10 Most Insufferable Johnny Depp Performances

Just whatever did happen to Johnny Depp anyway?

What happened to Johnny Depp? Seriously. Once regarded as one of the best and most diverse actors in Hollywood, the last decade has positioned the former heartthrob in something of a career nose dive. Indeed, the last five movies to have been released into cinemas with Johnny Depp's name plastered across them have flopped. Five in a row, people! That's near-on unheard of! What's more, Johnny Depp has transitioned from that of an icon of cool to somebody who is - generally speaking - actually quite annoying to behold. The guy seems to harbour an irresistible desire to play quirky, cartoon-ish characters (in make-up), after all, whose entire personalities seem to hinge on eccentric mannerisms and funny hats. The last ten years or so have seen Depp playing the same variations over and over again, and - quite frankly - it's a little boring now, almost to the point of self-parody. As a result, Depp has become something of a joke - especially since he makes so many of these "offbeat hat-wearing character movies" with offbeat hat-wearing director Tim Burton. In short, Johnny Depp has pretty much lost it and things only seems to be getting worse. His performances nowadays can only really be separated into two categories: those that are "quite insufferable" and those that are "seriously insufferable." Here, then, are the actor's 10 most annoying filmic appearances to date, starting with the least (but still very) intolerable to the downright unbearable. You've been warned.

10. The Big Bad Wolf - Into The Woods

This wasn't a major role for Depp or anything, and it could even be described as a cameo of sorts (had he remained uncredited or something), but it still manages to be entirely insufferable despite its brevity. That's to say, Johnny Depp plays "The Big Bad Wolf" in recent Disney musical Into The Woods, because OF COURSE HE DOES. Who else would they have got in to play the part, after all? It would have been madness to suggest another actor play a character that is both "in heavy make-up" and "bohemian." And presumably all Disney had to say for Depp to agree to swing by for a few days filming was: "You'll be dressing up as a wolf in a quirky costume. You in?" So, yeah, Depp's not in the movie a whole lot, but the annoying factor that goes hand in hand with the the fact that such an obvious Johnny Depp role went to Johnny Depp is inherently irksome. Just once it would have been nice if he'd have turned it down and surprised everyone. Nope: he's right here doing his usual schtick in all the ways we've seen it done before. Give someone else a go, Johnny.

9. Frank Tupelo - The Tourist

The Tourist is, by any definition, a very odd piece of work. Not sure whether it wants to be a drama or a comedy, it sort of settles to be both at the same time, but also none of those things, rendering it as a kind of tone-deaf genre hybrid that feels like it was directed by an alien. At the centre of the movie is the "relationship" between Johnny Depp and Angelina Jolie, who both play "characters," but c'mon, these aren't characters - they're mannequins in expensive costumes. Depp essentially plays a "fish out of water" for the sum of The Tourist, but it doesn't feel like he's really acting his part as much as living it for real. Presumably he had no idea what was happening over the course of production, or why he lacked so much chemistry with Angelina Jolie, which explains the "deer in the headlights" nature of his performance. Insufferable in its unrelenting blandness, it's a truly naff role.

8. Dr. Will Caster - Transcendence

Dr. Will Caster isn't the most memorable Johnny Depp character, but that's precisely the reason why he's made it onto this unfortunate list: Caster is so insanely bland, it seems like an insult coming from an actor who prides himself on excessive, animated performances of the grating kind. Seriously, it's almost as if Depp committed this character to the screen in a sleep-induced haze. Transcendence was panned by critics for being generally awful, especially in its plot, which managed to be both head-scratchingly pretentious and super dull. Depp plays Dr. Will Caster, a "brilliant scientist" (the movies are full of those) whose consciousness is uploaded into a computer after he's killed. "Consciousness" isn't a word that you'd associate with Caster, though, nor is it an emotion that you'll experience whilst watching him for the sum of two hours. For all his irksome traits, Depp rarely feels like he's phoning it in, but there's no other way to describe what he offers up here. It's almost as if Transcendence were a mere rehearsal for a play Depp was contractually obliged to appear in.

7. Captain Jack Sparrow - Pirates Of The Caribbean 2, 3 & 4

The first time the world got a glimpse of Johnny Depp in the original Pirates of the Caribbean movie, everybody said: "This is a fantastically unique performance - well done, Johnny Depp." And that was despite the fact that he just seemed to be channelling Keith Richards. Back then, of course, the concept of Johnny Depp in a costume wasn't as inherently annoying as it is today - now it all seems like overkill. So despite the fact that Depp is downright brilliant in Curse of the Black Pearl (he was rightly nominated for an Oscar, even though Disney executives were originally unsure about his version of the character), Jack Sparrow has reached a place of pure insufferableness in subsequent sequels, none of which captured the thrills - or general sense of fun - of the first picture. All schtick gets old, and Jack Sparrow - good as the character is - seems to get less and less interesting each and every time we see him. He almost seems like a go-to character for Depp whenever he gets the urge to dress up in a funny costume. Enough is enough: even the sight of the character is insufferable.

6. Tonto - The Lone Ranger

The Lone Ranger was presumably an attempt on Disney's part to build another giant franchise with all the weight of Pirates of the Caribbean - and hiring Johnny Depp in the part of Tonto was their way of cementing that agenda in the eyes of the general public. Unfortunately the general public saw sense, and rejected The Lone Ranger as dead on arrival - a fate it absolutely deserved, on account of its awfulness. Aside from all those accusations of racism that Depp's casting provoked, most people seemed to ultimately agree that his performance as a Native American wasn't racist - just really annoying. And that just about sums it up. Depp's insistence on talking in what can only be described as a "sombre baritone" was just grating. There's the sense that he honestly took on the role because it gave him the chance to dress up in a crazy new costume; his schtick feels so "calculated," after all - quirky for the sake of quirky.

5. Guy Lapointe - Tusk

Tusk is one of the weirdest movies ever made, and that's because it features a plot about a man who is forced to "become" a walrus for another man's sick pleasures - and also because it features Johnny Depp as a bizarre character called Guy Lapointe, who is - for all intents and purposes - downright ridiculous. It's one thing casting Johnny Depp in a Kevin Smith movie as a form of "watch bait" (he's not really in it for very long but hey, put his name on the poster and watch the pundits come in), but casting him as a bizarre ex-cop from Quebec with an insufferable accent garbed in awful make-up who feels plucked right out of a low-budget sketch show... well, it's just not the done thing, is it? A few points for Depp, somewhat, given that he actually agreed to play such an innately insufferable role in a low-budget horror flick (it flopped). But it's the kind of role you give to an actor who has a bit of innate goodwill with the audience; right now, Depp has fallen from grace and desperately needs to show the world that he can act for real. Playing Guy Lapointe didn't give him the opportunity to do so. At all.

4. Barnabas Collins - Dark Shadows

After the hellish experience that was Tim Burton's Alice in Wonderland, Johnny Depp decided that the next best place for him to go would be back to Tim Burton - this time with an adaptation of an obscure TV series called Dark Shadows, in which he'd be presented with the opportunity to play - you guessed it - a quirky character whose offbeat personality is derived from how much "crazy" make-up is present. Barnabas Collins, then, is what happens when Johnny Depp slums it but still has to play an excessively cartoonish character. The results, of course, are insufferable on their own terms - if you're going to give people another one of these characters, Johnny, at least give it all you've got, won't you? Most of the movie consists of Depp wandering about an old house with his mouth in a continuous "O" shape, which is about as exciting to watch as it is to read. Dark Shadows also marks the definitive point in time where even Burton and Depp decided that they'd probably be better off without each other for a while. At least this movie gave us something worthwhile: to date, it marks their last collaboration.

3. The Mad Hatter - Alice In Wonderland

For those folk who were actually all right with the occasionally wacky Johnny Depp performance, the actor's turn as The Mad Hatter in Tim Burton's Alice in Wonderland presumably marked something of a turning point in their opinions of the actor. "Another performance like this in another Tim Burton movie?" Seriously, Johnny, is there nobody else in Hollywood capable of delivering these roles?" So The Mad Hatter is, plainly put, insufferable from start to finish - every inch of this character has been honed from the Johnny Depp School of Annoying Performances, and all its "cute" mannerisms and "quirky" nuances are grating in every way imaginable. The whole ordeal pretty much consists of Depp mugging for the camera - something that might have been okay had we not witnessed exactly the same thing in countless performances beforehand. The film was quite insufferable, but Depp - talented as he is - should have eased the pain somewhat. Instead, his presence felt more akin to that old phrase "being kicked when you're down." Ouch.

2. Willy Wonka - Charlie And The Chocolate Factory

Was this first truly annoying Johnny Depp performance? The film where everybody turned to one another when the movie was over and said: "Johnny Depp was really annoying in that movie"? It certainly feels like it - especially since the actor's turn in this flick seemed to usher in a new era of similarly-acted performances from a talented guy who is is so much better than the shlock he puts up on the screen. So his "crazy" turn in Tim Burton's exhausting remake of a far better movie seems calculated beyond belief: weird for the sake of weird, and in the words of critic Ann Hornaday, "like those excruciating occasions when your parents tried to be hip." Spot on. As a result, seems to have misjudged the character of Willy Wonka entirely: he's meant to be odd and mysterious, but not "unlikeable" in the sense that Depp renders him. In Gene Wilder's own words: "As an actor I like very much... but when I saw little pieces in the promotion of what he was doing, I said I don't want to see the film, because I don't want to be disappointed in him." Good thing you didn't, Gene. You made the right choice.

1. Charles Mortdecai - Mortdecai

So here it is: through the act of its own chronological existence, Johnny Depp's most recent performance as Charles Mortdecai in the Godawful "comedy" Mortdecai stands as his most insufferable to date. It also comes out on the top due to its inherent "Are you f*cking kidding me?" factor. Has Johnny Depp lost all sense of self-awareness? In what way did he think that Mortdecai would be a good idea? How did this project even come about in the wake of badly received performances such as Tonto in The Lone Ranger or Barnabas Collins in Dark Shadows? Did anybody really believe it would do anything but flop? As a character, Mortdecai serves as a sort of amalgamation of all of his most ghastly creations. It's almost as if Depp and director David Koepp purposely set out to play homage to all the irksome protagonists that Depp has embodied over the course of the last decade. In short, it's an embarrassing, forgettable and ultimately shocking (for all the wrong reasons) performance - the kind with the power to end careers. Hopefully Mortdecai, for all its awfulness, will serve a singular great purpose: it will act as the definitive wake-up for Johnny Depp the Actor, who desperately needs to reinvent himself before it really is too late and people give up hope entirely.

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.