10 Most Messed Up Horror Movie Monsters
Monsters that really give you the willies.
There are certain monsters in horror cinema that are more than just big beasts or mindless killers. There are monsters that affect us on a deeply psychological level. The type of monsters that have been borne from the darkest nightmares, ready to haunt nightmares of our own.
We're looking at cosmic horror, body horror, horror that preys on sexuality, grief, and psychological trauma. These are the monsters that once you've seen them will stick with you, lurking in the back of your psyche.
For this list scary humans and ghosts do not count as monsters. Having sad that, some entries may indeed be humanoids, or are creatures that were once human that have transformed into something far, far more horrible.
10. The Behemoth - The Mist (2007)
One day David Drayton (Thomas Jane) was shopping at the supermarket, when all of a sudden a mist came a-rollin’ in. Unfortunately for him and the rest of the unlucky shoppers, that mist was chock full of Lovecraftian monsters intent on slaughter and destruction.
These monsters include: giant flying bugs, pterodactyls, big spiders, and a huge praying mantis thing.
So why is the Behemoth the most terrifying?
Yes the creepy crawlies are vicious and horrible, but there’s always the fear that there are even worse things hiding out there. When Drayton escapes the supermarket and heads deep into the mist he sees things neither he, or we viewers, could ever imagine.
The Behemoth, this utterly huge, myriad-tentacled, nightmarish creature, is pure cosmic horror. It is only shown briefly and at a distance. But by not dwelling on it director Frank Darabont does something truly frightening - he tells us that there are even worse horrors awaiting in the mist.
Whilst we could recognise what the previous monsters resembled (bugs etc.), the Behemoth signals our entry into a whole new realm of infinite, hopeless, unknowable horror.
9. Crawlers - The Descent (2005)
Okay, there’s not much to these monsters apart from being really scary. But that’s impressive enough to make the list. When we first see one on the video camera screen? One of the best jump scares out there.
The Descent is a terrifying film. If the idea of potholing in pitch black, claustrophobic, subterranean caves isn’t bad enough, then why not fill them with flesh-eating humanoids?
What makes the Crawlers great is that their design makes sense - with pale, slithering bodies and bat-like features, they are totally credible as creatures that could exist underground. There’s no real need to explain them any further. And they are, like the film itself, utterly ruthless.
As the psychological and interpersonal dramas of the women unfold in the red depths of the hell-like caves, the Crawlers never cease their hunt. They are the secrets and traumas that we try to keep hidden in the twisting depths of our souls that eventually tear us apart.
8. The Babadook - The Babadook (2014)
When trying to decide whether the Babadook or Freddy Krueger should make the list, I went with the Babadook, and here’s why.
What makes the Babadook so particularly messed up is what he symbolises. Amelia (Essie Davis) is a widow struggling to cope with her difficult son (Noah Wiseman). As Amelia’s exhaustion worsens, the Babadook begins to appear in the family home. It is seemingly fluid in its shape, a pervasive presence of blackness throughout the house where a father once was.
The Babadook is something more disturbing than some ghoul butchering random victims. It is the manifestation of a widow’s grief; of a mother’s mental unravelling, culminating in violence thoughts against her child.
The Babadook is ultimately not able to be destroyed, but it can be tempered and lived with.
7. The Cenobites - Hellraiser (1987)
“Demons to some, angels to others” is how Pinhead, leader of the Cenobites, describes his motley crew.
Which side of the fence you sit on depends on your sadomasochistic tendencies.
The Cenobites are deep into the fetish scene. All that black leather and bodily mutilation. Pinhead has a fully acupunctured bonce. The female has her throat pried open in an overtly sexual shape. They all have some sort of leaking or gaping wound proudly on display. And they’re keen to take us away from this dimension to their realm of torture.
Hellraiser explores the darkest desires of us humans. The link between pleasure and pain, sex and death. Even as Uncle Frank (Sean Chapman) is torn apart by the Hooks from Hell, he can’t help but lick his lips. What a perv.
6. The Bum Behind Winkies - Mulholland Drive (2001)
David Lynch is a filmmaker with an uncanny ability to create dreamlike movies. He’s also a filmmaker for whom duality is a recurring theme - light/dark, fantasy/reality, sex/death. It stands to reason then that just as dreams pervade the Lynchian world, so to do nightmares.
In Mulholland Drive there is a “man out back” behind Winkies who haunts an unnamed character’s dreams. In the movie’s most terrifying moment we come face to face with the “man out back”. We see him for about a second before he disappears back from whence he came.
Lynch sets up this encounter by informing the viewer that whatever is behind Winkies is more terrifying than we could ever handle. He makes good on this promise by having the nightmare man instantly collapse with fright at the appearance of the “man out back”.
We viewers are similarly shocked because we simply do not know what we are looking at when this creature appears, nor do we have time to process it. Was it some sort of witch? Was it male or female? Was it human at all?
In those fleeting moments, even in broad daylight, all we can know is the leering face of pitch black horror.
5. Pale Man - Pan’s Labyrinth (2006)
You enter a room. There is a wonderful banquet laid out before you. There is also a blind, naked, saggy-skinned creature sitting ominously at the head of the table, a plate of eyeballs before it. You have also been previously warned that his creature eats children. Do you a) steal some of its food? Or b) definitely not steal some of its food and leave?
So much of the Pale Man is freakish. It’s stillness and corpse-like appearance make us question - is it alive or dead? Is it, or was it ever, human? And why does it see through its hands??
We are told that the Pale Man eats children, but its emaciated appearance seems to contradict this fact, whilst its nakedness and the conflation between hands and eyes suggest a darker threat towards children.
Dangerous sexuality is prevalent in all fairytales, and Del Toro hints at it most strongly with the Pale Man.
4. Brundlefly - The Fly (1986)
What body horror does best is, instead of letting us scare ourselves with our imagination, it fully confronts us with slime, flesh, vile appendages and general anatomical perversion.
So, over to the master of body horror with David Cronenberd’s The Fly and a creature that is as heartbreaking as it is disgusting.
There is a slow tragedy to Seth Brundle’s (Jeff Goldblum) metamorphosis into a half-man-half-fly, as his body and mind gradually begin to change. Despite the obvious body horror elements, more disturbing is the way Brundle’s behaviour becomes manic and violent. Brundle’s newfound hyper-virility is another squeamish element as, like with most body horror, Cronenberg turns the sexual act into something perverse and horrifying.
All of this culminates with the eruptive birth of the Brundlefly monster from Seth’s human skin-shell. Slow, human decay is violently replaced by monstrous horror. How can Veronica (Geena Davis) mourn the loss of Seth when she is instantly confronted by a creature so nightmarish and repulsive?
Veronica must endure one final heartbreak as the monster, now fused with the teleporter itself, begs for her to kill it. So sad. And so gross.
3. Dr Pretorius - From Beyond (1986)
We now begin our journey further into the realms of cosmic horror with a film based on a story by H. P. Lovecraft himself.
From Beyond tells the cautionary tale of a perverted scientist, Dr Pretorius (Ted Sorel), who develops a machine called the Resonator in order to stimulate the pineal gland (because his in-house sex dungeon just wasn’t enough). In doing so, a portal to another dimension is opened, containing all sorts of cosmic nasties. Pretorius is dragged into said dimension, only to return later as a slimy, shape-shifting, sexually charged monster, whose pineal gland now protrudes phallically from his head. Eeww...
Much like in Hellraiser, our antagonist (Pretorius) revels in the far-out pleasures that exist in this other dimension, and soon sets his sights on taking beautiful blonde scientist Dr Katherine McMichaels (Barbara Crampton) there with him. Pretorius subjects Katherine to some properly gross sexual trauma, licking her, groping her with his elongated digits, and at one point brainwashing her to dress like a dominatrix (hmmm…). By the end of the movie Pretorius literally resembles a monstrous, insatiable phallus.
From Beyond ticks all the sexually charged horror boxes: body horror, sadomasochism, and the cosmic realm where horror and sex converge to fulfil the ultimate taboo pleasures.
2. The Thing - The Thing (1982)
The Thing can take many guises. Arctic wolf. Beardy scientist. Disembodied head that sprouts spider-like limbs and fleshy antennae before scurrying about.
The horror of the Thing works on two levels. The first - it is a perfect mimic. It could be anyone or anything, and paranoia soon infects the research crew faster than the Thing can itself.
Secondly, its design is such a wonderful exercise in body horror: twisting flesh, mouths on chests, a dripping mosaic of limbs and jaws and bones exploding and jutting in nightmarish forms. The Thing’s many guises take the form of puppets and animatronics covered in KY Jelly, all designed by Rob Bottin at the desire of John Carpenter to avoid ever having to use a man in a monster suit.
As such, the Thing never looks remotely human once its true form is revealed, only a nightmarish distortion of human components. Even scarier though is when it looks perfectly human.
1. Xenomorph - Alien (1979)
Topping the list is the Xenomorph from Alien. There are four stages to its life cycle, and each of its four forms conflate and distort both male and female sexual imagery and, in the words of the BBFC examination board, “pervert the process of reproduction”. Lovely.
We begin with the egg. It has what can only be described as a bi-labial opening (apologies). The egg is a female image of reproduction, but the way it breeds with Kane (John Hurt) is a violently male act of, well, face rape (apologies again), perpetrated by….
The facehugger. Perhaps the creepiest looking creature in the Alien franchise. It’s arachnid design is disturbingly vaginal but with a phallic proboscis that it uses to lay its egg inside Kane.
Then the chestburster. The maternal act of birth is here turned into a violent death. And the alien itself looks exactly like a phallus as it erupts from Kane’s torso.
And finally the adult xenomorph. H. R. Giger’s incredible, iconic design that just screams “killer”. Of course, the xenomorph is comprised of phallic imagery - its elongated head and its protruding second set of jaws which it thrusts into its victims.
More than just a scary alien, the underlying sexual horror of the xenomorph taps into our most vulnerable fears, making it the most messed up horror movie monster.