10 MCU Moments That Don't Quite Fit

Sometimes even our favorite heroes make us cringe. These ten moments Marvel moments missed the mark.

Captain America: Civil War
Marvel Studios

When Kevin Feige was handed the reigns to Marvel Studios in 2007, he planned to produce a series of individual hero movies before entwining them into a crossover. This began in 2008 with Iron Man. Since then, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has grown into over 30 feature films and nearly 20 television shows.

In order to preserve artistic integrity and maintain narrative, Marvel Studios formed a creative committee of six people familiar with its comic book lore (including Feige himself). This approach helped to maintain tone and continuity throughout the individual films and shows of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. In doing so, Marvel has been able to weave a tapestry with their characters and stories that have kept viewers invested for the long haul.

While this has been a proven model for success, there have been some moments in the MCU that just feel out of place. An ill-timed joke, out-of-character line or straight up dumb choice can take you out of the scene and remind you that you are just watching actors in a movie. These ten moments needed a few more revisions before making the final cut.

10. Star-Lord Temper Tantrum - Avengers: Infinity War

The Avengers are at their most frustrating when they act as their own worst enemies. Much like Tony Stark and Bruce Banner are kind of responsible for the destruction of Sokovia, Star Lord is more than a little responsible for the snap. If only Nebula had kept quiet, or Peter Quill showed better anger management skills, the whole thing could have been avoided.

In Avengers: Infinity War, we find our big bad Thanos truly vulnerable for the first time. This is thanks to Star-Lord's brilliant plan to collectively subdue the Mad Titan. All it would have taken was letting Iron Man and Spider-Man finish pulling the Infinity Gauntlet free. That's it. No gauntlet, no snap.

Once Quill realizes that Thanos killed Gamora to retrieve the soul stone, he ruins what would have been his biggest contribution to entire arc of the MCU. Instead, Quill allows his emotions to take over and begins to pistol whip Thanos. Besides having no positive impact, the tantrum allowed Thanos to regain his composure as well as the Infinity Gauntlet.

It's because of the snap that The Avengers must go back in time to retrieve the Infinity Stones. Since Black Widow dies in this process, her life can be added to the list of consequences. Not the kind of behavior upon which to build a franchise.


9. Vibranium Mine Fight - Black Panther

Early in Black Panther we see a stunning battle between T'Challa and Killmonger for the throne of Wakanda. The choreography is crisp and the setting is eye-catching. Why then would their final fight give us two cartoonish CGI characters fighting in a cartoonish CGI setting? It's unfortunate that this is the battle left in viewers' minds when the credits roll.

Black Panther had a lot of things going for it. Chadwick Boseman and Michael B. Jordan are spot on as T'Challa and Killmonger. The scenery of Wakanda and the exposure of Wakandan culture gives the film something to hang one's hat upon.

The problem comes in the third act, when it feels as though the studio paid animators double to get the movie done on time. Where there were once remarkable backgrounds and seamless choreography, the film's climax switches gears into a jarring CGI fest. The scene is akin to the underground "rave" scene in The Matrix Reloaded. Afterwards, you find yourself thinking "Overall the movie was really good, but there was that one scene...".

Considering the number of eyes on each Marvel project, it's surprising that somebody didn't raise their hand about this sequence. Audiences would have surely been willing to wait another couple or months if it meant cleaning up this otherwise out-of-place scene.


8. The Self-Cooking Hot Dog - Captain America: Civil War

If the DC Extended Universe can be criticized for being too dark and gloomy, Marvel can be criticized for taking the humor too far sometimes. It should be noted that just because Tony Stark is funny, it doesn't mean everyone who is in a scene with Tony Stark should be funny.

Humor must also be appropriate for the characters and the setting, otherwise it feels forced and pulls the audience out of the moment. This particular offense occurs in the beginning of Captain America: Civil War.

As Tony Stark walks offstage after delivering a philanthropic speech to the students of MIT, he’s followed by an enthusiastic but doltish faculty member who slimily courts Stark for money by pitching his idea for self-cooking hotdogs. Of all the things it could have been, the self-cooking hotdog is a little too far into cornyville to be believable. They double down by having the man explain that the secret is a small thermal charge inside each one. Funny is funny, but this requires too much suspension of disbelief.

We can buy that Tony Stark is Iron Man and gamma rays turn people into Hulks. We can't buy that a man intelligent enough to be an MIT professor would shoot his one shot at glory for a self-cooking hot dog.


7. Revealing The Mandarin - Iron Man 3

In a storyline that appears to be yanked from bad pro wrestling, The Mandarin's portrayal in the MCU has been, at best, confusing. At worst it's another patched-up continuity error.

The Mandarin has been Iron Man's arch-nemesis in the comics for decades. In 2013's Iron Man 3, we learn that a dastardly terrorist named the Mandarin is responsible for a number of recent attacks. Despite Mandarin's status in the comics, the film portrays Mandarin as a second-tier villain next to Extremis creator Aldrich Killian.

Iron Man eventually catches up to Mandarin only to discover... that he is not the real Mandarin! He is an actor named Trevor Slattery, a man who was installed as a puppet figurehead to protect the real Mandarin's identity.

Once we are deep into the movie's third act, we discover that not only was Slattery a fake, but the real Mandarin was in fact... Aldrich Killian? The plot twist fell flat with comics fans. What's worse is that in 2021's Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings, Marvel attempted to retcon this move by bringing in yet another "real" Mandarin (and they mean it this time).


6. "We Have Orders." - The Avengers

This scene comes from Joss Whedon's The Avengers. Everything we learn about Captain America up to and after this scene suggests that he will always prioritize his moral compass, even if it means disobeying an order. In some instances it feels as though in scenes with both Captain America and Tony Stark, Cap gets a little lamer and more conservative, mainly to juxtapose Stark.

After the two smartest people in the room (Stark and Bruce Banner) explain to Cap that SHIELD is hiding something regarding Loki and the tesseract, Cap dismisses their valid (and correct) concerns with a generic "We have orders. We should follow them." Rather than sound like something Captain America would say in the moment, it feels as though the writers wanted to pitch a softball to Tony Stark just to set up his comeback, "I'm not the following type".

The dialogue choice isn't offensive, nor does it warrant a major eye roll. It just doesn't quite fit. So, Captain America de-frosts after 70 years only to blindly follow orders from an organization he know longer knows, rather than give credence to a potentially disastrous issue brought forth by two super-geniuses.

It's not the move of a guy known for his prowess in military tactics.


5. Agent Sitwell's Name Drop - Captain America: The Winter Soldier

This scene has been the source of much debate by fans online. In Captain America: The Winter Soldier, SHIELD/HYDRA agent Sitwell confesses to Captain America that Dr. Zola developed an algorithm that could calculate if someone is a threat to Hydra based on their past actions. Sitwell specifically names Tony Stark, Bruce Banner and Stephen Strange.

The issue is that the events of Winter Soldier take place in 2014. Stephen Strange doesn't begin his training in the mystic arts until 2016. Marvel Studios has tried to explain this, stating that the algorithm names POTENTIAL targets. Fans defended the line, saying that the algorithm was so advanced that it knew what Stephen Strange would become. What has been dismissed as just a fun Easter egg to foreshadow Dr. Strange's arrival in the MCU feels like a continuity error that had to be cleaned up after the fact.

It's possible that there was no mistake, and what happened was exactly what was intended. If so, the onus is either on the writers of Winter Soldier for putting the line in, or the writers of Doctor Strange for not addressing it. Even a small explanation would be enough to let us stretch our disbelief a little bit further. As is, the scene feels like a small hole that was never filled.


4. Hawkeye's Brilliant Plan - Avengers: Age Of Ultron

Imagine this: You are highly-trained SHIELD operative Clint Barton. Your genius friends created an artificially intelligent robot who whomps the Avengers in their own home, creates an army of drones, and enlists the help of two mutants (One of whom can read minds). After the mind reader sends Hulk in a rampage and shows everyone their worst nightmares, you and your friends need to split ASAP.

Being a seasoned spy, you would have access to a number of off-the-book safehouses for just this kind of situation. Instead, you lead your friends (and potentially a murderous, metal horde) straight to your family farmhouse. Why did he do this? Ultron had access to all digital information and Wanda Maximoff could have read his mind, for all he knew.

After his lackluster portrayal in The Avengers, Hawkeye deserved to have a little more spotlight. Exposing Barton's background set the stage for what would become his Disney Plus series. Fans loved the introduction of Barton's family into the MCU, and it did increase emotional investment into the character.

Jeremy Renner and Linda Cardellini's innate charm are a win, but doing it in this way just seems questionable for a guy who was savvy enough to survive whatever the hell happened in Budapest.


3. "Beep Beep" - Avengers: Age Of Ultron

In some ways, Avengers: Age of Ultron feels as though it's a whole movie that doesn't quite fit with the rest of the MCU. It's a fun watch overall, and it has some fantastic moments. There is one though that seems to be stuck in the craw of some attentive viewers.

While unstoppable killing machine Ultron wreaks havoc on both Captain America and the surrounding city, Black Widow speeds to Cap's aid on a motorcycle. For perspective, Cap is absolutely getting his lunch eaten by Ultron. With her friend and an entire country's lives at stake, this is the time for Widow to be all business.

In this moment of high tension, Widow has to drive her motorcycle down a flight of outdoor stairs and back into the street. As she descends said stairs, this Soviet-trained assassin warns civilians out of her path with an unenthusiastic "Beep Beep".

At such a critical time, one may think that a "Move!" or "Get out of the way!" might instinctively come out. Rather, she treats the situation as though someone's grocery cart is blocking her entry to the bread aisle.

It wasn't funny or necessary to the scene. Should have fixed it in post.


2. Girl Power - Avengers Endgame

What are the mathematical chances of the nine main female heroes all being at the right place at the right time amid Endgame's epic final battle?

Marvel have had some great female heroes over the years, but for the longest time seemed to lack the confidence to ever put the spotlight on them, or give them their own movie. The fact Black Widow didn't get a solo flick until after she died was testament to that.

In this case then, it's another example of "It's not what you do. It's the way that you do it". Once ALL of the heroes arrive through magic portals, an epic melee ensues between hundreds, if not thousands, of combatants.

During the fracas, Spider Man is tasked with transporting the Infinity Gauntlet into safe hands. A battered Peter Parker is knocked to the ground when Captain Marvel arrives. After delivering another line doesn't quite fit ("You got something for me Peter Parker?") eight other female heroes simultaneously arrive on the scene.

From the audience's standpoint there is no prior communication between the women and no explanation for why they all just happened to be right where they needed to be. It's cool to see them all together, but falls flat because most of these women have no history with each other, no shared bond that allows this team up to truly resonate.

Keep letting women kick ass, but next time portray them in a way that doesn't elicit as many groans.


1. Steve And Sharon's Kiss - Captain America: Civil War

This is another example of an idea that sounded great at the moment, but feels awkward in hindsight. Even if one accepts the idea that Steve Rogers would be romantically involved with his soul mate's niece, the entire romance story arc ended at Civil War.

Since before Steve Rogers became a super soldier, he was enamored with agent Peggy Carter. Hers was the last face he saw and voice he heard before becoming a "Cap-cicle". We see Cap struggle when he returns 70 years later, knowing that Peggy continued to live her life, grow old, and eventually die.

Despite this, after Steve finds out that his cute neighbor has been spying on him AND is Peggy's niece, they share a romantic kiss in front of Falcon and Bucky. Then...that's it. Thanks to the merits of time travel, Steve quickly ditched the new and improved Agent Carter for the original recipe.

Had Marvel's creative committee known that Steve and Peggy would be together in the end, the brief romance with Sharon just made no sense. If they didn't know Steve and Peggy would be together in the end, no effort was made to address the fact that Sharon was being dumped for her dead aunt. It just doesn't quite fit.


Contributor
Contributor

George is a life-long fan of genre, wrestling and guitars. He is an actor, writer, CrossFit trainer and former WWE storyline writer. He currently works as talent development for PWX wrestling and resides in the birthplace of the zombie movie, Pittsburgh, PA.