10 Most Overrated Sci-Fi Movies Ever Made
They may be good, they may be great - but are these films really worth their salt?
It's been a banner century for the science-fiction genre so far on both the small and big screens. Though classic works such as 2001: A Space Odyssey, Star Wars, Blade Runner and Jurassic Park still dominate conversations, we're starting to see more recent fare such as Ex Machina and Arrival join the pantheon of the all-time greats.
But for every genuine barnstormer out there, fans may feel that there's another that isn't worthy of the acclaim that comes its way; that they struggle to see just what all the fuss is about and that such fare is diluting the conversation at the expense of more excellent, underseen efforts across the cinematic medium.
The matter of a film being overhyped is of course subjective - and there's plenty such movies that are still genuinely good, even great, underneath any such consensus of superior quality. With that in mind, there's several entries on this list that some will unashamedly love; it's just, to some of us, they may not warrant quite the level of praise they have received.
10. Prometheus (2012)
Though it takes place in the same wider universe as the Alien franchise, the creators of quasi-prequel Prometheus have always shied away from referring to it as such. Ridley Scott's long-awaited return to the sci-fi world he created originally started life as a fifth entry, before undergoing some nip-and-tuck production to distance it from the overall series - but the explicit title of follow-up Alien: Covenant would put paid to any suggestion this was not the real deal.
Alas, away from Michael Fassbender's particularly brilliant performance, the end product doesn't hang together with the panache and power of Scott's original forays into this universe, often feeling split between the high-minded intellectualism it wishes to install into proceedings and the more expected genre trappings without ever quite bringing the two sides together in a satisfying manner.
The sequel earned broadly similar notices but both aren't quite as clever as they think they are, with this one more of a particular offender than the other.
9. Zombieland (2009)
The zombie subgenre of horror and sci-fi is one of the most consistently skewered in the book and Ruben Fleischer's 2009 effort, penned by future Deadpool scribes Rhett Reese and Paul Wernick, proves no different in tackling its conventions with a savvy self-awareness from the word go, assembling gags and gore galore as it forges through its own post-apocalyptic world.
Except the idea of a group of effective quasi-strangers - or at the very least, individuals who can't stand each other for one reason or another - banding together on a journey through the horde had already been deployed better half-a-decade prior in Edgar Wright's genre-bending Shaun of the Dead, a film which managed to convey more heart and heft on the whole.
In fact, save Bill Murray's glorious late-act cameo, Zombieland just doesn't quite measure up like it should; a notion only further reinforced by its sequel Double Tap last year, which riffed on most of the same gags. Its lead foursome have chemistry to spare - but like Deadpool in its wake, there's an undercurrent of smugness at points that just kicks the legs out, undercutting its more genuine moments of comedic potential.
8. Back To The Future Part II (1989)
Films don't come much better in the more playful corner of the sci-fi pantheon than Back to the Future, while its two sequels filmed back-to-back were no slouch either. But the second entry in this franchise has only grown in stature over the last three decades; an odd phenomenon given that a cursory rewatch shows it really isn't up to the mark of Marty McFly's prior adventures.
The ambitious film takes the Hill Valley kid and eccentric mentor Doc Brown thirty years into the future, before a return to a dystopian 1985 sets alarm bells ringing. From there, they head back to 1955 and riff off previous scenarios from the original movie.
While Avengers: Endgame made great entertainment out of this latter gimmick, Marty's return to his parents' youth didn't mine such potential the way it could have - and by its finale, there's a sense of staidness setting in that's hard to ignore (albeit one that Part III would resoundingly sweep aside.)
7. Little Shop Of Horrors (1986)
Starting life as a Roger Corman black comedy in 1960, before earning a second life as an off-Broadway musical, Frank Oz's Little Shop of Horrors adapted the latter to gloriously camp effect, telling the tale of a nebbish flower shop assistant who inadvertently nourishes a bloodthirsty man-eating plant into full-bloom in this sci-fi horror work.
It earned critical raves for the most part and all these years later it remains a cult favourite - but the actual subject of its quality is up for debate, due to its significant deviations come the final reel, which saw the film eschew the darker ending of the stage production in favour of a more upbeat finale after test screenings reacted negatively.
Its effective modus operandi - as a black comedy that shies away from the true inkiness at its heart - feels almost willfully quaint now, and something of a missed opportunity. Many hope that an upcoming remake, reportedly starring Taron Egerton, Scarlett Johansson and Chris Evans, will faithfully stick to the original source and keep its extraterrestrial grisliness intact.
6. Never Let Me Go (2010)
Released on the festival circuit in 2010 before moving onto a wider release the following year, Mark Romanek's adaptation of Sir Kazuo Ishiguro's acclaimed Booker Prize-nominated novel has swelled over the subsequent decade to become something of a small cult favourite - but compared to the work it's based upon, it just isn't quite as up to snuff as it could be.
Despite a screenplay from future Ex Machina and Annihilation filmmaker Alex Garland and a trio of well-studied lead performances, it arguably plays its hand too early in making its big reveal, something from which it can be debated the film never recovers - and thereafter struggles to really hit home with the waterworks it seems to crave under its ethical questioning.
There's a lot to love about it - Andrew Garfield and Carey Mulligan are excellent and Rachel Portman's score is an unsung gem - but compared to the reputation it's gradually fostered since, it's not quite as deftly affecting as it is thought to be, more turgid than tragic at points in its execution (though arguably the complexities of the novel are as much to blame as the film itself).
5. Blade Runner 2049 (2017)
French-Canadian director Denis Villeneuve has proven one of the most masterful genre directors in the business over the past decade, with both Sicario and Arrival standing out as prime examples of his skill at deftly weaving weightier concepts into the bones of tensely calculated popcorn fare - and the odds are he'll somehow do it again with his upcoming take on Dune.
Yet his most recent film Blade Runner 2049 sits at an unusual crossroads. As a long-gestating sequel to the seminal sci-fi classic, it was always going to have to meet stratospheric expectations of a sort, and it is to its testament that it mostly does throughout, returning us to the world of Rick Deckard.
Yet with a runtime that can feel particularly punishing and less of a deft handle on its grand mythologising than it thinks it does, it likely falls just below the mark of greatness on reflection, despite its oft-brilliant nature. The sheer weight is mostly borne throughout by Villeneuve, who takes the film in interesting directions - but there's little escaping that he could have trimmed the fat here significantly while still retaining powerful character and narrative strength.
4. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (2016)
Ever since Disney began their expansion of the Star Wars cinematic universe - with both the long-awaited sequel trilogy and their anthology film series - die-hards of a galaxy far, far away have struggled to agree on pretty much any entry to date (though critics have only seriously soured on one film of the five released, last year's closing chapter The Rise of Skywalker).
But if there's one that is more overhyped than strictly divisive, it's likely the first non-Skywalker Saga entry in the book, the gritty quasi-prequel Rogue One. Set in the immediate hours leading up to the original film almost forty years prior, it's got all the ingredients to click as a genuinely different take on Star Wars lore - new planets, new players and a nostalgic affection, this time for old war movies more than swashbuckling matinee features.
That's why it's something of a bummer that it struggles to convey the heart or heft of its fellow chapters throughout, despite some top-notch production work and a talented cast. Few of its players really register the way they should - and though it makes some bold creative choices, it often feels choppy and indistinct in key parts. Critics mostly thought the Force was with this one - but it's just out of reach.
3. Men In Black (1997)
Last year's fourth installment in the Men in Black franchise was something of a soggy misfire for all involved, at least according to the critics who mangled it and the audiences who didn't really turn up. But nor was MIB: International necessarily having to match up to an outrageously high bar if a cursory rewatch of the original entry is anything to go by.
Tommy Lee Jones and Will Smith's sci-fi caper, based on the comic run of the same name, works best when letting its two stars bounce off each other - but after its initial flush of early delight, it struggles to recapture that early spirit for the second and third reels of the film, despite the efforts of its leading duo, as it bounces around trying to relocate that zest.
The two sequels that followed starring both men are undoubtedly not overrated - but this maiden effort doesn't particularly make this look good like remembered, too scattershot in its aim to truly convince us of its consistent quality. For a comedy, that's dangerous territory.
2. Avatar (2009)
It's been said before and it'll be said again - Avatar, the second highest-grossing film of all time when unadjusted for inflation, is less than the sum of its parts. The 2009 blockbuster - James Cameron's decades-in-the-making return to the science-fiction genre after his unprecedented success with Titanic - smashed past all expectations upon release, helping to herald the arrival of new technology and the rise of 3-D in cinemas worldwide.
But eleven years later, with its long-gestating sequels finally around the corner, there's little escaping that as a central hook, beneath all the technology and visual splendour, it just doesn't hold up in the way the very best blockbuster filmmaking does.
To briefly compare, it arrived a year on the heels of The Dark Knight, a film that managed to instill its themes with a sense of zeitgeist while ensuring it never lost sight of its more muscular credentials. Here, there's a lethargy to Cameron's work, while his characterisations often fall shy of the "show, don't tell" school of development with their expository nature. We hope his expansive slate of follow-ups can exercise these flaws with their expansion of Pandora - but we shall see.
1. Interstellar (2014)
Blockbuster auteur Christopher Nolan have often come with their minority share of detractors, but there's no denying that his widescreen visions have enthralled critics and audiences to impressively consistent effect for the best part of two decades now, from Dunkirk to Inception to The Dark Knight Trilogy.
If there's a lone blight on this run of copper-bottomed popcorn spectacles though, it's the ambitious time-and-space-flaunting Interstellar, a film that - like Blade Runner 2049 would do in its wake - becomes unfortunately preoccupied with its sense of grandiosity the further it delves into the particularly human story at its centre.
It's the director at his most esoteric - and his most frustrating to boot, crafting a sci-fi work that while undoubtedly satisfying up to a point, proves too portentous to truly click up into a higher gear. He's coaxed out another raft of awards-worthy performances here, who mostly bring their A-game - but despite its striking eye for visual panache, its disparate plot strands come together with a clunk and a thunk more than anything else, in sharp contrast to the smoother cohesion offered in several of his other works. It's by no means a bad movie - but it's surely his weakest effort of the past decade.