10 Lessons Batman Vs. Superman Can Learn From Superman: The Animated Series

Superman: The Animated Series had some good ideas with regards to Superman and Batman's complex relationship.

The currently untitled sequel to Man of Steel has created a lot of debate in Hollywood and on the internet, mostly related to casting decisions for particular characters and the announcement that fellow DC superheroes Batman and (to a lesser extent) Wonder Woman would appear in this film. The idea of a movie featuring both of DC's most popular characters has been a dream of many fans, but the reality is starting to set in. Man of Steel was a very polarizing film, so people are skeptical at best of what Zack Snyder and company are going to do with this movie. Now that production has been delayed 10 months, the team are probably reviewing the script before they go into shooting. With that in mind, here are 10 lessons the screenwriters and director can learn from a small-screen example of Batman and Superman working together, as seen in the Superman: The Animated Series three-part episode "World's Finest..."

10. Introducing Batman To Superman's World

One thing the associated filmmakers should remember is that this is a sequel to a Superman film, not a Batman film. It is disheartening that they chose to include Batman in the second film, which could imply the creative team doesn't believe that Superman's mythology alone has enough material for good films. However, since Batman is going to be in this movie, it is important to ensure that his role is secondary. It should be an opportunity for Batman to exist in Superman's world. In "World's Finest," with the exception of a short scene at a Gotham City jewellery store, the entire story takes place in Metropolis. The story is literally about Batman interacting with the supporting cast and the environment of the Superman series. When this three part episode was repackaged for DVD sales as The Batman/Superman Movie, my young mind was confused thinking it wasn't much of a team-up movie and more of a Superman story with Batman in it. That is what this new movie needs to be.

9. Establishing A Character Dynamic Between Clark, Lois & Bruce

At the end of Man of Steel, we are introduced to reporter Clark Kent. The relationship between Lois and Clark in this new film series is unlike anything we have seen before (as she is aware of him being Superman). A great way to contribute to their relationship is to provide some tension in the form of a rival for Lois' affections: Bruce Wayne. In Superman: TAS, Bruce Wayne asks out Lois immediately upon arrival in Metropolis, which creates an interesting character dynamic between himself, Clark, Lois, and their alter egos. Ultimately the heroes realize that she is attracted to different parts of each of them (Superman and Bruce Wayne). The key difference here is that Lois is unaware of Clark's secret identity, which would be a key difference for the new film. Expanding on this love triangle of sorts would help to develop both the relationship between Lois and Clark but also show the contrasts between the two heroes.

8. Including A Handful Of Batman's Supporting Characters

Irons Alfred1 It was stated previously that this film should be focused on Superman, but including a few members of Batman's supporting cast will help expand on his character and what his role is in this new cinematic universe. In Superman: TAS, Commissioner Gordon and Detective Bullock are seen briefly while the Joker, Harley Quinn, and Alfred are all major characters in the episode. It would be unwise to include the Joker or Harley Quinn (who recently has been teased to appear on Arrow) in this movie, but the casting of Jeremy Irons as Alfred demonstrates that the filmmakers recognize the importance of the butler's supporting role. Filling the movie with Batman characters and villains would simply take away from Superman's primary role in the film, especially considering so many of Batman's supporting cast have appeared on-screen already.

7. No Robin And/Or Nightwing

Nightwing Comic1 There have been multiple rumours suggesting different actors being cast as Robin or Nightwing in this movie. Going off the previous point, including too many central Batman characters will take away from the focus of this being a Superman sequel. In Superman: TAS (which had established Robin and Batgirl in previous shows) there is no mention of Batman's costumed sidekicks. Alfred performs all the necessary support in the story. This would be especially frustrating if the filmmakers chose to include Nightwing as that particular character has a long history which couldn't be explained in a cameo appearance.

6. Presenting A Good Reason For Bruce Wayne To Be In The Story

Wayne Enterprises Logo Large1 One of the problems with a lot of Silver Age crossovers between superheroes is that there was often no narrative reason presented for the two heroes to interact with each other. In Superman: TAS, the plot is set up that Bruce Wayne travels to Metropolis for business with Lexcorp while Batman searches for the Joker. In the context of Man of Steel, it would fairly simple to create a similar set-up. As Metropolis has been destroyed by the battle between Zod and Superman, Bruce Wayne could show up and offer to provide humanitarian assistance for the city, perhaps in conjunction with Lexcorp. Also: instead of Bruce coming to find the Joker, have him come to investigate Superman himself. The explanation that an older, more experienced Batman will be in the movie suggests a cynical and skeptical Batman who would be paranoid of the demigod from outer space.

5. Use Mercy Graves As A Template For Wonder Woman

For those unfamiliar with Mercy Graves, she was a character created for the animated series who was Lex's bodyguard and driver. She didn't speak much and kicked a lot of ass. Her role in this episode was to act as a foil for Harley Quinn, and to emphasise the important role Lex Luthor had in Metropolis. Beyond Gal Gadot's casting, very little is known about how Wonder Woman is being integrated into this new film or what her origins will be (there are rumours that Amazons will be of Kryptonian origin in the new films). It is clear that she will have a small role in this film, with larger roles in a solo film and a Justice League film. Having her act as Lex's bodyguard would be a great way to integrate her into the story, and also demonstrate her powers.

4. How To Utilize Lex Luthor

Lex Luthor will be played by Jesse Eisenberg in the new film, which suggests a younger version of the character will be featured. It should be clear for the filmmakers to make Lex the main antagonist for this new movie, as his wealth and position in society place him at great odds with Henry Cavill's Superman. In Superman: TAS, Lex is portrayed as a suave businessman who can put on a face for the public but is willing to get his hands dirty when needs be. In the series, he is presented as a person who has - as the Joker puts it - "built half of Metropolis." He is viewed as a leader and is respected by people in society. As mentioned previously, the wealth of Lexcorp could be used to rebuild Metropolis and create jobs (perhaps with some Wayne Enterprises assistance). This also creates a moral dilemma, as the people of Metropolis begin to trust Lex, who could create greater fear, antagonism and paranoia towards Superman.

3. Acknowledging The Differences In Strength

The argument between who would win in a fight between Bats and Supes is ridiculous in principle. Superman has a lot of superpowers, while Batman has none. Without any time for preparation, Batman would be defeated fairly quickly. In Superman: TAS, the first meeting between Superman and Batman establishes this character dynamic very subtly. Batman surprises Superman by flipping him over a table - to which Superman responds by sending Batman into a wall with a quick body check. The story builds upon the different skills these characters have, and they discover through collaboration how to work together. This is exemplified in the ways they learn of each other's secret identities. While Superman simply uses X-Ray vision to see through Bruce's mask, Batman has to plant a tracer on Clark and follow him home. This character dynamic should be established in the new film - not to show how much stronger Superman is, but rather how different each character is from the other. Which brings us to the next point...

2. No Versus!

The potential titles and the quote from The Dark Knight Returns (DKR) which is inspiring this film have me worried that this movie will focus on the antagonism between the two heroes. The Avengers had scenes where the heroes fought each other, but they were for the most part on equal ground. While it was cool to see the fight from DKR animated (I recommend that 2 part animated film), that should not be the focus of a film starring these two superheroes. As mentioned previously, their skill sets are so different that unless Batman has developed a specific strategy or Superman is somehow de-powered, there is no contest as to who would win a fight. In Superman: TAS, the conflict between Superman and Batman was played out with words (their first meeting being an exception). They argued over each other's methods, their respective sanities, their relationships with Lex and Lois, and their mutual skepticism of each other. It wasn't really until the final fight that the two heroes finally started working together. This should be how any conflict between the two characters should be portrayed in the new film.

1. Creating A Strong Relationship Between Superman And Batman

Batman Superman Logo2 In light of Ben Affleck being cast as an older, more experienced Batman, and Henry Cavill's character from Man of Steel, there are many opportunities for building a strong character dynamic. This universe's Superman is learning to trust humanity and encountering a seasoned vigilante who views Superman as a threat could be a critical turning point for Clark. Coming to reconcile the differences between the two of them might help this new Batman come to trust in the hope that the House of El is supposed to symbolise. So those are the 10 Lessons the "Untitled Man of Steel" sequel can learn from Superman: The Animated Series. Are there more lessons that were missed? What plot elements do you think should be considered in the new film? Share your ideas in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

A Catholic, Canadian university student who lives in the national capital city of Ottawa. Student of Public Administration, and lover of popular culture. Lover of film, comic books, MLP: FiM, and anime.