10 Major Issues Surrounding The Justice League Movie

Is DC's answer to The Avengers doomed to fail?

In a huge announcement that dictates the entire future of DC's Cinematic Universe, it was announced that Zack Snyder's still-untitled Man of Steel sequel will shoot back-to-back with a Justice League movie. On one hand, many comic book fans have every right to be excited that the long-awaited team-up is finally happening on the big screen, while others are concerned that the project has been fast-tracked in an attempt to cash in on the unprecedented success of Marvel Studios and The Avengers. It's hard not to feel sorry for Henry Cavill in all this. The British actor did a solid job as a more grounded Clark Kent/Superman in Man of Steel, and by the end of that movie the sequel was perfectly set up to carry on the established Superman mythos. Suddenly the actor finds his sequel needing to accommodate Batman, who will require just as much screentime, before Justice League will likely see his role reduced even further to make way for the rest of the ensemble. With the flurry of casting additions and rumors that have recently surrounded the project, the announcement has hardly come as a surprise. The original date for the Man of Steel sequel was pushed back from July 2015 to May 2016, with Justice League widely expected to arrive during the summer of 2017. This article will take a look at ten issues surrounding the project, how problematic they could be and how the production process could possibly solve them...

10. There Has Already Been A Failed Justice League Movie

DC and Warner Bros. have been desperate to get a Justice League movie off the ground for years now, and came mighty close a few years back. In early 2007, Kieran and Michele Mulroney were hired to write, with Mad Max and Happy Feet director George Miller behind the camera. Budgeted at a hefty $220m, the production headed to Miller's native Australia where the bulk of shooting was due to take place. Weta had begun pre-visualisation and costume tests, while the Justice League itself was fully cast. Armie Hammer, DJ Cotrona, Adam Brody, Megan Gale and Common were cast as Batman, Superman, Flash, Wonder Woman and Green Lantern respectively, with Aquaman and Martian Manhunter also part of the team and Jay Baruchel as the villain. However, with the cast in Australia prepping for the shoot the movie was abruptly cancelled. Studio executives were nervous over a movie featuring lesser-known actors taking place outside of the established movie continuity with a budget that had spiralled to $300m. Which is fair enough, really. Last year, the script for Justice League: Mortal leaked online and it certainly makes for an interesting read. Not necessarily a good read, but an interesting one nonetheless. Last time out a combination of low interest, a huge budget, an unknown cast and the writer's strike curtailed the Justice League movie. This time, all of the pieces seem to be falling into place but with Zack Snyder's version likely to be just as expensive and ambitious, hopefully they manage a better script.

9. The Back-To-Back Shoot

It has become a fairly common practice in recent years for massive productions to shoot back-to-back, and it is a practice that has brought decidedly mixed results. The critical and commercial response to the Lord of the Rings trilogy and Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows that proves the strategy works, although it seems better suited to literary adaptations where the source material already exists. The two projects that immediately spring to mind are The Matrix and Pirates of the Caribbean sequels; two follow-up movies to almost universally-loved blockbuster movies that were shot back-to-back. These franchises saw the first sequel make a huge increase in performance, but critical and audience apathy saw the box office returns significantly drop for the second sequel. However, it is safe to assume that Man of Steel, the first chapter in this instance, isn't as well-liked as either The Matrix or Curse of the Black Pearl. Shooting two parts of the same story back-to-back is difficult enough, but Superman vs Batman and Justice League couldn't be more different; one is a pseudo-sequel to Man of Steel that reintroduces Batman to cinema audiences, the other is an ensemble superhero movie that will see the big-screen debut of several DC characters in Warner Bros. answer to The Avengers. Then there is the danger that repetitiveness of creative fatigue could set in as Zack Snyder likely prepares to embark on what will be at least a 12 month shoot. Based on previous experience, the back-to-back shooting schedule hasn't brought the best creative results.

8. Has This Really Been The Plan All Along?

One of the main criticisms levelled at the announcement of first Batman vs Superman and then Justice League is that the whole strategy seems rushed together, in an attempt to capitalize on the success of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Whereas it took Marvel four years, five movies and plenty of Easter Egg references and credit stings to build towards The Avengers, Man of Steel was a seemingly standalone Superman movie that has snowballed into the catalyst for DC's Cinematic Universe. It is well known that DC and Warner Bros. have been craving a Justice League movie for years now, but it has never been able to come together. Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy took place in its own universe, Superman had to be rebooted for the second time in less than a decade after Superman Returns under-performed, while Green Lantern flat-out flopped. It seems that as soon as the pieces fell into place, DC have taken the ball and ran as fast as they could with it. The end of The Dark Knight trilogy presented the opportunity to introduce a new cinematic iteration of Batman, and perhaps the mixed reaction to Man of Steel led to the announcement that DC's two icons would appear in the same movie, a mere four years after the conclusion of Nolan's multi-billion dollar, critically praised series. Everybody knew that DC would eventually build towards a Justice League movie, but the announcement that it would immediately follow Batman vs Superman came right out of the blue, and smacks of DC and Warner Bros. throwing all of their eggs into one basket.

7. Recasting

Another problem presented by the announcement of the Justice League movie is casting the project. There has been a flurry of recent activity on the casting front regarding Batman vs Superman, so much so that the movie is starting to look a little crowded. And that's without even considering the further additions that the Justice League inevitably requires, which could also involve the tricky business of recasting. Ryan Reynolds infamously played the title character in 2011's Green Lantern, a bloated $200m misfire that barely made back its budget at the box office and instantly killed any franchise potential. Last year, David Goyer said that Man of Steel was the first movie in an expanding DC Cinematic Universe, which effectively eliminated Green Lantern from any canon. Such is the nature of the business, it is more than likely that Reynolds signed a contract that included sequels, and perhaps Warner Bros. could take up that option. However, it seems more likely that the character will be recast and audiences will get their second big-screen Green Lantern in less than a decade. Which could be for the best, given the reputation of Martin Campbell's big budget flop. George Miller's abandoned Justice League featured the John Stewart iteration of the character, maybe this one will too. Similarly, the two DC-related shows on television could create confusion when it comes to the Justice League movie. The Flash is a founding member of the Justice League, and a series based on the character is set to debut this year with Grant Gustin in the lead role. It seems unlikely that Warner Bros. will opt for an unknown television actor in their mega budget blockbuster, and the same will likely apply to Stephen Amell's Green Arrow. Despite being one of the most consistently entertaining shows on TV, if Green Arrow is involved in the Justice League movie it seems unlikely that Amell would be asked to reprise his role. Which is a shame; Amell has expressed his desire to take the character to the big screen, the actor has the support of a large portion of the fan community and it would provide some connective tissue between the big and small screen DC Universes.

6. Batman Vs. Superman Could Become An Afterthought

With all the buzz surrounding the announcement of the Justice League movie, let's not forget that we need to get the Man of Steel sequel out of the way first. It seems strange that the movie still doesn't have an official title given the imminent start of principal photography, and there is a real chance that the focus on Justice League could ultimately harm the movie. Think along the lines of Iron Man 2; a sequel to a blockbuster superhero origin story that served merely as a placeholder and focused more on establishing the wider mythology and foreshadowing coming events that acting as a self-contained movie. Seeing as Batman Vs. Superman is both a sequel to Man of Steel, a cinematic reboot for Batman and a direct lead-in to the biggest superhero movie outside of The Avengers, the project is in danger of collapsing under its own weight. As well as introducing Ben Affleck's Caped Crusader, along with Jeremy Irons' Alfred, the movie also needs to focus just as much on Henry Cavill's Clark Kent, who at the end of Man of Steel had just taken a job at the Daily Planet. This means the movie needs to set up the conflict between the characters, integrate Lex Luthor into the story, continue Clark's relationship with Lois Lane and interactions with Perry White, while also bringing Wonder Woman, Cyborg and possibly others into the fold in order to sufficiently set up the world of Justice League by the time the credits roll. With all this going on, the two iconic superheroes could be in danger of being overshadowed in their own movie.

5. Too Many Characters, Not Enough Screentime

One of the more obvious problems in creating a successful Justice League movie is to make sure that none of the characters are underdeveloped. The movie will have a hard time in maintaining the delicate balancing act between introducing new characters and paying service to the established ones, especially when you consider the sheer size of the cast that a project of this scale requires. Carrying over from Batman vs Superman will obviously be Henry Cavill and Ben Affleck, as well as Jeremy Irons, Gal Gadot and Ray Fisher. There is also a chance that Jesse Eisenberg, Holly Hunter, Diane Lane, Amy Adams, Laurence Fishburne and Harry Lennix could all appear in some capacity, depending on the outcome of the narrative. Then, in Justice League the movie will need to introduce the remaining team members, whoever they may be. It seems safe to assume that Green Lantern and The Flash will be part of the Justice League, and the filmmakers can choose from the likes of Aquaman, Green Arrow and Martian Manhunter to make up the numbers. Then there is the matter of casting the villain or villains, and the continuing rumors of Dwayne Johnson's involvement with DC and their movie division. Mixing the recognizable characters with those making their cinematic debuts will be a tough task, and it will be difficult to make sure that nobody gets lost in the shuffle. Which leads us to the next major issue...

4. The Script Needs To Be Very, Very Good

It wasn't just the fanboy wish-fulfillment and spectacular action sequences that made The Avengers such a massive success; the script was just as important. In Joss Whedon's hands, what could have easily disintegrated into a mindless series of set-pieces was instilled with wit, charm and no shortage of humor. It was maintaining this balance that made The Avengers such an enjoyable experience, and is something that the Justice League adaptation should keep in mind. However, the continued involvement of David Goyer doesn't instil a lot of confidence. Goyer reportedly landed a three-picture deal from Warner Bros. that covers Man of Steel, Batman vs Superman and Justice League, so at least there will be some connective tissue throughout the three screenplays. As a writer, Goyer has a lot of great ideas but comes up short in the character and dialogue departments when scripting on his own. It comes as no surprise that his most acclaimed screenplays were co-written with the Nolan brothers, or that Academy Award winner Chris Terrio was brought onboard to rewrite Goyer's draft of Batman vs Superman. At this moment in time the Justice League script is reported to be 'in development', which is to be expected given the release date is several years away. It would be safe to assume that Goyer will at least be involved in the initial drafts and working out the story, but a talented writer is definitely needed for the project. In a bold attempt to replicate the success of The Avengers just three movies into their shared cinematic universe, a Justice League script will need to balance the huge-scale action with the smaller dramatic moments and give each character their due, especially as several of them will be making their big-screen debuts. After the flat dialogue and dearth of humor that affected Man of Steel, a lot more vibrancy is needed in the scripting to prevent things from becoming tedious, especially with all the backstory that Justice League needs to get out of the way.

3. Is Zack Snyder The Right Man For The Job?

Zack Snyder is one of the most commercially successful directors working today, proven by the fact that his six features have earned well over $1.5bn at the box office. As a director he has a very distinct visual style, but his career has been dogged by claims that his work is all style and no substance. With a project as complex as Justice League, will Snyder be able to pull off the mix of ensemble feature, superhero movie and summer blockbuster without losing sight of the characters? I'm not so sure. Credit where credit is due; Snyder is one of the best visual directors working in Hollywood today. However, great scripts and character development aren't usually associated with his work. That being said, he is much better at adapting existing materials than creating his own projects as evidenced by the vitriolic critical and commercial reception to Sucker Punch. Although it seems increasingly likely than Ben Affleck will direct the next solo Batman movie, Zack Snyder is currently the only man behind the camera when it comes to the DC Cinematic Universe. Although that brings some consistency, it could also see things becoming stale and repetitive. While Man of Steel was undeniably spectacular when it came to the action scenes, the movie tended to fall flat when it came to the smaller moments. Too many characters were painfully one-dimensional, with woefully underdeveloped relationships and interactions. Snyder will no doubt acquit himself well when it comes to the action, but his ability to handle the more intimate moments will be under more intense scrutiny than ever as Batman vs Superman and then Justice League increase the number of characters and the increasingly complicated relationships between them.

2. Warner Bros. Don't Have The Best Track Record With The Characters

DC and Warner Bros. pressing ahead so quickly with a Justice League movie could very well have something to do with the fact that outside of Batman and Superman, the studio have struggled to make any of their other top-tier characters relevant to cinema audiences. It speaks volumes about the ability to create projects for their other characters that Batman and Superman boast 14 theatrical releases between them while Wonder Woman and others still sit at a big fat zero. Man of Steel rebooted the title character just 7 years after the disappointing critical and commercial performance of Bryan Singer's Superman Returns nixed any franchise potential. Similarly, Ben Affleck's upcoming turn as Batman will come just 4 years after the conclusion of Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy, generally regarded as the greatest superhero series ever committed to film. Green Lantern spent years in development, only for the movie to flop spectacularly when it finally hit theaters. Ever since the turn of the 21st Century talk of a live-action Wonder Woman movie has been constant, with the names of Joss Whedon and Nicholas Wending Refn interested over the years before Gal Gadot was announced to be playing the character in Batman vs Superman. The Flash was initially announced in 2004 with David Goyer at the helm, then with Shawn Levy in 2007 and again with Greg Berlanti in 2010 but nothing ever came together. There were rumors of an Aquaman solo project that quickly disappeared, adding to the list of DC characters that have failed to make the leap to the big-screen. With such a long history of adaptations that haven't even gotten past the development stage, its a risky move to throw nearly all of them into one movie without so much as an origin story.

1. The DC Cinematic Universe Has Expanded Far Too Quickly

Only two movies after Man of Steel, DC is playing its full hand and giving us a Justice League movie. While there is plenty of cause for excitement, it is also an incredibly risky move to hedge their bets for a shared cinematic universe on just one movie, given the number of variables. Man of Steel was widely predicted to sail past the billion dollar mark at the box office, and only in today's Hollywood would a total gross of $688m be regarded as a slight disappointment. Instead of allowing the Superman universe to explore the established mythology in a straightforward sequel, things quickly escalated and instead we are now having Superman vs Batman shot back-to-back with Justice League. The casting of Ben Affleck as Batman has greatly divided opinion, and the project will be one of the most anticipated movies in history. But how would it affect the Justice League movie if Batman Vs. Superman was a commercial disappointment? What if the movie received less than favorable reviews? That would create a severe problem for the follow-up. As for Justice League itself; if the reviews are less than great then the DC Cinematic Universe could be dead in the water. Poor reactions to the movie and/or the likes of Wonder Woman, Cyborg, Green Lantern and The Flash would make the public more reluctant to see these characters in their own standalone movies. Obviously, Superman and Batman would remain largely unscathed by any backlash but the Justice League project is as ambitious as it is risky; by placing all of their faith in one movie DC and Warner Bros. could either secure the future of their shared cinematic universe, or see the whole thing fall apart in just one movie. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor

I don't do social media, so like or follow me in person but please maintain a safe distance or the authorities will be notified. Don't snap me though, I'll probably break. I was once labelled a misogynist on this very site in a twenty paragraph-long rant for daring to speak ill of the Twilight franchise. I stand by what I said, it's crap.