10 Movies That Are Way Scarier Than You Think

The Craft In 10th grade, I got to take what is possibly still my favorite class of all time: an elective on writing horror, science-fiction and mystery. Every year, I look for a genuinely scary movie to add to my list of favorites. I have a demonological book club with a friend just so we can have an excuse to read too much into The Exorcist. But that's my usual thing. I'm not here to steer you towards Nightmare on 13th Street, Jason vs. Jamie Lee Curtis, The Heretic. I won't tell you which book you should read next. What I am here to discuss is a list of 10 movies that are scary for non-traditional reasons. This is part satire and part acknowledgment of Hollywood scare tactics. Feel free to add your own to the list as usual. And these are in no particular order. Happy Halloween, everyone!

10. The Possession (2012)

The Possession As I said in the intro, I love possession. I think the idea of a person being forced into literal submission by an invading spirit is one of the scariest things I can think of. I stumbled across The Exorcist one night when I was home alone in a house that was haunted and while I couldn't sleep for the next day and a half, I loved it. I own The Exorcism of Emily Rose because I love the psychology of that movie. The Possession seems at first to be Judaism's answer to The Exorcist. Girl with sucky home life starts messing with things she shouldn't oughta, girl displays mysterious behaviours, girl turns out to be possessed, girl requires an exorcism, etc. I do like the idea of the dybbuk, a dislocated spirit. So naturally, we're going to expect the climactic exorcism scene. William Peter Blatty's film version of this is an acting masterpiece, whether you believe in Christianity or not. This decade's answer to The Exorcist lays out that if you have a Hasidic in a hoodie, you can get him to yell the name of the demon until low-budget Gollum is cast out in a way that reminds me of Ghostbusters. While Father Karras had to rule out psychiatric explanations and seek permission from the archbishop... hoodieman seems to do it because, well, better nip it in the bud and we've got nothing else to do on a Saturday. I'm sorry, but I'm pretty sure that the practice of Judaism is a lot more profound than that. No, seriously, I have a lot more respect for Jewish doctrine and ritual than the screenwriters did. But no, that's not what makes this movie scary. I remember reading in that 10th-grade class a great article called "In Pursuit of Pure Horror." In it, they rounded up some of the great horror writers of the day, including the guy who wrote the book Psycho, and had them talk about how to inspire fear in the modern audience. Their idea was that Edgar Allen Poe might not get a rise out of modern readers because we're not scared of that stuff any more due to suspicion and not being so afraid for our immortal souls. They reworked "The Telltale Heart" based on contemporary fear of mental illnesses and disease and things like that. So, let's say that these people were trying to do that with The Exorcist. In this movie, the scary things are as follow: 1) The girl is anti-social. That means she will eventually come to school and kill 32 of her classmates. 2) The girl is found pigging out. She's not only going to kill everyone, she's going to have an eating disorder on top of it. 3) The girl lashes out at her bully. We've known since Carrie that self-defense means killing everyone on prom night and not allowing teachers to carry guns means that she'll come to school and kill 32 of her classmates. 4) The girl causes an infestation of insects just by opening her mouth. Admit it, we're all scared of needing an exterminator. Plus there is a certain amount of scariness to having the poor-man's Gollum forcing you to terrorise your psychiatrist with bad dentistry. I'm so scared of this movie that I'm putting in my living will that in case of demonic possession, I want William Peter Blatty to write my exorcism.

9. The Bad Seed (1956)

Badseed I know several people who associate blonde hair with a long-standing creep factor and it's because of Children of the Corn. Neither that nor Spike on Buffy the Vampire Slayer holds the blame for why blondies are creepy. No, I place the blame in the hands of the people who adapted the book into the play and the play into the movie The Bad Seed. This is a dystopian era where kids had penmanship contests and went on school picnics and had names like Rhoda and Claude. This movie would have never flown in modern times because Rhoda, the psychotic little granddaughter of a serial killer, would have been labeled with whatever disorder got her a prescription for something to make her more socially typical. This movie, though, scares the spit out of me for a different reason. I have friends whose kids make a disaster area of my house because any time they are naughty, the parents snicker at how boisterous they are and take a hands-off approach to discipline. I volunteered as a choreographer/director for a summer theatre group a couple of years ago and walked into the dressing room one day to find a 12-year-old stealing my iPod touch because "Well, I saw it and it seemed like no one else would want it." This was the same 12-year-old who lived in a mansion. In Harry Potter, we see these kinds of characters turn into Dursleys and Malfoys and they're the most annoying, if not villainous, of characters. So, we take this laissez-faire attitude towards parenting, take it back a couple of generations and we get back to Rhoda and her mother, Christine. Rhoda beats a rival to death with her tap shoes at a school picnic. She sets the janitor on fire when he makes fun of her. She confesses to having murdered a neighbor in Wichita. Yeah. This girl takes what is not necessarily always a bad parenting style and shows that our worst fears are true. What is cool about this horror is that she is unstoppable. No, seriously, she's the Energizer bunny of bratty little kid. Even her mother trying to kill her off with sleeping pills doesn't work, but by golly, the hand of God smiting her with lightning finally does. For further reference, see Macaulay Culkin's nauseating attempt to imitate this in The Good Son.

8. Thirteen Days (2000)

Thirteen Days I am a history nerd and I am even more intrigued by periods of history with which I am not very familiar. I like men in uniform, but they usually have to be in blue or grey. The Kennedy era was for my parents, not me, and my US History class only made it as far as the second World War. Thirteen Days is the story of the Cuban missile crisis, starring Star Trek's Captain Pike, Rex van de Kamp from Desperate Housewives and, heaven help us, Kevin Costner. No, Kevin's not the scary thing about this movie. He actually does a really good job in this movie. The movie is worth the thrill because it's an unnerving plot line that belongs in Tom Clancy novels, but was actually American history. You wouldn't think that you could be on the edge of your seat with the lack of technology, but no matter how much you know about the crisis, there's a wonderful amount of tension. The best parts of the movie are, for me, when Kevin Costner walks past a line of people wrapped around a city block waiting for confession and when he is waiting for Bobby Kennedy to finish negotiations with a Russian ambassador. The one unconventionally scary thing about this movie is that Waterworld's star, the man who has fewer facial expressions than Kristen Stewart, gives a great performance. Surrealism is always scary. Note: For an even more incredible political thriller, see Seven Days in May. You'd swear it was written by Clancy, but it was an attempted political coup penned twenty years too early for that. And it's scarier than anything the Russians could come up with.

7. Fever Pitch (2005)

Feverpitch11 It's a story of a boy meets girl, boy falls for girl, boy practically cheats on girl by being in love with someone else (in this case, Johnny Damon and David Ortiz), and both overcoming obstacles by going nuts for the 2004 Boston Red Sox. This is another case of "Yes, we know how it ended, but that's not the point!" (or at least, I hope you know how it ended - I'm finishing off this article during Game 6 of this year's World Series). Fever Pitch is the kind of movie that appeals to my roommate because she loves baseball movies about underdogs. It's the kind of movie that appeals to my family because we get to relive the triumph of our home team without having to stop for commercials and watch post-game analysis. We even watched it in a nearly-empty theatre in Salt Lake City where no one else sang along with "Sweet Caroline" and chanted the cheers during the game scenes. It's a scary story to live through on the Red Sox side. If you don't know why yet, go watch the movie and you'll see why. It's so uncertain how the whole thing will go down that the filmmakers actually had to change the ending when the Red Sox had the greatest comeback in baseball history. What worries me is how much I see of myself in the person who is initially deemed hopeless because of how obsessed he is with baseball.

6. Harry Potter And The Order of the Phoenix (2007)

harry potter order of the phoenix With the Cullen-killing, dragon-facing, Voldemort-resurrecting Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire just past, you would think that there was something of a break in store. After all, after Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets came Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, where Harry won Quidditch, got the Marauder's Map, regained his godfather and started standing up to the Dursleys. But no, even with the hilarity of Quidditch, the fantastic new characters of Tonks and Luna and the semi-snicker-worthy subplot of Grawp, Book 5 is a nightmare. No, seriously, every time that Harry falls asleep, things go downhill. This storyline leads to the moment when Voldemort possesses him minutes after Harry watches Sirius murdered. I initially hated this entire book before I read it because a friend of mine blurted out the ending one month before I could come home from missionary service and read the book. I had to open the book, read Sirius' death and go back to read the rest of the book. But what makes this movie/book so horrific is the character played by Imelda Staunton. Stephen King called Umbridge "the greatest make-believe villain to come along since Hannibal Lecter." It's not just her hideous collections of pink cardigans or her obsession with technicolor kitties. It's not her kindergarten-teacher delivery of a speech on governmental control that belongs at a Nuremberg rally. No, it's her never-ending quest to be evil for the world's own good. She wants to protect the children from the nasty liars who say the Dark Lord has returned. She censors the rebels by making them draw their own blood. She is only stopped from using the Cruciatus Curse on Dumbledore's Army members by a stroke of genius from Hermione Granger. She is a high-ranking bully with a well-equipped arsenal. I spent some time in high school being punished for telling the truth and spent three summer camp sessions being corporeally punished by my violin teacher for doing things wrong. I hate and fear her. I'm not-very-secretly glad she has PTSD triggered by the sound of hooves...

5. The Craft (1996)

The Craft I'm old enough that I remember some of my favorite VHS tapes. More importantly, I remember my favorite taped-off-TV VHS tapes. Top of the list is Star Wars with most of the final battle missing, but full of '80s commercial breaks that my parents forgot to turn off. Next in line is The Craft, a movie that my older and awesomer sister recorded. I watched it while my parents were out of the house because I was 15 and it was R-rated and they would never approve. 15-year-old me was pretty much blown away. 32-year-old me still laughs at 15-year-old me for various reasons. Yes, it's a movie that co-stars a real Wiccan with one of the greatest names of all-time - Fairuza Balk. Yes, it shows that bullying victims can get back at their tormentors over a decade before Harry Potter came on the scene. Yes, it even has a suicidal girl. What does this cautionary tale tell us, though? 1) You can think Goth girls are slutty. They are. 2) You can think Wiccans are slutty. They are. 3) Girl-on-girl bullying is hot, especially between blood sisters. Yeah, I'm very much over the thrill I got in 10th grade because I'm scared that all of the above might be true.

4. The Blair Witch Project (1999)

Blair Witch Project Speaking of things that we are so over, this was found-footage-revolutionary back in the day. Remember that this was years before Paranormal Activity supposedly rocked our world. It was a terrifying-run-through-the-woods before Cabin in the Woods and before the remake of The Last House on the Left. It was evil long-lasting before The Last Possession joined the lazy storytelling hordes blaming everything on Satanist grandmothers. The premise was okay. No one hates an in-over-their-head set of characters at the beginning. Yes, we all hoped they'd die horrible deaths, but we hoped they'd solve a mystery and at least one person would make it out alive. Let's start with something I just said a few words ago. We hoped they would solve a mystery. You never want to have more mysteries than you have cast members. There were the freaky signs of witchcraft in the woods that were in a tightening circle around the moronic filmmakers. There was the person who disappeared with a bodily organ the only hint that he might have already died. There was the serial killer whose reign of terror was an urban legend. There was the Blair Witch herself, who is never actually seen but feared pretty universally. Do any of these mysteries get solved? Well, yeah, we see a dead guy held hostage in the style of the serial killer. So we know the serial killer is somehow true. We think. Maybe? What's that, you say? This is about the Blair Witch? Oh, yeah... well... um... The scary thing about this movie is that the cult popularity netted the idiots in charge $10,931 for every dollar they spent. If only we could unleash them on cancer research fund-raising.

3. The Day After Tomorrow (2004)

Day After Tomorrow Horror movies are all about one phrase: "OH GOD, OH GOD, WE'RE ALL GOING TO DIE." Nothing quite brings that home quite so much as natural disaster movies. We've got Twister, The Perfect Storm, even Sharknado to a certain degree. So what's so special about about The Day After Tomorrow?This will be my shortest entry, because it has to be seen to be believed. I've known since Al Gore's An Inconvenient Truth that people would try to politicise global warming. This movie manages to show that the world is going to freeze over and people will die in droves... and it's all the Republicans' fault.I straddle the line between liberal conservative and conservative liberal and this is the movie that reminded me of why I do so. If you can't find a better villain than the GOP, please stop trying to write.

2. The Haunting of Sarah Hardy (1989)

Sarah Harding This is one of the first scary movies I ever saw. I term it a scary movie because even now, ghosts freak me out. But even more than The Craft, this movie strains the credulity of me having ever been frightened of it. Sarah York, as an already-traumatised 11-year-old, sees her mother commit suicide by drowning on the day of her father's funeral. Fifteen years later, she starts hearing her mother's voice, seeing her mother move out of the corner of her eye, etc. She fakes her own death, her husband dies, there's a cliffhanger that I won't go into now because you have to watch and laugh on your own. I only got to see it because they used my house to film part of the movie. Any time Sarah sees the psychiatrist, she's sitting in my dad's home office. The housekeeper makes sinister phone calls from my kitchen table. You can even see a Valentine's Day card addressed to Richard, which is not the name of the psychiatrist, in one shot. This is terrifying in its idea of what was scary back then. It's a movie that would never work in a world with cell phones. I think I have permanent trauma because the ghost's theme music is played badly on a harpsichord; years later, I still hate harpsichords. I also think that anyone who was creeped out by Bill Clinton saw this movie because all of the illicit sex scenes are heralded by saxophone music. And there are perms everywhere.

1. Wait Until Dark (1967)

Coming in at #1 is the movie that I saw two years after my first scary movie. This one I like to use on dates and Halloween and any time I need a really good jump. I once went on a triple date with two girls who had seen the movie and three guys who hadn't and we got our thrills from how well they imitated sopranos at the end. Audrey Hepburn plays a blind woman whose husband accidentally brings back a doll stuffed with heroin from Canada. He's at work when the drug dealers come to try and retrieve the doll, first by tricking her into revealing its whereabouts and then terrorising her into giving it to them. I have three letters for you: A. D. A. The American with Disabilities Act should have been all over the plot of this movie. It's bad enough that they're going for the defenceless woman, but the defenceless woman is blind. Surely someone could have stopped this from becoming artistic filmmaking. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

That's Kaki pronounced like the pants, thank you very much, my family nickname and writing name. I am a Red Sox-loving, Doctor Who-quoting, Shaara-reading walking string quartet of a Mormon writer from Boston. I currently work 40 hours at a stressful desk job with a salary that lets me pick up and travel to places like Ireland or Philadelphia. I have no husband or kids, but I have five nephews to keep me entertained. When not writing, working or eating too much Indian food, I'm always looking for something new to learn, whether it's French or family history.