10 Overused Movie Plot Devices We Never Want To See Again

001 There are so many movies out there that it's not so surprising we feel like we've pretty much seen it all. Some movies will without a care in the world dredge up a familiar plot device to propel themselves forward, resting on tried and tested formula that now nevertheless seems extremely trite and lazy. These devices might have seemed fresh and exciting the first fifty times they were employed, but now, they're just irritants and can often result in a groaning audience during an otherwise enjoyable film. Though it's hard to choose just 10, I've narrowed it down to the 10 I find the most head-smackingly overused. Let's get on with the list...

10. Ticking Time Bomb

Perhaps the most classic plot device on this list, the ticking time bomb is a famous scenario intended to sustain tension, usually at the climax of a film. The villain will have planted a bomb, and the protagonist will have to find a way to dispose of it or diffuse it. This trope appears everywhere from the original Batman TV series, to Speed, to The Dark Knight Rises, and contemporary films tend to also fit the bomb out with a handy LED timer, giving the hero an exact idea of how long he has to stop it (which somewhat undermines the tension, really). It was once upon a time a perfect way to wring thrills out of a film, but it's simply too played out, and 99% of the time I see this scenario now, it just seems dull and uninspired - the least imaginative way to end a movie for sure.

9. No Mobile Phone Reception

A classic trope of horror movies, this usually occurs once the protagonists - most often a group of nubile, intellectually middling young folk - have arrived in the desolate town or cabin in the woods, and suddenly, a character will look down to their phone to see that they have no signal. Of course, soon enough, the killing begins, and they're unable to summon help because the murderer smartly operates out of what is apparently a mobile phone black-spot. Aside from these sorts of areas being very few and far between these days, it's an extremely lazy, thoughtless way to write around the inevitability of the heroes just calling the cops and ending things very quickly. Hell, the battery running out would be more realistic than that, especially if they're using a smart phone!

8. A Hero Rises

This is a classic trope and one that's likely never going to go away, but it's been used so aggressively in so many Hollywood movies recently that I'm sort of sick of it. Films such as The Dark Knight Rises, Skyfall and Iron Man 3 have committed to a similar narrative trajectory, where the protagonist is stripped of all their toys and skills, thrown into a pit of despair (often a literal one), and then has to rise up once again to tear down evil. While it's not an especially original plot device in of itself, the manner in which each of these three films has gone about it is particularly similar, such that I doubt I could tolerate another movie property doing the same thing any time soon. Can we just put a moratorium on this for, like, forever? It's one of the few bad things following the Christopher Nolan-inspired turn towards a dark, gritty tone.

7. Off-Screen Gunshot

The Matrix This one's irritating because it rarely catches us off guard, even though it's usually filmed in such a way that the director clearly thinks he's got one over on us. The villain will usually be tussling with the hero for a gun, and we'll see a medium close-up of the hero's face just as a gunshot goes off. "Oh no, is the good guy dead?", we're supposed to ask, when by now we're instantly thinking, "Yup, bad guy's dead, either shot by the hero or an off-camera friend who saves the day", and 99% of the time, that is absolutely what happens. In fact, this trope is so overdone and cliched that enterprising filmmakers have a pretty good opportunity to usurp it; how galling would it be to see the scene play out as usual, except at the end the protagonist has been shot, and dies?

6. Buddy Cops

Here's a plot device that an entire genre of movies is devoted to - indeed, the "buddy cop" movie - wherein two police officers are partnered together who are polar opposites in terms of temperament, ethics, and often race as well. They usually begin with a strong dislike for one another - though, as in the genre's best example, Lethal Weapon, this isn't a requirement - and over the course of their partnering together, they come to an understanding that makes them a savagely efficient crime-fighting unit. The fact that it's a genre unto itself says a lot about its popularity, and audiences apparently don't seem too fazed about how predictable and generic these films can be in the wrong hands (i.e. without Shane Black). Nevertheless, have you ever watched one of these films and been surprised? Given how much character plays into films of this sort, the success of a film like this usually hinges on casting.

5. In Media Res

Fight Club A personal peeve of mine is the so-called "in media res" sequence in films, which is basically a hoighty-toighty way of saying that a film begins by showing us a pivotal scene from later on in the story, before going back to the beginning and telling everything. At its best, the technique can keep audiences guessing about what they've seen at the start, and within a new context later, can confound expectations viewers have come up with, yet most of the time, it's just a thoughtless, pointless affectation that doesn't help the film at all. Take the sci-fi dud Skyline; this is a film that began by showing us the alien invasion, then went back to the start of the story, and then returned to the opening scene a mere 20 minutes later. Without any additional context and such a speedy repetition of the scene, what the Hell was the point!? One of the few instances of in media res to truly work was in David Fincher's masterful Fight Club, where we later see the opening scene repeated with the new knowledge that Tyler is Jack, and Jack says, "I still can't think of anything", to which Tyler quips, "Ah, flashback humour", referencing Jack saying "I can't think of anything" at the start of the film.

4. The Training Montage

Another exceptionally lazy plot device to move things forward; if writers can't find a way to realistically show a character's progress within the regular pace of the film, they'll simply speed time up by way of a clunkily constructed montage sequence, showing their improvement in just two or three minutes of screen time, usually accompanied by a cheesy pop song of the moment. While this has charmed in films such as Rocky and The Karate Kid - as well as being ably spoofed in Team America: World Police - it's pretty tiresome if ever undertaken in a serious way nowadays. It generally just smacks of a filmmaker who isn't imaginative enough to find another way to convey progress other than smattering images together like a music video, but it's not likely to be something that's going away anytime soon, because it's so easy to do, and hey, lots of people love montages.

3. The Ugly Nerd Makeover

She's All That Otherwise referred to as the "Ugly Duckling Transformation", this occurs in variations in films like She's All That, Miss Congeniality and Never Been Kissed, whereby an apparently homely, unattractive girl is given a makeover, and now she is the zenith of beauty. This is spoofed hilariously in Not Another Teen Movie, in which the makeover consists largely of removing Chyler Leigh's glasses and putting her hair down, the joke being that the girls cast in these sorts of roles are always extremely attractive as is, whether they're wearing a smoking red dress or some paint-soaked overalls. It's such a transparent plot device and yet curiously overused; Hollywood needs to buck up and actually cast a plain Jane in a role like this, and then glam her up so she actually looks hot. Only then is this device not going to seem ennui-inducing.

2. Medicine Cabinet Jump Scare

The horror genre is full of antiquated tropes, and the most irritating to me has to be the jump scare, an attempt to give the audience an adrenaline rush by way of a sudden occurrence accompanied by a loud tension chord. Though these can usually be seen coming a mile off, one that's overused to the point of lunacy is the 'ol medicine cabinet mirror trick, whereby a character will go to the bathroom, close the door on their medicine cabinet, and as the mirror snaps back in line with the camera, we see that there's now a monster/killer/ghoul/whatever behind the character, with a loud piano chord for good measure. This one gets extra points if the character in the bathroom turns around only for the figure to be in their imagination. Why do filmmakers still persevere with crap like this? It doesn't fool anyone over the age of 10.

1. Amnesia

Even still, the mirror trick doesn't grate on me quite as much as what is the laziest and most overused, silly, soap opera-esque plot device out there - amnesia. Even when it's done well, as in the Bourne trilogy, it seems like an all-too-easy way to place the character on the same informational level as the viewer, such that when everything is explained to them in probing detail, it doesn't seem like a lazy way to convey exposition (even though it is). Furthermore, an amnesia plot almost always causes me to anticipate a narrative twist in which something the character has discovered throughout their journey has proven to be incorrect, or a character who they thought was on-side has been playing with their head the whole time. It can work extremely well from time to time with a strong mind at the helm - as in Christopher Nolan's Memento - but it's a device so easy to mire in soap opera histrionics. Which overused plot device annoys you the most? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Frequently sleep-deprived film addict and video game obsessive who spends more time than is healthy in darkened London screening rooms. Follow his twitter on @ShaunMunroFilm or e-mail him at shaneo632 [at] gmail.com.