10 Movie Plot Twist Clues We All Ignored
We all ignored these brilliant hints at devilish movie plot twists.
There's nothing quite like a movie plot twist that just takes you totally off-guard and leaves you flabbergasted by the sheer unexpected brilliant creativity of it.
Not every great twist needs to be a huge surprise, admittedly, and some are certainly more obvious than others. Many of the neatest twists, though, foreshadow the big reveal in advance, in a way that makes revisiting the movie a real treat.
And then there are those clues left in plain sight by filmmakers and yet, for one reason or another, viewers en masse opted to ignore them.
Perhaps you assumed the giveaway was actually a mistake on the part of the directors - a continuity error or strange artistic quirk - rather than a neon-signposted indication that nothing was as it actually seemed.
Inspired by this recent Reddit thread, these 10 movie plot twist clues went largely ignored by viewers, who either missed them entirely or pawned them off as accidental gaffes.
But where genius filmmakers are concerned, almost nothing is ever accidental, as so many of these sneaky hints prove beyond any and all doubt...
10. Tyler Exits The Wrong Side Of The Crashed Car - Fight Club
Near the end of Fight Club, Tyler Durden (Brad Pitt) is driving a car with the Narrator (Edward Norton) in the passenger seat. Durden eventually relinquishes control of the wheel and, soon enough, the car veers off the road, crashes, and flips over.
When the pair exit the overturned vehicle, though, Durden emerges from the passenger door.
On an initial viewing, anyone who caught this surely brushed it off as a rare bout of sloppiness on the part of director David Fincher - a continuity error not to be given much thought.
Except, this is instead hinting at the megaton plot twist dropped about 10 minutes later, that Tyler and the Narrator are the same person - dissociated personalities existing within the same body. Tyler exits the passenger door because the two characters are one and the same.
The lesson here? Nothing David Fincher does is by accident, and he'd never make a mistake this blatant unless it was actually on purpose.
9. Eli Walks Into A Chair - The Book Of Eli
The Book of Eli may not be a great movie, but it does offer up an amusingly ridiculous climactic plot twist, that nomadic, badass protagonist Eli (Denzel Washington) is actually blind, and has incredibly managed to conceal this fact from everyone he encounters - best of all the audience.
But there are some subtle hints early on. Namely, when Eli enters a dilapidated house in the movie's first few minutes, he walks directly into a chair.
It's a brief moment that the audience might simply dismiss as a mistake that the filmmakers kept in the film for some reason - perhaps it was the best take they had? - yet given that the film otherwise establishes Eli as a dexterous, unstoppable badass, it's odd to show him being so clumsy.
But of course, there's a very real purpose to it, to hint that all is not as it seems, and as incredible as Eli's blind navigation skills are, he's also not superhuman.
8. Marcee Doesn't Disturb The Pigeons - A Beautiful Mind
In Ron Howard's Oscar-winning biopic A Beautiful Mind, John Nash (Russell Crowe) takes a trip to Princeton University and meets up with his old friend Charles (Paul Bettany), and also Charles' niece Marcee (Vivien Cardone).
Charles tells Marcee not to run too far, at which point we see her running across a field filled with pigeons. Despite her fast, frantic movements, though, the pigeons strangely don't move an inch.
You might assume that this was simply a case of the pigeons being added to the scene for ambiance in post-production, and a VFX artist getting sloppy by not having them fly away when Marcee approaches them.
But in fact, it's actually slyly foreshadowing the big twist, that Nash is suffering from schizophrenia and as a result both Charles and Marcee only exist in his imagination. The pigeons don't move because, of course, there's nobody actually running up to them.
7. Mother Is Stiff As A Corpse - Psycho
Near the end of Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho, Norman Bates (Anthony Perkins) has an argument with his mother before picking her up and taking her down from her room to the fruit cellar.
While he's moving her down the stairs, she shouts at Norman to put her down, yet it's hilariously obvious that Anthony Perkins isn't actually carrying a real person - it's very clearly a mannequin instead.
On a first viewing this seems like a gaffe on Hitchcock's part, that he framed the shot in such a way as to accidentally reveal the artifice of it, but in actual fact that's not really true at all.
At the very end of the film it's of course revealed that "Mother" has been dead for an entire decade, yet Norman has been treating her mummified corpse as though she were still very much alive ever since.
As such, it makes absolute sense that Mother seems a bit, well, brittle and stiff when he's carrying her, because she totally is.
6. Verbal's Shoe Isn't Scuffed - The Usual Suspects
The Usual Suspects boasts one of the most ingeniously executed, mind-blowing plot twists in the history of cinema, that the shadowy crime lord known as Keyser Söze is none other than Verbal Kint (Kevin Spacey) - the very criminal being interrogated by Agent Kujan (Chazz Palminteri) throughout the entire movie.
Kint walks with a limp due to his cerebral palsy, but at film's end he dramatically ditches the limp to reveal that this was simply another affected aspect of his cover.
Yet there's a very early, very subtle clue that Kint isn't actually who he says he is. In the opening minutes of the film when we first meet Kint, the camera pans up from his shoes, where we see him limping and dragging his shoes across the prison floor.
But if you slow the scene down or pause it, you can easily tell that Kint's shoe isn't remotely scuffed up, as you'd expect from somebody dragging their shoe across the floor every day of their life.
Sure, it's possible that Kint just bought a new pair of shoes, and on a first viewing you'd probably dismiss this as a lack of attention-to-detail on the part of the filmmakers, but it's actually an upfront tell that Kint's talking and acting out of his ass.
5. All The Anachronisms - The Village
M. Night Shyamalan's The Village may be seen as a disappointment by many, but its big plot twist certainly lands with flabbergasting impact regardless.
After leading viewers to believe that the movie was set in the 19th century, it's eventually revealed that the story takes place in the present day, and the village of Covington is a commune intentionally walled-off from the outside world by its well-minted elders.
Yet there are some major tells from the very start of the movie by way of its production design.
Most of the buildings we see are constructed of modern materials, such as vinyl siding, which wasn't used on American homes until around 1950, many many years before the film is allegedly set.
There are also some giveaways in the characters' "period" costumes, such as ties and other garments that wouldn't have existed until the 1970s.
But given how firmly committed the movie's marketing was to presenting The Village as a period thriller, most would surely assume these hints were actually just careless mistakes on the part of the production design and costume departments.
Say what you will about Shyamalan, but he loves to labour over small details, so there's no way he would've let these blatant anachronisms slip through the cracks. They were supposed to playfully, slyly point the audience in the right direction.
4. Adelaide Snaps Her Fingers On The Off-Beat - Us
Props to Jordan Peele for even daring to hide this hint in the first trailer for his hit horror film Us.
Early in the movie, protagonist Adelaide (Lupita Nyong'o) is in the car with her family when Luniz's "I Got 5 on It" plays over the radio, and she starts snapping her fingers along to the tune.
If you're paying attention, though, you might notice that Adelaide isn't snapping her fingers on the downbeat (two and four) as you'd expect, but rather the off-beat (one and three).
This is especially concerning given that Adelaide has a childhood background in dance, and should therefore have a keen sense of rhythm.
This turns out to be pivotal at film's end, then, when we learn that "Adelaide" has actually been her doppelganger Red all along, having swapped places with Adelaide when they were both children.
As such, that's why she snaps her fingers on the off-beat, because she's the "wrong" Adelaide - the doppelganger who is out of place, and so lacks the rhythm that the real Adelaide would have.
3. The Presence Of Flip Phones - Final Destination 5
You can't really be blamed for failing to fish out the plot twist in a Final Destination movie. After all, the twists typically amount to "they all die in the end," and they're hardly the sort of movies that audiences expect brain-melting surprises from, right?
But Final Destination 5 actually cooks up a genuinely clever rug-pull by revealing in its final moments that the movie is a prequel to the original Final Destination, with the surviving characters ultimately being killed by the first film's doomed Volée Airlines Flight 180.
It was a brilliant shock, albeit one which was signposted in one major way: technology. Keep your eyes peeled throughout the film and you won't see a single smartphone in sight: everybody's rocking flip-phones because, of course, it's actually set in the year 1999.
Flip phones had pretty much died out entirely by 2009 - two years before the film's release - and so for anyone who was paying close attention, it was either a sly indicator that some chicanery was afoot, or that the prop department lazily cut corners by recycling old props.
2. Luke Doesn't Leave Footprints On Crait - Star Wars: The Last Jedi
Star Wars: The Last Jedi climaxes with Kylo Ren (Adam Driver) and Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill) duking it out on the salt planet Crait.
But when Kylo Ren finally makes "contact" with Luke, he realises that Luke isn't actually there, having Force-projected himself from the planet Ahch-To and providing a distraction which allows the Resistance to escape.
There's one big clue, though: keep an eye on Luke's feet throughout the scene and you'll notice that his movements don't create any footprints on Crait's surface to reveal the red floor underneath, as they do whenever Kylo Ren moves.
Director Rian Johnson even makes a point of focusing on their respective foot movements in a few key shots, but at that moment first-time viewers were probably more likely to chalk it down to a technical error on Johnson's part than a genuine indication of what was to come.
1. Chuck Struggles To Un-Holster His Gun - Shutter Island
The marketing for Martin Scorsese's Shutter Island made it pretty damn clear that nothing was quite as it seemed, and long before the movie's release many guessed that there would be a plot twist related to the identity of U.S. Marshal protagonist Teddy Daniels (Leonardo DiCaprio).
What they didn't count on, though, was the bigger picture, that in addition to Daniels not being who he says he is, neither is his partner Chuck Aule (Mark Ruffalo).
As it turns out, the events of the movie are largely part of an elaborate roleplay intended to cure Daniels, real name Andrew Laeddis, of his delusions after murdering his wife (Michelle Williams).
Chuck is really Andrew's doctor, Dr. Lester Sheehan, and the proof that he's not really a U.S. Marshall is basically there during one of the film's establishing scenes.
When "Teddy" and "Chuck" first arrive on Shutter Island, they're asked to hand over their weapons by Deputy Warden McPherson (John Carroll Lynch), and promptly do so.
But Chuck first struggles to un-holster his gun for a few seconds, at which point both McPherson and Teddy stare at him with a look that seems to say, "What the hell, man?"
Yet this is obviously because Dr. Sheehan isn't used to handling a gun, and the look of exasperation on McPherson's face is probably his irritation at having to enact this farce.
But when it first happens, we as audience members likely pawn it off as a slightly eccentric character affectation for Chuck, that he's a little wet-around-the-ears, rather than an indication that he might be an imposter.