10 Most Disappointing Movie Reboots Since 2000
Falling off a screen near you.
Mirror mirror on the wall, is there anything Hollywood won’t
remake at all?
Judging from the rebooting of everything from Psycho to Footloose, the answer seems to be a resounding no, but if Hollywood’s recycling of ideas has you reaching for the Tylenol you haven’t seen anything yet. Still to come are the proposed reboots of An American Werewolf In London, The Crow and Masters Of The Universe.
You can see why remakes appeal to risk-averse movie executives: movies like The Hitcher or Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles come with a massive potential audience nostalgic for the originals. Hollywood loves nostalgia, although in the case of the Hitcher remake we wished they didn’t love it quite so much.
Singling out ten disappointing remakes is no simple task and for each movie selected there are at least ten that could’ve taken its place so if you disagree with any of the choices remember that everything is subjective and besides, Rob Zombie’s Halloween wasn’t that bad.
10. Robocop
Adored by people who’ve never seen the original, this remake of Paul Verhoeven’s 1987 film plays more like an extended pilot episode for a proposed series with all the wit, satire and violence stripped away.
There’s a funny scene in Verhoeven's movie where Ronny Cox’s corporate villain says he had a guaranteed military sale with ED 209 – renovation program, spare parts for 25 years, the works. Then he says, “Who cares if it worked or not?” That’s this movie in a nutshell.
Even a watered down, forgettable Robocop remake has an audience, not to mention franchise potential – who cares if it works or not? Just add some cool effects, throw in a bunch of name actors (something the original didn’t really have) and you’ve got a guaranteed sale.
9. Fantastic Four (2015)
Time Out called Fantastic Four a movie of two halves “the first likeable and fun, the second tiresome and loud.” It takes its time (50 minutes) setting up the characters, but then goes horribly wrong as second guessing by the studio dilutes their motivations and muddies the narrative. By the second half, you’re no longer invested in the characters or their story because they’ve become more like pieces on a chessboard.
It wouldn’t be the first time a studio threw away a decent film and ordered reshoots to make it “commercial” – exactly the same thing happened to Clive Barker’s Nightbreed, whose scope and majesty was junked in favour of a slasher movie that would appeal to the Friday The 13th crowd.
Was Josh Trank’s movie another casualty of studio filmmaking, or did Fox make the right decision? Hopefully, we’ll see Trank’s cut so we can decide for ourselves.
8. Godzilla (2014)
Released to theaters in 2014 with hopes of reviving the franchise, Godzilla’s remit was simple: don’t be the Roland Emmerich movie. Director Gareth Edwards gamely took on the challenge, but his movie is po-faced, short on fun and ultimately pretty dull.
There’s also something vaguely sinister about the movie’s military fetishism, and critics were quick to point out that for every minute of Godzilla action there appears to be five minutes of loving close-ups of tanks, choppers and aircraft carriers.
The lead character is a Lieutenant in the US Navy and whenever he’s on screen the film turns into a recruiting ad, with shots of his perfect family followed by him conducting himself honourably in combat.
Not surprisingly, the military provided full support.
“Some of the people who will be watching Godzilla aren’t going to be watching the evening news,” said Lt Col Steven R Cole, a military advisor. “But they may learn about the Army from this or any other movie or TV show that we supported.”
7. The Mummy
Intended to launch Universal’s Dark Universe, The Mummy instead set tongues wagging with its bizarre creative choices. Why did Russell Crowe’s Dr Jekyll transform into Ray Winstone? Who decided to give Tom Cruise an undead comic relief sidekick?
Of all the phrases you’d never imagine yourself using before this film came out, “Tom Cruise is no Brendon Fraser” is top of the list, and this Mummy never manages to be as much dumb fun as the 1999 movie. That film might’ve been a glorified Indiana Jones-style adventure but it at least had a consistent tone and enough large-scale action sequences to cover its redundancies.
Never particularly funny, thrilling or appealing, this is one movie that might have benefited from Gerard Butler in the lead (emphasis on might have) who by now can make any nonsense at least partially interesting. Laugh all you like, but he still managed to turn Olympus Has Fallen into a franchise.
6. The Amazing Spider-Man
Lacking the wit and visual flair of Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man movies, this reboot (or rebranding or recalibration, whatever) settles for doing everything by the numbers. Raimi showed a good eye for character, but this version feels untouched by human hands, a pod person’s idea of what a superhero movie is supposed to be.
Assembled by committee, the film takes too long to cut to the chase, and when Spider-Man first confronts The Lizard, there’s more than a touch of déjà vu to the proceedings. Did we really need another action sequence set on a bridge where the superhero rushes to the aid of a parent who screams, “Help! My kid is trapped!”
If ever a movie could’ve learned from The Incredible Hulk and ditched the origin story in favour of plot and action, it’s this one. You can see why Sony lost patience with the series: between them, this movie and its sequel made less money in the US than Raimi’s Spider-Man did in 2002.
5. The Day The Earth Stood Still
In Robert Wise’s 1951 original, our planet was brought to its knees by Klaatu, a surrogate Christ who adopted the name “Carpenter” during his time on Earth. Killed by the people he was attempting to help, Klaatu was resurrected and urged world leaders to embrace pacifism before returning to the stars.
This 2008 remake casts Keanu Reeves as Klaatu and the filmmakers have unwisely retained the Messianic angle, even throwing in a scene where Keanu appears to be walking on water. That should at least guarantee a few cheap laughs, but the film’s ultimately too sluggish and po-faced to be funny.
Instead, the filmmakers jettison the whole pacifism plot so in this version the Earth doesn’t actually stand still, it has to be destroyed in order to save it. Or something. Then someone persuades Klaatu that humanity isn’t really so bad so he relents, and the last person left in the theater goes to the box office to demand their money back.
4. Total Recall
Ah, the summer of 1990: when Paul Verhoeven’s Total Recall opened that June, the R-rated movie cost a then unheard of $70 million and packed in more blood, gunfights and mind-bending ideas than any of its competitors.
Clearly, the only way to remake the film for the Twitter generation was to rate it PG-13, cutting out all the zingers, all the fun and most of the plot. So much story has been removed, and replaced by blah chase sequences, that all the life gets sucked out of the story. Jessica Biel suddenly appears, and there’s a chase. Bill Nighy suddenly appears, and there’s a chase etc.
Another disappointment is that the director is Len Wiseman, who made an auspicious debut with Underworld (2003), followed it with Underworld Evolution (2006) and burst onto the Action Director’s A-list with Live Free Or Die Hard (or Die Hard 4.0, if you’re European).
Total Recall has none of that movie’s verve or excitement (no free running Frenchman, either), and since we’ve literally seen it all before, done better, there’s no reason to bother with this boring failure.
3. The Fog
It’s difficult to see why audiences were so appalled by the Ghostbusters remake when a decade earlier Sony’s executives were responsible for a far more soulless and unnecessary remake.
In 2005, they sat down and said to each other: “Remember that John Carpenter film about the haunted fishing village? Here’s the remake: it’s Clark Kent and his African-American sidekick versus the ghosts from Scooby Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed. With a wimp rock soundtrack. From the director of MC Hammer’s U Can’t Touch This video!”
Most of The Fog’s cast either weren’t born or were still in diapers when Carpenter’s film came out, but hopefully they caught it on television. Hopefully someone did, although there’s not much evidence of that in the finished film. Antonio Bay has become Spooky Island, where the adults are corrupt and kids know best, so it’s a shame they don’t drive around in a van solving mysteries.
2. Planet Of The Apes
Credited by Charlton Heston with creating the cinematic space opera, 1968’s Planet Of The Apes was an enormous success that spawned four sequels and a TV series. When Fox decided to reboot the franchise, an executive named Dylan Sellers knew exactly what the remake needed.
“What if our main guy finds himself in Ape Land and the apes are trying to play a game like baseball but they’re missing one element, like the pitcher or something. And when our guy comes along, he knows what they’re missing and he shows them and they all start playing.”
Though the scene doesn’t appear in the finished film that’s exactly the mentality that produced Tim Burton’s woeful 2001 reboot, a movie so needless, banal and stupid that nobody involved has ever said anything good about it.
In his DVD commentary, Burton even avoids explaining the ending where Mark Wahlberg’s ship crashes at the feet of a statue dedicated to Ape-raham Lincoln.
1. Red Dragon
The first three Hannibal Lecter movies were directed by four-time Oscar nominee Michael Mann (Manhunter), Oscar winner Jonathan Demme (The Silence Of The Lambs) and four-time Oscar nominee Ridley Scott (Hannibal). Which filmmaker did the producers choose to helm this reboot? Brett Ratner, who made the Rush Hour movies with Chris Tucker and Jackie Chan.
The results are as soulless and uninspired as you’d expect from the director of X-Men: The Last Stand. Each of the main characters has their back story spelled out for the viewer, most tediously in an opening sequence where FBI agent Will Graham (Edward Norton) discovers evidence that suggests kindly Dr Lecter might not be all he appears to be.
Manhunter was fresh and gripping back in 1986, but Red Dragon has no more ambition than to tick off boxes as it rushes through the by now very familiar material. It’s slickly made, but whenever the material strives to reach the same notes as its predecessor you’re reminded that Brett Ratner is no Michael Mann.
Interesting footnote: Mann doesn’t have a star on the Hollywood Walk Of Fame, but Ratner does. He joins such distinguished entertainers as Kevin Spacey and Donald Trump.