10 Movie Universes That Make NO SENSE

Don't try to understand these movie universes. Just go along for the ride.

Hugh Jackman X-Men
20th Century Studios

Since the Marvel Cinematic Universe made more money than God, every major movie studio has scrambled to build as many franchises and interconnected cinematic universes as they can, because why the hell not?

The reality of course is that building an ongoing movie universe that's actually internally logical and consistent is extremely difficult.

The Marvel Cinematic Universe is basically an outlier in having an impressively firm handle on itself across almost two-dozen movies, largely thanks to the committed efforts of mega-producer Kevin Feige.

But given the enormously complicated nature of sustaining an ongoing franchise, usually incorporating the work of countless writers, directors, and producers, it becomes increasingly difficult for even the simplest movie series to maintain internal equilibrium.

And so, we come to these 10 movie universes, all of which have basically checked coherence at the door as they've gone along, for better or worse.

In unfortunate cases it's forced even hardcore fans to lose interest in the IP, while every so often a series proves itself so utterly uninterested in silly things like logic that it dares to become almost...charming?

Whether it worked or not, though, these movie universes took the fundamental laws of storytelling, physics, and time, and promptly set fire to them...

10. X-Men

X Men Apocalypse Wolverine Jean Grey
20th Century Studios

The X-Men franchise is undeniably one of the most seminal and important blockbuster IP ever made, but as it surged in popularity it also began to lose its grip on any sort of internal consistency.

The biggest issues abounded in the wake of the (admittedly terrific) X-Men: Days of Future Past, where director Bryan Singer used time travel to effectively jettison aspects of the existing continuity he didn't much care for.

But with each new prequel-sequel movie leaping forward roughly a decade in time, it became increasingly laughable to see actors like Michael Fassbender, James McAvoy, and Nicholas Hoult apparently playing people in deep middle-age.

The prevailing sentiment from the filmmakers seemed to be that the time jumps were worth ignoring the laws of ageing for, even if most fans might disagree given the middling quality of both X-Men: Apocalypse and Dark Phoenix.

This is without even getting into peripheral movies like Deadpool, Logan, and The New Mutants, none of which slot into any semblance of the continuity in a coherent way.

Though the majority of Fox's X-Men-branded movies have been relatively entertaining, the lack of consistency is majorly headache-inducing.

Hopefully the MCU might take a more measured approach when they inevitably integrate the mutants into the series in the future.


9. Cars

cars movie
Pixar

Though it's easy to watch the Cars movies and not give their wider world too much thought, upon even a superficial inspection it's tough to parse how its world exists at all.

While the universe within which the films reside contains no humans whatsoever, human influence is still clear throughout, with World War II-era vehicles even causing some fans to consider the possibility that a car version of Hitler must've existed.

Most obviously, though, is the inexplicable fact that all the cars have doors, windows, and mirrors, despite not a single human ever being seen throughout the trilogy.

The vagueness of the world's practicality has caused many to speculate that it may take place in a post-human apocalypse.

Hell, even the series' own creative director, Jay Ward, has stated his belief that humans did once exist in this universe, but were overthrown and eliminated by the sentient vehicles.

It's a fascinating idea yet ultimately too horrifying for Pixar to ever make outwardly canon, so the Cars world is stuck in an awkward state of limbo where it just...doesn't explain itself.


8. Saw

Jigsaw Tobin Bell
Lionsgate

The Saw franchise began simply enough, with terminally ill psychopath John Kramer (Tobin Bell) deciding to put those who "don't appreciate their life" through a series of creatively grisly traps to prove their fondness for existing.

But with each new sequel the mythology became both more dense and convoluted, introducing timeline shifts and dozens of new characters who, of course, were often inextricably linked to Kramer somehow.

By the time the flashback-heavy Saw V came around, the series resorted to lazy narrative retcons and ass-pulls to justify its continued existence, desperately trying to keep itself alive despite the fact that Kramer himself died all the way back in Saw III.

This reached its ridiculous apex in the most recent film, Jigsaw, where it was hilariously revealed that Kramer had yet another secret apprentice who both predated all the others and was still alive today.

Though the upcoming ninth film Spiral is touting itself as a back-to-basics soft-reboot for the series, fans would be naive to expect anything less than another muddy addition to the already nonsensical mythos.


7. James Bond

Skyfall James Bond Daniel Craig
MGM

The James Bond franchise is a shamelessly messy beast where its own internal history is concerned, and it's really best to just think of each actor's set of films as their own walled-off series of stories.

Despite that, the implication in the earlier Bond films in particular was that these movies were all a contiguous volume of adventures experienced by the same man, rather than the oft-cited fan theory that "James Bond" is actually a codename used by numerous individuals.

Notably in 1981's For Your Eyes Only, Roger Moore's 007 visits the grave of his wife Tracy, who died in the George Lazenby-starring 1969 Bond film On Her Majesty's Secret Service.

Though 2006's Casino Royale marked a hard reboot for the series as Daniel Craig took the mantle from Pierce Brosnan, this clear line of distinction was blurred by the carry-over casting of Judi Dench as M, as brilliant as she was in the Brosnan films.

All in all the series' lack of regard for the passage of time and the limitations of a single man's existence haven't hurt it one bit, so the producers have no incentive whatsoever to try and lock Bond into a concrete time and identity.


6. Terminator

Terminator Drak Fate Arnold Schwarzenegger
Paramount Pictures

Though the first two Terminator movies offered up some tantalising, philosophical questions about fate and causality - particularly the "chicken or egg?" paradox of John Connor's existence - the four sequels that followed lurched into increasingly incomprehensible territory.

Despite T2 fully elucidating the idea that Judgment Day could be averted, this clashed with the necessity for conflict that drives any movie franchise.

And so, T3 brashly contradicted this by confirming that the nuclear apocalypse was apparently inevitable (albeit with a ballsy downer ending for the ages).

Things got truly jumbled with the fifth film, Terminator Genisys, which effectively rebooted the entire franchise by reimagining the events of the earlier movies.

Furthermore, because the film never got a direct sequel, the identity of the person who sent the benevolent Terminator (Arnold Schwarzenegger) back in time to save young Sarah Connor was never explained.

And because the series hadn't abused its own continuity enough at this point, the most recent sixth film, Terminator: Dark Fate, once again rejigged the continuity, serving as a direct sequel to T2 which quickly infuriated fans by killing off John Connor (Edward Furlong). Oof.

Dark Fate's box office failure may well have finally convinced producers that the IP is just too much of a gibberish stew for even hardcore fans to care about anymore. Once you've lost them, you haven't got a hope in hell of keeping the casuals interested.

If Terminator will ever live again, it needs to start completely fresh and, painful though it might be, say farewell to Arnie.


5. Transformers

Anthony Hopkins Transformers: The Last Knight
Paramount

Michael Bay's Transformers movies are collectively a loud, excessive exercise in throwing everything at the wall and seeing what sticks.

Though it shouldn't be that difficult to make a fun kid-and-their-pet-robot movie out of the IP - as the recent Bumblebee actually proved - Bay typically funnelled his energies into glossy, chaotic Bayhem rather than anything approaching a holistic movie world.

Trying to keep track of the various technological trinkets, doodads, and MacGuffins throughout the films is a full-time job, not to ignore the ever-shifting allegiances of the various corruptible robots and a whispered-about wider world in space.

To date the series has cycled through three protagonists, randomly ditched characters both main and supporting, and attempted to hilariously shoehorn the Transformers into historical events like World War II and the Apollo 11 Moon landings, despite humanity at large somehow still not being aware of their existence.

By the time the series incorporates freaking Arthurian legend and you've got Autobots hanging out with Merlin (Stanley Tucci) and dinosaur-robots showing up, you just have to throw your hands up and say, "F**k it, why not?"

A pile of new Transformers movies are currently in development, and there's little chance any of them will manage to make much sense of this tangled storytelling web. It's probably best to not even try, honestly.


4. Star Wars

Rey Star Wars The Rise Of Skywalker
Lucasfilm

When any IP becomes sufficiently huge, it's extremely difficult - if not impossible - to juggle all the spinning plates with a real sense of consistency.

There are too many conflicting characters, power sets, and artistic visions competing for attention, and it just isn't possible for even an appointed franchise "Godfather" to ensure complete logical parity across every movie.

This is without even mentioning the wider continuity in novels, comics, video games and so on.

Though Star Wars has definitely attempted to maintain a measure of sense across its nine mainline movies in particular, the contradictions are nevertheless myriad.

Particularly frustrating is the fact that the prequels have more advanced tech than the original movies, and there's virtually no consistency to the powers of the Force, which are more-or-less deployed as befits the story.

Oh, you can bring someone back to life with the Force now, nine movies into the franchise? "No-one's ever really gone," we're told, a reminder that death doesn't really have much impact or gravitas in this universe.

Also, despite the size of the galaxy, most of the pivotal characters have excessively convenient familial links to one another.

Fans have of course strained themselves to explain away many of the series' inherent contradictions, but you're really better off just surrendering to the silliness and enjoying the Star Wars movies as a mythologically dense thrill-ride, rather than a storytelling tapestry intended to be taken literally.


3. Alien

Alien Resurrection Sigourney Weaver
Fox

Much like Terminator, the Alien franchise's first two instalments are basically water-tight, after which it becomes an increasingly incoherent slop-bucket of malformed, often conflicting ideas.

Most of the sequels and spin-offs radically altered the Xenomorph's gestation cycle for the sake of narrative efficiency, while Alien vs. Predator made the ridiculous assertion that the Xenomorphs have visited Earth since ancient times (though its canonicity is dubious at best).

Though it initially seemed like prequel Prometheus was going to bring order to the franchise by revealing the events that led to the original Alien, the introduction of both the Engineers and their black goo chemical weapon ultimately only made things even more complicated.

The means through which the proto-Xenomorph - aka the Deacon - was created were insanely convoluted. Plus, if this was apparently the progenitor of the entire Xenomorph race, then why were there drawings of the Xenomorph/Deacon on the mural earlier in the movie?

As if this all wasn't enough of a headache, Alien: Covenant decided to chicken out of explaining the Engineers' motivations for wanting to annihilate humanity, literally nuking them out of the franchise altogether and suggesting that the real creator of the traditional Xenomorph was actually android David (Michael Fassbender).

As brilliant as the first two Alien movies are, there comes a point where keeping up with the slippery non-logic of the series feels more like exhausting homework than anything.


2. The Fast & The Furious

Furious 7 Car Jump
Universal Pictures

The Fast and the Furious is one of the few franchises on this list to not only get away with making very little sense, but arguably benefitting from and even revelling in it.

It remains extremely difficult to reconcile that the original movie - a comparatively "realistic" heist film about a gang of petrolheads stealing VCRs - exists within the same tangible reality as F9, which includes giant magnets and rocket-powered cars apparently capable of flying to space.

The franchise is nothing if not an exercise in glorious escalation, gradually mutating itself into an increasingly silly tentpole IP focused less on urban grit and more on death-defying, CGI-assisted stunts.

The laws of physics are abandoned whenever necessary, where characters can fly through the air and land on top of a car without so much as cracking a rib.

Even the series' painfully earnest emotional throughline is ridiculous - the Family accepts Deckard Shaw (Jason Statham), who they believed to have killed one of their own, into the fold without many qualms at all.

Really the only vaguely authentic aspect of the series is the dynamic between the central characters, which is basically the crutch propping up the wilfully loony storytelling and action.

Again the series totally gets away with it because it's never trying to be anything more than bonkers fun, because if you actually tried to explain the A-to-Z logic of the narrative and physics on offer, you'd go cross-eyed.


1. Mad Max

Mad max Fury Road Tom Hardy
Warner Bros. Pictures

The Mad Max movies are a strange bunch, because while they all boast incredible world-building and unforgettable characters, every film also feels like it exists within its own pocket of reality, no matter that protagonist Max Rockatansky (Mel Gibson/Tom Hardy) superficially appears to be the same character throughout.

The central conflict in each movie becomes increasingly heightened, from the more personal revenge narrative of the original to the epic battle over resources in the sequels, each film leaving a large chasm of Max's journey untold between movies.

This is of course because the Mad Max plots are better thought of as fireplace myths rather than literal stories, with the second and third movies even including narrators who speak of the wandering legend known as Max.

Watching the movies through this lens makes it far easier to accept the almost-dreamlike logic across the series, whether it's actors appearing in new roles without any explanation or how utterly different the Fury Road Max feels from Gibson's version, far beyond the re-casting.

The Road Warrior is basically an avatar for drifter heroes rather than a single, specific person, because if you try to view the films as residing within a strict chronology, they really don't make any sense at all.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.