10 Most Divisive Films Of All Time
Love them or hate it, we can't stop talking about The Last Jedi.
The internet is a wonderful thing. It gives film fans access to all the latest movies, allows them to keep on top of upcoming releases and follow their favourite franchises, and argue with other fans until the small hours of the morning until they are blue in the face.
Of course, movies were polarising long before the advent of the 'net, but the online world has allowed our differences over the finer points of cinema to truly blossom. A passion for movies unites people just as much as our intense disagreements can divide us, and there's no shortage of forum posts and blogs outlining in great detail why movies are loved and maligned in equal measure.
Some movies really split the viewers down the aisle, transforming polite discussions into pitched battles between attackers and defenders. Manners are cast to one side in favour of all out war, each side determined to prove their opinion is correct.
Whether it's blockbuster comic book movies or films designed to please the art house crowds, these are the most divisive films of all time.
10. Death Proof
Few contemporary filmmakers are as divisive as Quentin Tarantino. To some he's the best filmmaker of our generation, creating one modern masterpiece after another while constantly pushing the boundaries. To others he's little more than a competent plagiarist, rehashing well worn cinematic tropes with big stars and glossy imagery.
Of all of his movies, Death Proof was the most polarising of all. A conscious nod to the exploitation movies of the 1970s, it's a film of two halves: the first is all sassy talk with quintessential Tarantino dialogue; the second, a lengthy car chase. Fans adore his fast talking build up to the chase, which they consider to be one of the greatest action sequences ever committed to film. To them, it's an underrated masterpiece.
On the other side, it's a dull and tedious slog with terrible performances delivering some of the worst dialogue ever written. Ask those who despise the film and they'll tell you it isn't just Tarantino's worst film - it's the worst film ever made.
Check out the user reviews on IMDB and the division is clear - the reviews bounce between 10 star and 1 star reviews for several pages with all the rapidity of Tarantino's dialogue.
9. Hulk
Hiring Ang Lee to direct Hulk was the kind of brave decision we're unlikely to see again any time soon. Best known for movies more likely to play in art house cinemas, he took to the project with enthusiasm and strove to deliver something which fully explored the emotional side of the character in favour of a big, dumb tentpole blockbuster.
Quite how well he succeeded in this aim has been the subject of intense debate over the 15 years since Hulk was released. Its fans have loudly and frequently declared it to be the best comic book movie adaptation of all time, delving into Bruce Banner's character development while treating the audience like adults, capable of foregoing constant action beats and allowing the plot to breathe.
Others are not so kind: Hulk is nothing more than "angry Shrek!" full of terrible CGI and a ridiculous scene with giant dogs. Many consider it to be the most boring Marvel movie of all time, with laughable and annoying split screen action sequences. "I came here to see a movie not watch a giant comic book!"
But mostly, they just wanted to see "Hulk smash!", and Ang Lee failed to deliver the prerequisite amount of carnage to keep the popcorn munching crowd happy.
8. Irreversible
Some filmmakers set out to make crowd-pleasing movies which entertain as broad an audience as possible. Chilean director Gaspar Noé is not one of those filmmakers. If anything, he's the anti-crowd-pleasing filmmaker par excellence, determined to ruffle as many feathers as is humanly possible.
Nowhere did he achieve this aim more successfully than with Irreversible, his 2002 psychological thriller starring Vincent Cassel and Monica Bellucci as a couple whose night out turns into a nightmare after a vicious rape in a Parisian subway. Structured in reverse, the film begins with a murderous act of revenge involving a fire extinguisher and a head, rolling back through a ten minute single take rape scene to earlier that day in a sunlit park.
Noé's film is deliberately grotesque and disturbing, which accounts for the audience's divided reaction. Hater either couldn't stomach the excessive violence or thought it to be pointlessly gratuitous. Fans, on the other hand, admired the confrontational seediness and Noé's technically accomplished direction, arguing that the vile imagery and audience repulsion at the violence was precisely the point.
The division was just as evident from the critics, with Roger Ebert describing it as "a movie so violent and cruel that most people will find it unwatchable". Others saw fit to vote for it as one of the greatest movies ever made.
7. The Passion Of The Christ
Mel Gibson's The Passion Of The Christ, like Noe's Irreversible, polarised audiences and critics alike for its focus on excessive violence, although in this instance it was a case of violence being sustained throughout much of the running time, rather than a few instances of sporadic yet brutal gore.
Throw religion into the mix as well and Gibson's film was inevitably going to enter a maelstrom of division. Some claimed that it was an antisemitic tract (which Gibson's infamous drunken outburst seemed to validate in the eyes of many). It was little more than an exercise in torture porn attempting to dress itself up as something more meaningful by wearing the garb of spirituality.
The Passion Of The Christ was also, at the time of its release, the highest grossing R-rated movie of all time. While many of those who saw it no doubt went to feel enraged at such a sacrilegious work of so-called "art", many others saw it as a visually stunning period piece which speaks to the suffering of Christ like nothing else.
As a near real time account of Christ's final moments, its fans see it as a transcendental work of pure cinema which hasn't been surpassed. Quite at odds with those who describe it as little more than "Jesus gets beaten up. Horribly."
6. Eyes Wide Shut
Many of Stanley Kubrick's finest films were once met with deep divisions from critics and audiences alike. While nowadays no one disputes the fact the 2001: A Space Odyssey, Barry Lyndon and The Shining are all masterpieces, at the time of their releases sharp divisions existed between those who loved them and those who despised them.
The same can't be said for his 1999 swansong, Eyes Wide Shut, his story of infidelity and sinister secret societies starring Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman. Its defenders lambast the marketing behind the film, claiming it as another masterpiece; a deep and thoughtful study of human nature, blending conspiratorial elements with a complex understanding of truth and love.
The haters view it as "semi-intellectual nonsense", deriding the slow pacing, excessive running time and wooden performances from the two leads. Eyes Wide Shut is "plotless rubbish" which makes little to no sense and goes absolutely nowhere - slowly. Once again, IMDB user reviews show a sharp split between 1 and 10 star user reviews, giving the impression that audiences watched two completely different films.
5. Triumph Of The Will
Leni Riefenstahl's propaganda film Triumph Of The Will, made for the Nazi party in 1935 and showcasing the mass popular support for Hitler in the years before the outbreak of the Second World War, is a film which screams divisiveness simply by the nature of its premise.
The principle bone of contention between those who admire it as a work of art and those who despise it as a work of fascist propaganda is centered around the ability - or inability - to separate the form from the meaning. While its admirers are certainly not apologists for fascism (although perhaps there are a handful who are), they can see in Triumph Of The Will a masterful use of direction and editing which secures its place in the annals of film history.
For others, however, there is no separation between form and intent, and not only is the technical skill irrelevant, it actually makes the entire project all the more reprehensible for its effectiveness as propaganda. It's also perceived by many as completely overrated on the technical side, consisting of little more than "speeches, marching, speeches, marching - rinse and repeat".
4. The Tree Of Life
Ever since his exceptional, dreamlike debut Badlands, Terence Malick has moved further and further away from conventional narrative structure towards something akin to visual poetry. His on-screen dialogue became increasingly sparse, replaced by ephemeral voice overs reflecting the internal turmoil of his characters.
The Tree Of Life represented the pinnacle of this approach, telling the story (or rather showing the memories) of a man reflecting on his childhood in 1950s Texas in a visual style closer to Expressionistic paintings than standard filmmaking. Understandably, this approach is more subjective in its interpretation than most, and the divided opinion on the film reflects this clearly.
Fans and critics alike were completely split, the former admiring his dreamlike imagery and loose structure, intent on showing the disjointed nature of memory and pleased to see Malick break completely free into a new kind of cinematic form. Others were "bored, bored, bored" by what they saw as a pretentious mess, urging people to avoid this "pointless crap" like the plague.
Depending on where you sit on this binary spectrum, the three hour cut recently released on blu-ray is either a treasure to be cherished or a new form of torture.
3. Star Wars: Episode VIII - The Last Jedi
Star Wars: Episode VIII - The Last Jedi is an unusual case of divisive movies, representing what is perhaps the starkest contrast in the history of cinema between the critics and the fans. Such is the disparity of opinion between these two groups that it will no doubt be discussed for many years to come.
One thing which stands out in many of the positive reviews from the critics is their assertion that "fanatics will no doubt love it" . Considered by many critics to be one of the most powerful and emotional contributions to the Star Wars franchise, they are keen to point out to readers that "the devoted will no doubt be delighted", and that have to "unlearn what they have learned."
Nothing could have been further from the truth. If the critical reaction seemed to prove that industry critics are completely dislocated from the fandom, the fans themselves were almost unanimous in their disapproval of how writer-director Rian Johnson handled the material.
From Luke's complete about turn as a character to General "Mary Poppins" Leia, the fan consensus was that Disney had constructed a nightmarish behemoth which has all but destroyed the franchise. Accusations that Disney were injecting the franchise with progressive politics - claims which were supported by statements from Johnson and producer Kathleen Kennedy - undermined the fans' approval even more.
2. Boyhood
Boyhood was shot over a period of twelve years by Richard Linklater, retaining the same cast and showing them grow along with their characters, in particular the central protagonist Mason, played by Ellar Coltrane between the ages of six and eighteen.
There's no argument regarding the impressive nature and ambition of the project - it's a unique film for obvious reasons, although whether or not the end result is actually any good is open to often furious debate. With no central narrative thrust, Linklater opted instead to show how life unfolds, sometimes with moments of drama, at other times with that vague continuity which we're all familiar with.
The lack of melodrama is often cited by fans as one of the film's crowning achievements. It captures the mundane rhythms of life perfectly, they say, just as the passing of the seasons blur into each other. It's a once-in-a-lifetime experience to be cherished, and unlikely to ever be repeated.
"Thank God", its detractors might respond, happy to be spared being put through a film in which nothing happens and takes three hours doing it. Life is boring and tedious, yes, but why pay good money to watch life being boring and tedious on the cinema screen when it's the daily experience for most people?
1. The Fountain
Darren Aronofsky is one of the most ambitious directors currently working in Hollywood, with carte blanche to create movies of seemingly limitless scope. Of all his films, The Fountain is perhaps his most thematically complex, an attempt to fuse mythical realms with psychological insight, taking place across time, space and multiple realities.
Given the breadth of his vision, it's not surprising that audiences were divided neatly down the middle in their reception of The Fountain. Its supporters have compared it to the greatest movies ever made; a cinematic journey on the level of Andrei Tarkovsky and Stanley Kubrick which delves into complex metaphysics without losing its emotional core. Reading the gushing praise and it's tempting to interpret the film as something close to an encounter with divine forces.
Or it could be a complete mess, if the other side of the aisle is to be believed. Incoherent, tonally unbalanced, uncertain of its philosophical ambitions and (here's a familiar refrain), "boring and pretentious". Fans accuse the detractors of "not getting it", to which they might retort, "there's nothing to 'get' - it's a waste of time."
Whichever view you take, it's clear that The Fountain is a film for which there is very little room for space on the middle ground.