10 Performances In Film Biopics That Got It Horribly Wrong

From Oscar glory to Razzie notoriety.

I Saw The Light Hiddelston
Bron. Studios

Taking on the leading role in a biopic is a road fraught with peril.

By their very nature, biopics revolve around some of the most memorable, compelling and influential human beings ever to walk this earth. No one wants to watch a film about an individual who holds the World Record for most number of candles extinguished by farting (apologies to Gerard Jessie of the Philippines - five is a very respectable figure).

There's an awful lot that can go wrong with bringing a character based in reality to life onscreen. While a degree of poetic license is unavoidable in the construction of a biopic, take too many liberties with actual events and producers may find themselves confronted with audiences enraged at what they perceive as an inappropriate depiction.

There is also the question of the look. While no movie buff expects the actor playing their biographical charge to be an exact physical replica of the person themselves, there is very little leeway given when the performer is simply not visually credible as the individual in question. Of course, it is also worth noting that nailing either of these factors counts for very little when the actor in question turns in a stinker of a performance.

10. Hilary Swank As Amelia Earhart - Amelia

Amelia Hilary Swank
Fox Searchlight Pictures

An international trailblazer during her lifetime and a feminist icon long after her disappearance, Amelia Earhart is arguably the most famous and celebrated aviator of all time. A ferociously ambitious pilot who became the first woman to fly solo across the Atlantic before disappearing in the most mysterious of circumstances, Earhart's life appeared to be a prime candidate for a cinematic adaptation.

Unfortunately for the legacy of one of most celebrated women in modern history, Hilary Swank's depiction of Earhart in 2009's Amelia is just a straight up debacle. Swank certainly looks the part but somehow fails to imbue her famously charismatic charge with any real soul across 111 tedious minutes that feel more like 11 years.

Amelia Earhart wasn't just a celebrity for her feats in an aircraft, she had a distinct personality that captured the attention of millions - a captivating disposition that often belied the glint of steel in her eyes. As such, Swank's performance is ultimately as dull as it is frustrating, a dreary case study in how to execute zero character development within a film, agonizingly compounded by poor direction.


9. Frank Grillo As Ferruccio Lamborghini - Lamborghini: The Man Behind The Legend

Lamborghini The Man Behind The Legend
Lionsgate

Despite flying under the radar with a low budget and little in the way of promotional fanfare, many automobile fanatics were still intrigued by the notion of a biopic concerning the Godfather of one of the most iconic sports car brands of all time, Ferruccio Lamborghini.

Regrettably, said fanatics and anyone else unfortunate enough to witness Frank Grillo's turn as the eponymous character likely found themselves wishing they had steered clear. As opposed to actually exploring Ferruccio's enthralling life story and complex persona with any significant depth, this bare bones offering lurches from one sequence to the next with the smoothness of a blindfolded learner driver clunking through gears.

The cinematic biography of this enigmatic figure appeared to possess all the requisite components for a gripping ride, but whenever Grillo's efforts appear to finally be moving in a positive direction, he stalls like somebody just broke the key off in the ignition. It's a genuinely frustrating piece of acting, a performance that should by its very nature be riveting, but instead comes across with all the refinement of an in-work training video.

The realization that the legendary cars themselves actually feature fairly minimally throughout the movie is the icing on a hilariously bad cake. Grillo is an immensely talented actor, with his work on MMA drama Kingdom standing as one of the most underrated television performances of the last decade, but this is one for the scrap pile.


8. Meg Ryan As Jackie Kallen - Against The Ropes

Against The Ropes Meg Ryan Omar Epps
Paramount Pictures

Meg Ryan was, and remains one of America's most beloved and celebrated actresses, despite a career stall following a misjudged turn in 2003's In The Cut - a relentlessly dark film that many fans and critics argued tarnished her image as America's sweetheart.

Recognized during her hey-day as Queen of the romantic comedy, Ryan is still universally adored for her roles in iconic installments in the vein of When Harry Met Sally, Sleepless in Seattle and You've Got Mail, with many critics lauding her as one of the finest performers never to receive an Academy Award nomination.

Regrettably, this only makes her appearance in 2004's Against The Ropes, a dramatized account of the life of razor sharp female boxing promoter Jackie Kallen, even more inexplicable. In a film audibly groaning with played out genre tropes and lazy writing, Ryan is simply woeful from start to finish. It's like watching a different actress wearing her face onscreen.

A cinematic take on such a seminal figure within the world of boxing should have been a sure-fire blockbuster smash, but the sheer indifference leaves audiences internally pleading to be knocked unconscious long before the end credits roll.


7. Leonardo DiCaprio As J. Edgar Hoover - J. Edgar

J. Edgar Hoover Leondaro DiCaprio
Warner Bros.

There was significant buzz surrounding Clint Eastwood's J. Edgar when the picture debuted in 2011. Everything seemed to be in place for a riveting dramatic exposé on one of modern history's most famous and controversial faces - the shady director of the organization that would go on to become known as the FBI, John Edgar Hoover.

Helmed by a legendary actor and director in Eastwood and featuring Leonardo DiCaprio - one of the finest and most naturally gifted performers of his generation - in the leading role, J. Edgar appeared to be an absolute shoe-in for a tidal wave of glowing critical reception, if not awards consideration. Unfortunately, the fact that much of the media buzz following the film's release was directed towards the prosthetics used in bringing Hoover to life spoke volumes.

While not perfect by any stretch of the imagination, DiCaprio ultimately turns in a fairly solid performance. With that being said, expectations are stratospherically high when it comes to the masterful actor and the unfortunate truth of the matter is that his performance here - with every imaginable nuance buried beneath 20 kilos of makeup - doesn't hold a candle to his spellbinding turns in the likes of The Aviator, Shutter Island and The Departed.

This combined with some uncharacteristically clueless direction from Eastwood combines for a drab offering from two titans of the industry.


6. Colin Farrell As Alexander The Great - Alexander

Alexander 2004 Film Colin Farrell Angelina Jolie
Warner Bros Pictures

Not matter how you cut it, bestowing Irish accents upon a large swathe of the cast of 2004's Alexander probably wasn't the most fitting decision Oliver Stone made for 2004's Alexander.

While Stone, the director of a movie concerning Ancient Greece, defended this decision, arguing that the accents were intended to signify the Macedonians were working class, one can't help but speculate that the reasoning for this bizarre choice was Colin Farrell's inability to successfully drop his Irish accent.

This does not exactly scream "exemplary casting". One of Ireland's finest dramatic exports, Farrell has garnered much deserved acclaim for his superb performances, culminating in an Academy Award nomination for 2022's The Banshees of Inisherin, but it doesn't change the fact that legendary conqueror Alexander the Great was a role which he was disastrously unsuited to.

Ridiculous accent choices aside, Farrell's panned take on the Macedonian King lurches between nauseating hyper-nationalism and a ludicrously over the top exploration of Alexander's sexuality, with Stone's plodding narrative taking some ridiculous liberties with historical accuracy along the way. While a degree of poetic license is a must for biopics, Alexander is hilariously bad at times.

Farrell may have rightfully burgeoned into an awards magnet in recent years, but this is a performance to forget.


5. Ashton Kutcher As Steve Jobs - Jobs

Jobs Ashton Kutcher
Open Road Films

When trailers broke featuring Ashton Kutcher as Apple tycoon Steve Jobs, one could have been forgiven for a swell of optimism. Kutcher certainly looks the part, and actually does a passable job - pardon the pun - mimicking several of the late technology mogul's mannerisms.

Sadly, Jobs' fatal flaw was the woefully inaccurate depictions of the personalities depicted within the film, with Kutcher's shallow take on Jobs taking centre stage. Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak brutally denounced the movie's initial script as "crap", having read about "as much as he could stomach".

Wozniak's later allegation that Kutcher never reached out to consult him during production sums up the inept state of affairs. The notion of attempting to play one of the most influential figures of the 21st century while failing to consult the individuals who were closest to him paints a picture of an actor unconcerned with honoring Jobs' legacy.

Michael Fassbender's mesmerizing turn as Jobs in 2015's separate biopic laid bare the failings at the heart of Kutcher's limp depiction in greater clarity. Not only did Fassbender receive an Oscar nomination for the manner in which he utterly threw himself into his performance, he played to the subtleties and nuances of the enigmatic man in a manner far beyond the dramatic capabilities of the ham-fisted Kutcher.


4. Tom Hiddleston As Hank Williams - I Saw The Light

I Saw The Light Hiddelston
Bron. Studios

The tumultuous life story of Hank Williams, one of the most beloved and enduring musicians of all time, appeared to be a sure fire recipe for critical and commercial success.

The "Hillbilly Shakespeare" was an iconic performer who was ultimately laid low by his own personal demons, with his personal and professional relationships crumbling under the weight of his rampant substance abuse. Despite his ignominious death from heart failure at the tender age of 29, Williams remains a revered figure in the music industry to this day.

Tom Hiddleston is decidedly not appalling as tortured soul Williams in 2015's I Saw The Light, and shares stunning chemistry with Elizabeth Olsen as his wife Audrey throughout the film. The fatal flaw with his performance - and I Saw The Light as a whole - is that he simply fails to do justice to Williams' endlessly complex personality or the quintessentially Southern nature of the man as a performer.

Throw in the inescapable fact that Hiddleston's singing skills are notably below par when compared to the inimitable musician - a sentiment echoed by Williams' descendants - and the end result is a meandering, formulaic offering. The legendary crooner may have brought us "Howlin' At The Moon", but it is swathes of the film's audience who are left howling with frustration at the events unfolding onscreen.


3. Demetrius Shipp Jr. As Tupac Shakur - All Eyez On Me

All Eyez On Me
Summit Entertainment

Tupac Shakur may have posited "Only God Can Judge Me" but it is not without hyperbole to state that the entire world judged Demetrius Shipp Jr's performance as unapologetically bad following a wooden turn as the iconic rapper in 2017's misjudged biopic.

In a way, the fact that Shipp looks so similar to Pac makes this performance even more unforgivable. Resemblance to the man himself aside, this was the first dramatized biopic that had been solely dedicated to the inimitable rap god himself, following a lengthy legal battle over rights to production.

Shipp Jr.'s resemblance is the only redeeming quality in what is a catastrophically awkward performance - a morbid case study in bad casting, highlighting that this was a role far beyond the talents of the young actor in brutal clarity.


2. Naomi Watts As Diana Spencer - Diana

Diana movie
Entertainment One

Kristen Stewart's stunning turn as Diana Spencer in 2021's Spencer was universally lauded, with the 33 year old actress receiving an Academy Award nomination for one of the year's finest dramatic bows with her magnetic depiction of the People's Princess.

This likely only compounded the levels of frustration Naomi Watts must have felt following the disaster that was 2013's Diana. There's simply not a good thing to say about Oliver Herschbiegel's picture. The innately talented Watts does her best to save this disaster but this is a TV-style movie nightmare come to life.

In a misjudged decision, the film shows very little sensitivity to Diana's tragic legacy, painting her final years as an endlessly hideous soap opera. An international icon beloved by millions, Diana should not have been a difficult character to get behind in the slightest, but despite her best efforts, Watts produces a miserable attempt.


1. Zoe Saldana As Nina Simone - Nina

Nina Zoe Saldana
RLJ Entertainment
"Please take Nina's name out of your mouth. For the rest of your life."

When one takes a gander at 2016's Nina - a biopic allegedly dedicated to legendary musician Nina Simone - it is not hard to see why Zoe Saldana's performance elicited this response from the iconic performer's estate. Rather, it is legitimately difficult to decide what is most offensive about the universally derided film.

Is it the film's array of cosmetics, that included some truly horrifying prosthetics and dark makeup? Avatar superstar Saldana, the actress tasked with bringing this nightmarish version of Simone to life, is Afro-Latina rather than African-American and looks nothing like Simone. It's such a thoroughly uncomfortable state of affairs that racial justice advocates have gotten involved in the debate.

Could it be the inexplicably rancid choice to portray Simone - a woman who dealt with bipolar disorder, alcoholism and spousal abuse - as a seedy, hedonistic figure, totally unconcerned with throwing away a seminal musical career in a haze of smoke and booze? No wonder that Simone's estate decried proceedings as "gut-wrenching" and "soul crushing"; this must have constituted a truly painful watch for the artist's legions of fans, let alone anyone personally associated with the High Priestess of Soul.

Saldana may have subsequently apologized and distanced herself from the film, but the damage has been done for those unfortunate enough to witness it.


Watch Next


Contributor

Law graduate with a newly rediscovered passion for writing, mad about film, television, gaming and MMA. Can usually be found having some delightful manner of violence being inflicted upon him or playing with his golden retriever.