10 MCU Moments Better Than Their Comic Origin

Marvelous movie moments that rise above their comic book beginnings...

Avengers Infinity War Thanos
Marvel Studios

The MCU is a modern-day miracle of cinema, with its expansive nature, interconnected narratives and likeable and aspirational characters entertaining audiences, impressing critics and shattering box-office records since the release of the first Iron Man movie in 2008 and showing no signs of stopping even after the end of the Infinity Saga.

Due to its influence, characters who were once considered to be in the B-list such as Iron Man and Black Panther are now household names and various actors with the first name of Chris are nearly at the top of the Hollywood mountain. However, it would be amiss of anyone to ignore that the comic books that inspired this massive franchise. Seminal Marvel storylines such as the Infinity Gauntlet, Demons in a Bottle, and Planet Hulk have inspired all of the MCU films to varying levels of success.

But it hasn't always been a case of pure adaptation, as the MCU tends to steer away from the source material to throw in some shocks. And frankly, the films have on more than one occasion surpassed their source material and turned cheesy, problematic, or otherwise dull moments into gems that added to their movies' overall entertainment value and quality.

10. The Birth Of The Vision

The Vision Paul Bettany Avengers
Marvel Studios

The MCU's resident android powerhouse/sweater-loving chef's origin in the movies is significantly more grandiose and relevant to the Infinity Saga's story than the comic iteration. Both versions are creations of the villainous Ultron to be used in his goal to destroy Earth's mightiest heroes.

However, the differences lie in the Vision's powerset, creation, change in allegiance, and motivations. The comic book Vision was specifically created to kill Ultron's creator, Hank Pym/the first Ant-Man but had a change of heart after an encounter with Janet van Dyne (the Wasp). The film version is also a creation of Ultron but he was designed to be the AI's final form, complete with an Infinity Stone and vibranium body.

What separates MCU Vision from his comic counterpart is how his being and creation represents an aspect of the core Avengers team. His synthetic body is lined with vibranium just like Captain America's shield, his personality is reminiscent of Jarvis, Iron Man's trusty AI system and he is brought to life by Thor's lightning. The presence of the Mind Stone in his forehead further ties him to the films' greater narrative, giving him a level of importance rarely seen in the comics.


9. Hail Hydra

Avengers Endgame Captain America
Marvel Studios

Two words uttered by everyone's favourite Star-Spangled Man with a plan sent shockwaves across comic book fandoms worldwide, and not in a good way. Once the Captain said the Nazi cult's calling card out loud, controversy ensued due to the implications that the very man who fought against Nazi tyranny and ideologies would be part of the cult itself. It was a betrayal of the character's spirit and ignored his creators' Jewish heritage.

It was all revealed to be reality-warping by the Red Skull who was in possession of a sentient Cosmic Cube, but it did not change the problematic nature of the story. However, Avengers: Endgame took this moment and actually made it work in an organic and fan-pleasing way.

During the film's time heist, Captain America attempts to retrieve the Scepter (which had the Mind Stone) from S.H.I.E.L.D./Hydra agents. He then finds himself in an elevator very reminiscent of the infamous elevator fight from Winter Soldier, down to being surrounded by the same agents.

However, instead of fighting his way through the agents, he simply whispers Hail Hydra in one of their ears and takes off with the Scepter without having thrown a punch. It was a great moment that called back to one of the more memorable fight scenes in the MCU and showed Steve Rogers' growth in his tactical work since his earlier days.


8. Peter Quill's Parentage

Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol 2 Ego
Marvel Studios

Star-Lord (Chris Pratt)'s parentage in the MCU greatly differs from its comics origin and as a result, it is more tragic and cosmic.

Both iterations' mothers are named Meredith Quill and their deaths are the result of their lovers (directly or indirectly) but that's where the similarities end. Comics Meredith lived to see Peter reach adulthood, only to be killed by a warrior alien race known as the Badoon. These beings were hunting J'son of Spartax, comics Star-Lord's father. Her film counterpart died of terminal cancer induced by her paramour and father of her child, Ego the Living Planet.

Both iterations of the hero's father were villainous in nature but Ego really took the cake in heinous and disturbing acts. In addition to killing Meredith, he murdered a countless number of his children that did not possess his Celestial genes and set out to consume numerous worlds, forcing Star-Lord and the rest of the Guardians to kill him, but at the cost of the life of Star-Lord's other father figure, Yondu.

The character's parentage in the MCU is weightier, more complex and messier than the more standard origin found in the comics.


7. The Avengers' First Assembly

Avengers Assemble
Marvel Studios

Marvel's premier superhero team's first heroic act was a lot grander in scale in the MCU compared to the relatively contained team-up in the comics. Both versions have the build-up behind them, Loki as the main villain, similar rosters (with a few exceptions) and a rampaging Hulk to deal with.

The comics version of the team-up was understandably smaller in scale and barely involved a physical version of Loki till near the story's conclusion, there are bonkers plot beats such as Hulk joining the circus to avoid capture and god-draining volcanoes. It's definitely a classic story and without it, we wouldn't have Earth Mightiest Heroes. However, it lacks any real tension and is very much defined by its era's camp and lightness.

The film version is still a breeze, but with more contemporary and subtle moments of humor and a grand scale befitting the capabilities of the heroes. It also helps that Captain America is a founding member as opposed to joining the team in its later adventures; his presence gives the team a tactical advantage and acts as the team's heart.


6. The Infinity Saga's Final Showdown

Avengers Endgame avengers assemble
Marvel Studios

One of the biggest moments in both the MCU and the comics was the climactic battle between the heroes and Thanos following the snap that decimated half the universe's population. Both versions of the conflict were some of the most epic battles in their respective mediums and are excellent showcases for how grand and complex superhero storytelling can be.

Right off the bat, the comic iteration had a wider scope (most of it takes place in space) and a massive cast of characters such as the Silver Surfer, cosmic entities such as Galactus, and the personification of Death. More heroes die in the storyline than its film counterpart and Thanos' grandaughter Nebula is the one who eventually defeats Thanos.

The film adaptation of this story eschews the large cast for a still high number of heroes and supporting characters, is relatively smaller in scope, and takes place on Earth. This grounds the event's proceedings and is more cathartic and emotional, especially during the resurrected heroes' triumphant return and Iron Man's sacrifice. Both versions work well under their specific set of conditions but the film adaptation has more relatable characters, is less convoluted and therefore easier to follow.


5. The Avengers' Opposing Ideologies During Civil War

Civil War
Marvel Comics

The Civil War storyline in the comics and MCU shook the foundation of each universe and effectively tore the Avengers apart and had long-lasting consequences on both versions of the team. The events that lead up to the titular clash are similar (an oversight by a relatively new hero leads to the death of innocents) and disagreements between the heroes on the impact the newly created legally binding document (the Superhero Registration Act and Sokovia Accords in the comics and movies, respectively) have on the heroes' personal liberties and freedoms.

The Civil War seen in the comics was characterized by betrayal, mistrust, and tested bonds between heroes such as the Invisible Woman and Mr. Fantastic and especially between Captain America and Iron Man. Their opposing ideologies led to Iron Man going down a dark path of imprisoning his former teammates in the Negative Zone and recruiting'reformed' villains. This painted the story in black and white, an act that some saw as robbing the story of moral complexity.

The film adaptation had fewer characters in the story but the main conflict worked due to the main heroes' motivation being more relatable and noble (albeit somewhat misguided) and the story had more personal stakes than its comic counterpart.


4. Killmonger's Death

Black Panther Erik Killmonger
Marvel Studios

The incredible success of the Black Panther film was a win for representation and it introduced wider audiences to the world of Wakanda and its fleshed-out cast of characters. One standout from this group is Erik Killmonger/N'Jadaka(Michael B. Jordan), who was reimagined as T'Challa (Chadwick Boseman)'s cousin in the films.

Despite different family ties, both the comics and film iterations share an intense hatred for the Black Panther and a burning desire to rule Wakanda and establish its global dominance through forceful means. His ideas for Wakanda's prosperity were in conflict with T'Challa's and this led to frequent clashes in the comics medium, some of them leading to his death.

The film version of N'Jadaka suffers a similar fate but his death here (thus far) is more impactful due to it being permanent and it happening on his own terms, wishing to die a free man than live in captivity. It aligns with his desire for his people's freedom from oppression, some of which he has firsthand experience. It's a powerful statement made by one of the MCU's more grounded and captivating antagonists.


3. Dr. Strange's First Encounter With Dormammu

Doctor Strange Dormammu Cumberbatch
Marvel Studios

The conflict between Dr. Strange and Dormammu is a classic David vs Goliath set-up taken up to eleven due to the considerable difference in power between the Dread One and the Sorcerer Supreme. This is especially noteworthy due to Strange possessing incredible mystical power in his own right.

Their first clashes both took place in Dormammu's domain, the Dark Dimension. They both involve Strange engaging Dormammu in place of his mentor the Ancient One and Dormammu dominating the fight due to his overwhelming power advantage, with Strange narrowly claiming victory. The difference lies in how the victory was achieved. The comics version of the encounter saw Strange actually empower Dormammu to defeat a group of beings called the Mindless Ones and this makes Dormammu indebted to Strange for his help.

The film version eschews the Mindless Ones and has Strange trick Dormammu by trapping him in a time loop courtesy of the Time Stone's power. It's a unique and inventive way of stopping a significantly more powerful villain and shows Strange's quick-thinking and intuitive nature.


2. Bucky Remembers Who He Is

Bucky The Winter Soldier
Marvel Studios

Bucky Barnes/the Winter Soldier is one of the more tortured individuals in the collection of Marvel characters due to his unwilling participation in the assassination of a large number of innocent souls across the second half of the 20th Century. This is worsened by the brainwashing and subsequent memory erasion at the hands of a Soviet faction and Hydra in the comics and movies respectively.

Fortunately, in both instances, he regains his memory (albeit with high levels of difficulty) after several encounters with his best friend/former teammate, Steve Rogers/Captain America. These encounters are thrilling and revolve around incredible fisticuffs and shootouts, but at the core of the clashes is an emotional journey of a man attempting to reach out to his best friend and saving him from his captors and cruel deeds.

What elevates the MCU iteration of this story over its comic counterpart is the larger conspiracy story being a backdrop rather than the focus, giving the Steve-Bucky friendship room to breathe, be explored and ultimately have a stronger emotional conclusion as Bucky gradually regains his memories and humanity.


1. The Motivation Behind The Snap

Avengers Infinity War Broken Infinity Gauntlet
Marvel Studios

The Snap performed by the Infinity Gauntlet-wearing Thanos was felt across the comics, movies and even the real world as trillions of lives were instantly lost and numerous members of the fandom were left in shock. This act is now a staple of pop culture with lots of references and parodies that are sure to rise in its wake.

However, the motivations behind the Mad Titan's desire to wipe out half the universe's population greatly differ across the two media. Comic book Thanos performed the act out of a desire to please the living embodiment of Death, a being that he fancied (for some reason). MCU Thanos decided to get all omnicidal due to his fear that the universe's population was exceeding the currently available resources.

It is very evident that the film iteration of the character had a slightly more reasonable (but still highly misguided) rationale for his actions and it gave him more layers as a character; he genuinely believed his quest made him a noble being who was doing the right thing for the universe as opposed to simply being a generic cosmic conqueror.


Watch Next


Contributor

David Ng'ethe hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.