10 Movies With Ridiculously Subtle Foreshadowing That Nobody Noticed
“Why do I get the feeling you’re going to be the death of me?”
"Why do I get the feeling youre going to be the death of me?" Obi-Wan Kenobi muses to Anakin Skywalker in Star Wars Episode II. Hahaha, do you geddit? Because later on Anakin kills Obi-Wan, but Obi-Wan doesn't know that so him saying it now is really funny. Ha. Ha. Ha.
Of course that's a prequel and you all know where it's heading, but it's incredibly emblematic of how blunt foreshadowing has become in movies. When a key plot point comes back into play the director wants to make sure everyone in the audience, even the guy more interested in his popcorn/phone, knows where it comes from. It's not overtly bad - the cracking Batman Begins repeatedly hammers home that the missing microwave emitter may actually be important - but boy is it tiring.
Sometimes though, a film can surprise you and slip a deliciously prophetic moment by you fresh to pick up in the rewatch. And sometimes a film will hide something so deep it'll take countless watches (or a good search of the internet) for you to gleefully discover. Here are ten of these smartly hidden foreshadowing moments that managed to pass just about everybody by. Given the nature of the is article, there will naturally be spoilers. Tread carefully.
Honourable Mention: Ed's Plan For The Next Day Are The Film's Key Events - Shaun Of The Dead
A seemingly perfect contender for this list, in recent years this deviously simple line has become well known in fan circles. After Shaun is dumped by Liz, Ed has a genius plan to help his buddy get over her; get drunk. While zombies do get in the way a bit, the plan is lived out in a warped sense. Just have a look at what he says: "Bloody Mary first thing, bite at The Kings Head, couple at The Little Princess, stagger back here, back at the bar for shots.
Sadly this has been done to death. One day somebody noticed it and quickly every Edgar Wright fan spread it round the internet like a zombie plague. A couple of years ago this was hidden foreshadowing. Now it's an overly well known easter egg.
10. The Frame Cuts Off Gwyneth Paltrow's Head An Hour Before John Doe Does - Se7en
Given just how shocking its final act is, Se7en didn't want to leave much for audiences to piece together the ending; Kevin Spacey's name was even kept off the opening credits to preserve John Does reveal. Instead, the story kept your mind incredibly set in the present with its drenched city and grimy, gory visuals. But even Fincher couldn't resist a little wink to the audience of how Mills wife will end up.
After a scene of Mills and Somerset brooding over what the villains plan is, the film cuts to Tracy, with the frame cutting off her body leaving her head on the screen just as we imagine John Doe does in the box. There's a few of these head shots throughout the film, turning this moment from a minor cinematography choice into subtle groundwork for the later, gut wrenching reveal.
Just before Mills kills Doe (there was a spoiler warning at the start) there's a one frame flash of Tracy's head, which many mistake this for being a shot of her head in the box, but it is in fact another frame of the film with her head isolated.
9. Mufasa's Circle Of Life Speech Gets Taken More Than A Little Literally - The Lion King
Given it's already been set up by an oddly catchy number, the audience of The Lion King listened up when Mufasa doled out his circle of life speech to Simba. But while it gave a good undercurrent to the film, highlighting what it is a king does and building the later essential father-son relationship, the key purpose of it probably went over the heads of many.
fter Mufasa dies in the stampede the sun sets and we don't see any natural light in the pride lands until Simba is king and the sun breaks through the cloud. The pathetic fallacy of it all is obvious, but it's a little more involved than that. It's an actual living out of Mufasas line in the earlier sequence: "one day, Simba, the sun will set on my time here, and will rise with you as the new king." It gets better; you can explain the light (both literally and tonally) of the Timon and Pumba sequence as an extension of this. Everything is a-ok for them because theyre outside where the light touches, so the rules of the kingdom don't apply.
The Lion King was resurrected Disney at its most creative, with the catchiest songs, darkest plots and striking visual themes, but it is little nods like this that push the screenplay into greatness.
8. Bloody Christmas Is A Microcosm Of The Plot - L.A. Confidential
Kim Basinger won a Best Supporting Actress Oscar for her femme fatale turn in L.A. Confidential, despite her being a rather muted presence throughout the film. Clearly the Academy had a thing for busty blondes that year. Of course, her ultimate lack of involvement was clearly signposted along with the fate of every major character in Bloody Christmas; she's not involved. Based on a true event (unlike the rest of the film), Bloody Christmas pits a gang of drunk, vengeful policemen against a group of already victimised prisoners and is a destructive as you might have expected.
Kicking the whole plot into motion, it also doubles up as a showcase of where each of the principal characters will end up. Russell Crowe's Bud White jumps right in fists blazing, Guy Pearce's Exley tries to calm the whole thing quietly while Kevin Spacey's Vincennes tries to keep out completely but is unwittingly in dragged in, ending up with a blood splatter on his shirt where he'll eventually be shot. As well as setting up the characters, elements like Vincennes' gunshot wound firmly put this in the world of foreshadowing.
7. Magneto Had Planned The Coin Meets Forehead Kill For A Long Time - X-Men: First Class
Before he was reduced to gleefully promoting British mobile companies, Kevin Bacon looked to be having a resurgence. His popularity was rising thanks to the Six Degrees game, Footloose was getting remade and he was the villain in the reboot prequel X-Men: First Class. And not just any villain. Sebastian Shaw is innately cool (despite sharing a name with the actor who played old Anakin in Return Of The Jedi) with an all threatening power and the film version only pushed it further, making him the nemesis of previous super-villain Magneto.
Bacon didn't seem to make much of an impact on fans, but what did was the creative death Matthew Vaughn and Jane Goodman cooked up for him. Finally cornered by Magento and frozen in place by Xavier, the former rams a Nazi coin all the way through his skull, mushing brain matter like EE mushes Bacon's appeal.
If that seems an elaborate death for Magneto to come up with in the spot, that's because he didn't. When we first see the Michael Fassbender version of Erik Lehnsherr he uses a photo of Shaw as the mutant equivalent of a dart board, planting the same coin in the centre of the pictures forehead. Foreheadshadowing you could say. But I wouldn't, because it makes no sense and isn't that funny.
6. A Schwarzenegger Joke Hints At The Mutant Suffocation - Total Recall
Total Recall is the Citizen Kane of foreshadowing. Pretty much every frame in the opening twenty minutes has some link to the later story, all helping build the mystery of whether or not Arnold Schwarzenegger is dreaming or it's all a lot of coincidence. From the spiel the Rekall guys dole out to the rant a sweating Dr Edgemar gives, the film delicately toes the line of reveals, making it just that little too hard to come down definitely on either side.
But there's one piece of foreshadowing that often gets overlooked, probably because it doesn't tie directly into the Rekall plot, but is still awesome. When Schwarzenegger's Doug Quaid meets (or rather remeets) mutant Tony he quips "Relax, you'll live longer." Clearly to show Quaid's increasingly cocky nature, it acts as a sly hint towards Tonys later fate; the advice becomes literal when he and the rest of the mutants are trapped in Venusville slowly losing air.
I don't quite know why this line hasn't been as focused on as the rest of the films foreshadowing. Yes it doesn't tie directly into the reality puzzle, but could easily be used as fuel for the dream theory; Quaid's mind is predicting whats happening next in his trip.
5. King Louie Is Right, Fire Is What Makes A Human - The Jungle Book
The DVD release strategy of Disney's Animated Classics is business brilliance; whereas pretty much every other in film in existence has continued availability, Disney tend to only let their films out of the vault for a short window, allowing for rabid buying and inflated prices. For fans of traditional animation this manages to delight and frustrate in equal measure. You may spend years waiting for your favourite to be released from the vault, eventually getting the elation of it finally being available dampened the sting of a tenner from your wallet.
One that caused quite a splash when it was released was The Jungle Book, the last film master Walt saw over and the last truly great film before the nineties resurgence. Adapted from Rudyard Kipling's Scout inspiring book, one of the film's most fondly remembered characters is the crazy King Louie. King of the swingers, this jungle VIP has one of the movies catchiest songs, but also a mind blowing bit of foreshadowing that completely alters his character.
rWhen Louie captures mancub Mowgli he believes the only difference between the two is the ability to harness fire. Silly, until we see later on that's exactly how Mowgli beats Shere Khan, the Tiger who strikes fear in the rest of the Jungle. On a simplified level, the reason the mancub makes it to the human settlement is because he can master fire, proving Louie perceptively right.
4. The Rainmaker's Origin Myths Are The Films Finale (Almost) - Looper
Time travel movies appear to be returning to the Back To The Future approach to the butterfly effect; it only really matters when it directly affects the plot. While that makes it sounds like an awfully contrived thing, there's been some standout films that have used it to explore exciting themes.
About Time had Richard Curtis subverting his stammering cliches with time alteration, but the hallmark has to be Looper. With its constantly changing, paradox rich science what can happen to the characters is so unpredictable that you wouldn't really be expected to find much foreshadowing (beyond the obviously misleadingly weakness of TKs). Well you expected wrong; Rian Johnson did a good job of hinting at the mystery of the Rainmaker.
Cid was already a pretty messed up kid before Old Joe came along, making it a pretty easy guess, but his identity was further set up by the posters in his room; those, along with some of his drawings, are of the Rainmaker's future henchmen. There's more than just identity hints though. When Old Joe discusses the mysterious crime lord he relays rumours he has a synthetic jaw and saw his mom get shot. Obviously that hadn't happened in Joe's version of the future, but is almost what happened to the current iteration of Cid.
3. Cloverleaf Has Strong Connotations With Interstates - Who Framed Roger Rabbit
The mystery behind the title of Who Framed Roger Rabbit is solved the moment Judge Doom walks on screen. Cloaked in black with overtly sinister mannerisms and surrounded by weasels, an animal second only to Hyenas as ideal scheming henchmen, even kids there just for the toon action will see where this is going.
But, aside from in a few specific countries, even the most on-it viewer wouldn't be able to really guess what the villain's plot actually is. Cloverleaf, the company who early on buy LAs' red tram, is a seemingly innocuous name, but to audiences in Sweden, Germany and, oddly given how little coverage this gets, America this is a real red flag to Doom's intersection plans.
For those not drivers in the above countries, a cloverleaf is a unnecessary complicated interchange that uses multiple levels and looks like a little like a four-leaf clover if you squint hard. So the interstate reveal that feels so sudden has very hidden roots through the film. What doesn't for some reason is Doom's identity as the toon who killed Eddie Valiants brother. Maybe the character was so unsubtle it was deemed the twist would be ruined with even the smallest hint.
2. Fischer Gives Saito The Idea For His Limbo - Inception
Similar to Total Recall, Inception spends a lot of time building up the big question of whether the whole thing or only part of it is an elaborate dream. Unlike the gore-splattered actioner, Christopher Nolan's more cerebral film did this in a last minute twist rather than an overarching theme, requiring rewatches that also help you pick up on bizarrely convoluted references.
When the van in the first dream level hits the barrier, the second level is sent into zero gravity while the third suffers a horrific avalanche. Gasping from a mixture of a the near death experience on the complexity of the plot, mark Fischer muses to Saito, "couldn't somebody have dreamt up a goddam beach?" Easy to chalk up to Fischer wanting to be out of the snowy maze, nothing, even this realistic aside, are coincidental in this film.
When Saito falls into Limbo what does he dream up but a beach. This is an interesting example, as while its foreshadowing, it's an entirely contained event; Fischer's comment probably influenced the increasingly unstable Saito in creating his Limbo base on a beach. And just when you thought you'd got the film's many threads down, right?
1. A Throw Away Quip Tells You Who Stole The Truck - The Usual Suspects
The plot of The Usual Suspects is kicked into motion by a truck full of gun parts being hijacked outside of Queens. Between the usual suspects (aha) being brought in (meaning the cops have no idea) and the plot moving so briskly ahead the identity of the hijacker becomes so unimportant that by the time the reveal of who did it rolls around (it was Todd Hockney and the truck owner was one Keyser Söze) the audience can be forgiven for not being too bothered (or even noticing it at all).
Those on the lookout for sly references (and not totally focused on the twist), however, may have been able to figure this out way back at the beginning. A gloriously cocky line from Agent Kujan early on has him proclaim he has a foolproof way to tell whos the guilty man in a room of felons; it's whoevers sleeping, resting as they know theyre caught. And when the gang are in the cell who's the only man laying down catching a short nap? Why, it's Hockney. An unbelievably intricate detail, this is another hidden gem in Christopher McQuarrie's deeply layered screenplay.
Are there any other films with deeply hidden foreshadowings? Which of these hadn't you come across before? Head down to the unforeshadowed comments section and have your say.