10 People Who Deserve To Have Won Oscars

alfred hitchcock

Every year since 1929 the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences meets up to decide who will be the winners at The Oscars. And every year a multitude of people will complain that these awards did not go to the right people. After the awards have been announced, there is the inevitable barrage of criticism from disgruntled cinephiles who disagree with the decisions made by The Academy.

But should film fans really care so much about these awards? At the end of the day, a film receiving the title of €˜Best Picture€™ is still very much the same film it was before the award ceremony. The only difference is that now it has a flashy badge of approval from the group of elite individuals who constitute The Academy. To narrow the selection down to one definitive film or one definitive acting performance must be an incredibly difficult task. In fact, to zoom in with a laser eye of objectivity and single out one winner is damn near impossible. But for whatever reasons, The Academy makes their decisions and there is nothing we can do but accept it. I€™m not going to pass judgement or criticise any of their choices. Instead, I€™m going to provide a list of 10 immensely talented and influential directors, actors and cinematographers who are equally deserving of owning one of those small golden statuettes.

10. Gordon Willis

url-11

Nomination and Year:

Best Cinematography for: Zelig (1984) Best Cinematography for: The Godfather: Part III (1991) Gordon Willis is one of the great cinematographers of the 20th century. He has an innate knowledge of how to manipulate light and shadows that he has used to compose some of cinema€™s most iconic settings. His technical prowess is evident in The Godfather trilogy, particularly in Don Corleone€™s office on the day of his daughter€™s wedding. Though it is easy to be distracted by the cuteness of Don Corleone playing with his cat, take a look at how lighting is used to intensify the sinister ambience. Even Michelangelo would blush at Willis€™ gorgeous cinematography. Willis frequently collaborated with Woody Allen, being his director of photography from Annie Hall (1977) through to The Purple Rose of Cairo (1985). Despite receiving only a mere two Oscar nominations, the film industry admired his penchant for murky lighting, leading him to acquire one of the coolest nicknames around, €˜The Prince of Darkness€™. However, better late than never his achievements were finally acknowledged by The Academy, when in 2009 he won an honorary award for €˜unsurpassed mastery of light, shadow, colour and motion€™.

9. Christopher Nolan

Nomination and Year: Best Motion Picture of the Year: Inception (2011) Best Original Screenplay: Inception (2011) Best Original Screenplay: Memento (2002) It is merely a matter of time before Christopher Nolan wins his first academy award; the man is a genius. His mind-bendingly awesome thrillers Memento and Inception narrowly missed out on the Best Original Screenplay award, losing to Gosford Park and The King€™s Speech respectively. His reinvention of the Batman series brought him worldwide fame as a director, even if The Academy disregards him when choosing their nominations. Amazingly, The Dark Knight Rises hasn€™t received a single nomination at this year€™s Oscars. However the Oscars has a strange tendency of belatedly rewarding people who are long overdue one of those golden statuettes. It wasn€™t until 2007 that Martin Scorcese won his first Oscar for TheDeparted. A similar case could be made for Al Pacino who picked up the Best Actor award in 1993 for Scent of a Woman, despite delivering a succession of other knock-out acting performances in the previous twenty years of his career. I may not be able to tell you when, but I am confident that Christopher Nolan€™s day will come.

8. Peter O'Toole

OToole-Peter-22-600x300 Nomination and Year: Best Actor in a Leading Role: Venus (2007) Best Actor in a Leading Role: My Favourite Year (1983) Best Actor in a Leading Role: The Stunt Man (1981) Best Actor in a Leading Role: The Ruling Class (1973) Best Actor in a Leading Role: Goodbye, Mr Chips (1970) Best Actor in a Leading Role: The Lion in Winter (1969) Best Actor in a Leading Role: Becket (1965) Best Actor in a Leading Role: Lawrence of Arabia (1963) Though Peter O€™Toole will forever be remembered for his mesmerising performance in Lawrence of Arabia, he is a truly esteemed thespian of the highest calibre. O€™Toole is a revered graduate from the Shakespearian school of acting and has enjoyed a long and illustrious career on stage as well as on the silver screen. O€™Toole has made Oscar history for receiving the most acting nominations without a win, with an astonishing 8 nominations (his acting associate and good friend Richard Burton is a close second place with 7). In 2003 he received an honorary award for being an actor €˜whose remarkable talents have provided cinema history with some of its most memorable characters€™. However he very nearly turned down the award €“ O€™Toole didn€™t want a consolation prize, he wanted the real deal. In 2007 he did receive another nomination for Venus, but a sense of ill-fated deja-vu struck again as he lost out to Forest Whitaker€™s performance in The Last King of Scotland. Always gracious in defeat, O€™Toole jokingly remarked, €˜always the bridesmaid, never the bride, my foot€™ as he accepted his honorary award.

7. Alfred Hitchcock

alfred hitchcock

Nomination and Year: Best Director: Psycho (1961) Best Director: Rear Window (1955) Best Director: Spellbound (1946) Best Director: Lifeboat (1945) Best Director: Rebecca (1941) It€™s probably common knowledge that despite being one of the most influential directors to have graced the earth with his heavenly presence, Hitchcock never won an Oscar. But it€™s worth reiterating just how absurd this seems. Even receiving a total of 5 nominations (a princely sum by any director€™s standards) seems a rather measly amount given the cinematic legacy he left in his wake. However in 1968 he was awarded the Irving G. Thalberg Memorial Award, an accolade reserved for those €˜whose bodies of work reflect a consistently high quality of motion picture production€™. Despite an Oscar-less career, Hitchcock€™s name will forever be engraved into the halls of cinema fame. He is portrayed by Anthony Hopkins in the recent release Hitchcock which looks at the turbulent production process of his timeless classic Psycho.

6. Akira Kurosawa

akira kurosawa

Nomination and Year: Best Director: Ran (1986) From one legendary director to another, next on the list is €˜The Emperor€™, Akira Kurosawa. Growing up in Japan, Kurosawa was influenced by the westerns of John Ford. The cinematic tribute to his idol came full circle in Kurosawa€™s case with three of his films (The Outrage, Seven Samurai and Yojimbo) being remade into westerns. Other significant works in his expansive filmography include the wonderfully innovative Rashomon and the epic Ran, for which he received his only Oscar nomination. However perhaps it is not so surprising that Kurosawa never won an Oscar. One of the criticisms of the Academy Awards is that it seems to pay lesser attention to films which require subtitles. Though the award for Best Foreign Language Film was introduced in 1956, the vast majority of winners are from Europe. Only six recipients of the award have been from Asia. And it is extremely rare that these films will be put forward for the Best Picture category. But this is a different issue altogether. Despite being somewhat overlooked by The Academy during the peak of his career, in 1990 they gave him the recognition he deserves. Kurosawa received the honorary award €˜for cinematic accomplishments that have inspired, delighted, enriched and entertained worldwide audiences and influenced filmmakers throughout the world€™.

5. Annette Bening

annette bening

Nomination and Year: Best Actress in a Leading Role: The Kids Are All Right (2011) Best Actress in a Leading Role: Being Julia (2005) Best Actress in a Leading Role: American Beauty (2000) Best Actress in a Supporting Role: The Grifters (1991) Despite only being the modest height of 5€™6€, Annette Bening has a formidable screen presence, which has led her to an impressive to four Oscar nominations. Bening€™s breakthrough role was in TheGrifters, a crime thriller starring Anjelica Huston and John Cusack, where she played a sassy and seductive con-artist. The nineties were a bit of dry spell for Bening until 1999, where she landed the role of Carolyn Burnham in the modern masterpiece American Beauty. Her turn as the pushy real estate agent and struggling mother of a dysfunctional family was critically well-received, and the film went on to win Best Picture.

4. Brad Pitt

brad pitt Nomination and Year: Best Motion Picture of the Year: Moneyball (2012) Best Actor in a Leading Role: Moneyball (2012) Best Actor in a Leading Role: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (2009) Best Actor in a Supporting Role: Twelve Monkeys (1996) He€™s dated Juliette Lewis, Gwyneth Paltrow, Jennifer Aniston and Angelina Jolie. His name is mentioned in the Shania Twain song €˜That Don€™t Impress Me Much€™. He has been banned from entering China. And People Magazine has named him the sexiest man alive. Twice. At the age of 49, Brad Pitt has probably already ticked everything off his bucket list. But he has yet to win an Oscar. Over the last years couple of decades Pitt has established himself as one of Hollywood€™s leading males. Throughout his career he has showcased incredible versatility as an actor. Pitt has played the role of an insane animal rights fanatic in Twelve Monkeys, a bare-knuckle boxing Pikey in Snatch and a man who ages backwards in The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, for which he received a Best Actor nomination. Pitt has frequently been likened to the great Robert Redford, both in his physical appearance and for his protean acting talent. Redford won an Oscar, and I think Pitt deserves to win one too.

3. Paul Thomas Anderson

paulthomasanderson600

Nomination and Year: Best Director: There Will Be Blood (2008) Best Motion Picture of the Year: There Will Be Blood (2008) Best Adapted Screenplay: There Will Be Blood (2008) Best Original Screenplay: Magnolia (2000) Best Original Screenplay: Boogie Nights (1998) Though he only has six writing and directing credits to his name, Paul Thomas Anderson has emerged as one of the most innovative and stylish filmmakers in cinema today. The viewer immediately knows they are in a PTA film through his idiosyncratic use of a constantly moving camera, as it effortlessly navigates around the scene. Take this dexterous camerawork, add it to an expertly crafted screenplay, and you have the recipe for a top-notch film. Anderson broke onto the scene with Boogie Nights, a film about the life of ridiculously well-endowed swordsman Dirk Diggler, and his ventures into the porn industry. Despite the plotline being based around a rather risqué theme such as pornography, the screenplay is handled masterfully and is thoroughly deserving of its Oscar nomination. The Master is nominated for three awards at this year€™s Oscars, all of them in the Best Acting Performance categories.

2. George Lucas

george lucas Nomination and Year: Best Director: Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope (1978) Best Original Screenplay: Star Wars: Episode IV €“ A New Hope (1978) Best Director: American Graffiti (1974) Best Screenplay Based on Factual Material: American Graffiti (1974) Another eminent director who made the list is George Lucas. Lucas is the founder of Lucasfilm and the mastermind behind Star Wars, the saga which turned him into a cinematic icon almost overnight. With the exception of Episode IV - A New Hope (which was heavily influenced by Kurosawa€™s TheHidden Fortress), all the Star Wars films were independently produced by Lucas himself. Due to A New Hope becoming the highest grossing film ever released at that time, he no longer required funding from the studios. This meant Lucas could channel his profits into developing Lucasfilm projects such as THX, and the now beloved Pixar. At the 1992 Oscars Lucas received the Irving G. Thalberg Award, for his outstanding contribution to cinema. Recently he has made the headlines by controversially selling Lucasfilm to Walt Disney in a multi-billion dollar move. With JJ Abrams confirmed to direct Stars Wars: Episode VII, maybe there is new hope for the Lucas franchise to bag an academy award.

1. Kevin O'Connell

kevin o connell

Nomination and Year: Best Sound: 20 total nominations from Terms of Endearment (1984) to Transformers (2008) Imagine the scene. It€™s 2008 and we€™re at the 80th annual Oscar awards. The award for Best Adapted Screenplay has just gone to Joel and Ethan Coen for No Country For Old Men. As the Coen brothers leave the stage, Kevin O€™Connell sits up in his seat €“ his category is next. A bead of perspiration drops from his brow. His heartbeat quickens. His palms are sweaty. This is his 20th nomination in this category. He is mentally going over his acceptance speech in his head €“ it hasn€™t changed much since he was first up for an award in 1984 with Terms of Endearment. Jonah Hill and Seth Rogen are presenting the award. After a brief interval of jovial joking around, they open the gold envelope and announce the winner of the Best Sound Mixing award. €œAnd the Oscar goes to... The Bourne Ultimatum!€ Kevin O€™Connell punches the table in despair and raises his eyes to the heavens, lamenting the injustice of the cold and indifferent universe we live in. In reality, events probably didn€™t unfold this way. I€™m pretty sure by this point Kevin O€™Connell couldn€™t care less about whether he won an Oscar or not. The fact that he has been nominated a record-breaking twenty times is an epic achievement in itself. He has been a sound recording mixer on a staggering amount of successful films, including Star Wars: Episode V €“ The Empire Strikes Back, Raiders of the Lost Ark, Gremlins and Top Gun. Therefore Kevin O€™Connell tops my list of people who deserve to have won Oscars. Though he may not be the owner of small gold statue, he has given a golden contribution to sound-mixing in movies. Like this list? Let us know in the comments section below.

 
Posted On: 
Contributor

A student currently doing an English Language & Literature degree. I'm kind of a big deal. My apartment smells of rich mahogany and I have many leather-bound books. Anchorman is my favourite film.