10 Oscar Winning Films That Are Actually Bad

The fact that these films won anything is beyond comprehension!

Crash Michael Pena
Lionsgate

Some people (mainly those who make up the Academy) think that the Oscars are the quintessential end-all be-all for what makes a film prestigious. If your movie wins an Oscar, it’s high-class film and if it wins Best Picture you might as well just give up now because you’ve achieved the apex of cinema.

Basically, the Academy Awards are the closest thing cinephiles have to a Super Bowl and to think that people will stop caring about them anytime soon is unrealistic, but film-lovers have begun to sour on the festivity.

Many times, the Academy nominates films they think should win, not films that deserve to. The Dark Knight, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Ex Machina, Children of Men, Boogie Nights, Blade Runner, Rosemary’s Baby, and Almost Famous are just a small sample size of films that missed out on the main prize in order for films like you’re about to see to find a place.

No, these ten films are not the worst movies ever made, but it’d be impossible to argue any of them as good and many not even surpassing average. A few ground rules before we dive in: 1) the film must have won at least one Oscar 2) must have been nominated for no less than three.

Yes, Suicide Squad won an Oscar, but it was also only nominated for one, so it doesn’t constitute much as an awards movie; more like an abysmal film that unfortunately got lucky.

10. The Descendants

The Descendants Car Ride
20th Century Fox

Director Alexander Payne is surely an Oscar darling having seen five of his seven feature films nominated and The Descendants nabbing five for itself. While his other Oscar nominated films (Election, About Schmidt, Sideways, and Nebraska) ranged from fine to pretty damn great, The Descendants is just not at that level.

Clooney earned a deserved Best Actor nomination, but the film’s Best Picture nom and Best Adapted Screenplay win are beyond baffling. The film’s plot is white men complaining about their guilt of owning Hawaiian land while Clooney brings himself and his two daughters to say goodbye to their soon to be deceased mother. Payne was going for dramatic comedy but just so happened to miss both.

Shailene Woodley co-stars in her first major film role, so we can thank the film for giving us a refreshing and appreciated actress to indie-cinema, but not even that can excuse just how utterly boring and inconsequential the film feels.


9. Vice

Vice Christian Bale
Annapurna

Adam McKay crossed the line from esteemed comedy director (Talladega Nights, Step Brothers, The Other Guys) to critically successful dramedy director in 2015 with The Big Short; a landmark rehash of the 2008 Recession. The film was a frontrunner for Best Picture till Spotlight edged it out but regardless, had everyone excited for what McKay had coming next.

Vice; a biography of Vice President Dick Cheney chronicled how he became one of the most powerful people in the world. Originally titled Backseat (a much better title), the film on paper had all the workings of an Oscar worthy film, but those workings didn’t come together as all had hoped.

Christian Bale’s superb performance was accompanied by caricatures from Sam Rockwell and Amy Adams as well as poor writing that had maybe ten minutes of memorable dialogue. The story of Cheney was interesting, but a documentary about him would have probably been more informative. And more entertaining.


8. Shakespeare In Love

Shakespeare In Love
Universal Pictures

Shakespeare in Love is a movie no one asked for and, in a way, hurt the incredible play that is Romeo and Juliet by giving us an unfaithful and unnecessary lore on the making of. The film’s status is often just weighed against its notoriety in Oscar history.

The film won Best Picture in 1998, the same year that Saving Private Ryan was up for the top prize also. Shakespeare in Love was the first film in 9 years to win Best Picture without a Best Director Oscar, as Steven Spielberg won for Saving Private Ryan. It’s not that the movie isn’t as good as its rival (it’s not) but that it’s just not good to begin with, upset aside.

Besides Gwyneth Paltrow and Judi Dench (both won Oscars for the film), the acting is atrocious and laughable at times (looking at you, Affleck). The romance can at times be a tad bit compelling, but the plot of the film is preposterous and the melodrama artificial. It’s not the worst film to win Best Picture, but it’s surely the largest gap between winner and the film that deserved it.


7. Boyhood

Boyhood Mason
IFC Films

Boyhood’s six Oscar nominations resulted in one win, Best Supporting Actress for Patricia Arquette. That nomination along with Best Supporting Actor for Ethan Hawke are the only awards it should have been nominated for. The film’s ambition made critics and academy members blind to its complete lack of structure or compelling narrative.

Richard Linklater should be applauded for his feat, but the fact that only 9 out of 304 critics gave it a less than positive review is far beyond what the film deserves. The main actor, Ellar Coltrane, was adorable and fun to watch in his youth but grew into a teenager who had a severely hard time making his performance feel authentic; especially when Arquette and Hawke were so stellar beside him.

This pick will surely be the one of the more controversial on the list. The film by itself, void of any of the production facts, is not good. Had the director used different kids or de-aging CGI and told the same story, critics and audeinces would have torn the film apart.

Luckily, Birdman was able to take the main prize away from Boyhood, which was the heavy frontrunner.


6. Cold Mountain

Cold Mountain
Miramax Films

Renée Zellweger got her third nomination in three consecutive years and finally won for Cold Mountain. The film seems like the worst type of “Oscar-Bait;” a period-piece full of over-acting, war, tears, romance, and big names. Director Anthony Minghella is an Academy favourite who’s two previous films before Cold Mountain earned numerous nominations and wins as well.

The stacked cast of Zellweger, Jude Law, Nicole Kidman, Phillip Seymour Hoffman, Natalie Portman, Giovanni Ribisi, Brendan Gleeson, Donald Sutherland, Charlie Hunnam, and Jack White make up the far too loaded cast. Even actors and actresses with so many awards and accolades such as the one mentioned couldn’t perform the pretentious and emotionless script they were given with any sort of authenticity.

The film tried to be the next Gone with the Wind, Glory, or Dances with Wolves, but failed wholly. The movie has fallen completely out of the public’s consciousness and lives virtually nowhere within cinematic memory. The director has not made another film in 13 years after the justifiably lukewarm critical and audience reaction to the period drama.


5. Babel

Babel Brad Pitt
Paramount Pictures

The worst part of Babel being such a colossal mess is how much of an established and appreciated name director Alejandro G. Iñárritu has now become. The director of Birdman, The Revenant, 21 Grams, and Biutiful earned his first Oscar nomination for Babel; a Pulp Fiction-esque narrative that shows a tragedy and the dozens of individuals affected by it.

The film seemed brilliant on paper as the consequences of an accident effects everyone from rich Americans to poverty-ridden middle easterners. It’s just too bad the film’s scope was far larger than the audience’s emotional stake in it. The movie had too many characters and it failed to allow viewers to grow attached too. When a character we’ve seen on screen for less than five minutes dies or is in peril, it’s pretty hard to have a visceral reaction to it.

The filmmaking was stellar and it solidified Iñárritu’s future to have free reign to create the movies he has as of late, but there was zero need for the Academy to honor the film with seven nominations, including Best Picture and bafflingly Best Original Screenplay. Not even the great Brad Pitt or Cate Blanchett could save this film.


4. The English Patient

english patient
Miramax

The English Patient will always be the archetype for critics of the Oscars to go back to and use in their favour. The film is a 162-minute slog that somehow won 9 of its 12 Oscar nominations. The WWII war-romance-drama beat out Jerry Maguire and Fargo to take home the top prize; an accolade it vehemently didn’t deserve.

It’s not that the film isn’t deserved of its Best Picture win, it’s that it’s a terrible movie. Ralph Fiennes and Willem Dafoe are the only source of recourse in a film that’s as slow as a film can be.

The film offers two theories as to what’s consistently wrong with the academy; they’re all cinema-goers who’re so off of with what the public enjoys they genuinely think this is quality cinema or they sincerely don’t watch all the nominated films and think that a movie such as this just sounds perfect for a win.

The English patient gets a branded bad for being a non-worthy Best Picture win, but I’d argue against that; it should get branded bad for being a bad film.


3. Crash

Crash Matt Dillon Thandie Newton
Lionsgate

the criteria and are much worse than the 2006 Best Picture winner. Maybe not as much of an upset as the 1998 Oscars but Crash winning Best Picture over Brokeback Mountain is a travesty that still irks the angriest of cinephiles. Paul Haggis’ L.A. centered race-relations drama shows how the lives of different people from different backgrounds come together in an overly-emotional and cringy-worthy way.

Matt Dillon, Sandra Bullock, Brendan Fraser, Don Cheadle, Terrence Howard, Thandie Newton, Michael Peña, Ryan Phillippe, and Ludacris star in the film and nearly all besides Newton and Dillon give less than subpar performances. Haggis is much more known as a screenwriter than a director, which Crash gives, as evidence with atrocious filmmaking; the key role of a director is to evoke authentic performances by their performers, something Haggis must have forgotten.

The film seems like it can’t decide on its message and just wants to throw uncomfortable and depressing scenes in front of you. Haggis’ writing nomination the year prior for Million Dollar Baby emphasizes how lazily the script was written, since we knew what he was capable of.


2. Chicago

Chicago - Cell Block Tango
Miramax

Chicago is a horrendous film and no amount of singing, dancing, or charm can prove otherwise. In keeping with tradition, Chicago maliciously stole Best Picture from films in 2002 such as The Pianist, Gangs of New York, and The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers.

Director Rob Marshall has made a name for himself directing musicals (Chicago, Nine, Into the Woods, Marry Poppins Returns) and I’d confidentially argue the other three are superior to Chicago. The film looks like it was shot on a Broadway stage with zero respect for the art of filmmaking and what one can do with it. There are great musicals that use their cinematography and scope to help tell the story and highlight the performances/music; Chicago seems to be too important a story for any of that.

Catherine Zeta-Jones and John C. Reilly are, without hyperbole, the only redeeming attributes to the film. Overacting and flair may have a place in the theatre, but films like Les Miserable, Singin’ in the Rain, La La Land, and Sweeney Todd prove that their omission is greatly appreciated.


1. Bohemian Rhapsody

Bohemian Rhapsody
Fox

Bohemian Rhapsody is one of the few films to be nominated for Best Picture and win every award it was up for besides the big one. The worst part? It deserved all four of its wins; Best Film Editing, Best Sound Editing, Best Sound Mixing, and most deservedly Best Actor. Rami Malek’s performance is a ’69 Corvette parked right in the middle of a junk yard. The film’s 61% on Rotten Tomatoes is the second lowest of any Best Picture nominee, only behind (in front of?) Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close at 46%.

Queen is the greatest rock bands in history and for their story to be crumpled up into an inaccurately cheesy feel-good flick and sent out with a bow on it is damned infuriating. Director Bryan Singer (let’s not even get into it) made a fluff piece that followed every stereotype in the musical-biopic arsenal.

To add fuel to the more than rational fire, not only was the film a colossal mess, but fans ate it up like no one could have imagined; the movie made over $400 million globally and is already starting the trend of giving every musical legend their own film. The script was nonsense and the direction similarly so, often written like a hallmark film and having characters talk as no humans actually do. Never in the Oscars 91-year run has a Best Picture nominee been less deserving of the accolade.

What Oscar winning film do you feel is the worst? Let us know in the comments!


In this post: 
Crash oscars
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

If you talk in a theatre I'm in, be prepared to get some pretty passive aggressive stares.