10 Most Disappointing Sci-Fi Movie Sequels Ever
From missing the point to complete misfires, which sci-fi sequels let us all down?
The science fiction genre has provided moviegoers with some of the most ambitious, outlandish and thought-provoking material in cinematic history. A reliable source of thrills (and kills), the level of adventure that these type of films offer has allowed cinema to make incredible leaps in multiple departments - including story and special effects.
Unfortunately, being revolutionary can come at a cost, as the popularity of these ambitious offerings often results in studios going to the well again (and again and again and again and again). And as any sane person would know, going to there one too many times can sap even the most creative of wells, taking the fun and awe out of a story that was once truly great.
Yes, Hollywood's incessant desire to franchise everything is still capable of producing some real gems, but more often than not, it results in a truly outstanding film or two being followed by a host of uninspired sequels that threaten to taint the original's reputation - something that is particularly prevalent in the sci-fi genre.
With that in mind, let's take a look at some of the sci-fi sequels that failed be more than a major letdown.
10. Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines
Is Terminator 3: Rise of The Machines the worst of the Terminator franchise? Hell no! The film is a thoroughly enjoyable thrill-ride with a solid antagonist in the T-X, ridiculously ambitious set-pieces and some of Arnie's best one-liners, and it's certainly cut above the majority of sequels that followed it. In 2003, however, that just wasn't enough.
For many a years, it filled the role of 'lacklustre Terminator sequel' simply because, in spite of how much fun it was, it somewhat missed the point of the franchise's story, remained too light on the character development front and ultimately failed to live up the standard set by both of its incredible predecessors.
Sure, it didn’t help that we didn't have an abundance of poorer sequels to compare it to back then (which now highlights how decent it actually was), but that doesn't change the fact that the Terminator franchise's decline started with T3. It's just a shame it didn't end there as well.
9. Thor: The Dark World
With Thor's current presence as one of the Marvel Cinematic Universe's most beloved characters, it's interesting to look back at how he used to be presented. It goes without saying that Taika Waititi's ridiculously fun Thor: Ragnarok turned him into something of a pop-culture phenomenon, and that's certainly a good thing considering that the second film in the franchise was one of the MCU's hardest watches.
Thor: The Dark World isn't a bad film per se, it's just unbelievably dull. The Dark Elves were bland, Jane Foster's backwards evolution into damsel-in-distress was unforgivable, and the grim tone of the film just made the whole thing seem devoid of anything remotely fun.
No, the first Thor wasn't a perfect film, but the 2013 sequel completely deleted everything that worked - the whimsical tone, the light-hearted nature of Jane and Thor's dynamic and those beautiful colours - to turn the God of Thunder's second tale in a turgid and all-round uninteresting affair.
8. Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom
After a series of entertaining-but-lacklustre sequels and a decade of development hell, Jurassic World revived one of cinema's greatest franchises by paying tribute to the film that started it all. Unfortunately, history started to repeat itself as its 2018 sequel distanced itself from what made its predecessor work - much like the first JP sequel did back in 1997. The only difference is that The Lost World was a far more enjoyable film.
Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom rehashed the genetically-modified hybrid strand of its predecessor (to much lesser success) while single-handedly destroying the one thing that made the Jurassic Park films so visually appealing: The freakin' dinosaur island.
So while it started off rather well - the volcano stuff and the dino rampage was great - the bloated production's slow-moving second half was too far removed from what the franchise was built upon. The mansion setting felt far too restrained and it took the film into horror film territory. Again, the idea of doing something different in a franchise now built on nostalgia was certainly admirable, but it just felt misguided in a Jurassic Park film.
Let's just hope the upcoming third film can take things back to basics in order to let the JP story - or this chapter of it at least - end on a high.
7. RoboCop 3
RoboCop's debut offering in 1987 was considered something of a phenomenon. A highly-compelling story centering on how Detroit police officer Alex Murphy's near-death experience turns him into an unstoppable cyborg of the law known only as Robocop, the film's mature writing and impressive special effects were praised by critics, which saw it become a cult classic very quickly.
Unfortunately, the downside of success is that it forces the-powers-that-be to dilute something perfect by writing sequels that were completely unnecessary. RoboCop 2 is where the cracks started to show, but it survives because it at least attempts to have some interesting ideas (even though none of them were executed right), but to say the franchise bottomed out with the third installment would be a massive understatement.
Like other superhero-like franchise's of the '70 - '90s, the sequels forsook the protagonist's journey for a standalone villain-centric plot that had little to offer in terms of story depth while everything else just looked depressingly cheap because of the significantly reduced budget. Oh yeah, and RoboCop himself, Peter Weller, wasn't even in it.
Yes, RoboCop had become a shiny polished shell of what he once was as the franchise ended in complete and utter disappointment.
6. Alien 3
Another classic sci-fi series reduced to a shell of itself in one fell swoop, Alien 3 was the beginning of a downward spiral for the once-glorious space horror and, in many people's minds, was the lowest point of the entire franchise.
In all honesty, it's not as bad as most think and, in spite of a controversial decision here and there, there are some silver linings that ultimately see it through (Sigourney Weaver being one of them).
However, that doesn't change the fact that it was a major comedown for the Alien franchise. It's not unheard of for a sequel to miss the mark, but as the first follow-up - Aliens - took the series to even greater heights than the original, the decline in standard between films was more than a little deflating.
A film that was marketed as '3 times the suspense, 3 times the danger, 3 times the terror', it failed on all three counts and only succeeded in terrorising its fans with how much of a setback it was while the only thing it put in danger was the whole bloody franchise.
5. The Amazing Spider-Man 2
When it comes to Spider-Man sequels, it goes without saying that the Tobey Maguire-starring Spider-Man 3 is undoubtedly the most divisive of them all - so much so that it unexpectedly ended up being the last in Sam Raimi's classic franchise. With that in mind, you'd think Sony would have learned its lesson when it came to producing Spidey's follow-up film series. Unfortunately, they did not.
While the first Amazing Spider-Man film rehashed some familiar plot points, it did contribute its own interesting ideas - ideas that should have been followed up on in the sequel. And yet, history repeated itself as The Amazing Spider-Man 2 was - like Spider-Man 3 - bogged down with too many villains, while attempting to do far too much at the same time.
A case in which the most disappointing is also the worst, The Amazing Spider-Man 2 was a meaningless follow-up to a film that had a lot of untapped potential, failing to explore said potential as it substituted some of its only original narratives with predictable plot twists while just cramming far too much into one film. And because of that baffling decision to revisit past mistakes, Spidey's future was once again cut short.
That is, until the MCU saved the day.
4. Aliens Vs. Predator: Requiem
What? Were you expecting to see a different Alien vs. Predator film here? Sorry, that would be too predictable.
Sure, 2004's AVP may not have lived up to the decade of hype, but there were enough silver linings in that film to make it an enjoyable offering if nothing else. The same cannot, however, be said for the sequel AVP: Requiem, which failed to capitalize on, well, everything.
Taking the most promising thing about its predecessor - the Predalien cliffhanger - and making a whole film about it was certainly a brilliant idea, but the execution was all over the place - and what could have been a highly engaging science fiction follow-up that justified AVP's existence in the first place was instead a mindless slasher far too reliant on gratuitous gore, undermining both of the Alien and Predator franchises in the process.
It's hard to argue that the Predalien itself wasn't visually great... well, it would be if you could actually see anything. The film's dark colour palette made it incredibly hard to see what was actually happening, and the choppy editing didn't help either.
Flawed as it was, AVP felt like a big-budget cinematic smackdown. This felt like a direct-to-DVD sequel.
3. S. Darko
Donnie Darko is undoubtedly one of the biggest cult classics of all time. A critically-acclaimed masterpiece that understandably divided audiences - most loved it, but others were left wondering what the hell was going on - it left us asking so many questions by the time the credits had rolled, as we couldn't help but get drawn into Donnie's story and his doomsday-ish visions. The same cannot be said for the sequel nobody asked for: S. Darko.
Focusing on Donnie's little sister - now all grown up - the film attempts to further the story of the original by using Samantha's similar experiences. Unnecessary as it seemed, it could have offered up some more compelling character-driven material and linked it all back to Donnie's experiences, but all it does is rehash the story beats of the first film without any of its insight - and in the process, it ends up undercutting the open-ended mysteries of its predecessor.
It's hard to be disappointed by something that should have never even been made, but somehow, this baffling follow-up pulled it off.
2. Superman IV: The Quest For Peace
If we used the same philosophy we used to justify Terminator 3's position on this list here, we might have picked Superman III instead of this one (because that's where things started to go a bit wrong). But a standalone superhero film series as iconic as Christopher Reeve's Superman one could have easily bounced back from a lacklustre entry had the next one been great. But, oh boy, it wasn't.
Without question one of the worst superheroes movies ever made, Superman IV: The Quest For Peace remains a hard-watch to this day because of how far the hero's adventures had fallen from grace. Yes, the story was bland and uninteresting, but that wasn't even the worst thing about this sequel.
The budget restrictions were obvious from some absolutely terrible unfinished special effects and the lack of effort that was put into the production when compared to the first two films in the series was very noticeable.
So yeah, maybe Superman IV wasn't the disappointing entry in the franchise, it was the awful one. But the sight of Reeves' mighty Superman forced to work with some of the truly awful material he had here? Now that was disappointing.
1. Justice League
The DC Extended Universe's tumultuous beginnings are well-documented at this point, but it managed to overcome the lows of Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice and Suicide Squad with the absolutely glorious comeback that was 2017's Wonder Woman. And in the space of one truly wonderful film, the DCEU's endgame (if you will) was back on track. And then it wasn't... again.
The film that every single high and low of the Warner Bros. shared universe was building towards was Justice League - a film that would also see the most iconic superheroes of DC Comics unite on-screen for the first time ever. And yes, the pressure was arguably working against it from the beginning, but all it really had to do was be half as good as Wonder Woman. Needless to say it wasn't.
A convoluted mess that only showed occasional promise, Justice League was hampered by conflicting creative visions, an underwhelming (and very on-the-nose) story and that bloody CGI mustache-less Superman.
While Batman v Superman and Suicide Squad are widely believed to be worse films, it was easy for WB to move on from them (given their financial success and the popularity of those characters). Justice League squandered a long-awaited opportunity and produced one of the most flat superhero films of all time. And given the star-power involved (both in actors and characters) and how long fans had been waiting for something like this, that's just disappointing.
-
What do you think is the most disappointing sci-fi sequel of all time? For more, check out our list of new upcoming sci-fi TV shows to get excited about.