10 More Horror Movie Performances That Proved EVERYONE Wrong
Nobody was expecting these actors to be this good as horror stars.
In the eyes of many, horror is a genre that sits a rung below everything else on the great ladder of cinema. It has a reputation of being cheap, un-artistic, and generally just lesser-than, despite the fact that it takes a lot of skill to convincingly perform in a horror picture. It doesn't help that so-called "big names" don't often get stuck into horror, but when they do, they do so in the most surprising of ways.
Some of the shiniest names in acting have tried their hand at scaring people, so much so that there's already a full list of them on this very website. As it turns out, there's enough material for an entirely separate countdown of actors who surprised everyone with these darker roles.
Most of these performers were in serious danger of being typecast before these movies came along and changed everyone's perception of them, getting to display a breadth of abilities that wasn't normally afforded to them. These performances may not have led to any great changes in their careers, but at least these famous faces will always have their horror field trip to look back on with fondness.
10. David Tennant - Fright Night
In 2011, David Tennant had just wrapped up his first stint as the Tenth Doctor on classic sci-fi monolith Doctor Who. Viewers had gotten very used to seeing him as an affable hero overflowing with bumbling British charm, but that all changed when he appeared in the remake of the classic vampire movie, Fright Night.
In the film - which also starred Anthon Yelchin, Colin Farrell, and Toni Collette - Tennant plays Peter Vincent, who Roddy McDowell originally portrayed. Vincent is an actor who found fame as a fictional vampire hunter but has his world turned upside down when a fan, Charley Brewster, turns up at his door and demands help in fighting the real thing.
The character of Peter Vincent is wonderfully snivelling. He’s a complete washout, a shell of the dashing hero he plays on TV, and Tennant handles this grovelling cowardice with ease.
This was the first real hint that the former Time Lord could handle a role that wasn’t so squeaky clean, and this role helped pave the way for his performances in Jessica Jones and Good Omens - there’s more than a little bit of Vincent in Crowley.
9. Tom Hiddleston - Crimson Peak
To millions of Marvel fans across the globe, Tom Hiddleston will always be Loki, trickster god, adopted brother of Thor, and the man who’s come back to life more times than the Nightmare on Elm Street franchise.
2011 was when it all came together for Hiddleston, as he starred in Thor, Woody Allen’s Midnight in Paris, and Steven Spielberg’s War Horse all in the same year. He won legions of fans through his clean-cut brooding Britishness and, for a while, that’s exclusively how he was seen.
The former Mr. Taylor Swift pushed himself in 2015, when he took on the part of Thomas Sharpe in Guillermo del Toro’s Crimson Peak. Sharpe is the proprietor of the titular mansion, which he introduces to his new bride Edith. Whilst staying there, Edith discovers some dark secrets about the Sharpe family through the various ghosts that inhabit the house.
Crimson Peak allowed Hiddleston to get seriously dark for the first time since becoming a major star. The Britishness from before was still there, but it was being utilised in a much more menacing way. Think Loki, but more quietly sinister.
8. Rachel Sennott - Bodies Bodies Bodies
Fans of 2020 coming-of-age comedy Shiva Baby will know Rachel Sennott as the lead character Danielle, a young bisexual woman who has to deal with her eclectic family whilst attending a Jewish funeral. Recent cinemagoers will also recognise her from Bottoms, a high school comedy that she also wrote. However, if none of these sound like your cup of tea, then you need to give 2022’s Bodies Bodies Bodies a go.
Set in a remote house during a hurricane, Bodies Bodies Bodies follows a group of mostly unlikeable people as they descend into chaos after one of them turns up dead. Everybody suspects everybody else of the murder, which in turn leads to even more bloodshed.
Sennott plays Alice, a podcaster who plays a key role in shifting the blame around from person to person. This is still a comedic role, as she definitely plays up Alice’s arrogance to a laughable degree, but there’s more here than just laughs as Alice’s self-preservation instincts kick in.
Even if you don’t like Sennott’s work, Bodies Bodies Bodies is still worth watching, especially for the twist.
7. Bill Pullman - The Serpent And The Rainbow
Cinephiles will recognise Bill Pullman from a lot of different places.
He was Tom Hanks' love rival in Sleepless in Seattle, the lead in David Lynch's mind-boggling Lost Highway, and one of the greatest fictional Presidents of all time, Thomas J. Whitmore in Independence Day.
Before he was giving speeches so rousing they could raise the dead, Pullman made his big breakthrough as the lead character in Spaceballs, Mel Brooks' irreverent take on sci-fi. Less than a year after this comedy tour de force, Pullman appeared in something completely different - a Wes Craven joint named The Serpent and the Rainbow.
Pullman plays an anthropologist who is sent on a mission to Haiti to recover a drug used in so-called "zombie" ceremonies. Whilst there, he encounters the full force of these ancient rituals and ends up embroiled in a battle against a villainous witch doctor.
This was a stark contrast to Pullman's Han Solo parody from a few months earlier, one that caught a lot of people off guard. He would go on to appear in more horror movies, such as Lake Placid, but the less said about that the better.
6. Paris Hilton - House Of Wax
Paris Hilton is a fascinating individual.
One of the first major reality TV stars, Hilton initially gained global fame through her series The Simple Life (as well as something less family-friendly) and helped establish the 21st-century trend of "being famous for being famous". As the world wondered exactly what it was this heiress actually did, she began entering the world of movies, including 2005's House of Wax.
A loose remake of two previous movies, House of Wax is about a group of teens who become the targets of two sadistic killers who murder their victims with hot wax and then leave their bodies on display.
The film wasn't a knockout by any standards, but one thing that took everyone by surprise was that Hilton wasn't the worst thing about it. She actually held her own pretty well, nothing Oscar-worthy, but she didn't embarrass herself in the way some people expected.
Hilton's performance in House of Wax is a classic case of why you should never judge a book by its cover, and goes to show that reality stars aren't as useless as some people would have you believe.
5. Dakota Johnson - Suspiria
Though she’d made a few appearances in minor roles up to that point, Dakota Johnson properly became a mainstream star when he took on the part of Anatasia Steele, the love interest/kidnap victim of Christian Grey in the Fifty Shades of Grey trilogy.
The series was roundly dismissed as smutty fodder and Johnson’s next big headline performance, the rom-com How to Be Single, didn’t fare much better. She did get some more diverse work through the likes of Black Mass and A Bigger Splash, but it wasn’t until she took part in Luca Guadagnino’s 2018 remake of Suspiria that people started to take her more seriously.
Johnson plays a dancer who earns a place at a prestigious academy in Germany. However, once she gets there, she discovers that it is actually a front for a coven of witches, which sends her life spiralling in a very dark direction.
Whilst Johnson’s performance and Suspiria itself divided opinion, the actor had proven that she was willing to take on less conventional roles. And then, a few years later, Madame Web came along and ruined all of her hard work.
Shame.
4. Daniel Radcliffe - The Woman In Black
Between the ages of 12 and 22, Daniel Radcliffe was Harry Potter. Not just in the sense that he played the character in the movies, but more he was the boy wizard in the eyes of millions of people around the world.
Once that series wrapped up, there was concern that Radcliffe would be overshadowed by the role for the rest of his life. Those concerns didn't last for long though, as the year after the Deathly Hallows - Part 2 came out, Radcliffe appeared in something completely different.
He took on the lead role in the second movie adaptation of Susan Hill’s The Woman in Black, playing a man who becomes entangled in the web of a vengeful spirit. The picture, which was marketed on the fact that it was so scary, was a long way removed from the whimsy of Potter and showed that the geeky kid with the glasses was going to be alright.
Since The Woman in Black, Daniel Radcliffe has continued to diversify his output, playing Allen Ginsburg in Kill Your Darlings, a magical creature in Horns, and a dead body in Swiss Army Man. Now that’s variety.
3. Robin Williams - One Hour Photo
Whilst the late great Robin Williams will always be fondly remembered for the countless times he made people laugh, he was much more than a funnyman. He was a four-time Oscar nominee, which included a Best Supporting Actor win for his part in Good Will Hunting, and his lengthy career took him to all sorts of places, including some movies that required him to play the straight man.
One film that sticks out like a sore thumb from the rest of his catalogue is 2002’s One Hour Photo, in which he plays Sy, a technician at a photography store. Sy lives a lonely existence with no family or friends to call his own and forms an unhealthy relationship with a family of customers. When his perception of their perfect life is shattered, he decides to make their life a living hell.
Considering this is the guy who once played a live-action version of Popeye, it’s remarkable that Williams manages to be so terrifying in this film. He plays Sy with a dead-eyed emptiness that makes you believe he is capable of anything - a stunning reversal of his usual type.
2. John Goodman - 10 Cloverfield Lane
John Goodman is one of those actors who is a lot of different things to a lot of different people.
To some, he’s the gun-toting maverick Walter Sobchak from The Big Lebowski. To others, he’s the voice of Sully, the good guy monster from Pixar’s Monster’s Inc. And, if you’re really old, he’s Dan from Roseanne.
In 2016, he became something else entirely when he joined the very minimal cast of 10 Cloverfield Lane. Goodman plays Howard Stambler, one of three people trapped in an underground bunker after a “world-ending event” happens on the surface. The reason that’s in quotation marks is because Michelle, another inhabitant, is sceptical that her fellow tenants are telling the truth, or if this is all some masterplan by Howard to keep them trapped there.
This fantastically claustrophobic film hinges on Goodman bringing a mixture of normalcy but also quiet terror to Howard’s character, He is, on the surface, just an ordinary man, but in this confined world, he poses more of a threat than anyone could possibly realise.
John Goodman was absolutely terrific in this role and a large reason why 10 Cloverfield Lane is so good.
1. Tom Cruise - Interview With The Vampire
Whether he’s riding a motorcycle, jumping out of planes, or running like no other human being has ever run before, Tom Cruise is one of those actors often tagged with the “always plays themselves” label.
This is why it’s always so strange when he steps outside of his wheelhouse, be it as a hedonistic musician in Rock of Ages, a self-aware motivational speaker in Magnolia, or as a brooding bloodsucker in 1994's Interview with the Vampire.
As Lestat de Lioncourt, Cruise's story is recorded by a reporter, including the transformation of Brad Pitt's Louis and Kirsten Dunst's Claudia into fellow vampires and his various scrapes across his long and eventful life. This was a brand new side to the superstar, way darker and over-the-top than anything audiences had seen from him up until that point.
Though he ultimately went back to being a living Action Man, the role of Lestat is forever linked to Cruise and is always one of the first examples deployed when talking about actors playing against type. This performance will live on forever, partially through all the distrubing fan fiction out there between him and Louis.