10 Last-Minute Replacements If Ben Affleck Quits The Batman
These guys wouldn't break the bank, but they would get the job done.
One of the many positives to follow in the success of Patty Jenkins' record-breaking Wonder Woman is that a story bubbling behind the scenes of DC's Extended Universe for months now has at least temporarily faded into the background; the troubled pre-production of The Batman.
As we all know, star and producer Ben Affleck dropped out of the director's chair and Matt Reeves was eventually hired as his replacement, but not before negotiations almost collapsed entirely. Then came rumors that the script was being rewritten from scratch once Reeves came onboard. Even Joe Manganiello, who was officially cast as Deathstroke, revealed in an interview that he isn't sure if he's still in the movie.
Even with the start of production locked in for next year, word began circulating that Affleck wanted out of his contract citing reasons like creative dissatisfaction and the constant pressure and scrutiny that comes with playing such an iconic character, not to mention the vocal portion of the fan base that have rejected the actor from the moment his casting was announced.
So could November's Justice League really be Ben Affleck's last time under the cape and cowl? In the name of wild speculation and nothing else, lets just assume that it is. If DC and Warner Bros end up having to find a replacement Dark Knight at the last minute, here are ten names that should be under consideration that wouldn't come at a high cost, but could definitely do a solid job with the character.
10. Scott Adkins
Scott Adkins may be the least-known name on this list and an unknown quantity to most audiences, but the English actor and martial artist is a longtime favorite among aficionados of straight-to-video action movies, so much so that his fans even started an online campaign to get him the role of Batman before Ben Affleck was cast as the Dark Knight.
While Adkins did ultimately end up auditioning for the Caped Crusader, he admitted that he never expected to be under serious consideration and was grateful to his fans for the free publicity. However, if Warner Bros. were looking to secure a replacement on short notice should Affleck give up the cowl, Adkins could be a solid choice.
The 40 year-old looks the part in a tuxedo and has the right understated charisma to convince as Bruce Wayne, while his martial arts prowess is a perfect fit for DC's resident expert in hand-to-hand combat. While there would be question marks over his dramatic range as an actor and lack of star power, he surely couldn't be worse than Val Kilmer or George Clooney, right?
9. Eric Bana
Eric Bana may not have secured the A-list stardom that many were predicting for him a decade ago, the Australian actor remains a talented and versatile screen presence that would be more than capable of convincing as both a billionaire playboy and a costumed crime-fighter.
It is Bana's adaptability that would make him a solid dark horse candidate for the role of Batman; the 48 year-old has worked in almost every imaginable genre from historical epics to romantic comedy via sci-fi and horror and while his movies are very often hit-or-miss, he always gives 100% to his performances.
While the dark, brooding, intimidating nature of Batman and the charm and confidence of Bruce Wayne are both well within his wheelhouse as an actor, Bana seems much more content these days to play supporting roles in big-budget blockbusters as opposed to having his name on the marquee.
8. Scott Eastwood
Without a doubt the biggest wildcard and most 'WTF' entry on this list, Scott Eastwood has spent the last few years establishing his own identity as an actor in an attempt to step out of the enormous shadow of his legendary father. And what better way to strike out on your own than to take on the mantle of one of the most famous characters in popular culture?
Admittedly, he is way too young for the current older, wiser, more grizzled iteration of the character which is ironic considering his father was frequently linked with the part of middle-aged Bruce Wayne when The Dark Knight Returns was being considered for the big-screen in decades past but Eastwood Jr. undoubtedly has a long career ahead of him, so his time may yet come.
Of course, Eastwood already has a role in the DCEU but given the brief and undeveloped nature of his part in Suicide Squad, a lot of people have probably already forgotten that he was even in it. Nonetheless, the naturally-charismatic 31 year-old has improved massively as an actor in recent years and could be an interesting left-field choice for the Dark Knight in the future given his chiselled looks and a jawline you could set your watch to.
7. Frank Grillo
If you want your Batman to be grizzled and world-weary with a sideline in dry humor then look no further; Frank Grillo is your man. Despite not getting his big break in Hollywood until his mid-40's, the last few years have seen Grillo firmly establish himself as a confident and commanding presence on our screens.
At 51 he may be no spring chicken but remains in incredible shape, and with decades' worth of training in amateur wrestling, boxing, martial arts and MMA he could definitely kick your ass. Although he secured the relatively high-profile role of Crossbones in the Captain America franchise, the fact that he was blown up in the opening scene of Civil War seemingly leaves no doubts about his availability. But could he convince as the Dark Knight?
The current big-screen version of Batman is broken, beaten and scarred from years of cleaning up the streets of Gotham and Grillo would have no trouble bringing a 'seen it all, done it all, got the t-shirt' vibe to the character. Even more interesting would be his take on pampered playboy Bruce Wayne, with his effortlessly natural acting style and lived-in features suggesting something entirely different from what's been done before.
6. Matt Bomer
This may be an article suggesting actors to take up the role of Batman should Ben Affleck walk away, but it should be noted that Matt Bomer has a long history with the other half of DC's 'Big Two'.
Bomer screen-tested for Superman 15 years ago (opposite Amy Adams, interestingly enough) during pre-production on the abandoned Superman: Flyby and was again rumored during Man of Steel's casting process. Not only that, but the actor has played 'The Big Blue Boy Scout' twice; voicing the character in the animated Superman: Unbound and in a couple of unintentionally hilarious Japanese Toyota Prius commercials from 2009. No, seriously.
As his work over six seasons of White Collar demonstrated, Bomer has the necessary charisma and charm to play suave playboy Bruce Wayne, but a huge question mark remains over his action credentials, which is surely nothing several months of the requisite fight training can't fix.
The actor also looks the part, with a square jaw that would look right at home under the cowl and the physique that the character demands. The Golden Globe winner turns 40 in a few months but could easily pass for much younger, with the potential to grow into the role over a number of years much like Chris' Evans and Hemsworth have done over at Marvel Studios.
However, would it be ridiculous to say that Bomer looks too similar to Henry Cavill to be under serious consideration? The DCEU seems to be pitting Batman and Superman as opposite sides of the same justice-related coin, but that would be a little jarring if they looked like brothers.
5. Liev Schreiber
Arch-enemy of autocorrect Liev Schreiber has been doing the best work of his career on the small screen in recent years, with his role as the title character on Showtime's Ray Donovan netting him four consecutive Golden Globe nominations for 'Best Actor in a Television Series'. A quick glance at the 49 year-old's IMDb profile states that he 'often plays angry tough guys who behave unpredictably'; sound like anyone we know?
Standing at an imposing 6'3", built like a brick sh*thouse and with a piercing stare that gives off an undeniable sense of barely-contained rage, on paper Schrieber has all of the attributes necessary to make a compelling Dark Knight.
Perhaps the biggest concern would be Schrieber's deliberately understated and often calculating acting style. Taking on the role of both Bruce Wayne and Batman almost requires two entirely different performances and while Ray Donovan has proven the actor's ability to kick ass and look dapper in a suit, it remains to be seen if he could handle the delicate balance required to convince as a spoiled billionaire and costumed vigilante independently of each other.
4. Jim Caviezel
Any fans of the criminally-underrated Person of Interest (also known as 'the best TV show your friends have never seen') will already be nodding their heads in agreement on this one, as the series' five-season run essentially presented a Batman story on the small screen with a few cosmetic changes, which surely isn't a coincidence given that the concept came from a certain Jonathan Nolan.
Jim Caviezel's John Reese is an expert in hand-to-hand combat, uses guns but refuses to kill, utilizes gadgets to help solve crimes and has allies working within the police department. Sound a little familiar? When you position Michael Emerson's Finch as the Alfred to Reese's Batman (which also checks 'enigmatic billionaire' off the list), the similarities become even more striking.
However, Caviezel's work is much more than a thinly-veiled Batman impression. Sure, there's the whole 'gruff and husky voice' thing going on, but during the show's run the 48 year-old actor gave great depth to a character that could easily slip into one-dimensional 'generic badass' territory, painting Reese as a man constantly at war with his past and generating sympathy from the audience while also beating dozens of interchangeable henchmen to a pulp.
With his grey-flecked hair, all-American looks and a gap in his schedule, Jim Caviezel would be a great dark-horse candidate to take up the mantle of a world-weary and battered Batman should the role need to be recast in the near future.
3. Richard Armitage
An actor used to sporting a cumbersome costume on the set of a studio blockbuster after playing Thorin Oakenshield in the Hobbit trilogy, Richard Armitage is also no stranger to big-budget, greenscreen-heavy features thanks to appearances in The Phantom Menace, Captain America: The First Avenger, Alice Through the Looking Glass and... The Vicar of Dibley.
The 45 year-old was under consideration for the role of Batman during the casting process for Batman v Superman and even met with Zack Snyder, but was ultimately unsuccessful as the director opted for Ben Affleck, who is only one year younger than Armitage. Still, he remains a solid candidate should the part become available once again in the near future.
Its not easy for a 6'2" man under a pile of prosthetics to convince as a dwarf, but the versatile Armitage did just that in the Hobbit movies and imbued Thorin with a sense of stoicism, dedication and internal conflict, traits that are pivotal to the duality of Bruce Wayne and Batman. His critically-acclaimed work in Hannibal also proved he has no trouble playing an out-and-out psychopath either, which Batman may or may not be depending on who you listen to.
And of course there is Armitage's commanding baritone voice, which would lend itself well to a black-clad vigilante lurking in the shadows of Gotham, giving his take on the Dark Knight an instant sense of intimidation, while also serving as the polar opposite of Christian Bale's gargled Nick Nolte impression.
2. Luke Evans
Luke Evans has been a regular presence in big-budget blockbusters since the turn of the decade, but still arguably hasn't been given a high-profile role to really sink his teeth into. While it may seem strange to label an actor whose movies have grossed almost $6bn at the global box office as 'underrated', the 38 year-old Welshman is just that.
Usually cast in a supporting role in studio projects, Evans has provided solid backup in the likes of the Hobbit and Fast and Furious franchises, along with Disney's Beauty and the Beast. He even emerged unscathed from the turgid Dracula Untold, with a rare lead performance being one of the movie's few redeeming features. And for the six or seven people that have seen 2012 B-movie No One Lives, there is no denying that Evans owns every scene as the mysterious, charismatic and very murdery 'Driver'.
Recognizable without being too famous, comfortable and experienced working in action-heavy blockbusters with the right look and ability to play characters that are heroic, charming, sinister and even outright violent if necessary, Evans is at the perfect stage of his career to ascend to A-list status and would make a great Batman if Ben Affleck were to walk away from the cape and cowl.
1. Karl Urban
Karl Urban has already done a fantastic audition for Batman. It was called Dredd. Comic book adaptation? Check. Gravel-throated protagonist? Check. A total bad ass taking on crime while acting on a loose definition of the law? Check. A charismatic and deadpan lead performance delivered while acting almost entirely with nothing but his chin? Checkmate.
Of course, there is plenty more evidence outside of the 2012 cult classic that prove the 45 year-old New Zealander would make an excellent Batman. A seasoned veteran of big-budget blockbusters with proven action hero credentials, Urban has gone toe-to-toe on the big screen with genre icons Dwayne Johnson, Vin Diesel and Bruce Willis during his career, while his brief stint on television in the sadly short-lived Almost Human showed the actor to be no slouch at playing a gruff, seasoned detective with a troubled past.
At only two months older than Ben Affleck, Karl Urban would be an ideal replacement should the former give up the part. He has the physical attributes, the look and the screen presence required for such an iconic role, and anybody that's played Dungeons & Dragons with Dame Judi Dench should immediately be launched to the top of any casting list, no questions asked.