10 Most Overrated Performances In MCU History (So Far)

Marvel at these slow-burning flops, and hope the Avengers have enough Pym Particles to change them.

WandaVision Wanda Maximoff Elizabeth Olsen
Disney

The Marvel Cinematic Universe is a large and terrifying entity, spanning galaxies all the way from Earth to Asgard, and encompassing some of the greatest heroes ever to grace page, stage or screen. But behind every pair of spandex pantaloons is an actor, and, much like the multifarious characters they represent, they come in all shapes, sizes and skill levels.

Given the breadth of films and talent involved, it is possible that more actors by volume – and certainly more major-league actors – have starred in the MCU than any other franchise, save perhaps the Carry On series. But, 27 films in, whose performances have stood the test of time?

Awash in the skin-tingling glow of another billion-pound behemoth leering at us from the silver screen, fans and critics alike have heaped praise on just about every major player in the MCU, though not always deservedly.

For whatever reason, whether a lack of depth, monotonous delivery or fundamental miscasting, some of these performances were not all they were cut out to be. Now that we can view them from the sobering position of a lumpy sofa, far from the dogged cries of fanboys and greasy-palmed critics, and without bone-breaking subwoofers and a fifty-foot screen to back them up, we are free to reappraise and cast judgement anew.

Now, let's crack open 10 of the most overrated MCU performances, and hope the multiverse doesn't collapse in the process.

10. Michael B Jordan – Erik Stevens

Black Panther Killmonger Michael B Jordan
Marvel Studios

2017's Black Panther set the film world abuzz, seizing recognition, accolades and those sweet sweet box office bucks by the bucket-load.

Making huge strides for representation in superhero media, popular media and celebrated films in general, it was the first superhero film to be nominated for Academy Award for Best Picture, alongside nominations in six other categories, and won three Oscars overall, including the first ever African American win for Best Production Design (Hannah Beachler).

So something had to give.

And that something is Michael B Jordan's Erik Stevens, aka Killmonger. Jordan's performance as the film's antagonist is not bad, not by a long stretch, but it is hella overrated. He received nominations for best supporting actor from a wide number of global awards associations and foundations – more than any other actor in the film.

But the proof is in the pudding and, though the writing is great and Jordan put in a decent performance, the hype simply does not match the end result. Post-Black Panther, Killmonger has receded into the scenery as another in a long line of forgettable MCU bad guys.

To be fair to Jordan, in a film so loaded with excellent performances, the odds were stacked against him. And this is not helped in the slightest by the decidedly ratty CGI that plagues the final act and boss fight between the two Panthers.


9. Benedict Cumberbatch – Stephen Strange

Spider-Man: No Way Home Doctor Strange
Sony Pictures Releasing

Doctor Stephen Strange entered the MCU back in 2017 and has been a major player ever since, featuring in five films so far – and only one of them his own!

Pity then that Kevin Feige and co. have cemented Benedict Cumberbatch into the role, even going so far as to dub him "The best, the greatest and the only Doctor Strange”. But he has never quite fully embodied the comic book character of Dr Strange – not in the way that, say, Tom Holland fits Spidey, or Chadwick Boseman T'Challa.

One of the big problems throughout the MCU is that they have never got the the more mystical, spacey costumes quite right. Contrary to the sublime tech and suit design of the Earth-based heroes, these often end up looking gaudy and cheap – like Thor's Warriors Three, or Guardians' Sovereign. Along with the wavering North American accent and the glued-on goatee, this frequently results in the sensation of watching Bandersnatch Cumperdink do a very pricey cosplay.

All of this might be forgivable, however, if the performance was to the point, but Cumberbatch never quite settles into its groove. It is not his acting, per se, that is the issue, so much as the fact that he is terminally miscast in the role of the sorcerer supreme.

His opportunity to play a far darker side of Strange in the upcoming Multiverse Of Madness is promising but, nonetheless, the key issue surrounding his fit for the role still stands.


8. Dave Bautista – Drax

Guardians Of The Galaxy 2 Drax
Marvel Studios

Dave Bautista has turned in some solid performances since completing the transition from a household name professional wrestler to a household name supporting cast member.

Whether in his portrayal of neo-old-school Bond villain Mr Hinx in Spectre, farming replicant Sapper Morton in Blade Runner: 2048, or the meat-headed Glossu Rabban in Denis Villeneuve's Dune, Bautista has proven that he has the range necessary to inhabit a variety of roles. And while his appearance in 2014's Guardians Of The Galaxy seemed to play true to this idea, his performance as Drax the Destroyer may not be all it's cracked up to be.

A warrior who seeks vengeance for his family's death, Drax begins his journey in the MCU as something of a tragic character, whose inability to comprehend the motivations and meanings of others undercuts the character's seriousness.

Unfortunately, with each subsequent appearance of Drax, the character continues to dumb down, moving from revenge-driven noble warrior to banana-skin comic relief. Granted, he is amusing – in a slapstick, Jar Jar Binks kind of way – but, after four films of this, the same set of tired jokes are wearing thin.

There is not an awful lot to work with script-wise, which is on the writers more than Bautista himself, but his one-note guffawing buffoon could really do with a serious injection of nuance.


7. Gwyneth Paltrow – Pepper Potts

Pepper Potts Endgame
Marvel Studios

Pepper Potts is to Tony Stark what salt is to, well, pepper. Beginning life on our screens as Stark's tolerant yet long-suffering PA, the pair's romance blossomed and she went on as much of a transformative journey as the tin man himself.

Gwyneth Paltrow was excellent in this role for the first few Iron Man films, providing in Potts a balance, reserve and sense of subtlety that played well against Robert Downey Jr's cocky, entitled "billionaire playboy philanthropist" Stark. However, Paltrow allowed her disinterest in the role to seep into her performance, appearing less and less and pulling less weight each time.

Her malaise with acting is well documented, and in recent years she has preferred to focus on other things, like her ghost-written cookbooks and infamous Goop.

Unfortunately, this means Paltrow's much-anticipated return for Infinity War and Endgame was unfortunately not the triumphant lap of honour many hailed it as, even with her own super suit. She let her increasingly sharp private persona bleed into the performance, with none of it ringing true – something that is especially crucial to nail when you have to perform a large green screen battle and watch your in-universe husband die...


6. Jamie Foxx – Max Dillon

Spider-Man: No Way Home Electro
Marvel Studios

As everyone who's anyone should know by now, Spider-Man: No Way Home brought together three different iterations of the web-slinger and villains from across their series for a big ol' fracas around NYC.

While everyone loved the sizable volume of old-school cast members the studio crammed the latest Spidey flick full of, there seemed to be a significant lack of direction – not just in the action, but in the acting. For heavyweights like Alfred Molina and Willem Dafoe, it was just another day at the office, and they were able to slide back into their roles no problem, but for others it wasn't so simple.

The result? Jamie Foxx. A lot of Jamie Foxx. Just SO MUCH Jamie Foxx.

Many fans have been blinded by the sheer nostalgia of it all, but as Max Dillon/Electro, Foxx chews scenery like bubble-gum, start to finish. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 had the benefit of the character going through a big transition – from shunned computer geek to Blue Man Group auditionee – but with No Way Home, Foxx was charging full tilt from the off.

Yes, Foxx has put in outstanding performances in some outstanding films, but it takes magic on both sides of the camera to make this happen, and director Jon Watts forgot to check the rapper-cum-actor's ego at the door. While a notoriously firm directorial authority like Quentin Tarantino can reign in the bluster, showboating and two-tonne personality that Foxx brings with him, unfortunately Watts was simply not up to the task.


5. Elizabeth Olsen – Wanda Maximoff

Avengers: Endgame Wanda Maximoff/Scarlet Witch
Disney

Wanda Maximoff, or Scarlet Witch to use her "made-up name", was a much anticipated addition to one of the Marvel Comics universes, pre-2014. Many long-time fans were hoping to see her appear in Fox's X-Men canon, as the daughter of Ian McKellen's Magneto.

Instead, she arrived in 2014's Avengers: Age Of Ultron, utterly unconnected to the mutants as we know them, in the form of Elizabeth Olsen (Mary-Kate and Ashley's li'l sis). To our delight, Wanda had brother Pietro/Quicksilver (Aaron Taylor-Johnson) in tow; to our dismay, she was as wooden as a petrified Groot.

While Olsen's performances in the role have improved with each entry, her progress is not as stark as many critics and fans would have us believe. In recent films, where she has been paired with Paul Bettany's synthetic lifeform Vision, it has often been hard to tell which one is the android. Thankfully, she has phased out the awful, faux-Eastern European accent supposedly native to the people of Sokovia, adopting a more common-sense North American one that doesn't require any linguistic gymnastics.

Wanda is not without her share of heartbreak, tragedy and critical moments – her actions kick off the events of Civil War that ultimately see the near-permanent disassembling of the Avengers. But during each of her key moments, there has been some significant oomph lacking in the performance.

That won't stop us holding high hopes for her future though, and we wait with baited breath for her appearance in the next Dr Strange.


4. Robert Downey Jr – Tony Stark

Tony Stark Avengers Infinity War
Disney

While Downey began the series with a knock-out entry in Iron Man, and acted as the lynchpin for the extended franchise for the better part of a decade thereafter, he also let this success and career revival go to his head.

With each film, the standards slipped and, soon, he was sleepwalking through the role, giving us little from the Tony Stark character that we hadn't already seen one way or another – a snarky, sarcastic suit with a goatee.

Iron Man 3 was a highpoint in terms of expanding the character and attempting to bring greater gravitas to the role, but the suit gradually became more interesting than the man inside – and, given the suits post-Ultron (the film which delivered the ingenious Hulkbuster) swiftly became regurgitations of things we had seen before, this was a concerning position to be in.

Endgame may have cemented his legacy and redeemed the character in one final act, but it is hard to deny that even through this gargantuan conclusion to the original Avengers series, Downey was not serving anything world-shattering.

To make matters worse, Avengers director Joe Russo has revealed that Downey used an earpiece to have lines fed to him while on set. Fans and critics alike have made the far from compelling case that this allows him to get on with the serious business of 'acting' without being impeded by such nonsense as learning the words he is speaking, but try telling that to Daniel Day-Lewis.


3. Chris Pratt – Peter Quill

Guardians Of The Galaxy Star Lord
Marvel Studios

If the Marvel Cinematic Universe has created as much of a star as Robert Downey Jr out of anyone, it is Chris Pratt.

Transitioning almost instantaneously from lovable schlub Andy on Parks & Recreation to the chiselled global superstar we know today, Pratt hopped on the Marvel gravy train and never looked back. In the years since, he has starred opposite some of the biggest names in Hollywood, voiced Disney characters, and even led the Jurassic Park franchise, all the while maintaining that Chris Pratt look and goofy charm.

And that's the problem right there.

While there has always been positive buzz surrounding Guardians Of The Galaxy and his character, Peter Quill/Star Lord, even at their worst, Pratt has never demonstrated an ability to play away from type. Wherever he appears, he is the same character in a different outfit; it is not so much that Pratt doesn't suit the role of Peter Quill, but that the role is just more of Chris Pratt being Chris Pratt.

And the more films we see in which he plays a version of himself, the further this breakout performance is diluted. But, with him billed for this year's Thor: Love And Thunder, there are no signs of him taking a break any time soon.

We can only hope, this time, it is Peter Quill who comes back with the metal beard and beer belly. Then, you never know, we might get to see a bit more character.


2. Sebastian Stan – Bucky Barnes

Avengers infinity war bucky barnes
Marvel Studios

Sebastian Stan is undeniably great as Bucky Barnes in The First Avenger, acting as a solid support and emotional counterweight for Chris Evans' first appearance as Captain America.

Equally, Stan is pitch-perfect as the Winter Soldier for Cap's second solo outing, putting on his bag guy face and treating us to an unexpectedly sinister spy thriller. However, once the mask and the eyeliner come off, and Bucky returns to the fold, the teeth really fall out of his performance. He remains a fan-favourite, but (at least in the films) it has been increasingly difficult to fathom why.

Meandering, moping, sulking, and not doing a whole lot of anything else, he is a wet blanket of the highest order. Even as the MacGuffin of Civil War, he has a hard time giving the audience anything juicy to sate our thirst for Bucky. This is surprising, given Stan has proven time and again that he has chops, range and credibility as a skilled performer (one need only look as far as Hulu's new Pam & Tommy to testify to this).

But, outside of playing Captain America's perfect moral dilemma, the writers don't really know what to do with him. With appearances spanning a whopping seven MCU films, Bucky has had little development and few hero moments to speak of (spinning a raccoon doesn't really count), so perhaps we should just stop expecting so much of him.


1. Mark Ruffalo – Bruce Banner

avengers infinity war bruce banner hulkbuster no helmet
Disney

Hailed by many as an invaluable players in the Avengers saga, Bruce Banner/Hulk is one of the most recognisable Marvel heroes ever created.

The character was introduced in the second MCU film back in 2008, with Mark Ruffalo taking up the mantle for 2012's Avengers. Although he has now appeared in eight films, rarely have his performances been convincing or memorable.

To be clear: Mark Ruffalo can act; this just isn't it.

Ruffalo's Banner is a bland everyman, never quite fitting the timid boffin role, nor the monster with the aching heart. He is strongest in Thor: Ragnarok, where the big green guy's personality is brought to life for longer in mo-cap, and Chris Hemsworth's comedic lead gives Ruffalo's straight man some purpose. But, equally, he is weakest in its successor, Infinity War, when the Hulk crutch is gone and Ruffalo is reduced to a silly little head cheerleading the team from within a giant battle suit.

The fact that he hasn't had his own solo Hulk film is something of a double-edged sword, insomuch as it hasn't allowed Ruffalo to take centre stage, but also that it perhaps displays the studio's lack of confidence in his ability to do so.

The latest development is the most promising yet, however, as Endgame's Professor Hulk offered a new take on the character that managed to skirt the awkward, angsty part Ruffalo had been gently murdering throughout the preceding films. But it is surely a sad indictment that his performance is best when he's computer-generated.


Contributor

Writer, editor, trend-setter. Slayer of gnomes and trolls. Letterboxd: Byronic0