9. Spider-Man (Sam Raimi's Spider-Man Trilogy)
Although they were essentially playing the same character, Tobey Maguire's version of Spider-Man came across as slightly more powerful than Andrew Garfield's. While their power-sets were basically the same, the extent of Maguire's version was undoubtedly greater. Speed was pretty much the same between the two versions - Maguire's version could dodge bullets too - but his durability and strength was tested to the point that better showings on both fronts occurred. Maguire Spidey took repeated shots from giant Sandman's fist, giving him greater durability, while his strength in stopping a moving train was greater than anything Garfield's Spidey showed on the strength front. The fact that his webbing was also biological meant he didn't have to worry about malfunctioning technology or an opponent breaking his web-shooters (which Lizard did to Garfield's version, for instance). He also had the same enhanced senses as Maguire's version.