10 Movie Sequels That Just Copied The Original

"How could the same sh*t happen to the same guy twice?"

Terminator 1 T2 Arnie
TriStar Pictures

Like the fast food industry, Hollywood believes that uniformity is key to a product’s success. They know that some people will always queue for more of the same, even though what they’re getting isn’t necessarily good for them. Popcorn movies ought really to be called “Hamburger Movies”, a uniform product that lacks any real nourishment.

It’s no coincidence that some of the highest grossing franchises of all time made their money by giving audiences the same movie over and over again, only with a different cast and locale.

Take Paranormal Activity (please), a film you wouldn’t think could lend itself to franchising. Even if you don’t include the spin-offs Tokyo Night and The Marked Ones, that’s 5 movies where people film themselves sleeping and walking down corridors.

Or how about the Spider-Man films? Are we really supposed to believe that New York is populated by mad scientists that turn into super villains at the drop of a hat, and the only person hip to their shenanigans each time is your friendly neighborhood wall-crawler?

Some sequels simply remix elements from earlier instalments – Resident Evil: Retribution, Terminator Genisys – but for the most part, screenwriters are content just to repackage the first film.

10. Die Hard 2

die hard 2
20th Century Fox

Credit where it’s due: Die Hard 2 was one of the first sequels hip to the fact that it was just recycling elements from the first movie and has fun mocking the illogicality of its storyline. From the dialogue (“How could the same sh*t happen to the same guy twice?”) to the tagline (“They say lightning never strikes twice…they were wrong!”) this is one sequel that’s in no danger of taking itself too seriously.

Given the number of recycled elements, that’s probably a good idea. Once again, the movie opens at an airport on Christmas Eve and once again John McClane stumbles across nefarious activity that threatens his wife’s safety. For good measure, the filmmakers also bring back Sergeant Al Powell and Richard Thornburg, who once again gets bested by Holly McClane.

It even has the gall to end the same way, with Mr and Mrs McClane walking away while Vaughn Monroe sings Let It Snow Let It Snow Let It Snow. Fortunately, the movie gave Bruce Willis enough box office clout to persuade the producers to abandon the formula for Die Hard With A Vengeance.


9. Scream 4

scream 4 images1
Miramax

Sequel #3 brings to mind what Bill Hicks said about The David Letterman Show – it thinks it’s edgy and hip, but it’s just as mainstream and commercial as its competitors.

We get a taste of how hip the movie thinks it is during the pre-title sequence, which tries to freshen things up by pulling the movie-within-a-movie trick not once, but twice, but that turns out to be a clever-clever false scare to distract us from the fact we’re not really seeing anything new.

When a killer stalks a bunch of cine-literate teens (again), taunting them with horror movie trivia (again), David Arquette’s cop proves such an incompetent goofball (again) that the real detecting has to be done by Neve Campbell and Courtney Cox. Again.

For all the nudge-wink self-awareness, the suspense and surprises are few, all the disposable characters wear Red Shirts and the killer’s identity is predictable. Surely it’s time that owning a Ghostface mask became illegal in Woodsboro?


8. Terminator 2: Judgment Day

Terminator 2 sarah connor linda hamilton
Studiocanal

I know, I know – everybody loves T2, James Cameron is a visionary filmmaker and criticising either is worse than laughing at the “jokes” in Terminator Genisys.

But have a think on this: the only reason Cameron returned to the well was because his previous film, The Abyss, went belly up at the box office. He needed a hit and because Arnold Schwarzenegger was the #1 action movie star in the world, reteaming with him for a sequel seemed like a no-brainer.

It’s the the same story on a $100 million budget, so instead of a human protector and a T-800, a “kinder, gentler” T-800 and a terminator made from liquid metal travel through time, which allows Cameron to show off the CG effects he developed for The Abyss. Instead of a car chase through a parking garage, there’s a truck chase through a storm drain. Instead of attempting to kill Sarah in a police station, the bad terminator tries to kill her in a mental hospital etc.

“Original” ideas such as Cyberdyne discovering Terminator technology and Sarah proposing they destroy the company were conceived for the first film – check the deleted scenes on your Terminator DVD.


7. Taken 2

Liam Neeson Taken 2
20th Century Fox

Taken 2 is the kind of sequel you make when you can’t quite believe that the original was a success, you don’t know why it worked and you don’t know how to follow it up. From the characters to the plotting, the film misses the mark often enough to make you wonder if the filmmakers were aiming for camp.

For instance, the movie once again revolves around a kidnapping, but this time it’s Liam Neeson who’s been abducted by the relatives of the bad guys from the original and he has to rely on his daughter for help. In other words, the only person who can save the day is Maggie Grace, the least convincing action heroine since Tanya Roberts in A View To A Kill.

It all ends pretty much the same way it did in the first movie, but after a repeat viewing, certain nagging doubts persist: is Neeson playing the same character or is he just limbering up for his hilarious cameo in Ted 2?


6. Hostel Part II

hostel 2 paxton.jpg
Lionsgate

Coming after The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003) and Saw (2004), Eli Roth’s Hostel arrived at just the right time to exploit the audience’s desire to see young folks being tortured and hacked up by sickos. In fact, the film was such a smash hit that Roth remade it 2 years later with female leads.

It calls itself a sequel and picks up where its predecessor left off, but after killing the sole survivor of the first film, Hostel II tells the same story with a cunning twist. Instead of 3 guys travelling to Slovakia where they encounter a pair of femme fatales, we get a story about 3 women that arrive in the region and fall afoul of 2 American men who’re there to torture and kill strangers.

The film even repeats the original’s gimmick of having a director associated with extreme cinema make a cameo appearance: in Part I, we saw Takashi Miike (Audition) as a businessman at the warehouse, so Part II gives us Ruggero Deodato (Cannibal Holocaust) as “The Italian Cannibal” who’s shown feasting on a victim’s leg.


5. Escape From L.A.

Escape From LA basketball
Paramount

Set in 1997, John Carpenter’s Escape From New York starred Kurt Russell as Snake Plissken, a war hero turned bank robber sent to rescue the President from Manhattan Island, now a maximum security prison.

Set in 2013, Escape From L.A. dispatches Plissken to Los Angeles Island, where undesirables are deported, in order to recover a doomsday device from the President’s daughter. Once again, he’s offered a full pardon if he succeeds in his mission and, once again, he’s given an injection that will kill him unless he completes his task within an allotted time.

“It’s got a lot more to it,” Carpenter said. “I think some people didn’t like it because they felt it was a remake, not a sequel. I suppose it’s the old question of whether you like Rio Bravo or El Dorado better. They’re both essentially the same movie.”

As it turned out, audiences couldn’t have cared less and the movie barely made half its $50 million production budget at the box office.


4. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Next Generation

Matthew McConaughey Texas Chainsaw
New Line Cinema

Until near the end, this 3rd sequel to Tobe Hooper’s The Texas Chainsaw Massacre plays more like a remake. The plot involves a young woman (Rene Zellwegger) whose friends are hacked up for barbecue by a family of cannibals and writer/ director Kim Henkel (who also co-wrote the original) recycles several moments from Hooper’s movie.

There’s a sledgehammer murder, a dinner party and a sequence where one family member is berated for allowing Leatherface to cut through the front door while pursuing a victim, all of which are recreated without irony. Henkel seems to know what he’s doing, too, hence the number of cameos made by actors from the original.

In the final scene, no less than three actors from the 1974 film appear. There’s John Dugan (Grandpa) as a cop, Paul Partain (Franklin) as an orderly and, billed as “Anonymous”, Marilyn Burns (Sally) as a patient on a gurney. Dugan asks Zellweger, “Do you know that girl?” and….the film ends.


3. The Hangover Part II

The Hangover 2 Stu tattoo
Warner Bros.

If ever a movie could’ve used a dose of Die Hard 2’s self-consciousness about being just another big dumb sequel, it’s The Hangover Part II, which after all was supposed to be funny. It’s too bad nobody informed the filmmakers.

As you’ll recall, Hangover I was a painfully funny movie about 3 guys who wake up after the stag party from hell to discover that they’ve lost their friend somewhere in Las Vegas. Proving that jokes become less amusing with repetition, Hangover II is a painfully unfunny movie about 3 guys who wake up after the stag party from hell to discover that they’ve lost their friend somewhere in Thailand.

Mike Tyson and Ken Jeong return, and it’s too bad somebody didn’t think to cast Bruce Willis as the tattoo artist after the cast and crew objected to Mel Gibson taking the role. Imagine the comic mileage the film could’ve gotten out of Bruce lecturing them about how to make a sequel – it’d be better than anything that made the final cut.


2. I Spit On Your Grave 2

I spit on your grave 2
Anchor Bay

Released in 2010, Steven R Monroe’s I Spit On Your Grave was a remake of Meir Zarchi’s notorious rape-revenge movie (which Kim Newman claimed was “among the most loathsome films of all time”) that toned down the suffering of its female protagonist and turned her into a cartoonish avenging angel inflicting over the top punishments on her attackers.

Released in 2013, the imaginatively titled I Spit On Your Grave 2 does something truly loathsome – it turns rape-revenge into a franchise. This time, the violence is directed against a different woman (played by Jemma Dallender), but it’s the same story all over again and relocating the action to Bulgaria doesn’t change that.

After being kidnapped, tortured and raped by some one-dimensional clowns that have “dead meat” written all over them, Dallender exacts revenge as only a woman in a movie written and directed by men could – she crushes testicles, tortures her opponents with electroshock and drowns one unfortunate in a toilet. See what I mean about loathsome?


1. Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens

Star Wars The Force Awakens Rey
Lucasfilm

The trouble with fan service is that it has no effect upon the casual viewer, who judges the film by the strength of its story. When most of the story is lifted from another movie, what point does the film have other than to make money?

Consider the similarities with A New Hope: after coming into possession of a droid programmed with sensitive information, a kid is hunted by a brutal would-be dictator who denies his humanity, wears a mask and strangles his failed subordinates. This black-garbed villain is also readying a planet-sized weapon that can destroy entire worlds, prompting our heroes to launch an attack. Towards the end of the film, he strikes down an older character who knew him before he turned to the Dark Side.

As sequels go, The Force Awakens serves its brand well, setting up the characters and conflicts for the future instalments. It’s basically a series pilot writ large, one that’s burdened by its attempts to mimic its inspiration at every turn. Taken purely on story terms, it’s so insubstantial (and predictable) that it falls apart in front of your eyes.


Watch Next


Contributor

Ian Watson is the author of 'Midnight Movie Madness', a 600+ page guide to "bad" movies from 'Reefer Madness' to 'Poultrygeist: Night of the Chicken Dead.'