grace over the years. His latest films have all floated so under the radar and gone straight to DVD/VOD, he's slowly become a new Steven Seagal. But last year's The Fanatic was something you couldn't ignore.
As a character called Moose, I'm not sure what first-time viewers expected with Travolta's portrayal as a vulnerable individual whose obsession with an actor that turns violent.
But I do know this is a performance that would never win any awards, it will be a defining mark on Travolta's long and fluctuating career.
3. Jake Gyllenhaal - Nightcrawler
Gyllenhaal's portrayal as Louis Bloom is uncomfortable and upsetting to look at. He's a slender-man with bug eyes, high cheek bones and he looks like he doesn't wash often. But when Louis opens his mouth and starts working with the scenery around him, that's when the audience is put on edge.
Louis is neither upset nor excited by what he films, and the way Gyllenhaal portrays that lack of emotion might be the most shocking part of his performance.
In a film that focuses on the exploitation of tragedies, Gyllenhaal's incredible performance is the most unsettling thing we see.
2. Steve Carell - Foxcatcher
It's hard to put a label on Steve Carell: his long-running stint as the obnoxious boss on The Office US, the leading role in 40 Year Old Virgin or a sidekick bit-part in Anchorman, should mark him down as the safe and reliable funny man.
But then we get him in films like The Way Way Back and Little Miss Sunshine, where he's displaying acting abilities that prove he's so much more than just comedic.
This is best conveyed in 2014's Foxcatcher, where he plays the real-life eccentric millionaire John du Pont.
Behind the prosthetic is still a hilarious actor, but the atmosphere generated by Steve Carell is poisonously uncomfortable. The tension is laid thick by an actor who is really embodying a gross individual.
Acting opposite Mark Ruffalo and Channing Tatum, Steve Carell isn't just uncomfortable, he's scary. He portrays a man we don't feel sympathy for, but are repulsed by and pity.
Thankfully since Foxcatcher, Steve Carell has stopped being the doofus in films and has since appeared in more serious roles. While he'll always be Brick from Anchorman, it's good to know he can slip into a menacing persona at any point.
1. Robin Williams - One Hour Photo
Robin Williams was a very specific and very rare kind of actor, in that he could literally play any role. Whether it was the charmer, the comedy relief, the wise father figure or the hapless goof in an adventure.
2002 saw Robin come out in two films that really flaunted his acting capabilities: Insomnia and One Hour Photo. In Insomnia he played a more directly villainous character, but it's his performance in One Hour Photo that astounded viewers more.
The therapist from Good Will Hunting had twisted his persona into a very passive, but very haunting and dangerous figure that changed our perceptions of Robin Williams. Audiences who grew up on Aladdin, Jumanji, Jack or Mrs. Doubtfire had seen the delightful performances from before morph into the traumatized, unsettled and obsessive character of Seymour Parrish.
It's definitely a great turn that really demonstrated his talents (even after winning an Academy Award for Good Will Hunting), but it's still just eerie to see him play such a disturbing character.