10 Movie Plot Twists That Were Hiding In Plain Sight
Sometimes, you really do miss all the signs...
Hollywood loves a good plot twist. The good guy was the bad guy all along, the bad guy was the good guy all along, or the good guy and the bad guy are both the same person inside a little boy’s daydream when he’s looking into a snow globe... you get the idea, we've seen it all.
The fun thing is being able to go back and watch a film all over again and pick up on subtle clues the filmmakers left along the way and you’re like, “Well played, fancy director person!”
But then there are times you go back and think to yourself, “Well this is rubbish! How did I fall for that?”
10. The Sixth Sense
Twist: Dr. Malcolm Crowe died at the beginning of the movie.
In 1999, M. Night Shyamalan pulled off one of the most memorable plot twists in cinema history, but all along there were clues planted throughout the film transmitting what would be the film’s big reveal in the finale. Haley Joel Osment plays a kid who can talk to dead people, and his name is Cole Sear. Wait a minute. His freaking last name is “See-er”? Okay, gonna let that one pass for now.
Bruce Willis plays Philadelphia’s top child psychologist who comes to aid Cole with what is at first thought to be a phase of antisocial behavior. After Dr. Malcolm Crowe has earned Cole’s trust, the boy reveals to him his big secret: that he has a bunch of naughty magazines under his bed. No? Okay, it’s that he can talk to dead people.
Viewers knew that from the trailer, but the big secret revealed in the final moments is that Dr. Crowe is one of the dead people who communicates with Cole, having died about a year before when he was shot by a former patient in the film’s opening scene. The clues pointing toward Dr. Crowe weigh heavily on visual cues, such as he doesn’t speak to anyone but Cole, you never see him entering or leaving rooms and he is always wearing the same outfit from the night that he died.
The plot twist of The Sixth Sense was such a cultural phenomenon that it affected the way people watched supernatural thrillers, as they were now trained to look for clues, and would end up spoiling the surprises of future films. Like that of the next entry on this list.
9. The Others
Twist: Grace and her children have been dead all along.
In The Others, Nicole Kidman plays, Grace, a widow raising two children on her own just after the end of World War II. The film is set in a mansion isolated on the countryside. Both of her children suffer from a rare disorder that makes them sensitive to sunlight, so all of the curtains have to remain shut at all times.
After Grace hires three servants to help her with the household, she begins seeing signs (such as those pesky curtains being left open), leading her to believe the house is haunted, only to find out that she, her kids, and the servants are all spirits who died in the house and are in fact the ones who are haunting it. Turns out they’ve been dead a while, they just didn’t know it, and a new family (the ones she refers to as “the others”) have moved into the house.
The reveal at the end of The Others might be less obvious for someone watching it for the first time today, but when it originally came out, it was just two years after the smash hit, The Sixth Sense, and having the exact same plot twist, audiences guessed it early into the film because the visual cues were so similar to The Sixth Sense.
8. Unbreakable
Twist: Elijah Price is the villain.
Since we’re discussing M. Night Shyamalan, let’s go ahead and delve into his follow-up to The Sixth Sense, 2000’s Unbreakable, starring Bruce Willis yet again, and Samuel L. Jackson, which has absolutely nothing to do with The Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt. Audiences expected Unbreakable to be another supernatural thriller, but Shyamalan subverted those expectations by giving them instead a low-key superhero origin story.
Willis plays David Dunn, the sole survivor of a train accident who somehow went his whole life without knowing he was indestructible, has superhuman strength, and let’s go ahead and toss in a slight mind-reading ability, cuz why not? After the accident, Dunn finds a cryptic note under his windshield wiper that alludes to his super-powers.
The note also contains the address of a comic book store. Dunn and his son go to the store and meet Elijah Price, played by Jackson, the owner of the store with a rare disorder that makes his bones brittle. Price gives Dunn a juicy, villain-esque monologue about his crackpot theory that if he is so easily breakable, then there has to be someone out there on the other end of the spectrum: someone who is unbreakable.
At the end of the film Dunn discovers that Price has been spending his small fortune from art dealing looking for real-life superhumans, going so far as causing the train crash Dunn was in, as well as many other horrific tragedies.
If it wasn’t obvious from Price’s villainous demeanor, his over-the-top hairstyle and penchant for purple suits, we are also treated to a scene at an art showing where Price’s own mother approaches Dunn and dumps a load of exposition about how the most powerful supervillains are the feeble ones who use their intellect instead of brawn to overpower the superheroes.
Just the overall zealousness of Price and actions such as leaving a note under Dunn’s windshield made him stick out as a sketchy character from the beginning, giving what was supposed to be a shocking reveal seem pretty trite. Maybe Shyamalan should have gone the extra mile and just named Bruce Willis’s character David Dunn-Dunn-Dunnnnn!!!
7. The Prestige
Twist: Borden has an identical twin brother.
Hugh Jackman and Christian Bale play Robert Angier and Alfred Borden, respectively, who worked together as apprentices for a magician, and then grow up to become rivaling magicians in turn-of-the-19thcentury London. Borden has a showstopper trick where he appears to teleport himself which Angier becomes insanely jealous of and wants to steal for himself, if only he could figure out how Borden pulls it off.
Angier is led to believe that he is using a teleportation machine invented by Nikola Tesla. Angier travels to America to meet the inventor and purchases the machine for himself, against Tesla’s warnings. The teleportation machine makes an exact copy of the object being teleported, so when Angier uses it on stage to make a copy of himself, he decides to drop the original body through a trapdoor in the stage where it falls into a tank of water and is drowned inside. Angier sees an opportunity and uses this to frame Borden for his own murder. Borden goes to jail and is executed.
Then Borden somehow shows up to Angier’s show posthumously and shoots him. This is when we discover that Borden had an identical twin brother all along and they had kept this a secret throughout their entire careers so they could someday pull off a great illusion.
Through the whole movie Borden always had a bagman or something, known as “Fallon,” who was obviously Borden wearing a disguise. Not only is the double in plain sight to the audience throughout the film, but it is also in front of Angier all along. We also get a hint from Sarah that Borden is swapping places with "Fallon" as she reveals she knows when he means it when he tells her he loves her. Some days he doesn't and it's obvious - which is clearly the days when it's not her Alfred at all.
Even as everyone insists that Borden was using a body double for the teleportation trick, Angier just can’t accept the easy answer as the truth.
6. Saw
Twist: The Jigsaw killer was in the room the entire time.
The first entry in the Saw series begins with two men waking up in a restroom room that looks like it has never been cleaned. Both men are chained to the walls. Between them is a dead man who appears to have shot himself. The body is still holding the gun, as well as a tape recorder. Using cassettes found in their pockets, the two men use the recorder to discover that they are being held by the serial killer known as Jigsaw, and one must kill the other in order to save their loved ones. They are also given a time limit of 7 hours to complete their task.
After the rollercoaster of a plot is dished out through flashbacks, offering up several red herrings, as well as gory deaths, one man does end up killing the other, but to his shock, the dead body in the middle of the floor rises up and turns out to the real Jigsaw Killer. This twist was literally in plain sight. How Jigsaw was able to trick a doctor into believing he was dead for several hours is up in the air. Man, that took some crazy effort.
Later this year a reboot will hit theaters starring Chris Rock and Samuel L. Jackson. If it opens with either Jackson or Rock laying dead on the floor, it’ll be a major disappointment.
5. Star Wars
Twist: Darth Vader is Luke Skywalker’s father.
Picture it: 1980, you’re seeing The Empire Strikes Back for the first time. When Darth Vader says those iconic words to Luke Skywalker, “No, Luke, I am your father,” your German friend can’t understand why you are so shocked. They say to you, “What? You didn’t know that?” This is because the words “darth vader” roughly translate to “dark father” in German.
Emphasis on the roughlypart. While “vater” with a “t” means “father” in German (and in Dutch “vader” with a “d” does mean “father”), the “dark” part isn’t a straight translation. “Dunkell” means “dark” (and “donker” in Dutch). But you can probably stretch this theory that “Darth Vader” means “dark father” since “darth” and “dark” are nearly homophones.
This theory has been around for decades, and some believe that George Lucas started it himself as a way of making fans believe that he had planned on the reveal of the father-son connection between the Sith Lord and the orphan Skywalker all along. So take this one as being more of a retroactive twist hiding in plain sight.
And don’t forget, in the original Star Wars, Obi-Wan Kenobi doestell Luke that Darth Vader murdered his father, Anakin Skywalker. This too was retconned in Return of the Jedi when Lucas has Kenobi conveniently come back from the dead to tell Luke he was fibbing in the first film.
4. Wonder Woman
Twist: Sir Morgan was Ares all along.
2017’s Wonder Woman sees Princess Diana leaving her isolated home, Themyscira, to venture to the frontlines of World War I to seek out who she believes is behind the Great War: None other than Ares, the god of war (not to be confused with Kratos, although that would been cool as hell).
Diana is convinced that the German General Ludendorff is Ares, but after she fights him and impales him with the Godkiller sword, this does not stop the war from continuing. The true Ares then reveals himself to be the politician, Sir Morgan, who has been pulling strings behind the scenes all along.
Ludendorff always seemed too buffoonish to be the real Ares. If he was the god of war, why would he need that drug synthesized by Doctor Poison to enhance his strength? The whole thing just didn’t seem right.
Sir Morgan on the other hand, made so much more sense. It is Sir Morgan who gives Steve Trevor and Diana funding to go after Ludendorff. Morgan must have sensed that Diana was an Amazonian (if he couldn’t just tell because he’s a god, then surely the accent gave her away).
Ares/Morgan wants Diana to get to Ludendorff and kill him with full intention of revealing himself to her so he can show her that man is inherently evil and convince her to join him or die. When you think about it, this turn makes a pretty bold statement that Ares would more likely be a politician than a soldier.
3. Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol 2
Twist: Ego is the bad guy.
In Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 2, the team are picked up by Kurt Russell’s Ego, who turns out to be Peter Quill’s missing dad. Ego then takes the Guardians to his home planet, a world which he has godlike control over because 1) He’s a god and 2) The world is actually him.
Ego tells Quill that he was in love with his mother on Earth, but he had to return to his home planet before his humanoid form deteriorated. This is why he was unable to be there for Quill growing up. The father and son form a bond and then Ego reveals his real intention: he went around the universe crossbreeding with different species until he found a true heir. Quill is the heir apparent and the only one who can help him take over the universe. Oh, and he gave his mother the cancer that killed her.
If it wasn’t obvious from the beginning that Ego was going to turn out to be evil, then it must have been by halfway through the film when no discernible big bad showed up (it sure as heck wasn’t Taserface). Ego’s status as a villain in the MCU is even hinted at in the end of the first film when Yondu refers to Quill’s dad being an “ass.” But also, the guy’s name is Ego for crying out loud.
2. Captain Marvel, Avengers: Endgame, Spider-Man: Far From Home
Twist: Nick Fury and Maria Hill were replaced by Skrulls
2019’s Captain Marvel left us wondering where the two missing Skrulls, Talos and Soren, could be hiding between the film’s 1990s setting and Endgame. Marvel didn’t keep us in suspense for very long as just under 4 months later the answer was revealed in the Spider-Man: Far from Home post-credits scene when SHIELD director Nick Fury and agent Maria Hill shape-shift into Talos and Soren.
The reason why this one was pretty obvious was because, well, the internet guessed it before it even was revealed. Fans meticulously combed over suspects and clues until they crossed everyone off the list, leaving one Nick Fury, mainly because ever since faking his own death in Captain America: The Winter Soldier, Fury had largely taken a backseat to several major events in the MCU—which was very uncharacteristic for the guy who formed the Avengers in the first place.
When Captain Marvel and Fury first meet, she asks him to tell her some obscure thing about himself that no one would ever know. He tells her that he can’t eat toast if it’s cut diagonally. This connects to a scene in Age of Ultron when Fury makes a sandwich and cuts the bread diagonally (although this is debated because it’s hard to tell, but it makes sense that the writers of Captain Marvel would have sought out something in the previous films they could use).
The telltale sign that is better than the bread thing are times when Maria Hill calls him by his first name, Nick, instead of Fury. Whenever this happens it suggests that Soren is in Hill-mode and Talos is in Fury-mode, such as their post-credits scene at the end of Infinity War. The likeliest theory is that Talos and Fury swap whenever Fury needs to go off-world or needs to be in two places at once.
1. The Dark Knight Rises
Twist: Miranda Tate is Ra’s al Ghul’s daughter.
Over-bloated as it was, The Dark Knight Rises was a pretty decent action film with some heady sociopolitical commentary. But Christopher and Jonathan Nolan just couldn’t fight that urge to stick with their brand and give us one big plot twist at the end of the film. Only this time, nobody fell for it.
When Bruce Wayne’s back is broken and he is sent into a prison inside of a pit (that is surely against some United Nations regulations), he is told the story of Ra’s al Ghul’s wife who was lowered into the pit while pregnant. Mrs. Ghul has a child inside the pit and Bruce believes this to be Bane, the big bad guy who’s currently terrorizing Gotham City. The problem with this red herring was that anyone who’s read the comics knows Ra’s has a daughter, Talia, not a son. Had Bane turned out to be Ghul’s son would have actually been a bigger twist—albeit one that surely would have angered fans.
When the big reveal came at the end that the new CEO of Wayne Enterprises and awkward one-night stand, Miranda Tate, was in fact Talia al Ghul, fans the world over turned to each other and said, “Oh yeah, we knew that already.” It cannot be expressed enough that this plot twist did not work because EVERYONE EXPECTED IT.
The internet called this practically from the day Marion Cotillard was cast. Everyone called it that Nolan’s final chapter of the trilogy would wrap back around to the Ra's al Ghul and the League of Shadows from the first film. The filmmakers and Cotillard herself kept telling the media that, no, she was a completely new character, a love interest for Bruce Wayne, but nobody bought it. It went down as the Nolans pulling an unnecessary twist.