10 Movie Sequels That Lost The Main Characters

Losing Jason Bourne is just careless...

Pirates Of The Caribbean
Disney

It's careless to lose track of continuity and make plotting mistakes but to lose entire main characters? That's just neglectful.

Incredibly, it does still happen, even in hugely successful films. Despite how valuable continuity is (unless you're making a X-Men or Terminator film, obviously), some sequels come along and major characters have conspicuously disappeared. Fair play to the film-makers for soldiering on without their main stars, to be honest, but it's not always the smartest move, judging by the resulting movies.

This isn't merely a case of a passing of the torch, like in the original Planet Of The Apes franchise, or a shift of focus like in Hannibal (where it shifts from Clarice to Hannibal Lecter), these movies simply left out the original main characters. And some of them suffered badly for it...

10. 2 Fast 2 Furious

2 Fast 2 Furious Paul Walker.jpg
Universal Pictures

Who Disappeared? Dom Toretto (Vin Diesel)

After the first Fast & Furious movie made $200m at the global box office, a sequel was spirited into production with John Singleton installed as director. Paul Walker returned, but he and the muscle cars were some of the only constants from the original. Even Ja Rule priced himself out of a return (and was replaced by Ludacris) and a whole new cast came in around him.

Most devastatingly for fans of gravel voices, Vin Diesel's Dom Toretto was nowhere to be seen. He was replaced by Tyrese Gibson (before he'd actually started using his surname in billing) and only appeared in a brief flashback. After just one movie, the franchise had lost one of its twin leads.

Why He Didn't Return

Diesel was actually offered $25m to return, but he wasn't interested after reading the screenplay and believing the studio were approaching it "like they did sequels in the '80s and '90s, when they would drum up a new story unrelated for the most part, and slap the same name on it" as he told Variety.

He instead opted to make The Chronicles Of Riddick, which has very little to do with predecessor Pitch Black, ironically. He's since expressed regret for turning his back on the franchise, at least initially, because he felt there's an obligation to the audience to make the films as good as possible.

At least he was drawn back eventually.


9. Speed 2

Speed 2 Cruise Control
20th Century Fox

Who Disappeared? Jack Traven (Keanu Reeves)

The first Speed did wonders for the career of Keanu Reeves - at least in terms of his action movie credentials - but when the time came for a sequel to the devilishly simple, hugely popular original, he was nowhere to be found.

Instead, Sandra Bullock's Annie Porter returned without her old boyfriend and went on a cruise with her new one, confirming that she has the worst travelling luck and if you ever see her boarding a train you're on, you should get off.

Why He Didn't Return

The sequel almost lost BOTH leads after Sandra Bullock initially pulled out, but she agreed when she was offered financing for Hope Floats in exchange for returning as Annie. And for between $11–$13 million in wages, which probably helped.

Reeves was also offered the same, but didn't like the script, was financially stable already and wasn't "ready to mentally and physically" to make another action movie after Chain Reaction. Instead, he made The Devil's Advocate and went on tour with his band, while Jason Patric stepped in as the new cop alongside Bullock.


8. Sicario 2: Soldado

Sicario 2 Soldado Benicio Del Toro
Columbia Pictures

Who Disappeared? Kate Macer (Emily Blunt)

After the first Sicario was critically acclaimed and made reasonable money at the box office, Lionsgate commissioned a sequel that was eventually described as a stand-alone spin-off, focused primarily on Benicio Del Toro's menacing character from the original. Initially, Del Toro, Josh Brolin and Emily Blunt were all confirmed to return, but by the time the film made it to screen, Blunt had dropped out of the cast.

Instead, focus shifted more to Del Toro as the main character, with Brolin still working as his CIA handler.

Why She Didn't Return

This one came down to a writing decision. Speaking to The Wrap, screenwriter Taylor Sheridan said: “Her arc was complete … I couldn’t figure out a way to write a character that would do her talent justice. Look what she went through. It was a difficult role. Here I write this lead character and then I use her as a surrogate for the audience."

Bringing her back would have made Sheridan change the character, who had represented our passivity as the audience and the impotence felt by law enforcement:

“What do you do next? She moves to some little town and becomes a sheriff and then gets kidnapped and then we have Taken? I had to tell the story that was true to this role, and I didn’t feel like I could create something with that character that would further that world that would do Emily’s character justice. That said, there could be room for [her character] somewhere else down the road.”

7. Independence Day: Resurgence

Jeff Goldblum Independence Day Resurgence
20th Century Fox

Who Disappeared? Steven Hiller (Will Smith)

Independence Day is often credited as one of the true touchstones for modern blockbuster film-making and while it gave us a revival of the disaster movie genre, it more importantly also gave us Will Smith. This was his breakout moment and while it's an ensemble cast, he is very much the heart of the piece: the young flyboy trying to save the planet and get back to his fiancee.

He's also the key to anchoring the film's tone correctly, adding a cheeky charm and some humour to what might otherwise have been fairly serious. But when the sequel came along, belatedly, his Captain Hillier had been killed off screen and Jeff Goldblum's David Levinson was the new main hero.

Why He Didn't Return

Roland Emmerich initially wanted Smith to return - obviously - but conceded defeat when he claimed Smith was just too expensive. Smith, meanwhile, said that he actually declined to return because he was busy making Suicide Squad, which is a little bit like avoiding the measles by contracting an STD.

Instead, Emmerich pushed Goldblum's role, hired Liam Hemsworth and Jessie Usher (to play Smith's son) and traded the cast quality down significantly.


6. Pirates Of The Caribbean: On Stranger Tides

Pirates of the caribbean on stranger tides jack sparrow
Walt Disney Studios

Who Disappeared? Elizabeth Swann & Will Turner (Keira Knightley & Orlando Bloom)

You could be forgiven for believing Disney's shtick that the Pirates franchise is a star vehicle for Johnny Depp's Captain Jack Sparrow, but it wasn't really to begin with. He just became more heavily featured as his popularity grew. Initially, the first trilogy was as much about Will Turner and Elizabeth Swann as it was about Sparrow - in fact, they were arguably even more important to the established lore - but when the time came for a fourth movie, they'd been dropped entirely.

Instead, Jack Sparrow became the ascended lead, with support from Barbosa, Penelope Cruz's Angelica and Sam Claflin's dull-as-dish-water Philip Swift.

Why They Didn't Return

Depp only agreed to return if he liked the script (and was given a hefty $55.5m for doing so), but both Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightley chose to sit the fourth chapter out, with both reportedly keen to go on and take different roles as they wanted new challenges.

They were replaced with spiritual copycats (Claflin's pastor and a mermaid) and everyone else simply didn't talk about them. Until the fifth film, when their desire to move away from the characters clearly waned and they came back.


5. The Bourne Legacy

Bourne Legacy
Universal Pictures

Who Disappeared? Jason Bourne (Matt Damon)

You might claim that The Bourne Legacy isn't a sequel in the same vein as the other films here, but it was initially intended to be the fourth film in the Jason Bourne series and it would have starred Matt Damon had the original plans come to fruition. But then by the time it came to the big screen, Damon was gone, Jason Bourne was nowhere to be seen (aside for his name above the door) and instead, Jeremy Renner was brought in to play brand new character Aaron Cross.

Bourne's shadow was cast over the film, as the fallout from black ops programmes Treadstone and Blackbriar is contained and everyone involved in the alternate programme creating supersoldiers like Cross is killed off. It didn't go down nearly as well as the first three films and Damon was eventually brought back for his fourth film.

Why He Didn't Return

Damon said very publicly that he wouldn't return to play Jason Bourne unless Paul Greengrass was directing and he had already bowed out. Tony Gilroy also suggested that there was no way he'd ever recast Bourne, so his stipulations on taking the directing job were that Damon wasn't to be involved at all, nor Greengrass nor Jason Bourne as a character in the interest of preserving everything that went before.

Damon still expressed his openness to playing Bourne again, but in 2010 had said they were at least 5 years away from doing so.


4. xXx: State Of The Union

XXX State Of The Union
Columbia Pictures

Who Disappeared? Xander Cage (Vin Diesel)

As well as initially turning his back on Dom Toretto (before going back on it), Vin Diesel also turned his back on another of his franchises - xXx - handing over main duties to Ice Cube, who played the delightfully named Darius Stone.

He was introduced as a bad-ass replacement to Xander Cage, who was killed off-screen, who was imprisoned for Not Playing By The Rules and whose approach to life appeared to be to growl at everything possible.

Why He Didn't Return

Both this and the Fast & Furious bail happened around the same time and both were partly influenced by The Chronicles Of Riddick. That awful film was what Diesel chose to do as his one sequel of the period and he apparently dropped out of State Of The Union - according to Variety at least - because he had no desire to shoot two sequels in a row.

So in the end, Cage was killed off in a short film called The Final Chapter: The Death of Xander Cage that was included as a DVD Extra and starred Diesel's stunt double, spliced into archive footage. That was supposed to offer closure, but they all just ignored it to bring Diesel back for the third xXx movie anyway.


3. Transformers: Age Of Extinction

Transformers Age Of Extinction
Paramount Pictures

Who Disappeared? Sam Witwicky (Shia LaBeouf)

When Michael Bay kicked off the Transformers franchise, he focused on human lead Sam Witwicky as the audience's in-point rather than just one of the robots and it worked to the tune of several billion dollars. But then when Transformers: Age Of Extinction came around, he was nowhere to be seen and everyone seemed to be on a gagging order not to mention him.

We eventually found out that he was killed off-screen in a drawn-out sequence in The Last Knight when Laura Haddock's Vivian confirms she is the last surviving Witwiccan heir to Merlin. For Age Of Extinction, he was replaced by Mark Wahlberg as Texan inventor (!!) Cade Yaeger, which is definitely not a real name.

Why He Didn't Return

Initially, LaBeouf was diplomatic about his exit saying he didn't think there was anywhere to take Sam:

"I've learned a great deal from Michael, as a person, as an actor, as a person on set. And it's not that I don't enjoy working with Michael. I love working with Michael. I would do any movie Michael wants to do. I just don't think there's anywhere to take it with Sam."

Then later, when suggesting that he no longer wanted to be famous any more (which came before he started work on his own biopic), he revealed the real reason he didn't go back:

"My hang-up with those films was that they felt irrelevant. They felt dated as f*ck ... You come up on these stories about Easy Rider and Raging Bull and De Niro and Scorsese and Hopper, and you find value in what they do. Meanwhile, you’re chasing energon crystals. It’s very hard to keep doing what you’re doing when you feel like it’s the antithesis of your purpose on this planet."

2. The Lost World: Jurassic Park

Jeff Goldblum Jurassic Park Lost World Dr Ian Malcolm
Universal Pictures

Who Disappeared? Dr Alan Grant (Sam Neill)

In the first Jurassic Park film, the hero is very much Sam Neill's Dr Alan Grant. He's the obvious Indiana Jones stand-in (right down to the attitude and the hat) and he looks ready-made for an extended franchise. But then The Lost World came along and Grant was gone, to be replaced by a more action movie iteration of Jeff Goldblum's Ian Malcolm.

Because everyone knows that mathematicians are the best people to take down dinosaurs and pull off dangerous rescue missions... Ultimately Grant returned in Jurassic Park III, but the less said about the better, to be honest.

Why He Didn't Return

It's fairly simple, really: despite Steven Spielberg making significant changes to the original novel, the one thing he did stick rigidly to is the fact that Dr Alan Grant simply doesn't appear.

It also probably helped that Jeff Goldblum was the most enthusiastic star about returning.


1. Hellboy 2: The Golden Army

Meyers Hellboy
Universal

Who Disappeared? John Myers (Rupert Evans)

In the original Hellboy, Agent John Myers is basically the audience's representative in the strange new world of monsters and mysteries uncovered by the revelation of the BPRD. His dynamic with Hellboy was also delightfully rewarding as the pair clashed over fellow agent Liz Sherman (Selma Blair).

However, when the sequel (which was initially intended to be the middle film in a trilogy) was announced, Rupert Evans wasn't included and Agent John Myers was no more.

Why He Didn't Return

Unfortunately for fans of the character, Evans couldn't return because he'd been cast in a stage version of "Kiss of the Spider Woman" in London in 2007 and had to be written out of the sequel entirely.


Watch Next


Guess The Films From These 80s Horror Movie Taglines

1980s Horror
Columbia Pictures

1. Be Afraid. Be Very Afraid.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.