10 Most Insulting Movie Sequels Ever
When follow ups flop hard...
Putting together a follow-up to any massively popular project is not an enviable task. Many great filmmakers have fallen victim to Difficult Second Movie Syndrome, failing to follow up an innovative original despite their best attempts.
However, this is not a list of those noble failures. Instead, what we’ve compiled is a set of flicks which looked at the much-loved original and decided to follow it up with as little effort as possible. Taking much-loved titles and dragging their names through the mud, these are sequels which didn’t even offer an ounce of their predecessor’s charm.
Some are late-in-the-franchise instalments which ran out of steam and soiled the reputation of earlier films. Some are second films which lost their way and ruined any chance of further adventures for their characters. All of them are the sequels which were the worst smack in the face for fans of their instant classic originals.
10. Freddy’s Dead: The Final Nightmare
If a horror franchise survives long enough, you can be sure every iteration will have its own defenders. Some fans love former Rorschach Jackie Earle Haley’s interpretation of Freddy Krueger as a grim, unsmiling presence; some refuse to acknowledge any Freddy not played by horror icon Robert Englund.
Despite this discord, every once in a while, a sequel comes through which unites every warring fandom faction in their absolute disgust, and the sixth instalment of the phenomenally popular Nightmare on Elm Street series did just that. Where to start with this one—the inexplicable Roseanne cameo? The Goo Goo Dolls’ theme song? The Power Glove product placement?!
No scene better encapsulates the derided fifth sequel better than the sight of Springwood’s adults losing their marbles, reacting to the wholesale death of the town’s adolescent population by… riding around in bumper cars and rewriting history books so they star the titular menace. Mercifully the title was as misjudged as the rest of this movie, and the next sequel managed to pull the franchise out of the doldrums with an injection of meta-horror in Wes Craven’s New Nightmare.
9. Saw V
The Saw franchise is a complicated case. Many believe—critics in particular—that the intense psychological torment of the original film could not be topped and was best left alone, particularly after its barnstorming final twist.
Some more forgiving fans enjoy the sequels and wanted a chance to better understand Jigsaw and his many apprentices. Some revel in the increasingly inventive and outlandish torture devices. Some prefer to try and keep track of the ever-more-convoluted string of deceptions and double crossings that comprises the franchise mythology.
However, one thing unites all Saw fans, and that is disdain for Saw V. The limp fifth instalment started on a bum note, telegraphing its blatant twist within the opening half hour.
The film soon devolved into a series of less inventive kills, but also some truly unforgivable twists which made a mess of the franchise chronology.
Even the most generous viewer would have a hard time finding redeeming features in this dud, so it’s no surprise that later sequels and the eventual reboot were seen as improvements on Saw V’s disappointing performance.
8. Men In Black: International
The most recent instalment in the MIB franchise attempted to reboot the series for its fourth outing, but all Men in Black: International managed was to do was insult fans of the original.
Jettisoning aging agents J and K in favour of some new blood, the recent retool underestimated the importance of their chemistry. The film centred visual FX rather than the rapport between new stars Chris Hemsworth and Tessa Thompson, whose dynamic never gelled as they struggled with a sluggish storyline.
Despite the presence of heavyweight talent such as Emma Thompson and Liam Neeson, the plot was tension-free and directionless. The distinct lack of stakes wasn’t helped by glaringly obvious twist signposted throughout the film, but even without this issue the film was destined to flop.
Retconning the history of the titular organisation, the reboot went through development hell, with the original script being cut to ribbons and the film itself being so heavily recut that, at one point, two directors were working on separate edits of the same film.
7. Lethal Weapon 4
Lethal Weapon set the bar high for any attempted sequels, melding charming character comedy with gritty action and a genuine mean streak. However, returning screenwriter Shane Black managed to keep the franchise fresh with the first sequel, upping both the comedy and the violent action stakes without sacrificing heart.
Soon after though, Lethal Weapon 3 dropped the ball by refusing to pony up the requisite cash for Black’s services—understandable, given the screenwriter’s salary had shot up to nearer seven figures at this stage. The second sequel had its merits, though, and isn’t reviled by fans despite its softer tone.
Enter Lethal Weapon 4. Replacing the cynical black comedy of the first film with broad buddy comedy, the fourth instalment is as silly as a Beethoven sequel and about as exciting and intense. Lethal Weapon 4 was far from unmissable, relying on its aging stars and a struggling Chris Rock to prop up a plot which may have been bloodier, but was also more boring and predictable than its trio of predecessors.
6. Kick-Ass 2
The original Kick Ass was no ordinary superhero movie, and credit where it’s due, the sequel is also not your average caped crusader flick either. Unfortunately, that’s where the flattering part of the comparisons end.
Where the first film took Mark Millar’s edgy source material, kept the funniest ideas and coolest sequences, and toned down the hyper-bleak nihilism, the sequel makes the mistake of trying to have it both ways. Both more broadly comic and darker than its predecessor, Kick Ass 2 fails as both an adaptation and a follow-up to the first film.
Despite the presence of Jim Carrey (who soon disowned the film) and Chloe Grace Moretz the sequel never comes together, aiming for funny and landing on cruel far too often.
The best encapsulation of the sequel’s failure comes in the attempted rape scene by the villain Motherf***er (a slumming-it Christopher Mintz-Plasse). A dark, humourless moment of character-defining depravity in the source material, here it becomes… er, an extended joke about erectile dysfunction. You know, just what you want in your hyper kinetic superhero satire.
5. Jaws: The Revenge
Jaws was always going to be an impossible act to follow, but Jaws 2 was a passable effort which saw much of the original cast return, if not superstar director Steven Spielberg. The auteur wouldn’t go on to shoot a sequel until 1997’s Jurassic Park follow-up, The Lost World, and watching the decline of his killer shark series, it’s easy to guess why.
Jaws: The Revenge opts for a bizarre twist as its villainous shark is revealed to be hunting down the Brody family for their crimes against shark-kind. The revelation leads viewers to wonder why this family would opt for beachside vacations after their many seaside misfortunes, but luckily, it’s not the silliest thing in the film.
No, that dubious honour goes to the infamous roaring shark—perhaps the filmmakers thought the hilariously inept model work would be less obvious with the distraction of a suddenly vocal killer fish. Add a miscast Michael Caine into the mix and its impossible not to laugh at this flop of a four-quel.
4. Hot Tub Time Machine 2
The original Hot Tub Time Machine was a surprise delight when it hit theatres in 2010, a bawdy, hysterically funny and unabashedly sentimental throwback to classic 80s raunchy teen comedies. After the charming first outing was a hit with critics and audiences alike, a decent sequel shouldn’t be too much to ask for, right?
Alarm bells should have started ringing when John Cusack, essential in the chemistry of the first film’s quartet, refused to return for more than a (soon-to-be-cut) cameo. But Parks and Recreation star Adam Scott should be a worthy replacement, right? Right?
Relying on nasty humour and cheap gross out gags, Hot Tub Time Machine 2 betrayed the spirit of the original film to disastrous effect. Characters who had been developed into likeable leads were reverted to thoughtless, charmless tools, Scott was lost in the mix, and the plot went nowhere. The first film may have been an instant classic, but due to Cusack’s refusal to go near sequels this one was always destined to be dead in the water.
3. The Hangover Part III
Todd Philips may be better known for his Oscar nods than raunchy R-rated comedies these days, but some of us are old enough to recall when he was the reigning king of funny blockbusters. That reign came crashing to a halt with The Hangover’s misjudged threequel in 2015.
Making an inexplicable genre hop into thriller territory, The Hangover Part III ran far away from the bro-mantic comedy and goofy drunken antics which made the first film a classic upon its 2009 release. Instead the second sequel was mostly a grim, violent crime movie which happened to star Stu, Alan, and Phil.
The tone shift was a strange call to say the least, one which baffled audiences and critics alike, neither of whom responded positively. It’s not hard to see why—anyone expecting further adventures from the central trio were right to be disappointed by a film which featured four onscreen deaths, a decapitated giraffe, and an inexplicably convoluted heist storyline. We here at WhatCulture are glad Todd has since found a more fitting outlet for his darker side than raunchy blockbuster comedy sequels.
2. Live Free Or Die Hard
What two words do you think of when you hear Die Hard? Okay, admittedly they might be five words depending on your spellcheck, but the iconic catchphrase “Yippee-ki-yay motherf***er” is as ingrained in the public consciousness as “Where we’re going, we don’t need roads”.
So, it was a pretty sizeable red flag when Live Free or Die Hard (also known as Die Hard 4.0) was announced as a PG-13. The rating meant John McClane couldn’t utter his classic line, and sure enough the film featured only a neutered version which many fans found worse than no attempt at all.
However, this was only one concern among many which derailed this instalment. Live Free or Die Hard also sees the franchise retcon John and Holly’s happy endings—you know, that driving force behind the first two films?
As well as the liberties taken with franchise history, there’s also the escalation of the action in the fourth film. While many may believe bigger equals better, few would argue that seeing McClane pilot a car into a helicopter is anywhere near as cool—or at least close to believable—as his gritty fight with Karl in the first film.
1. Paranormal Activity 4
Every long-running horror franchise is bound to run out of ideas sooner or later, and the microbudget found-footage Paranormal Activity series is no exception. While the first few films followed the standard law of diminishing returns, they nonetheless delivered scares. Sure, the formulaic haunted house instalments were unable to reach the terrifying heights of the Spielberg-approved original, but sequels one and two did add interesting lore for the franchise to explore and didn’t disappoint too hard.
However, this lucky streak soon came crashing to an end with the fourth instalment. Widely viewed as the worst of the series, the camera is wielded this time around by a pair of insufferable teens. The duo tries to uncover the source of strange goings-on throughout their neighbourhood, but you won’t care.
It’s just as well audiences didn’t care about the film’s mystery, as it is never explained or even revealed before the film’s abrupt cut-to-black ending. Adding nothing to the overarching story running from film to film, Paranormal Activity 4 is also the slowest of the films, grinding a predictable plot out to almost-interminable length.