10 Most Inconsistent Actors Working Today

Less than reliable.

Uncut Gems
Netflix

There really is no business like show business. One minute it’s crying on cue for the next thoughtful drama; laying bare the flaws in the human soul for all to see, the next it’s hamming it up opposite John Goodman whilst punching a CGI dragon.

And while career variety is always a creative benefit, some actors today have a little too much variety in their resumes.

There’s nothing wrong with a cameo in a bland comedy every now and again, but when you go from working with the Coen brothers to working with the Wayans brothers, it’s probably time to have a firm and frank discussion with your agent.

Yet to have said conversation are the entries on this list, actors and performers with whom it’s unclear whether they’re actually talented, or just got lucky once or twice.

Some of them have a decent track record that’s in danger of being recently tarnished, others have had bumpy careers from the start.

When you buy a ticket to see these folks: beware, nothing is certain. Well, apart from the maddening knowledge that these “professionals” are getting paid millions for their mediocrity, while if you were this inconsistent, you’d have been fired by now.

10. Mel Gibson

Mel Gibson is an inconsistent actor because Mel Gibson is an inconsistent person.

Once seen as an established actor/director, Gibson has (surprisingly, more than once) put his career in jeopardy with bizarre remarks on just about everything, from race and sexuality to alcoholism and domestic violence. Yikes.

As such, he went from leading smash hit successes such as "Braveheart" and "Passion of the Christ," to doing hammy appearances next to Will Ferrell and Mark Wahlberg in "Daddy's Home 2." Quite the transition there.

In between those polar opposites, Gibson's done everything in between, from the so-so "Signs" to the critically acclaimed "Hacksaw Ridge," although that was admittedly only a directorial credit.

In a way, its a shame that the man known for playing wild and outspoken characters like those in "Mad Max" and "Lethal Weapon" turned out to be wild and outspoken himself, because without the rocky personal life, Gibson probably would have had a solid and consistent legacy.

It's almost as if refraining from being a massive racist can further your career considerably.

But hey, just because Hollywood doesn't want you doesn't mean you don't have a mortgage to pay off.


9. Eddie Redmayne

When Eddie Redmayne shot into the public consciousness in 2014 for his Oscar winning portrayal of Stephen Hawking in "The Theory of Everything," all bets were on this charming young man going very far indeed.

Sure, he'd been in a few questionable productions before that, but as a working actor you've got to do what you've got to do. And now that Redmayne had star power on his side, he could do whatever he wanted.

He followed this worthy win up with a relatively small, (admittedly Oscar baitey) film called "The Danish Girl," for which he won decent critical acclaim, if not mainstream interest.

However, Redmayne must have thought things were going a little too well for him, so he also decided to appear in 2015's "Jupiter Ascending." That film... yeah. That film was bad. And he was arguably one of the worst parts of it, snagging a Razzie for his baffling performance.

Since then, Eddie's not done much outside of his lukewarm portrayal of Newt Scamander, and his once bright future has turned into a very rocky present.

Oh, he's also been in "Les Miserables." Whether that's good or bad seems to depend on your general opinion towards the concept of musicals. DO YOU HEAR THE PEOPLE SI-


8. Emma Watson

Considering how child stars usually turn out, Emma Watson's done pretty well for herself. But that doesn't mean that her career's been all that magical after Hogwarts.

While she's done well in films like "The Perks of Being a Wallflower," she's also been incredibly boring in the Netflix production "the Circle," and her portrayal of Belle in "Beauty and the Beast" wasn't anything special. Maybe she needs to take a leaf out of Daniel Radcliffe's book and just go for the weirdest roles possible. Or go the Rupert Grint route of buying an ice cream van and then pissing off forever.

Even in acclaimed productions like Greta Gerwig's "Little Women," Watson was outshined by her co-stars. Now admittedly, her co-stars were Florence Pugh and Saoirse Ronan, two of the best young actresses working today, but even so, being just alright isn't exactly what we expect from someone who attended Oxford.

Still, Emma Watson can always say she was Hermoine that one time, she's used that to platform important stuff like Women's rights and equality, so maybe that's more important than talking good at a film camera.


7. Russell Crowe

Russell Crowe has been in a lot of films. A LOT. So, just by the law of averages, there are bound to be a few stinkers in his back catalogue.

But what makes Crowe so inconsistent is the fact that he seems to have long, drawn out runs of bad performance after bad performance, almost as if he's secretly trying to see how long of a streak he can pull off before audiences get fed up with him.

This is made even more infuriating by the fact that he'll suddenly pull an absolute blinder out of the bag, like his excellent turn as Jackson Healy in "The Nice Guys." This came after an especially depressing run of films like "Noah," "Robin Hood," and a distinctly bored looking Jor-El in Zack Snyder's "Man of Steel."

Still, Crowe's been a staple in popular films since his leading performance in the outstanding "Gladiator," and has had three consecutive Oscar nominations in his illustrious career. That, and the fact that he has a couple of releases just around the corner, means he's probably not going anywhere soon.

"Are you not entertained?" Well, sometimes we are, Russell. Sometimes.


6. Dakota Johnson

Dakota Johnson has faced an uphill battle from day one.

With her first outing into mainstream acting being as the star of the questionable "Fifty Shades" franchise, it would have been easy for Johnson to become yet another ruthlessly sexualised young actress (see: Megan Fox, Lindsay Lohan, etc.) whose career never quite recovered from that first stumble.

Yet recover she (sort of) has.

Since the "Fifty Shades" debacle, Johnson has gone on to win great merit with performances in dark and violent productions like "Black Mass" as well as a criminally underrated leading role in the "Suspiria" remake- one of the scariest films to come out in recent memory.

Having said that, she's also made some missteps as well, like her frankly bland performance in "Bad Times at the El Royale,"and her strange choice to appear in the "Need for Speed" adaptation of 2014.

Still, not bad for a woman known chiefly for badly written BDSM fanfiction. And hey, with a few more years and few more smart choices, there's a good chance Dakota will earn enough respect to go from inconsistent to "hey, she's pretty good." Now, if only we could get Jamie Dornan to do the same...


5. Nicolas Cage

Nicolas Cage is responsible for some of the worst professional performances in cinematic history. He's also responsible for some of the best. The jury's still out on whether he's a good actor overall, but good or bad, it can't be denied all of his performances are uniquely glorious.

Cage began his career with serious, thoughtful performances and character studies that sometimes got a little bit weird. Then, at around the late 80s/early 90s mark, ol' St. Nic took an absolute nosedive off of the cliff of sanity.

"Face off," "Con Air," "Vampire's Kiss," all of these films are hallmarks in the era of Cage craziness. While it's hard to say whether these performances are good or bad (or whether they're even performances at all) they were the beginning of Cage's descent into so bad its good filmmaking, sadly culminating in the just plain bad, like "Ghost Rider" and "National Treasure."

But in recent years, Nic Cage has had something of a Renaissance. With solid performances in films like "Colour Out of Space," and "Kick-Ass," it seems we're seeing the return of properly good acting from Cage.

Then again, he's still not immune to the odd questionable performance every now and again, so watch out for any bee related pictures with his name on them.


4. Adam Sandler

There's a good chance that Adam Sandler would make the cut for a lot of "Bad Actor" lists, and this would not be without merit.

After an eye watering tirade of distinctly un-funny comedies like "Pixels," "The Ridiculous Six," and "Blended" it was the opinion of many that Sandler had had his day, and it was time for him to politely and quietly f**k off.

But people forget just how believable of an actor Adam Sandler was. While he may not have spouted Shakespeare or recited depressing monologues about the nature of the Human condition, Sandler was (and is) very, very good at playing the bumbling everyman, seen in his old classics: "Happy Gilmore," and "Billy Madison."

On top of that, while his scripts leave something to be desired, when he works with an outsider - and not his loyal band of Kevin James stand-ins - he's not just good, he's great.

Take "Punch Drunk Love" or "Uncut Gems" for instance. Written and directed by the Safdie Brothers, Sandler's portrayal of a sleazy pawnbroker has already been widely praised, and it shows that even after all these years he still has acting chops.

Just don't watch anything of his if he's in drag. You know the film. And Christ alive, what a film that was.


3. Ben Affleck

One has to wonder whether Ben Affleck tosses a coin before deciding how to act in/shoot a movie. Heads - Oscar winningly good. Tails - "Daredevil."

Affleck EMBODIES the term inconsistent, never putting in too many good or too many bad performances in succession. And most of his performances could be argued either way.

Even his take on the same character is inconsistent, putting in a grounded and violent portrayal of Batman in "Batman Vs. Superman," before lazily phoning in the same character on "Justice League." Seriously, how hard is it to put on a rubber suit and punch aliens for millions of dollars?

It was the same after "Good Will Hunting", considered by many to be Affleck's best and most thought provoking film. Affleck then for some reason decided to be in a mindless action film about blowing up an asteroid. Talk about from one extreme to the other.

As recently as last year his performance credentials have been called into question, with his milquetoast and forgettable work in "The Accountant" and "Live by Night."

But even then, he followed up said performances with his heartbreakingly honest look at alcoholism in "The Way Back."

Seriously, this man is a bookies worst nightmare.


2. Kirsten Stewart

If there's one woman who's experienced both the highest highs and the lowest lows that the acting experience has to offer, it's Kristen Stewart.

In 2010, she was the world's highest paid actress, beating out the likes of Angelina Jolie and Charlize Theron. By 2012, she had all but dropped off the face of the Earth, ending the Twilight saga before evaporating into obscurity like a Vampire turning to mist.

She returned in 2014 with "Camp X-Ray," an intriguing and harrowing look into the practises of Guantanamo Bay, and a far cry from her days as a boring and emotionally bereft Dracula enthusiast.

Since then she's put in some incredibly solid performances in several independent films like "Certain Women" and "Cafe Society"; her off beat and quirky style clearly lending itself better to smaller character studies than big blockbusters.

And it's the blockbusters where she still falls down. While Stewart was probably the best part of the film, the "Charlie's Angels" reboot landed with all the skill and grace of a dead elephant, and her attempts at a thriller film in "Underwater" was even more painful.

The advice here, then, is look at the budget. If it's in the billions, Stewart's performance probably isn't worth it.


1. Will Smith

Ah, Will, it hurts to put you on this list.

Once a surefire Blockbuster success, Smith has, over recent years, disintegrated into something of a shaky gamble for producers.

Which is a shame, because he's still so damn charismatic. He just seems to choose films that require the complete opposite of charisma, as evidenced by "Gemini Man" and the travesty that was "After Earth."

Smith will always be famous for his roles in Fresh Prince, as well as "Seven Pounds" and "Men in Black," yet even back in the day he had a few misfires like "I am Legend." But those pale in comparison to the performances he's put in lately.

Even in his most recent picture, "Aladdin," the best you could say was that at least he didn't tarnish the legacy of Robin Williams.

Thankfully, his talent hasn't completely left him, having done some good work in "Concussion" and the latest "Bad Boys" sequel, but they're meagre change compared to the oceans of cash he used to be capable of bringing in.

Not only that, Smith is responsible for starting the trend of A-list celebrities having their own YouTube channels, and headlined the much despised YouTube Rewind of 2018. The subsequent memes were not kind to poor Will.


Watch Next


Oscars Quiz: How Well Do You Know The Best Actress Winners Of The 21st Century?

The Squid And The Whale Jeff Daniels Laura Linney
Samuel Goldwyn Films

1. Who Won In 2001?

In this post: 
Adam Sandler
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Currently attempting to convert the desire to play video games into the desire to work.