10 Movie Happy Endings That Ignored One Devastating Thing

So, why'd you do nothing about the Nazis, Diana?

Wonder Woman Hitler
Warner Bros.

You should never believe a happy ending without committing to SOME sort of scrutiny. Some of the seemingly most satisfying happy endings - Truman escaping his reality show prison, Harry marrying Sally, Doc Brown not being killed by Libyans - all come with nasty stings in their tail if you follow the logic far enough.

While Hollywood's script-writers like to add this sweet little full-stops on movies, it's usually the work they put in before that point that undoes them. No matter how hard you try, you can't just forget the established human nature of the characters simply because "they all lived happily ever after" and it seems that some writers are simply intent on making us all ignore the glaring distractions from those happy endings.

But, you can't fool all of us and it's very obvious that not everyone emerges from the happy endings we accept on face value to live lives full of joy and light...

10. The Other Girl - Taken

Taken Amanda
Fox

The Happy Ending

Having been the bear that was idiotically poked, Bryan Mills gets to show off his certain set of skills, infiltrates a sex slave auction and rescues his daughter from the filthy paws of her would-be Arab buyer and her "seller" Patrice Saint-Clair. He kills lots of people, because that's what he does and the family enjoys a happy reunion in America.

Then Holly Valance turns up to cement the happy ending.

But Wait...

What about the other girl, Amanda, who was abducted with Kim and who Bryan finds dead in the safe house full of drugged captive girls? Leaving the other potential sex slave girls is one thing (since he can't take down the ENTIRE system himself), but somewhere, while the Mills are enjoying their reunion, Amanda's family aren't even informed on camera about their tragic daughter.

Hell, even Kim seems to get over her best friend's death pretty quickly, thanks to getting to visit Holly Valance. But hey, Amanda wasn't a virgin, so maybe it's ok for her to die as a morality tale or something?!


9. The Ghostbusters Trapped Innocent Ghosts - Ghostbusters 2

Ghostbusters 2 Titanic
Columbia Pictures

The Happy Ending

Despite them being royally screwed by all of the ungrateful New York residents who manage to forget the fact that they saved them from oblivion not so long ago, the Ghostbusters are once more triumphant at the end of their second movie. They commandeered the Statue Of Liberty to help rally the citizens and sent Vigo packing before he could steal Oscar's little baby body.

The ghosts that were let loose on New York are then presumably all rounded up and sent to ghost prison to live forever in a metal tomb in the Ghostbusters' HQ basement.

But Wait...

Not all of the ghosts deserve to be herded like vermin. As Ghostbusters 2 confirms with the arrival of the Titanic at the docks, some of them are just innocent dead people who can't get their eternal rest.

So the idea of those ghosts being locked up for all eternity with little wankers like Slimer and full-blown monsters is a little... unfair, to be honest. They'd already had to die horribly and now they've gone on to worse without cause.


8. The Kids Will Struggle To Reintegrate - The Lion, The Witch & The Wardrobe

The Lion The Witch And The Wardrobe
Walt Disney

The Happy Ending

After defeating the White Witch and leading Aslan's army to victory against seemingly insurmountable odds, the Pevensie children are crowned King Peter the Magnificent, Queen Susan the Gentle, King Edmund the Just, and Queen Lucy the Valiant.

They rule over Narnia for 15 glorious years at which point they accidentally stumble across the lamppost while chasing a white stag and end up back home, reverting back to the day they left. They're once more children and nobody has a beard anymore.

But Wait...

How the hell could anyone who has aged 15 years - the 15 most difficult formative years of anyone's life at that - go back to being a child and be absolutely fine with it. At the very least, the four children would be terribly maladjusted and unable to connect with anyone their age. They're now basically adults trapped in youth, with all of the experience and epiphanies involved but not the body.

And on top of that, they were literally kings and queens and they're going to have to go back to school and be forced to know their place. At best, they'll be deeply unhappy, but at worst, they'll end up being massive d*cks to everyone as the superior growing up they'd experienced has been robbed from them.


7. The Abductees Lives Are Utterly Ruined - Close Encounters Of The Third Kind

Close Encounters Of The Third Kind Abductees
Columbia Pictures

The Happy Ending

Whether you believe the end of Close Encounters is happy probably depends on your point of view but for Roy Neary, his obsessive search for UFOs and proof of life on other planets pays off as he's taken on some intergalactic travels by the aliens who have come to Earth. His family probably aren't as happy, since he just plain buggers off and leaves them, but it's not really their story and they were just in his way anyway.

On top of Roy leaving, the aliens also return some of their former abductees including animals, little Barry Guiler and the missing crews of Flight 19 and the SS Cotopaxi, who were taken years ago. Everyone rejoices.

But Wait...

The abductees haven't aged a day, which is fine for Barry as he's not been gone long and who really cares about the animals? More concerning are the pilots and Cotopaxi crew, who were missing for DECADES.

It's all well and good bringing them back, but their families are probably dead and the Earth will have changed massively since they were abducted. Their reintegration - which will probably include years or government probing and press invasion - is pretty much going to be impossible.


6. She's A Criminal - Big

Big Josh Baskin
20th Century Fox

The Happy Ending

Having learned the valuable tale that you shouldn't always get what you want (and also that you shouldn't wish your life away because older boys will try and ruin your inventive new toy pitches), Josh Baskin realises he wants to not be Big any more and turns to Zoltar to turn him back into a child.

It works and after months of his family thinking he was kidnapped, he goes home to be reunited with them. Presumably, they've got lots of questions, but at least he's home.

But Wait...

Aside from Josh getting the taste of adulthood that would make the rest of his childhood difficult, the more difficult revelation will come for Elizabeth Perkins' Susan who has just watched her boyfriend turn into a 12-year-old.

The boyfriend she was very much sexually active with.

Now, wizards and magic are involved, so she doesn't TECHNICALLY have sex with a child (at least not in body), but responsisilbity and maturity are part of the whole age of consent thing. So, she's going to have to live with the fact that she would be classed as a criminal for the rest of her life. Even if it doesn't come out in public, knowing that she had sex with a pre-teen has got to leave a mental mark.


5. He's Probably Going To Burn Out Horribly - Whiplash

Whiplash Miles Teller
Blumhouse

The Happy Ending

Just as La La Land is about the cost of following your dreams (or achieving them, more specifically), Damien Chazelle's Whiplash is very much about what it costs to be truly great. Miles Teller's Andrew learns that you have to put blood, sweat and tears in and endure bullying to be improved.

But the film ultimately sees him overcome as he shrugs off villainous teacher Fletcher's attempted humiliation on stage by returning and playing the complex Caravan defiantly. He and Fletcher even seem to share a moment of clarity and mutual respect as Andrew "wins" the moment.

But Wait...

All Andrew does in "beating" Fletcher is prove he was right to treat him the way he did. The undercurrent of the movie focuses on the ideal of it being better to die in a blaze of glory than to fade away in obscurity. And by returning to Fletcher and to drumming, Andrew has basically condemned himself to realise his dream but to probably either burn out or worse die young in the continued pursuit of it.


4. The Coachman Still Kidnaps Kids - Pinocchio

The Coachman Pinocchio
Disney

The Happy Ending

Having escaped Pleasure Island and avoiding becoming a donkey, as well as escaping Monstro the whale and finally becoming a real boy, Pinocchio gets his happy ending (even though he temporarily dies along the way for a while).

Roll credits, everything is right in the world!

But Wait...

What about all of the other real little boys who didn't have a conscience or a Blue Fairy to save them? Because Pinocchio isn't the only one who ends up at Pleasure Island thanks to the coercion of the sinister coachman. Sure, they're classed as "naughty boys" (though it's a VERY broad definition if Pinocchio qualifies), but they definitely don't deserve to be turned into animals and forced to work in salt mines.

And even though Pinocchio escapes, hundreds of others don't and the Coachman is still free to go about his kidnapping business to keep the mines stocked with workers. Couldn't have Pinocchio at least told someone?


3. Diana Did Nothing About Hitler - Wonder Woman

Justice League Wonder Woman
Warner Bros.

The Happy Ending

Diana saves the world by shrugging off the offer of Ares to work with him to annihilate mankind and restore paradise on Earth and killing him with his own lightning. Sure, Steve Trevor dies, but it's a noble death and he helps convince Diana that mankind has some good in them worth saving.

The war ends and Diana retires from being a hero. Or at least she does until the 80s when she reappears to fight Cheetah in the sequel, despite it being made clear she'd been retired. It's almost like that wasn't really planned, or something.

But Wait...

If the first war to threaten mankind was enough to bring Wonder Woman out of hiding and Doomsday's appearance was enough to bring her out of retirement and Cheetah's plotting in the 80s was also enough to make her active again, why wasn't World War II?

What was it about the Nazis trying to take over the entire world and exterminating people at will that didn't qualify as a pressing enough issue for Diana to dust off her costume? And while you might say she DID help out but it was in secret, that's way too convenient considering Bruce Wayne was able to find evidence of her involvement in the First World War fairly easily and didn't mention anything else.


2. Rose's Husband Got F*cked - Titanic

Jack And Rose Titanic Staircase Kiss
FOX

The Happy Ending

Despite tragic Jack Dawson going to the bottom of the ocean as a big lump of perfectly-coiffed ice, his girlfriend Rose survives because she's selfish with her floating door and goes on to live a long life (to over the age of 100, in fact). Ultimately, she dies of old age, having passed on her story and dropped the Heart Of The Ocean into the sea for some unknown reason and is reunited with the love of her life back on the Titanic.

But Wait...

When Rose gets back to the Titanic, her name is not Rose Dawson. Her name is Rose Calvert, because she married one Mr Calvert and had two children with him. He died prior to 1996 when she visits the Akademik Mstislav Keldysh on its search for the Titanic's lost treasures.

So, she was married to a man for decades and had two children with him and he doesn't get to spend his afterlife with her? You can just see him waiting expectantly at the top of a staircase, unaware that she's already gone back to the time when she was REALLY happy with the man she met for a couple of days when she was young. That's hardly fair on him.


1. What About The Other Kids? - Labyrinth

Labyrinth Goblins
TriStar Pictures

The Happy Ending

In the end, Sarah and Toby the baby get away from the evil Jareth before his deadline that would turn the latter into a goblin forever. Sarah realises that Toby is, in fact, more important to her than her teddy bear and that she's not too grown up for her toys/friends.

Jareth is vanquished and flies away into the night in his owl form.

But Wait...

Not only is Jareth still free to continue kidnapping babies from under the not at all watchful eye of selfish babysitters who prefer their teddy bears to their infant siblings, but there are already lots of other lost children still in the Labyrinth.

Every one of Jareth's goblin army were once children taken there by the Goblin King and transformed, meaning there are probably hundreds of pairs of parents in the real world who have no idea where their children went. It's an unimaginable tragedy that just seems to get swept under the rug because the goblins appear to be happy enough.

Which other happy endings with darker implications belong on this list? Share your picks below in the comments thread.


In this post: 
Wonder-Woman
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.