10 Most Underrated Movie Remakes Since 2000

Judged way too harshly upon release, it's time to reappraise these remakes.

"Remake." Is there any word more primed to irk a cinephile than "remake?" Remakes, after all, are generally considered to be the scourge of the movie world. Why take a product that is already good and spend the time, effort and money trying to replicate its successes all over again? For many, such an act symbolises Hollywood at its worst. Because there's something inherently futile about the idea of a remake. It's near impossible to "capture" what, exactly, has made something popular in the first place; despite what Hollywood seems to think, taking an existing film and updating it for a new audience rarely works. And it's not as though the majority of remakes ever turn out to be worthwhile. Occasionally you'll get a tolerable remake; rarely will it turn out to be any better. That said, some remakes get a hard time purely on the basis that they're remakes. Sometimes, then, it's worth trying to separate yourself from the original movie and trying to appreciate said film on its own merits. Nostalgia can play a huge part in our reactions to remakes and - as a result - some recent movies in this vein have been treated unfairly. To reinforce this point, here are the 10 most underrated remakes since 2000, none of which were anywhere near as bad they were made out to be. Some, even, are rather great...

10. The Thing (2011)

A unusual cross between a remake and a prequel, The Thing attempts to tell the story that leads up to the events depicted in John Carpenter's 1981 classic of the same name (basically: what happened at the Norwegian base?). In doing so, it pretty much settles for reprising the beats of the first flick, cementing itself as a remake pretending not to be one. The film was met negatively upon its release, with many critics quick to call The Thing "pointless" and "unnecessary," citing it as a pale imitation of the original. But there's a sense that they might have been a little harsh on the film in retrospect: this is a worthwhile little horror movie, all things considered - a kind of love letter/companion piece to the original that fans of the Kurt Russell classic can enjoy purely on a "spot the reference" basis. Effort has been made to ensure that The Thing makes sense when viewed alongside its predecessor, and there are lots of clever nods scattered throughout. No, it's nowhere near as good as the original, but viewed out of context The Thing clings to a fun, old-fashioned approach to the horror movie, and Mary Elizabeth Winstead makes for a highly compelling lead as Dr. Kate Lloyd, an American posted at the Norwegian base.

9. Total Recall (2012)

When the news came that Len Wiseman, director of Underworld and Live Free and Die Hard, was to helm a remake of sci-fi classic Total Recall, there was a collective sigh from fans the world over. Why remake something as inherently original as Total Recall? And with Colin Farrell as Douglas Quid? How was he supposed to top Arnold Schwarzenegger? Looking back at the finished result, then, the answer to those questions is clear. There was no point in remaking Total Recall, and Colin Farrell doesn't come anywhere close to reaching the memorable heights that Schwarzenegger did back in 1990. That said, Total Recall is not the awful remake that everyone claims it to be: sure, it's familiar, lacks punch, and makes lots of bad narrative choices, but that doesn't mean it isn't a fun action flick from start to finish. The fact that it's of the throwaway variety matters not. And there are things to like: the action scenes are the total highlight of the flick, not to mention that - as a sort of bonus - you have Bryan Cranston in full-on scenery chewing mode as villain Vilos Cohaagen. What's more, the remake boasts an impressive production design; the world feels intricately realised. In need of a revaluation is this one, for sure.

8. The Hills Have Eyes (2006)

Wes Craven's horror classic, The Hills Have Eyes, was always going to get a remake: given its inherently interesting premise (which concerns a mutated cannibal family living out in the New Mexico desert who pray on travellers), such a thing was plainly inevitable. What nobody expected, however, was a remake that not only lived up to the legacy of the original, but arguably surpassed it in a good number of ways. Not that many people agreed, of course - The Hills Have Eyes was met with mostly negative reviews, but - looking at it again - there is lots to like about Alexandre Aja's 2006 remake. Firstly, The Hills Have Eyes is creepy as hell. The general atmosphere of the picture is seriously uncomfortable from start to finish, whilst the pacing - which allows the movie to build and build to a horrific, chilling revelation - is well-mantained. Aja essentially treats his remake as an old school horror flick, and the use of practical make-up, effects and gore ensure that the tone retains a sense of self-awareness (which many critics missed). The movie's highlight, however, is its central character: uber-nerd Doug (played by Aaron Stanford) makes the transformation from super meek husband to certified badass, and it's a pleasure to watch. If you've written this remake off, give it shot: it's a great little horror.

7. Assault On Precinct 13 (2005)

Unloved and forgotten, this is the second remake on the list to have hailed from a John Carpenter movie (John Carpenter's original, interestingly, was in itself a loose remake of Howard Hawks' classic western Rio Bravo). Starring Ethan Hawke and Laurence Fishburne, Assault on Precinct was derided upon first release as "formulaic," but most people seemed to miss the point: this remake was clearly rendered as a B-movie homage - and taken in that vein, it's something of a doozy. Clinging to a simple story that sees a group of policeman and a bunch of criminals teaming up to defend a police station on the verge of closure, the flick offers great fun and big thrills. There's a sense that, had this movie been an original, reception would have been far more positive. Whilst it offers little in the way of innovation, it's hard to argue that Assault on Precinct 13 is anything other than entertaining. And the performances from Hawke (always good) and Fishburne are compelling enough to make you care about the outcome. Regardless of the original's iconic status, this is an underrated remake that you can genuinely imagine John Carpenter sitting down and enjoying. And it's bloody as hell!

6. The Secret Life Of Walter Mitty (2013)

The Secret Life of Walter Mitty emerged as one of those films that people seemed to either really love or really hate: few seemed to think that it was "just OK." Whilst that's an understandable reaction (it's not the easiest movie in the world, nor is it as accessible as lots of other Ben Stiller vehicles), it does a huge injustice to what it is a seriously underrated remake: one that is bold, beautiful, and actually rather complex. A remake of the 1947 film of the same name (of which it shares little resemblance), The Secret Life of Walter Mitty stars Ben Stiller as the hero of the title - a daydreamer with a penchant for conjuring up adventurous scenarios. Stiller gives a wonderful performance in a movie whose message genuinely seems to be "live life to fullest," and there are moments of real life scattered throughout the picture that render it as genuinely tender and heartfelt. The Secret Life of Walter Mitty clings to a score of just 50% on critical aggregator site Rotten Tomatoes, which seems genuinely unfair. It's rare that the critics get a movie as wrong as they did this one, but Walter Mitty - whilst not perfect - has a lot to give. It is a rare remake that not only transcends the original, but dares to go further. And it succeeds.

5. Fright Night (2011)

Oh, look: another Colin Farrell remake that deserves a whole lot more attention than it originally garnered upon release - this time with the 2011 version of Fright Night. Fright Night was lambasted on its announcement purely on the basis that it's a remake. People seemed less willing to give it a go, too, because it stars Colin Farrell. Now, Farrell is a capable actor and - like this remake - he's a bit underrated. That said, there's something about him that means his films almost always flop. You can't argue with the statistics. Anyway: Fright Night, based on the cult film of the same name about a couple of teenagers who suspect their next door neighbour is a vampire, is (despite what the naysayers will tell you) loads and loads of fun; an unabashed '80s throwback with a simple agenda: to give you a good time. Not to mention that Farrell, playing a vampire, is great in the lead role. Granted, the CGI is a bit dodgy at times and there are a few questionable moments scattered throughout, but for what it's worth this is a really entertaining little remake. It's not like it tried to be anything other than exactly that, after all, and it should be judged on those terms and those terms alone. Also: David Tennant and Christopher Mintz-Plasse!

4. The Italian Job (2003)

"You were only supposed to blow the bloody doors off!" A classic line from a classic movie. How dare they remake The Italian Job for modern audiences back in 2003? You just don't mess with the classics! That's, like, a rule! For some reason, then, the remake of The Italian Job has a reputation as being something of a dud. Going back and actually watching the movie, however, reveals that this widely-held opinion is wrong - really wrong. No, it's not quite as good as the original, but it is a highly competent and rather thrilling blockbuster. And nobody talks about it these days, which is kind of a shame given that it's a really entertaining way to spend two hours. The key to this success of this underrated remake, really, stems from the fact that it doesn't take itself all too seriously. Directed by F. Gary Gray (who just had a major hit with N.W.A. biopic Straight Outta Compton), it's rendered as an old-fashioned heist flick in the vein of Ocean's Eleven. You know, slick characters extensively plotting to get their revenge. It's time, perhaps, that everyone stopped turning their noses up at this movie just for the sake of it: for an "unnecessary remake," it's a heck of a lot of fun.

3. Vanilla Sky (2001)

Without a doubt, Vanilla Sky is Cameron Crowe's most underrated feature film. Whilst the director has certainly turned out some rather middling pictures over the years, all deserving of their terrible reviews, there's a sense that Vanilla Sky was a little hard done by. Starring Tom Cruise, Cameron Diaz and Penelope Cruz, Vanilla Sky is a remake of the 1997 Spanish film Open Your Eyes (which is, in all honesty, a much better film). But whilst Vanilla Sky is something of a mess, it's a strange, absorbing and hypotonic mess - a film made more interesting on account of its failings. It also features a great performance by Tom Cruise, who plays a handsome, wealthy man who loses everything (and his mind). Open Your Eyes was a strange film to remake, all things considered; that Tom Cruise was interested in starring in an American version is likely the only reason it got made. Still, most people seem to remember Vanilla Sky with frustration; as though they were robbed of the movie that they expected to see. Revisiting Crowe's flick (and it's certainly the sort of movie that warrants at least two viewings) reveals it as a flawed but ultimately complex picture. If your only memories of Vanilla Sky consist of that scene in which Cameron Diaz makes Tom Cruise drive his car off a bridge, give it another chance; it's very underrated.

2. Freaky Friday (2003)

Yes. Seriously. Despite what you think of Lindsay Lohan nowadays (and it can't be a lot), there was a time when the actress was churning out great remakes like it was nobody's business. So whilst The Parent Trap is a family classic, no question, there seems to be a lack of love for the 2003 version of Freaky Friday (which also stars the wonderful Jamie Lee Curtis). The plot, which sees a bickering mother and daughter transferred into each other's bodies, makes for ripe comedy - and whilst said premise could have led to disaster, it actually results in a consistently hilarious flick. Lohan is good in the role of a spoiled teen, but it's Jamie Lee Curtis who outright steals the film as the well-to-do mother who learns to live a little. Indeed, she was even nominated for a Golden Globe (and she should have won). What's more, this updated version is far superior to that of the original film, which was entertaining enough in parts, but lacked the consistent laughs of this remake. There's a manic energy that carries the remake all the way to the credits; it's a blast to sit through. Go on: give it another chance. You know you want to.

1. Maniac (2012)

A remake of the exploitive 1980 horror movie of the same name, Maniac was met with mixed reviews upon its release. It currently holds a very telling 49% on Rotten Tomatoes, thus proving just how dividing the film was as far the critics were concerned. And yet, despite the fact that the movie was talked up as a modern horror classic in the months prior to its release, Maniac came and went with little fanfare. Which is a shame, given that it's a seriously creepy horror flick featuring a truly transformative performance from Elijah Wood (clearly channelling his cannibalistic character, "Kevin," from Sin City) as a serial killer who takes over ownership of his mother's mannequin shop after her death. Whilst most viewers responded negatively towards the film's excessive use of gore, in retrospect it seems a little odd to hate on the movie for that particular aspect: the gore is in service of the plot, after all, and is - in an odd way - rendered with genuine artistry. Violence aside, Maniac is a horror experience unlike any other; its central conceit, that we only see events from the POV of the main character, feels both bold and innovating. As a result, Maniac has the feel of a strange, surreal experiment for the sum of its runtime. And, in a rare turn of events, it winds up being one remake that's a lot better than the original. Like this article? Agree or disagree that these movies are a bit underrated? Any others to add to the list? Let us know all your thoughts in the comments section below.

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.