10 Movies That Should Have Been Horror

Is there really that much difference between Carrie and Matilda?

Contagion Matt Damon
Warner Bros.

In order for a movie to gain entry to the horror genre, it has to pass a certain set of requirements.

The film has to invoke a feeling of fear through either scaring or repulsing an audience through heavy subject material or gruesome sights. It has to push the boundaries on what would traditionally be acceptable to show on screen. A sombre ending is usually on the cards, and there should always be an unknown or unexplainable sensation conveyed throughout the film.

And being a horror movie certainly has plenty of pros from a creative aspect: namely the fact that a horror movie is completely unchained when it comes to what it can show, and the punch it can carry is arguably unlike anything else in the world of film.

Whether it be through capitalising on the scares that were already in place, or really letting go of the brakes and taking the overall potential down a new direction, there are plenty of films that have an abundance of horror aspects already to them, without necessarily being in the genre itself.

With that in mind, here are some films that surely would have benefitted by taking things further down these routes and investing more into the horror.

10. Room

Room Movie
A24 Films

Released in 2015, Room is an independent movie directed by Lenny Abrahamson and based around a 2010 novel of the same name.

Starring Brie Larson and Jacob Trembley, the film revolves around a mother named Joy and her son Jack who have spent seven years living in captivity confined to just one small room. Their captor is a man named Nick, Joy's ex-partner and Jack's biological father, who routinely beats and abuses the mother and son.

The pair eventually escape their captor in a wonderfully thrilling action sequence, and the film's second act follows the two of them adjusting to life back in the real world. However, the film focuses more on the themes of coming of age and the love between a mother and her son, rather than being an outright dark crime story and ultimately ends on a reasonably positive position for the pair.

Room's dark premise is plucked straight from a nightmare and could have very easily lead to one of the darkest horror movies of the year being released.

Upping the amount of graphic material on show and altering a couple of scenes to help with a more sombre tone would have been fairly easy, and could have really helped bring out the true nightmare feel of the film's story.


9. Contagion

Contagion Lockdown
Warner Bros.

Featuring a star-studded cast ranging from the likes of Matt Damon, Kate Winslet and Laurence Fishburne, Contagion is a science fiction thriller released back in 2011.

In the wake of various medical pandemics around the world, director Steven Soderbergh and writer Scott Burns were inspired to produce a film that revolved around a viral infection spreading across the world, and humanity's response to such a threat.

The film features the Soderbergh-staple method of shooting from multiple perspectives and focusing each story on a different theme. Matt Damon's character Mitch is the 'normal everyday man' that shows off how society can break down in times of crisis, whilst Fishburne's character of Dr. Ellis Cheever is the embodiment of the research and scientific responses to such a disaster, for example.

Being released nearly a decade ago now, Contagion was written and filmed just before the wave of dystopian horror movies began sweeping across the world. It's easy to imagine a film like Contagion throwing in some biological body horror to really ramp things up to the next level.

Praise has already been thrown to the filmmakers for preparing a movie so committed to scientific accuracy, so really going out of their way to showcase the effects of such a virus could have made Contagion one of the go-tos for a terrifying look at an alternate reality.


8. 127 Hours

127 Hours movie
Searchlight Pictures

Written and directed by Danny Boyle and starring James Franco as canyoneer Aron Ralston, 127 Hours already has a storyline that revolves around a real nightmare scenario going for it. Based off a real story involving Ralston, the film revolves around the canyoneer being trapped between two boulders and his subsequent battle for survival.

With his right arm pinned behind a boulder, Aron begins rationing out his food, water and supplies and begins recording a video diary to try and help keep himself staying sane. After six days, he musters up the drive to break and then amputate his arm and slide himself to freedom. It's a remarkable story, a real example of the human will to survive against all costs and makes for a thrilling watch.

However, as ever with something as gruesome as an amputation serving as a key plot point, there's the possibility of taking things up a gear and bringing out the true horror of the situation a little more.

Not only could they easily throw in a little more body horror by showing all the ins and outs of Aron's amputation, there's also every chance of playing around with the torment and depression the canyoneer experiences through all his flashbacks and hallucinations whilst trapped that could have made for an even more shocking experience.


7. Labyrinth

David Bowie Jareth Labyrinth
TriStar Pictures

As well as being one of the definitive classic movies of the 80s generation, and the embodiment of Bowie's undeniable charm and charisma, Labyrinth is the kind of film with visuals and a story that would never pass as a lighthearted fantasy release these days.

Revolving around the legend of the Labyrinth, the film follows sixteen year old Sarah Williams traversing through the strange world of Jareth the Goblin King with all of his minions and snazzy tunes in the search for her baby brother.

The puppetry and striking visuals haven't aged the best and have a certain terror that could have them pass within a budget horror movie, but the plot of a strange man kidnapping children wouldn't need much work to land an age rating.

Even the more subtly hidden themes about coming of age and Sarah's growing from a young girl to a woman have been some of the most powerfully hit in the world of horror over the years. Not that it ever should, but if Labyrinth ever found itself in the works for a remake, it would probably swing much closer to the horror genre than anything else.


6. Buried

Buried Ending
Lionsgate

Another film with a hellish premise to work through, Buried is a 2010 Spanish film starring Ryan Reynolds, written by Chris Sparling and directed by Rodrigo Cortes. The film follows truck driver and veteran Paul Conroy who, after being attacked one day, wakes up to find himself buried alive in a wooden coffin with just a handful of materials to survive.

Claustrophobic and intense throughout, this thriller has all the potential to stand as a terrifying horror flick with just a couple of tweaks. Tight dark spaces have been a staple of the horror genre for countless years, and the ordeals Conroy is put through, both physically and mentally, in his battle for survival is something a script with a more graphic direction could have really hammered home.

On top of that, Buried's hopeless ending is the kind of sombre end note one would usually reserve for the world of horror.

Horror movies have also garnered a reputation for being the best at making the most out of a simple premise, and Buried can hardly make things any more simple during the course of its runtime.


5. Willy Wonka And The Chocolate Factory

Willy Wonka And The Chocolate Factory
Paramount Pictures

At its core, Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory is a story about a deranged old man housing an exotic group of unpaid workers, who goes out of his way to revel in throwing various children into his strange machines and contraptions.

The 1971 film directed by Mel Stuart and starring Gene Wilder as Wonka may have been nominated for Academy Awards and Golden Globes and become a real cult classic that most people know most of the words to, but its slightly shady premise is quite hard to look past when an audience actually stops to think about it.

Then there's the fact that the film itself seems to begin question whether it actually wants to be a harmless child-friendly release or not during its runtime. Wilder's performance might be iconic to many, but his portrayal of a man whose emotions swing dangerously around the place have been put under the microscope plenty of times over the years.

Throw on top questionable scenes such as the infamous trip down the chocolate river, which crew members and the actors on set genuinely took as Wilder going insane, and there's an argument to say that Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory is already well on its way to becoming a classic horror flick.


4. Matilda

Matilda Ending
TriStar Pictures

Another one of those cult classic films based on a Roald Dahl story that seems a little bit more sinister when it comes to revisiting it, Matilda is a 1996 film starring Mara Wilson and directed and produced by Danny DeVito.

Matilda is a genius of a child who is constantly neglected and emotionally abused by her parents and her school's headmistress, Miss Trunchbull. She has a remarkable gift of telekinetic powers which she eventually uses to overcome those holding her back and bags herself a happily ever after ending.

However, buried in amongst this fairytale story, is the illegal Wormwood car sales, Miss Trunchbull's horrific teaching practices, punishment rooms and the surprisingly heavy subplot of her being the head suspect of a possible murder charge.

It's also hard to ignore the possible Carrie-vibes present in Matilda, with both films focused on a slightly traumatised young girl discovering their telekinetic powers when pushed too far.

With the foundations already set in place, it would have been very easy to rewrite Matilda's ending in a way that saw this gifted girl running riot across the school playground causing havoc, rather than happily walking away with her new adopted mother.


3. Oldboy

Oldboy Long Take
Show East

Based on a classic Manga comic, Oldboy is a 2003 South Korean neo-noir thriller directed by Park Chan-wook and starring Choi Min-sik. The film won the Grand Prix at the 2004 Cannes Film Festival and has since been acclaimed for its gritty action sequences and themes set around revenge and vengence.

Oldboy follows the story of Oh Dae-su, a businessman who is kidnapped one night and held captive for fifteen years. He is released and begins a quest to hunt down the man responsible for his captivity, all while trying to work out exactly what the motivations behind him might be.

There are shocks and revelations hidden around every scene, and the film is stacked full of gruesome imagery that packs a real punch for those watching. It might not be everyone's cup of tea, but it sure is one of the most original films to have been released over the past twenty years.

With so many heavy things revealed, so many gory sights and plenty of violent action set pieces, it's easy to see Oldboy slotting alongside some of the other bloody horror flicks that were becoming popular in the early 2000s.


2. Jurassic Park

jurassic park
Universal Pictures

One of the undeniable greats of movie history, Jurassic Park is a 1993 timeless classic that already blurs the lines between action, adventure and outright horror.

The film follows John Hammond, the eccentric owner of an island just off the coast of Costa Rica who has found a way of recreating and breeding dinosaurs in the hopes of opening a theme park. When his investors begin to get itchy feet following the death of a worker, he recruits a range of specialists to help get the green light on the park.

Naturally things go array quite quickly upon arriving at the park, and the characters are forced to evade all manner of prehistoric predators before escaping the island.

The visuals are spectacular, the acting is superb and the wonder of seeing dinosaurs rampaging around is unquestionable, however there's no denying how brilliant it would have been had Jurassic Park gone down the horror route a little more.

Most of the dinosaurs' kills are naturally obscured or take place off screen entirely, save for arguably the best sequence in the film involving Donald Gennaro and a toilet, so seeing these unrestricted would have really sold the terror of the entire situation much more and left a far greater impression for audiences to take away with them.


1. Parasite

Parasite movie
Neon

Undoubtedly one of the best films released in the past decade, Parasite is a 2019 film directed by Bong Joon-ho and follows the poor Kim family. As a way of earning more money and tasting a bit more of the good life, the family pose as unrelated, but decently qualified, workers for the wealthy Park household.

Blurring the lines between atmospheric tension, suspense and an outright black comedy, Parasite is a film that revels in messing with the audience's minds. So many nods and hints are layered in throughout, and the cinematography does a great job in selling enough fakes in each scene that helps keep a viewer's attention away from what is right in front of them.

It also has some of the heaviest revelations and surprisingly bloody moments before its curtain closes. Whilst these heavy themes and slasher-like moments aren't exactly the point of the film, it's easy to imagine them taking up more of the stage and being given more of the limelight in an outright horror flick.

Parasite is undoubtedly a mastery in cinematography and suspense, but with a more horror-focused perspective on the secrets and truly sinister moments unearthed as its runtime goes on, it could have easily been propelled to a legendary level.


Watch Next


Horror Movie Quiz: Who Directed These Classic Films?

Insidious (2010) Film
Alliance Films

1. Insidious (2010)

Contributor
Contributor

Horror fan, gamer, all round subpar content creator. Strongly believes that Toad is the real hero of the Mario universe, and that we've probably had enough Batman origin stories.