10 Notorious Box Office Bombs That Are Actually Pretty Good
Some of these movies are by no means classics, but better than their reputations would suggest.
With that in mind, this article will take a look at ten notorious box office bombs that are actually pretty good movies in their own right, although admittedly none of them are anywhere near on a par with the aforementioned classics. Despite the fact that many of these movies have some pretty major shortcomings, not to mention combined losses of hundreds of millions of dollars for the studios involved, they are nowhere near as bad as their tainted reputations would suggest.
Famously troubled productions, failed franchise starters, mega-budget misfires and genre flicks that sank without a trace all feature, so read on and see if you agree that these movies have been remembered for all the wrong reasons.
10. Hard Rain (1998)
Budget: $70m Box Office: $19.9m Rotten Tomatoes Score: 29%
One of the biggest commercial disasters of 1998, Hard Rain performed so poorly at the domestic box office that it ended up bypassing theaters entirely in many countries and going straight-to-video instead. However, the movie found a new lease of life on home video, and is now something of a cult favorite amongst action movie aficionados.
Born from a time when high-concept pitches were the way to sell an action project and Christian Slater was still a movie star, Hard Rain is essentially a small-town heist flick set against the backdrop of a major flood. As you would expect from the writer of Speed, the plot moves at a frantic pace and doesn't pause for a moment to think about things like dialogue, logic and believability but it provides plenty of entertainment value nonetheless.
Hard Rain just about overcomes the cliched script and characters by having the narrative run at a breakneck pace, and offers plenty of blockbuster spectacle thanks to some brilliant stunts and impressive special effects. It may be loud and stupid, but its a hell of a lot of fun. And where else would you see an action movie that boasts Morgan Freeman and Betty White amongst the cast?
9. Waterworld (1995)
811515Budget: $175m Box Office: $264.2m RT: 42%
Waterworld was written off as a dud long before it hit theaters, thanks to a legendarily troubled production that had seen the budget swell to $175m, making it the most expensive movie ever made at the time. However, it was actually one of the ten biggest box office hits of 1995 (out-earning both Braveheart and Heat) and even managed to turn a profit thanks to home video sales. Also, its actually a better movie than many people would have you believe.
Well, the Director's Cut is anyway. The theatrical version of the movie remains impressive from a visual standpoint, featuring massive practical sets and set-pieces that were becoming increasingly rare in the wake of the oncoming CGI revolution. Narratively, it falls wildly short and suffers from an uneven tone, a lack of characterization and plot holes you could sail a ship through.
By adding 40 minutes of previously unseen footage, the Director's Cut gives more depth to both the plot and characters, as well as an ending that is much neater than the one seen in theaters. Its hardly a great movie by any means, but Waterworld remains a hugely ambitious and frequently entertaining example of Hollywood grandiosity, despite its tainted legacy as a byword for studio excess.
8. John Carter (2012)
Budget: $267.3m Box Office: $284.1m RT: 51%
One of the costliest box office bombs in history, John Carter's disappointing commercial performance saw Disney post a writedown of over $120m thanks to the massive production and marketing costs, which wasn't exactly what the Mouse House was looking for from its latest big-budget potential franchise-starter.
The big screen adaptation of Edgar Rice Burroughs' eternally-popular novel had spent decades spent in development hell, with Andrew Stanton the man to finally bring the project to fruition, making his live-action directing debut in the process. Stanton's love for the material is evident in almost every frame, as John Carter presents plenty of richly detailed world-building, as well as an old-fashioned sense of adventure.
As is the case with many studio blockbusters these days, the main problems came from the narrative. Forgettable performances, thinly-sketched characters and an increasingly dense plot bog down the story, with many critics labeling it as derivative despite the fact the source material had inspired everything from Star Wars to Avatar. That being said, John Carter still provides perfect Saturday afternoon viewing; an ideal way to switch off your brain for a couple of hours and enjoy the unique blend of 21st Century visuals and retro escapism.
7. The Lone Ranger (2013)
998008Budget: $225m Box Office: $260.5m RT: 31%
Another movie that was long-predicted to be a box office bomb long before it hit theaters, The Lone Ranger managed to make back the production budget during its theatrical run, but quite why the studio thought it was a good idea to spend so much money on a Western is anybody's guess.
The Lone Ranger has its problems. Many of them, in fact. The production team transported the Pirates of the Caribbean formula to another genre, but didn't learn from any of the mistakes that had made Dead Man's Chest and At World's End so disappointing. The movie is at least 40 minutes too long, suffers from a hugely uneven tone that incorporates both poop jokes and a villain that eats peoples hearts in the same movie, features too many unnecessary characters and a plot that is over-complicated almost to the point of nonsense.
That being said, The Lone Ranger does have its merits. The cinematography is stunning, Armie Hammer and Johnny Depp have great chemistry as the central duo, and the action sequences are incredibly well put together, with the climactic train chase in particular one of the best set-pieces in recent years. While it will never go down as a classic, the movie will surely find life as a guilty pleasure of cinema fans for years to come.
6. White House Down (2013)
Budget: $150m Box Office: $205.4m RT: 51%
In the box office battle between the two 'Die Hard in the White House' movies, it was Olympus Has Fallen that came out on top, posting a bigger profit and spawning a sequel. Despite the similar premise of both projects, Roland Emmerich's blockbuster took itself a lot less seriously than Antoine Fuqua's, and is arguably the more entertaining of the two.
Writer James Vanderbilt's spec script was purchased for $3m, but must have been heavily altered by the studio before shooting began. Otherwise, it beggars belief as to why a story packed full of one-dimensional characters, plot twists signposted a mile away and countless genre cliches could have possibly cost so much to procure.
However, the chemistry between Channing Tatum and Jamie Foxx does generate an old-school buddy picture vibe, backed by a strong supporting cast including Maggie Gyllenhaal, James Woods and Richard Jenkins. Despite a distracting editing job that was surely implemented to secure a PG-13 rating, the movie gladly embraces the ridiculousness of its premise after a standard first act, and turns into an enjoyably stupid popcorn flick that propels itself along on sheer dumb fun.
5. Treasure Planet (2002)
Budget: $140m Box Office: $109.6m RT: 68%
After the 'Disney Renaissance' of the early 1990's that gave us classics like Beauty and the Beast, Aladdin and The Lion King, Walt Disney Animation Studios suffered something of a creative lull towards the end of the decade as Pixar redefined the very idea of the animated feature, with the majority of the studio's output failing to reach the high bar set by the previously mentioned all-time greats.
Although setting Robert Louis Stevenson's timeless novel in outer space gives the movie an interesting premise, the script doesn't deviate too far from the source material, yet suffers from some weak characterization and a reliance on the typical Disney formula. However, Treasure Planet boasts plenty of stunning visuals and great set-pieces, with both the animation and the movie itself successfully pulling off the delicate balance between the classic and cutting edge.
4. The Assassination Of Jesse James By The Coward Robert Ford (2007)
Budget: $30m Box Office: $15m RT: 76%
On paper, The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford had 'awards contender' written all over it; critically-acclaimed writer/director Andrew Dominik's first movie in seven years was adapted from a best-selling novel which was itself based on a legendary piece of American folklore, with a brilliant ensemble cast led by Brad Pitt that also featured Casey Affleck, Sam Shepard, Jeremy Renner and Sam Rockwell.
Despite being released in the midst of awards season to an enthusiastic critical response, the movie didn't make enough of an impact at the box office to receive a nationwide expansion, reaching only 300 theaters across the country in its widest release, grossing only $3.9m. One of the most overlooked movies of 2007, the slow-burning Western featured on the top ten list of many respected publications within the industry, with word-of-mouth seeing it earn almost as much in home video sales as it did at the multiplex.
With Dominik's assured direction backed by Roger Deakins' typically stunning (and Academy Award nominated) cinematography, Jesse James may run a little too long at nearly 160 minutes but still provides a superbly-acted, engrossing and intelligent period piece with Casey Affleck's turn as the titular coward in particular one of the best supporting performances of recent years.
3. Serenity (2005)
Budget: $39m Box Office: $38.8m RT: 82%
Seven years before he assembled the Avengers, Joss Whedon made his feature directing debut with the big-screen adaptation of his cult television series Firefly. Much like the show on which it was based, Serenity received enthusiastic reviews from both critics and fans, but didn't make enough of an impact on general audiences.
Although it was only on the air for three months, Firefly amassed enough of a following and registered such strong home video sales that Universal commissioned a feature-length continuation of the story. Unfortunately, Serenity suffered from the same fate as its small-screen counterpart; the movie failed to earn back its budget at the worldwide box office, yet managed to eventually turn a profit thanks to rentals (remember them?) and DVD sales.
Even if you hadn't seen the show, Serenity still provided an entertaining sci-fi adventure for the uninitiated, a unique blend of space opera and Western that is full of likeable characters (not to mention Chiwitel Ejiofor's villainous performance), great dialogue, plenty of humor and an old-fashioned sense of fun that is increasingly hard to come by in the genre.
2. Grindhouse (2007)
Budget: $53m Box Office: $25.4m RT: 83%
Two of the most well-known film enthusiasts in Hollywood, best buddies and frequent collaborators Quentin Tarantino and Robert Rodriguez turned their love of exploitation cinema into a 191 minute double-feature, complete with an intermission and trailers for 'upcoming' releases. Unfortunately, audiences were unsure of how to react to the 1970's-inspired experiment, and Grindhouse ended up massively under-performing at the box office.
The movie's failure at the domestic box office saw Planet Terror and Death Proof released separately overseas, which defeats the purpose of Grindhouse entirely. On their own, they are good but not great; Rodriguez delivers an entertaining tongue-in-cheek genre flick, and despite being the weakest entry by far in Tarantino's filmography Death Proof features a brilliant third-act car chase and Kurt Russell on top form as Stuntman Mike.
Add in intentionally missing footage, scratched film and fake trailers by Rodriguez, Edgar Wright, Rob Zombie and Eli Roth that featured cameos by everyone from Simon Pegg to Nicolas Cage, and the end result is one of the most unique and interesting cinematic experiences of recent years.
1. The Iron Giant (1999)
Budget: $70m Box Office: $31.3m RT: 96%
Brad Bird's directorial debut is now regarded as one of the best animated features of the 1990's, which makes The Iron Giant's commercial failure all the more baffling. The movie just about scraped into the domestic top ten, opening in ninth place with a dismal $5.7m and failed to even earn back half of its production budget at the worldwide box office, but has since come to be known as a modern classic of animation.
The Iron Giant was released during a pivotal transition phase for the animated feature; Disney's early 90's renaissance was over and the studio's output was becoming increasingly mediocre, while Pixar were redefining the genre with their cutting-edge computerized techniques and intelligent storytelling that appealed to audiences of all ages. With its combination of both hand-drawn and computer animation, an ambitious narrative and well-developed characters, The Iron Giant was perhaps the most overlooked family movie in years.
Packed with adventure, humor, warmth, heart and emotion, Bird's movie is much more complex than the average animated movie. In what was to become a feature of the director's work, The Iron Giant is as strong visually as it is thematically, a smartly-written and massively entertaining blend of sci-fi, comedy, drama and action.
Do you agree with the article? Are there any other underrated box office bombs that you would have included instead? As always, sign off in the comments below.