10 Movie Origin Stories We Almost Got
These origin stories sadly didn't make the cut.
Moviegoers often complain that studios are far too eager to come up with origin stories for characters who, honestly, don't really need it.
This is especially true in the horror genre, where an antagonist can derive enormous power from their backstory being kept ambiguous - we all know how thoroughly Michael Myers was ruined by the Halloween sequels completely demystifying his origins.
Not all origin stories are inherently bad, of course, and sometimes they can even find greatness where fans least expected it. Yet on rare occasions, planned character backstories actually get cut during production for one reason or another.
Perhaps a visionary filmmaker insisted an origin story wasn't necessary, maybe it didn't fit with the movie's tone as it evolved through rewrites, or it was simply whittled down in the editing process due to pacing issues.
From origin stories we didn't really need to ones that almost definitely would've improved things, these 10 proposed backstories were all given the executive chop at some point in the process, ensuring they'll never see the light of day in their intended form...
10. The Joker Almost Had A Studio-Mandated Backstory - The Dark Knight
One of the defining aspects of The Dark Knight's Joker (Heath Ledger) is his ambiguous origin story, which consists entirely of the supervillain telling a few conflicting tales about how he got his grotesque facial scars.
Christopher Nolan made the smart decision to never settle on a concrete backstory for the Clown Prince of Crime, leaving fans free to speculate wildly forever more.
But this creative call did receive some worried responses from the big-wigs at Warner Bros., who felt that depriving audiences of The Joker's origins was a huge risk. Story writer David S. Goyer recently said of the internal reaction:
"I do remember when we were talking about, 'Well, what if the Joker doesn't really have an origin story?' Even after the success of Batman Begins, that was considered a very controversial thing. We got a lot of pushback. People were worried."
In the end the studio of course ceded to Nolan and Goyer's vision, but had they been a little more insistent upon a Joker prologue, the film absolutely would've featured it.
9. Godzilla Was Frozen In Ice - Godzilla (2014)
Gareth Edwards' 2014 Godzilla reboot introduced an origin story for the iconic creature in which he had lived for thousands of years, with the 1954 Bikini Atoll nuclear tests actually being an attempt by the U.S. government to kill him, setting the stage for his return in the present day.
But according to the movie's behind-the-scenes book "Godzilla: The Art of Destruction," Godzilla's origin story was initially supposed to be markedly different, with the monster instead being discovered frozen in the Siberian tundra.
This was scrapped, however, after Warner Bros. executives realised this bore a fair similarity to the Fortress of Solitude being buried in ice in Man of Steel - which was released only a year prior - and so opted to radically rework it.
The original planned story was likely the inspiration, then, for the villainous King Ghidorah being discovered encased in ice in the sequel, Godzilla: King of the Monsters.
8. The Explanation For Palpatine's Return Was Cut During Editing - Star Wars: The Rise Of Skywalker
Among the many things fans complained about in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker was the film's bizarrely casual approach to Emperor Palpatine's (Ian McDiarmid) revival as a zombie-puppet...thing.
Rather than make the basically expected effort to explain his resurrection, the film doesn't do much more than tell the audience, "He's the most eviliest magical wizard that's ever lived - deal with it!"
However, one of the film's editors, Maryann Brandon, explained shortly after release that The Rise of Skywalker's laboured editing process included ditching much of the explanation for Palpatine's revival.
"It was kind of a delicate balance and went back and forth a lot about how much we wanted to reveal. Some scenes changed quite a bit, the way that we wanted to present it to the audience. In the end, we ended up showing a lot less of it than we started with. [There was] a little more information about it, what was keeping [Palpatine] alive, but it seemed to go off topic.
There was so much information in the film and so many characters that we wanted to have an audience concentrate on. I think we felt we didn't want to clutter the film up with things you didn't need to know."
Ian McDiarmid later stated that an earlier script also confirmed Palps to be a clone, before this was cut from subsequent drafts:
"It's interesting because at one point the script had a line in that first scene with Adam [Driver] when he says 'You’re a clone.' And I said in that original script, which is no longer with us, 'More than a clone. Less than a man.' Which seemed to me to sum it up really."
7. Pennywise Eats A Baby In The 1600s - It
Though It Chapter Two did provide fans with a brief glimpse of Pennywise's (Bill Skarsgård) origins - by way of his arrival on Earth via a meteor and a fleeting depiction of his "human" form Bob Gray - a more disturbing look at the character's past was cut from the first movie.
Writer Gary Dauberman penned a flashback scene which depicted Pennywise in the early 1600s as a naked, half-formed impersonation of a human, who convinces a local woman to surrender her young child in order to avoid the entire town being feasted upon.
The scene ends with Pennywise devouring the baby while its mother is hypnotised by the deadlights. Though the sequence was actually filmed, and director Andy Muschietti hinted it would be released at some point, to date it still hasn't surfaced.
6. Broomhilda Had A "Nice" Owner Before Calvin Candie - Django Unchained
If the character of Django's (Jamie Foxx) wife Broomhilda (Kerry Washington) seems a tad underwritten in Quentin Tarantino's masterful western, that's because the part was originally much larger before being whittled down by Tarantino during rewrites.
Broomhilda's original backstory saw her first sold into slavery as the mistress of Scotty Harmony, an overweight and inexperienced yet pleasant young man intended to be played by Jonah Hill.
However, Scotty ends up losing a card game to Calvin Candie (Leonardo DiCaprio), and after an argument over Candie's suspicious in-game conduct, Candie shoots him dead, taking Broomhilda for himself in the process.
To make matters worse, Candie then strips Broomhilda naked and whips her through the streets of Greenville, dovetailing into her predicamet in the final movie itself.
This certainly would've lent some added tragic shade to Broomhilda's already horrifying story, and made her a little less of a prize than she appears in the version of the film that actually got made.
5. Cyborg's Tragic Backstory Was The "Heart" Of The Movie - Justice League
Without question the most frustratingly under-developed character in the DC Extended Universe to date is Cyborg (Ray Fisher), who after making a piecemeal cameo in Batman v Superman, was supposed to get his full coming-out party in Justice League.
But as the movie was reworked by a panicking Warner Bros. during post-production, the overwhelming majority of Cyborg's backstory filmed by Zack Snyder was cut to ensure the film met its studio-mandated two-hour runtime.
This is especially troubling as Snyder called Cyborg's arc the "heart" of the movie, which isn't at all apparent in the Joss Whedon-assisted theatrical cut.
Scenes showcasing a pre-Cyborg Victor Stone playing football, suffering his car accident, and adjusting to his new cybernetic abilities were all left on the cutting room floor, as well as the death of his father Silas (Joe Morton) mid-way through the movie, and a haunting sequence in which Victor visits the graves of his family (including himself, who is presumed dead).
Fisher has made it clear he wasn't happy with either how Cyborg turned out in the movie or how he was treated on-set by both Joss Whedon and producers, and so fingers are firmly crossed that the upcoming Snyder Cut might finally restore the emotion that was missing from the original release.
4. The Thing's Arrival On Earth - The Thing (2011)
Fans of John Carpenter's 1982 horror classic The Thing were understandably nervous when Universal announced plans to release a prequel almost three decades later.
And though hardly terrible, the prequel largely felt totally irrelevant, failing to add much to expand upon the prior movie's tantalising lore.
Yet The Thing 2011 was very much a victim of executive meddling throughout shooting and post-production, resulting in the original practical creature effects being replaced with wonky CGI, and an origin story for The Thing being ditched almost entirely.
An original, partially-filmed prologue sequence would've explained that the alien piloting the buried spaceship crashed on Earth and killed itself for reasons initially unknown, while another alien would exit the ship and allow itself to freeze to death while being assimilated by the Thing.
Part of the original ending would then see Kate (Mary Elizabeth Winstead) find the ship full of dead aliens, implying that the aliens collected the Thing as a specimen, only for it to breach containment, spread throughout the ship, and finally make its way to the ice outside, leading to what happens in the actual movie.
In the end, Universal felt that the movie's climax was becoming too complicated and so ditched the Thing's backstory, which in turn required the prologue to also be cut. Boo.
3. Jesus Christ Was An Engineer - Prometheus
Much has been written about how Prometheus changed drastically from Jon Spaihts' original script to the less-Alien-centric version rewritten by Damon Lindelof at the behest of Ridley Scott.
But one of Scott's ideas which didn't actually make it into the final shooting script made an extremely provocative declaration, that Jesus Christ himself was an Engineer who was executed due to his supernatural abilities:
"If you look at it as an 'our children are misbehaving down there' scenario, there are moments where it looks like we've gone out of control, running around with armor and skirts, which of course would be the Roman Empire. And they were given a long run. A thousand years before their disintegration actually started to happen. And you can say, 'Let's send down one more of our emissaries to see if he can stop it.' Guess what? They crucified him."
It's ironic that, despite the film disappointing many fans with its total non-explanation of the Xenomorph's origins, Scott instead gave everyone the Jesus origin story they never even asked for.
And though Prometheus itself never confirms Christ's origin story, it also does nothing to conflict with Scott's comments either.
2. Young Thanos Watches Titan Be Destroyed - Avengers: Infinity War
Despite Thanos (Josh Brolin) being described as the protagonist of Avengers: Infinity War, it's surprising how little we actually learn about his backstory by the end of the Infinity Saga.
However, Joe Russo did confirm that writers Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely did write drafts of the Infinity War script which featured the Mad Titan's origins:
"We even had a draft where you saw ten minutes of his backstory. You saw him as a child, you saw him try to convince his planet that it was doomed and recommend that they randomly kill half the population to save the planet. He gets sent to a prison off-planet and eventually watches the planet destroy itself. It is a whole other film, but sometimes that's the value in a story room, of writing that draft in the script because you go 'alright, at least I have that in my brain now.'"
Though Infinity War does make it clear that Thanos had to watch as Titan was ravaged by over-population despite his calls for a cull, it would've been incredible to see this play out for ourselves with a younger Thanos in tow.
1. Politics - Tomorrowland
Brad Bird's Tomorrowland is centered around the titular alternate dimension, which while designed as a utopian hideaway for the world's greatest minds to advance society unimpeded, has since fallen into disrepute.
It's briefly mentioned that Tomorrowland was the brainchild of an outfit called Plus Ultra, consisting of Gustave Eiffel, Jules Verne, Nikola Tesla, and Thomas Edison, though director Bird also commissioned an additional animated sequence which would further detail Tomorrowland's origins.
The gorgeous scene, which Bird eventually released on YouTube, was set to take place at the start of the movie when a young Frank Welker (George Clooney) visits the 1964 New York World's Fair and sets eyes upon Tomorrowland for the first time.
The animated short film would explain that Plus Ultra constructed Tomorrowland to be free of corporate giants attempting to exploit their inventions for mutual gain and warmongering countries using them to flex their geo-political power.
The plan was to unveil their creations to humankind 20 years after Tomorrowland's construction was completed.
When Bird realised that the short, though beautiful, killed the film's pacing, he decided to ditch it, despite being one of the most interesting aspects of the entire movie.
At least it was fully animated and completed so that fans can savour it forever more - and it makes for a pretty nifty short in its own right, too.