10 More Terrible Extras Who Completely Ruined Their Scenes
Who cares about Kevin... ELVIS LIVES!
There used to a simpler, more blissful time when the Movie Extra was a dependable, undisruptive influence on movies: they would turn up, do their bit and head home for the day, their pockets nicely lined with a small but fair fee, and their egos sufficiently massaged to stop them ever having unjust aspirations to conquer the world of "real" acting. But then, we discovered that there was actually a clandestine history of Extras not doing as they should have, ruining scenes either by badly over-acting, or simply being bad at things normal people manage every day, like not walking into door-frames, or eating convincingly.
Their actions, whether conscious or otherwise stole focus and ruined their scenes, and it seems the rabbit hole goes even further, with more revelations of useless and destructive Extras emerging all the time. Very occasionally, they can be a positive influence, like the careless cab driver who almost killed Dustin Hoffman on the set of Midnight Cowboy and unwittingly inspired the unscripted line "I'm walking here"!
But mostly, they're a toxic influence, when they get ideas above their station. With that in mind, we're offering a second portrait at the Extras who ruined their scenes, revisiting the concept to bring you ten more idiots who shouldn't really be trusted with even the minor roles. There was almost a place for humble attention seeker Conan O'Brien, whose background appearance in How I Met Your Mother completely overshadowed the entire scene in the foreground, but since that was done in the name of charity, and sight gags don't get the praise they deserve, the talkshow legend gets a pass.
For now.
A special note has to go to Ken Levine who fought back against an over-zealous Extra who attempted to avoid being hit by any pies in a pie fight scene by requesting everyone pay special attention to not getting her. Levine's response was to tell everyone to hit her. Justice.
Honourable Mention
Abusing John Malkovich
John Malkovich is a wonderful actor, whether it's seducing his sister and impressionable young debutantes in Dangerous Liaisons, attempting to kill the president in In The Line Of Fire, or unsuccessfully trying to execute a stuffed bunny in Con Air, his range is astonishing. He even managed to play a really bad actor in Johnny English.
But poor Malkovich was completely upstaged on the set of the very good, but hugely smug Being John Malkovich, by a rogue Extra who took it upon himself to flaunt employment law and acceptable artistic practices to get drunk and ding a can of beer off the actors head from a moving car. How wonderful...
...Except the claim is total horse-plop - no more than the Director's Commentary shenanigans of odd-ball director Spike Jonze. Malkovich himself confirmed that the scene was in fact scripted, and that no such drunk Extra existed.
The thrower of the can was in fact John Cusack's writing partner, as Malkovich told Reddit... "Spike Jonze wanted to cut it because we were late that night and he felt no one would be able to hit me on the head with a half full can of beer from a passing car, and about 70 or 80 sets of hands shot up on the crew saying they would like to try. eventually the task fell to johnny cusack's writing partner and he nailed it on the first try."
10. Elvis Lives... Sort Of
This one harks back to a long-running internet rumour, which undoubtedly has very little basis in truth, unless you're a particularly big fan of conspiracy theories or urban legends, to the degree that normal logical thought completely escapes your brain when confronted with completely refutable evidence.
In John Candy's big Home Alone scene (which was shot with all of his screen time in one long 23 hour day,) in which he channels the spirit of his famous Planes, Traines & Automobiles character, it's almost impossible to ignore the striking looking man in the background behind careless mother Catherine O'Hara. Usually, you'd notice him, and the exchange would end there: he is an Extra after all, and that is his only job.
But that's not how the internet wants this scene to go down, and a particularly virulent rumour strain suggests that this man is none other than Elvis Presley. Rubbish! You cry outrage, and rightly so, but it's an almost impossible feat to watch this scene now and not scrutinise the bearded man's face for some sign that he is in fact The King walking among us once more. He isn't, but that doesn't stop the scene being ruined. Thanks, internet.
9. Batman Begins - The Forgetful Policeman
Usually, a good Extra will blend into the background, even when given a reasonably sized responsibility like telling Batman to turn off his engine, or being involved in a silly sight joke that probably has no place in a gritty realist actioner like Batman Begins for instance.
For some reason, both of those responsibilities were given to the same man, unless the uniformed cop above is one half of identical twins, of course. First off, the cop tells Batman to step away from his vehicle, at the start of the clip below, delivering his line with authenticity and conviction and not really drawing too much attention to himself. Mighty fine work, even if it's not actually very successful.
But then less than two minutes later, the same cop, clearly suffering from some kind of temporary emotional memory loss, asks dispatch to confirm what Batman's car looks like. Apparently, he teleported himself across the city, just as Batman did in The Dark Knight Rises...
Degenerative memory diseases are nothing to be laughed at, but you perhaps shouldn't employ an actor who is going to forget something as big and bold as Batman's car. Because obviously, there's no way the writing or background casting could be to blame here, given that Christopher Nolan is pretty much God.
8. Literally The Worst Crowd Ever - Return Of The Musketeers
Direction: Just act naturally. Response: Immediately forget what natural means.
In the background to this important scene in Russian musical Musketeer film Return Of The Musketeers, not one, but three Extras take it upon themselves to utterly upstage the foreground action.
There must be something about being given a black hat with a white feather that made Extras on the film feel entitled to be ridiculous: first the central actor, with the very obvious effeminate touch, shows his range by reacting wild-eyed to the most meager of prompts, and then the two "artists" to the right hand of shot jostle to remain in shot, looking directly at the camera on at least two separate occasions and generally drawing way too much focus away from the central action.
Shame on you, you merciless attention seekers, and never blight our screens again!
7. Footballer Changes Colour - Wildcats
A continuity error this one, unless the Extra employed in Goldie Hawn's American Football movie Wildcats was some sort of wizard who was able to change his genetic make-up at the drop of a hat.
If that is the case, which it probably isn't, the Extra needs to take a long hard look at himself for the inappropriate time he chose to change his race, while in the middle of a key action scene. Picking the ball up from the quarter back in a sneaky switch move, the African American runner (number 89) negotiates the oncoming traffic of the pack before being taken down by no less than three opposition team members. Progress, and the crowd goes wild.
And then he goes and spoils it all by standing up to salute his coach Goldie Hawn, having somehow turned into a Caucasian during the tackle. Way to spoil a scene.
6. Sinister Man Hits Child In Face - Willy Wonka & The Chocolate Factory
Ignoring the fact that all of the children in this clip willfully ignore the fact that they are supposed to be playing British children, with their not-even-remotely hidden American accents, one of the little blighters gets in the way of a key choreographed routine, and almost gets a considerable whack in the mush as payment.
The Candy Man song is already creepy enough, and not because of the lazily mentioned uncomfortable undertones of the simple man's affectionate treatment of his customers - instead it is the behaviour of the children, who effectively ransack the small businessman's shop, stealing and greedily devouring sweets from the jar, as if they were Class A Drugs.
These little sugar fiends terrorise the sweet shop proprierot, and it's no surprise that he snaps at one stage, opening a hatch in the counter just as a little girl has her face in the way. The subsequent movement looks a lot like the lightning-like ninja reactions of a Matrix manipulating messiah, or like the hatch connects in a sweet spot - either way, disturbing implications all round.
5. Extra Gets Too Big For His Unsatisfied Boots
An Extra is supposed to be inconspicuous and unassuming by his very essence and definition: he must blend in seamlessly, uttering perhaps a few sparse words when given the auspicious opportunity, and never, ever upstaging a main player.
But then sometimes a background artist comes along with ideas above their station, like Layla Sakaralo, who famously improvised her own lines in Star Trek IV and had to be paid more and inducted into the Screen Actor's Guild as a result, and the very worst of these charalatans is a man called Jesse Heiman, who has transcended the usually limiting role of the Extra inhis own special way.
Because he is so terrible at being an Extra - in that he is completely noticable - Heiman has been labelled the World's Greatest Extra, and gets hand-picked for jobs by talents as bright as Michael Bay to loiter around in the background of movie scenes, quite often with his shirt off. This man is not to be cherished - he is a disgrace to his chosen profession, and every time he appears in a movie scene, he ruins it, stealing focus in a way that suggests that Hollywood and TV show producers are far happier to endlessly re-run one stale joke than they are to have their Extras actually blend in.
Nice work if you can get it though. Jesse actually has a comic book equivalent - a pair of hipster cops who appear in numerous comic book storylines, without any explanation. The difference of course, is that these two are MADE UP, and have no aspirations to be actual actors, despite clearly possessing no skill at all.
4. Sweeping Nothing - Quantum Of Solace
What could be simpler than sweeping the floor in the background, and receiving a wage packet at the end of a reasonably easy day's work? It's hardly the most complex acting gig you could get, no matter how low your level of experience.
But even that seems comically beyond this Extra from disappointing James Bond sequel Quantum Of Solace, who for some reason decides to mime sweeping, rather than just getting on with some actual sweeping. Perhaps offending the floor was too much for his tender sensibilities, or perhaps there simply wasn't the budget for the audio team to deal with the huge, invasive sound of bristles on concrete?
Whatever the explanation, the result is the sight of what appears to be a mentally unstable man brushing the air. Because of this man, there is probably now someone with the official job title Broom Wrangler, or Sweeping Tutor on call for every major Hollywood production requiring a little bit of background cleaning.
3. Careless - 10 Things I Hate About You
Extras cannot be relied on to know the rules of cinematography, or the boundaries of a scene, unless they are explicitly marked for them to see. This is naturally difficult if such markings would be visible to the audience, say if they were on the bright green grass of a school football pitch, so clearly sometimes it's better just to hope that the Extra can remain in character as long as they're in frame, or until the director shouts "cut."
This particular Extra from teen Shakespeare reboot 10 Things I Hate About You didn't get that memo: initially she shows her skill and commitment by listening to the silent instructions of her co-Extra to seek medical help for the impaled teacher and running off. Okay, job done - all she needed to do was continue running until the scene ended.
But instead she drops out of her role as soon as she thinks she's ran out of shot, clearly too lazy to expend any more energy than totally necessary. Sadly, she is still completely visible.
2. Man Loves Shark Attacks - Jaws
In the prequel to this article, we mentioned the Jaws Extra whose delivery of the simple line "a what?!" was so comically over-blown and inauthentic that it ruined the dramatic impact of what was a key scene, and he wasn't the only background artist at Martha's Vineyard whose work could be classed as sloppy.
Faced with the somewhat difficult prospect of negotiating the surf and also convincingly conveying the immediate threat of a shark attack, one Extra proved that some men actually cannot multi-task at all, by forgetting the second part of his responsibility.
Rather than rushing into the water with the required look of horror and the immediate need to save the poor souls in the drink, the moustachioed Ron Jeremy lookalike instead runs casually into the water, a huge grin on his face, as if larking about care-free on a summer's day.
1. The Over-Zealous Henchmen - The Dark Knight Rises
As a spectacle, The Dark Knight Rises was great: the style was grand and epic enough to fit the concept, and the tonal decisions were also nailed on. It's just a shame the editing was comparatively poor (especially in terms of how good its predecessors were) and the writing a little imbalanced.
It was all a little sloppy, which is largely the reason why critics take points away from the film (no matter how many commenters suggest that the film was unflawed and universally lauded to the highest degree) and that extended to the background work of one Extra in particular.
This time the Extra mistake cannot be blamed on poor continuity (as the Batman Begins example previously) as the stuntman/Extra involved in this shoddily choreographed fight scene has noone but himself and Batman to blame for falling over without so much as a hint of contact...
Did we miss any terrible Extras who should have made the list? Share your own picks below.