10 Movies Where Evil Won
Forget it Jake, it's Chinatown.
It's fair to say that most Hollywood movies follow a pretty strict structure - the hero faces a problem, they venture off on a quest to fix said problem, they battle the villain and triumph. The End.
But of course, not every film dares to follow quite that precise formula, and sometimes we'll roll credits with the antagonist coming out on top.
This typically skews towards villains who are a little more morally ambiguous in their behaviours, and perhaps have a genuinely compelling reason to be doing what they're doing.
But every so often, pure evil wins out.
It takes a little something extra for a movie antagonist to truly qualify as actual evil, because even some of the most heinous actions committed by classic cinema villains can be qualified through some measure of conflict on their own part.
These 10 villains, however, represent evil in the purest sense. From hellish supernatural forces to demented serial killers, tyrannical space terrorists and good 'ol fashioned human trash, these entities weren't merely the worst of the worst - they also won, too.
Audiences were largely left slack-jawed by the bold decision to have such pervasive villainy prevail so decisively in these movies, and in each case the filmmakers certainly made the right call not to serve up a happy Hollywood ending...
10. Drag Me To Hell
Let's kick things off with a movie featuring literal, supernatural evil, in Sam Raimi's masterful 2009 horror-comedy Drag Me to Hell.
The plot revolves around bank loan officer Christine (Alison Lohman), who denies a loan to a European "gypsy" woman, who in turn places a curse on Christine's jacket button (and as a result, her also).
Over the days that follow, Christine is tormented by a demonic entity which plans to drag Christine to Hell after subjecting her to three days of torture.
After making numerous attempts to shift the curse - including sacrificing her dear cat - she believes she's finally passed it on by burying the cursed button with the corpse of the recently deceased gypsy woman.
But as Christine meets her boyfriend Clay (Justin Long) at a train station in the film's final scene, he reveals that she buried the wrong envelope, at which point demonic hands emerge beneath the train tracks and, yes, drag her straight to Hell as Clay watches on in disbelief.
Given the reasonable expectation from most audiences that Christine would find a way to beat the curse and live a happy life at the end, it came as a genuine surprise that Raimi went ahead and ensured his film fully lived up to its awesome title.
It's still a shocker, but still an extremely satisfying victory for evil. And to think, it was all over a bloody bank loan.
9. Se7en
Serial killer John Doe (Kevin Spacey) may be only a human manifestation of evil - and moreover, he dies at the end - but that does little to dilute the ugliness of his heinous actions throughout David Fincher's superbly grimy thriller.
Doe crafts an elaborate and thoroughly revolting plan to highlight the worst of humanity by theming his kills off the seven deadly sins - a man is forced to eat until his stomach ruptures (gluttony), a pound of flesh is ripped from a lawyer (greed), a model commits suicide after having her face disfigured (pride) and so on.
But Doe saves the best for last, with the final two sins coming ferociously full circle. The sixth sin, envy, is Doe's own to bear, harbouring jealousy over Detective Mills' (Brad Pitt) family life and murdering his pregnant wife (Gwyneth Paltrow) as a result.
As Mills is delivered a box containing his wife's decapitated head, he's able to contain his anger for just a few scant moments before shooting Doe dead, fulfilling the seventh and final sin - wrath.
Doe's plan is undeniably convoluted, but it's worth it for the sheer sick poetry on display and the creativity of his scheme. If that ain't evil - and, admittedly, mentally ill - then what is?
He may have ended the movie with a bullet in his brain, but Doe's death was a necessary condition for his moral victory over a corrupted, defeated Mills.
It's an ending that Fincher and Pitt had to fight New Line Cinema for, who originally intended to replace the wife's head with that of a dog and cut Doe's death entirely. For shame.
8. Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines
Can artificial intelligence be evil? That's a question posited by so much contemporary science fiction, and if you've seen the first two Terminator movies - which, let's be honest, you surely have - then the answer seems pretty damn obvious.
But after T2 delivered audiences an uplifting and optimistic finale where Judgement Day was averted and humanity was left to make of their future whatever they saw fit, the belated threequel swiftly decided to undo all that.
Easily the best part of an otherwise standard issue sequel, T3's climax reveals that John Connor (Nick Stahl) and Katherine Brewster (Claire Danes) were never supposed to stop Judgement Day, but simply survive it.
In one of the all-time bleakest endings to a $180+ million blockbuster, billions of lives are wiped out as Skynet launches an awesomely destructive nuclear holocaust on Earth. Connor and the other survivors are then presumably left to fend for themselves in a post-apocalyptic wasteland while Skynet flourishes.
As much as it flies in the face of T2's ending, as a commentary on the inevitability of humanity effectively plotting its own demise, it's really quite ballsy and brilliant.
7. No Country For Old Men
Much has been written about Anton Chigurh (Javier Bardem), the antagonist of the Coen brothers' Best Picture-winning western, with many noting him to represent both the "unstoppable evil" trope recurrent in author Cormac McCarthy's novels, and also the inevitability of both violence and death.
Chigurh's mission throughout the movie is to recover a satchel of money from a drug deal gone wrong, sending him on a collision course with both Llewelyn Moss (Josh Brolin), who stumbles across the cash, and an in-over-his head Sheriff, Ed Tom Bell (Tommy Lee Jones).
Some may argue that Chigurh's methods - whereby he decides the fate of anyone he crosses with a coin flip - are too random to be evil, but McCarthy and the Coens seem to ultimately leave it up to the audience to decide. After all, the coin isn't killing anyone by itself.
The film ends with Moss dead and the implication that Chigurh escaped with the money, while a defeated Bell is simply left to his own devices. Chigurh is involved in a nasty car accident before he leaves town, but it's quite clear that he makes a clean(ish) getaway regardless.
This is precisely why more casual audiences found the film so challenging - Brolin's more conventional action hero is gunned down off-screen a good while before the end credits roll, Jones doesn't step up and have a final showdown with the brutal antagonist, and as for the antagonistic force itself, it passes through Texas mostly unimpeded.
6. Saw
The Saw franchise tries to paint the Jigsaw Killer aka John Kramer (Tobin Bell) as anything but a serial killer.
There's a rather discomforting hand-waving of his actions throughout the franchise, which suggests that because he gives people a chance to escape his demented traps, he somehow avoids the label of murderer.
But apply any real-world logic here and Jigsaw is an ingenious force of evil, guilty of dozens of deaths, if possibly a result of the terminal cancer pressing on his brain.
Still, 99.999% of the world's brain cancer patients don't decide to test humanity's capacity for survival in their final days, so Kramer is absolutely a monster of the highest order.
And while Jigsaw categorically prevails in the first two movies with his last-minute rug-pull reveals, even following his death in the third film, he continues to prove himself a master puppeteer beyond the grave.
The rest of the franchise cooks up a laughably convoluted series of events featuring an impossible degree of planning on Jigsaw's part, and one which sees him triumph over his enemies again and again.
This reaches its nutty apex in the seventh film, Saw 3D, where Jigsaw recruits his old victim Dr. Gordon (Cary Elwes) to deal with the off-the-rails Jigsaw apprentice Detective Hoffman (Costas Mandylor), cementing the apparent "integrity" of his legacy.
And the 2017 reboot-sequel Jigsaw takes this another step further, by ret-conning a secret first apprentice for Jigsaw, Logan (Matt Passmore), to continue his work in the present.
John Kramer may be dead, but as long as people will keep watching these movies, the legend of Jigsaw will never die. And as the series itself says, that is true immortality.
5. Avengers: Infinity War
Yes, there are those who half-jokingly believe that intergalactic terrorist Thanos (Josh Brolin) actually did nothing wrong by, uh, redressing the balance of the universe at the end of Avengers: Infinity War. But come on, he's about as evil as they come.
Nobody views themselves as a villain in their own mind - just look at real-life tyrants for proof of that - but the Mad Titan's finger-snapping actions ultimately speak for themselves.
Skynet may have obliterated a decent chunk of the human race at the end of Terminator 3, but that's child's play compared to what Thanos did: with the snap of his Infinity Gauntlet-clad fingers, he wiped out half of all life in the universe.
Some will contest that Thanos' lack of discrimination over who lived and died means he can't truly be evil, but the catastrophic nature of his act is really all the proof you need.
Thanos' intentions may be "for the best" in his own sick mind, but since when isn't an unprecedented level of genocide about as evil as it gets?
This entry deserves an asterisk if only because Thanos' victory at the end of Infinity War is practically guaranteed to be temporary, but in terms of game-changing shows of force that left audiences totally bunny-stunned, it's practically peerless villainy.
4. Final Destination
The Final Destination franchise - which is imminently being rebooted - brings with it one hell of a narrative hook.
The series' poor saps typically avoid a cataclysmic event after one of their group has a deathly premonition, prompting Death to continually return to the "lucky" survivors, attempting to off them for good by not-so-subtly influencing the world around them.
Now, perhaps if Death was just killing the survivors in their sleep, you could argue that the unseen force was simply re-balancing the cosmic scales and keeping the world's population in check. But the needlessly cruel, violent and often darkly comic manner in which the human meat shields are dismantled ultimately says otherwise.
In these movies, Death is a kid putting an insect under a magnifying glass on a hot summer's day - it knows exactly what it's doing, and has not a single care for the suffering inflicted.
A consistent through-line across the five movies to date, moreover, has been the inevitability of death and the inability of the protagonists to escape it.
Though several of the movies appear to end with the heroes triumphing or escaping the "curse", every single movie ultimately concludes with a final "gotcha!" death, confirming Death's dominance over all.
Dying isn't inherently an evil or bad thing - it's the most natural thing in the world. But as a sentient, discriminating force, the Death depicted in these movies clearly has one hell of a sick sense of humour.
3. Chinatown
And now we pivot back to a far more tangible and real evil in Roman Polanski's masterful 1974 film noir Chinatown.
In one of the all-time best downer endings in cinema history, protagonist Jake Gittes' (Jack Nicholson) plan to get Evelyn (Faye Dunaway) and her daughter/sister Katherine (Belinda Palmer) safely away from their rapist father/grandfather Noah Cross (John Huston) goes horribly wrong.
As Cross attempts to take custody of young Katherine, Evelyn shoots him and drives away, at which point the police shoot Evelyn, killing her.
A distraught Katherine is then taken away by Cross, presumably free to be abused by him forever more, while Gittes is powerless to intervene, and effectively told to just move on ("Forget it, Jake. It's Chinatown").
The gritty gumshoe protagonist can't save the day, the female lead gets shot and the antagonist gets away scot-free with the movie's only remaining vestige of anything approaching innocence. Flawlessly devastating.
2. The Vanishing
If you haven't seen George Sluizer's incredible 1988 Dutch thriller about a man desperately searching for his missing girlfriend, you absolutely need to change that. Like, right now.
After Saskia (Johanna ter Steege) disappears at a service station, her boyfriend Rex (Gene Bervoets) spends the rest of the movie unable to move on, even as the years pass by.
As is uncommon for the genre, Sluizer's film doesn't try to shield the audience from its antagonist, instead depicting kidnapper Raymond (Bernard-Pierre Donnadieu) in all of his unsettling ordinariness.
And that is the true genius of this film - evil is everyday and banal, and could manifest within your neighbour, your co-worker or that guy in front of you in the supermarket.
Rex's determined fascination with finding out what happened to Saskia ultimately leads him to meet up with Raymond, who promises to reveal what happened to Saskia if Rex agrees to go through the same process.
Rex, wracked by his curiosity, agrees to drink a drugged coffee given to him by Raymond, after which he wakes up buried alive, doomed to his fate.
The movie then ends with Raymond enjoying a relaxing day at home with his family, cementing the deeply disturbing duality of his "normal" life and the impossible evil lurking within.
Frustratingly, when Sluizer remade the movie for Hollywood a few years later - starring Kiefer Sutherland, Sandra Bullock and Jeff Bridges - he served up a happier, endlessly inferior ending (where the boyfriend character kills the kidnapper). Gross.
1. Hereditary
Ari Aster's incredible directorial debut is one of the most startling and unforgettable films of any genre from the last few years - a deliciously intense, nerve-shredding horror classic.
The film revolves around Annie Graham (a brilliant Toni Collette), who begins to experience supernatural phenomena in her home following the death of her mother.
Over the course of the film, it slowly becomes clear that her dear old mum wasn't quite who she appeared - she was in fact part of a coven plotting to resurrect the demon Paimon by transferring his consciousness into that of a suitable male host.
Over the course of the movie, Annie and her family are dismantled by the coven - her daughter Milly (Milly Shapiro) is decapitated in a vehicular "accident", her husband Steve (Gabriel Byrne) is burned alive, and she herself ends up possessed, before slicing her own head off with a piece of piano wire.
And that's not even the worst of it - her son Peter (Alex Wolff), who drove the car that killed his sister, is emotionally brutalised during the film, weakening him enough that Paimon can enter him in the final scene.
Hereditary concludes with Paimon inside Peter, a virile host, with a fleet of endlessly loyal coven members ready to do his bidding. It is the very definition of evil prevailing, and absolutely haunting in every fibre of its being.
Was evil right to prevail in these 10 movies, or should the hero have won out in the end? Shout it out in the comments!